Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset over this

109 replies

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 19:30

My husband and I have been married for over 10 years.

In that time I had never even met his older brother as the family had been kind of estranged from him for 25 years.

My BIL moved down 2 years ago following his divorce, my in laws helped him buy one of the family Buy to Let's (which was supposed to be my husband's inheritance).

Anyway I have always had a good relationship with my in laws.
I have always helped them whenever I could and basically done the job of my BIL.

My husband is a wonderful son and helps them where he can.

I am now feeling a certain type of way.
My BIL is renovating his house and in laws have been helping him.

Bearing in mind both my in laws moan about him not ever helping them, seeing them, spending time with them etc.

It got me thinking.
In all these years I dont think my in laws have ever spent as much time helping me as they are doing with my BIL.
In fact I dont think they have ever helped me.

The only thing they do is buy me chips every now and then.

I have spent hours helping them with legal paperwork, gardening, shopping, chores, doctors, brought them presents to cheer them up.

My BIL couldnt care less about them.
He has never helped them, he is just selfish and all about himself.

He stayed away for 25 years and only came back because his ex left him with nothing.

Deep down I dont feel appreciated, I feel as if they take me for granted.
They claim to see me as a daughter, but I dont feel or see that.
They never help me.

Am I being unreasonable to be upset and to not want to help my in laws again?

OP posts:
Goldie2021 · 05/09/2023 12:24

You are a good DIL and I’m sure they appreciate you even if they don’t show it. They have just got their son back in their life after 25 years. No matter the age, he is always their son. Don’t punish them for wanting a relationship with their son.

pinkcandyj · 05/09/2023 12:22

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 05/09/2023 12:22

Next time someone says 'oh but they see you as their daughter' or 'you're like the daughter we never had' simply smile and say 'your actions don't match your words'

I agree with pp, drop the soap, you're busy or can't help for whatever reason.

100% spot on.

OP posts:
BanditsOnTheHorizon · 05/09/2023 12:22

Next time someone says 'oh but they see you as their daughter' or 'you're like the daughter we never had' simply smile and say 'your actions don't match your words'

I agree with pp, drop the soap, you're busy or can't help for whatever reason.

pinkcandyj · 05/09/2023 12:19

Thebigblueballoon · 05/09/2023 11:54

I’ll say one thing (as the estranged member of my family): you do not know what happened with your brother-in-law and in-laws in the past. You do not know WHY their relationships developed as they did. And you don’t know the motive behind them helping out your previously estranged BIL. I’d be willing to wager things aren’t as you believe.

Yes I know everything and both parties have told me.

BIL got married and moved away had his own family.
He didnt even want his family at his own wedding and my in laws and husband were treated like outcasts at the wedding and for the duration of the marriage.

BIL blames all this on his ex wife.

BIL only came back into their lives as he was broke and had nothing at 60 and took pity on him.
They have told me numerous times they regret giving him the house, he is selfish etc.

I was told all this but wanted to make my own opinion on him and when I helped him a few times I was never even thanked - the apple dosent fall far from the tree.

Im annoyed because I have taken on the role of the sons. Lockdown for example I was the one doing all mine and their shopping.
Going out every week and putting myself at risk - nobody else helped them and on the few occasions I ask for help I am mugged off.

BIL comes after 25 years ago for his own benefit and they help him non stop - thats why I am so annoyed.

OP posts:
Thebigblueballoon · 05/09/2023 11:54

I’ll say one thing (as the estranged member of my family): you do not know what happened with your brother-in-law and in-laws in the past. You do not know WHY their relationships developed as they did. And you don’t know the motive behind them helping out your previously estranged BIL. I’d be willing to wager things aren’t as you believe.

FairytaleOfLancashire · 05/09/2023 11:51

YABU

pinkcandyj · 05/09/2023 11:49

It is the fact that I feel used and unappreciated and it is very one sided.

Im the one who is doing all the giving - when it should be give and take.

I have literally spent hours helping my in laws - things their own children should be helping them with.

But on the few occasions I have asked for help - I am either ignored or they are too busy.

It is not my place to be doing all these chores and errands, I have my own life to be living as other posters have rightfully pointed out.

There has been some good advice offered here and I will be making changes.

