Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to homeschool DS??

38 replies

NeverendingChaos · 04/09/2023 19:03

DS going into Yr9. Starts back at school on Wednesday. He is insisting on being homeschooled as he hates school and states he can learn more efficiently at home. Wants to homeschool himself, presented me with a timetable and all the resources he’ll use. Has decided on what GCSE’s he’s taking (only 6 so he gets the highest possible grades as he only needs 5 for A levels!) and he’s put them all on his timetable.

I do wonder if he’s on the Autism spectrum (high functioning) as he is super intelligent and prefers to be on his own. Him being as he is, he’s extensively researched it and insists he’s not.

He complains that other DC are annoying and not like him and the teaching is too slow. He has a few friends at school but he refuses to meet up outside of school and won’t do any clubs or activities.

He’s spent the summer at home quite happy in himself, occasionally being dragged out to the leisure centre to do some sports with DH and his older brothers under much protest.

There is no bullying that we were aware of (I’ve asked and asked but he’s always denied) until last night he broke down in tears saying that his friendship group had frozen him out just before the school holidays due to him a silky argument with one of them so he’d blocked them all on WhatsApp and now wouldn’t have anyone to be with at break and lunch when he goes back. We’ve obviously impressed on him that it’ll have been forgotten about by now and he can make new friends (although that will be hard for him). I think there may be more to it though and he’s struggling to fit in with peers in general.

We’ve moved since he was at primary school (had very few friends there as well) and I don’t know any of the parents of the friends he’d made at secondary so don’t know what went on. I was on at him constantly over the summer to arrange to meet up with friends and he’d said he didn’t want to.

He was diagnosed with a serious medical condition last year which I know he’s struggling with psychologically but won’t admit it or agree to therapy. School attendance was 60% last year due to this as condition worsens while at school as he’s obviously under stress (I believed social stress and DS has only now admitted it) so I was constantly having to collect him and he was having days off as feeling ill. Requested meeting with school who said no social issues observed, extremely well regarded by teachers, excellent behaviour etc. He still got 95%+ in end of year assessments.

It was for this reason alone that I considered home schooling but I am worried he won’t reach his potential and will be isolated socially but he insists he will be much happier. Have looked into a fresh start at a new school but all schools in area are full and have waiting lists. Can’t afford private.

He is using medical condition as a argument that he must be homeschooled which I kind of agree with as I think he’s got enough to deal with without school stress but I think it will just be a disaster!

If I deregister him from current school, someone on waiting list will take it and he won’t be able to get into another school.

WIBU to force him back to school?

He is adamant I’m not to speak to school about helping him socially nor will he agree to seeing s therapist.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BlibBlabBlob · 26/01/2024 13:22

Zombie thread alert!

Felicia19 · 26/01/2024 13:20

He has worked out how he will organize the home schooling, he is bright and motivated. Give him the chance to do it.

I don't agree that school is necessary for social purposes, and I wouldn't make the homeschooling dependent on him doing other social activities. If he feels a need for these, he is capable of organizing them for himself.

The school system doesn't suit all children.

Waterfallsandrainbows · 26/01/2024 13:17

Do Uni courses want a minimum of 7 GCSE’s? Not sure but this number rings a bell 🔔

If he has a serious medical condition this needs to be factored in. Maybe make a deal with him? Look at home schooling communities and if he can socialise with them.

I am not saying you should say yes to all his terms but maybe there is a compromise which benefits him and puts your fears at ease.

LadyDanburysHat · 26/01/2024 13:12

Malapataraso · 04/09/2023 19:46

Compromise: You will allow homeschooling if he will see a therapist.

I agree with this. There needs to be some give and take. He can't have it all his way.

TheSandgroper · 26/01/2024 13:10

You talk about GCSE’s but also talk about school,starting in Wednesday and summer activities. Are you in Australia? Would trying SIDE be a halfway house? If you are WA based https://www.side.wa.edu.au/. NSW https://education.nsw.gov.au/teaching-and-learning/curriculum/rural-and-distance-education/distance-education. Other states will have their own departments within Education.

School of Isolated and Distance Education

School of Isolated and Distance Education

https://www.side.wa.edu.au/

Workawayxx · 26/01/2024 12:58

I'd want him to do 9 GCSEs and commit to some active and social activities outside the home and/or home ed groups (even if he switches about a bit to see which suit him best).

Do you think you'd need to help him / chivvy him into working or would he be self-motivated? Does he understand there would be no going back? Can you afford the resources required? I think I'd want a proper course via an online school or similar as he'd have some accountability but they can be expensive.

It may be that he's using up all his social ability just coping with being in school and will be much more able to engage in life if he doesn't have that stress.

moomoomoo27 · 26/01/2024 12:50

It's better to have a broader range of GCSEs at slightly lower grades than a few at the max grade.

I studied English, but my first choice Russell Group university required me to have a good grade in a foreign language GCSE. My sister got just as good grades as I did but couldn't even apply for the same university because she didn't do a foreign language past year 9, whereas I had no problems getting in.

You never know what jobs and opportunities are going to come up in the future for him where it would have been better to have a particular GCSE and he doesn't have it purely on the basis that he didn't take enough.

The plan sounds positive in other respects, but is he just trying to avoid things rather than face them? He should at least give it a try, because there are so many things he's not going to like as an adult that he can't run away from.

Hufflemuff · 05/09/2023 05:14

I think if you're going to homeschool you need to address social side of things too. I don't think it will benefit him long term to isolate himself from the world. He needs friendships and to learn to work with others. In the future presumably he will go to Uni if very clever and will experience "people" in concentrated form. The workplace is also inevitable.