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 05/09/2023 11:40

You're wanting to stop doing nice helpful things for people you have a good relationship with, because they have started to do nice helpful things for another person?

UABU.

Maddy70 · 05/09/2023 10:36

You are being ridiculous. It's their son. Yes he was estranged for years , now he isn't and they're making up lost time together.

billy1966 · 05/09/2023 10:27

OP, you are not whiney.

You are just being used.

Have a hard look at your quietly controlling husband?

What EXACTLY is his appeal?

I can see yours for him!

Young, kind woman to be skivvy for my parents.

His comments about you seeing friends is manipulative and controlling.

Not a good man, but a user.

Expect him to be unpleasant when he realises that you no longer wish to be his parents skivvy.

Your inlaws relationship with your BIL is their business.
Forget about it.

What you can do for YOU is no longer be available.
Forward their requests on to your husband.
No longer respond to THEIR complaints about your BIL, nothing to do with you.

Unfortunately your youth has seen you sucked into a situation where all these people think you are there to be used, very much including your husband.

This happens to kind, soft women with poor boundaries ALL the time.

They will use and run you ragged as their carer and your husband will happily allow it.

Start thinking hard about what you want from your lifevand future and get yourself out of this situation asap.

HIS parents are HIS responsibility.

Start seeing friends and family on your own.

Stop having any free time.

Stop listening to your husband lies that they do so much for you🙄.

Do not trust someone who would tellbsuch a blatent self serving lie.

I hope you have financial independence.

Testina · 05/09/2023 10:02

If I start spending time with friends my husband will get funny and say "Oh I tnink they realise your not bothered about them" which makes me feel guilty.

Again, you have a husband problem!
You were initially defensive because he has An Important Business, but really he’s cut from the same cloth as his brother: take take take (from you).

You can do 2 things:

  • just stop feeling guilty, every time you start to, stop - recognise the discomfort and where it’s coming from and then let it pass. Once you start to identify - hang on, he’s on a guilt trip, it will stop having the same power
  • actually tell him, “cut out that shite, it’s your mum”.
Keyworks · 05/09/2023 09:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

pinkcandyj · 05/09/2023 09:05

BrawnWild · 05/09/2023 08:33

Like another poster said, make yourself too busy to help. "Sorry I have yoga class"

Kindly, do you have friends and family that you actively go out to se for pleasure? It is your world quite small with them taking centre stage?

Hi yes I have quite a lot of friends and family but it is tricky at times as the in laws think that they should be invited whenever I have family over and get offended.

If I start spending time with friends my husband will get funny and say "Oh I tnink they realise your not bothered about them" which makes me feel guilty.

I have to keep reminding my husband that they are not my parents - I dont owe them anything.

I have started to take a step back as I have my own family that I want to help.

OP posts:
Stratocumulus · 05/09/2023 08:47

Cowlover89 · 04/09/2023 22:33

Let them crack on. Concentrate on your own family.

This ^
Grafually step back. Make subtle changes and become less available. Count to ten & say “let me get back to you. I need to check my diary.”
I don’t think you are whiny as someone above has said, and can see quite clearly you’ve been taken for a mug.
Time to put the brakes on OP. Start today.

BrawnWild · 05/09/2023 08:33

Like another poster said, make yourself too busy to help. "Sorry I have yoga class"

Kindly, do you have friends and family that you actively go out to se for pleasure? It is your world quite small with them taking centre stage?

BrawnWild · 05/09/2023 08:29

They probably do see you like a daughter and thata how they would treat her - expecting the world from her for anbag of chips whilst they idolise two brothers who are too busy to help.

LittleBrenda · 05/09/2023 07:52

which was supposed to be my husband's inheritance
That's not a thing.

You've taken on what should have been your husband's responsibilities. When I married my husband, I didn't start sending his mother flowers on her birthday and all that jazz.

His parents aren't going to turn away an estranged son because you've been taking them to appointments. They are allowed to spend their own money on whatever they want. Be it their son or a sports car.

If you wanted financial recompense for all of the things you have done for them, that should have been discussed.

WhateverMate · 04/09/2023 23:46

As I am only mid 30s, my husband is in his early 50s, BIL is 60 and in laws are 79 it kind of falls on me as the youngest person to do everything.

I missed this, sorry OP but it actually made me laugh 😂

I'm in my early 50s, I have a very physical full-time job and a 92 year old dad that I care for, I'm peri-menopausal and have a very underactive thyroid and yet I manage to get everything done and cram in time for me.

Perhaps I should divorce my DH and find a 30 something woman to do everything for me?

WhateverMate · 04/09/2023 23:42

When someone says 'you're like the daughter they never had', that's exactly what they mean - like.

As much as I'm sure they love you, you are not their daughter. Their son is their son and I'm sure the feeling of having him back in their lives will be indescribable.

Do less and encourage your husband to do more.

And stop taking their love for their previously estranged son so personally.

Testina · 04/09/2023 23:36

As I am only mid 30s, my husband is in his early 50s, BIL is 60 and in laws are 79 it kind of falls on me as the youngest person to do everything.

Oh for heaven’s sake!
When I suggested that your husband ought to have been doing more for his parents than you, you told us about his Very Important Business than stops him doing dull shite.
Now you’re saying it’s be worse he’s early 50s?
Me too.
He’s no age and that no excuse for dumping so much on you and manipulating you with crap about being like a daughter to them. He’s as selfish as they are. And his brother.
You do need to take responsibility too though, for making excuses for him.

ThereIbledit · 04/09/2023 23:16

For years I have felt like an unpaid carer.

I think it is time to do stuff for myself, pets, family etc.

I will make it clear to my husband that I will not be involved in the future care or my in laws as it is not my place and I have already sacrificed a lot of my time for them.

As I am only mid 30s, my husband is in his early 50s, BIL is 60 and in laws are 79 it kind of falls on me as the youngest person to do everything.

Absolutely do follow through with this and remain resolute. The status quo benefits your husband and your in-laws, so they won't give it up without a fight. You MUST stand firm. TELL your husband exactly what is going to change, with immediate effect. You are WORKING from home, (and then after work you have a yoga class or whatever) - he can do whatever it is they need when he can around his self employed work - the joy of being self employed is that in theory at least your hours are flexible - so best he start getting into practice with looking after his own parents, isn't it. Redirect MIL's request to your H or BIL every time: "Oh no I can't help, I'm busy with things for my own parents at the moment, I'm sure DH or BIL will sort it for you, ask them." "MIL I'm sorry I have too much on to be able to help you, ask DH/BIL, they'll have to sort something out for you." If they say "Oh but you're so good at this, oh but you're our daughter too, give them a Paddington stare and repeat "But I'm not your daughter. I'm married to your son. DH and DBIL are your sons. They are capable of helping you." "Oh but they won't do it as well as you/they're too busy/too useless, sob sob" "It's not my job to look after you. It's your sons' job. Ask them."

Absolutely DON'T step in as a temporary carer if she hurts her knee!! Or for any other reason, it'll become status quo immediately and be 10 times harder to change.

And for goodness sake have the tough love conversations with your DH and PIL that you will NOT be becoming their carers when they need it - They and their own sons will need to arrange their care needs.

SkaneTos · 04/09/2023 23:07

Your BIL is their son. It is what it is.

Perhaps your husband can help his parents some more?
Not make you do everything?
But of course, your husband has his very important business, which is very important.

BicOrange · 04/09/2023 23:00

Jeez, you're well on your way to caring for them all for the next 30+ years unless you put a stop to it now.
Start living your own life, for you, and let them all get on with it.

pinkcandyj · 04/09/2023 22:51

@Scattery yes I agree with you!

For years I have felt like an unpaid carer.

I think it is time to do stuff for myself, pets, family etc.

I will make it clear to my husband that I will not be involved in the future care or my in laws as it is not my place and I have already sacrificed a lot of my time for them.

As I am only mid 30s, my husband is in his early 50s, BIL is 60 and in laws are 79 it kind of falls on me as the youngest person to do everything.

OP posts:
Lampzade · 04/09/2023 22:49

Echoes of the bible story of ‘The Prodigal Son’
Your in laws are probably grateful to have him back in their lives and don’t want to risk losing him
The problem with this is that the loyal members of the family often feel unappreciated