I'd also give him until the end of December to show he is willing to attend therapy and go in for meetings with the school to try and resolve things too. The school may even support a flexible schedule whereby he attends school 50% of the time and he HS the other 50%.

Bibbetybobbity · 05/09/2023 04:48

I agree with @Ohthatsabitshit , I’d want to understand why he thinks he needs so few GCSE’s and this fact alone is a reminder that he’s bright but young and fallible… even if his specific college course requires this, it would be very limiting. No way I’d be agreeing to that element.

itsgettingweird · 05/09/2023 04:47

Camhs said to me when attended that someone choosing to be alone - isolating themselves should be respected. It's not fair to dictate someone's else's feelings - especially someone ND - on behavioural norms and what we think they should feel.

itsgettingweird · 05/09/2023 04:46

Have you looked at inter high and HE groups?

Having an autistic son myself I think you need to consider the damage you'll do forcing him into a situation where he's saying it's too much.

You can always have attending counselling as a condition of him being HE.

curaçao · 05/09/2023 04:29

Your son MIGHT need intelligent (i will come back to that) but it sounds as though his social skills are sorely lacking.He is not going to develop them by sitting alone in hus bedroom all day!
If you are stopping school, you are taking away what seems like his only social opportunity!
Most t intelligent kids I know do 11 or 12 GCSEs, and if you are only putting him in for so few , it is not doing him justice

Ohthatsabitshit · 05/09/2023 00:39

I’d be more concerned with his odd ideas about taking quite so few GCSEs and doing so little physical exercise. What does he want to do at Uni and how does he suggest he gains the social skills necessary for adult life. (I’m a HEer but I think it sounds a bit half arsed).

babbscrabbs · 05/09/2023 00:29

To be blunt, he's already isolated socially by the sound of it.

So that leaves reaching his potential as your other major concern. Even though he got great marks despite missing half of school...

The thing is, being really unhappy at school will affect his potential as well.

Could you afford a tutor every now and then to assess how he's doing? Or could he earn £ himself to pay for it as part of the deal?

I'm so impressed with the fact he's put together a plan and even a timetable of how it would work. I think for that effort alone I'd look to trial it if possible. It seems really clear it's what he wants. It's HIS life.

Saracen · 05/09/2023 00:17

Your son has made a lot of good points and has clearly given everything careful consideration. What's more, if his medical condition continues to affect his attendance as much as it has been doing, he'll only be able to access 60% of an education at school, whereas if he were home educated he'd be at 100% of his lessons. You say he is still excelling at school despite missing almost half his lessons, so it seems he is either very bright or very hard-working or both. Think how much more he'll learn if he can get a full education.

On the face of it, his proposals make sense.

Could you explain more about your reservations?

MintJulia · 04/09/2023 20:53

You need to talk to the school. You are the adult here. And the school can't help if they don't know what is happening.

Make a list of all his issues with school and then ask to meet with the head of education, and the head of pastoral care.

Wildhorses2244 · 04/09/2023 20:44

I think that I would sit down and have a really in depth conversation about how school promotes exercise, teaches social skills and supports with learning social communication etc. With a really honest assessment with him of what he’s strong at and what needs more practice across a more holistic spectrum.

I would then give him back his timetable and say that he can home educate if he can work out an alternative way of accessing that sort of learning, not just the gcse learning. As an example, I would accept a weekly team sport with his brother, a home Ed drama class and scout group as a replacement for that sort of learning.

Good luck!

DesertIslandHereICome · 04/09/2023 20:36

My youngest son has been home educated since 14, it's worked out really well. In his own words he's never been happier. He sits his exams at a local private college, he is totally responsible for his education, he is more than capable.
School worked for him up until a certain age, he spent 10 yrs in school, he is very confident and articulate. He is applying to go to university very shortly.
In my opinion he has had the best of both worlds and it's been a really positive experience.

Humanswarm · 04/09/2023 20:24

I think I have to agree with PPs, if he wishes to home school and he is motivated to learn, then do so.
There is so much pressure on our children to fit societal norms, and to conform to an education system which, let's face it, is not fit for purpose.
I have a DS who is almost 8. He had his first day back today and first day in KS2. I am giving it until half term, before making a full decision on deregistering.That is the deal, I guess that we made, in that we'd try it. I wfh so I can just about make it work. But ultimately his state of mind and happiness is paramount.

Seagullchippy · 04/09/2023 20:22

I'd let him try it, if you can manage it with work etc., but on the condition that he does some sport for health/outdoor time and one or two short social things a week, but things that are not too stressful for him as masking can put a big strain on mental health for autistic people. It sounds like it could be better for his health if he's able to work in his own way and feel listened to. It sounds like he's very responsible and hard working, too.

DragonCatcher · 04/09/2023 20:21

I'd suggest an agreement that he attends a therapist and school until half term. Then you can discuss with the therapist if HE would be a good choice for him.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 04/09/2023 20:16

If he is a bright button who can teach himself, let him.

ASimpleLampoon · 04/09/2023 20:13

His social problems may well work themselves out if he does this and is happier as a result.

stbrandonsboat · 04/09/2023 20:13

Have you looked at online schooling? Parents get hung up on the social aspect of school, but in my experience it's way over rated, particularly if they're miserable and don't fit in anyway.

CrawleyEstate · 04/09/2023 20:05

My son (autism,pda,adhd etc) refused to go to school once he was 7.

It’s been trial and error but he is 100% happier and more successful being home educated. Once he is out of the school stress you may well discover he is actually keen and happy to socialise because he is less stressed out all the time.

My brother wasn’t home educated but school refused a lot and taught himself through A Levels. He went off to a Russel group uni fine.