Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What to do about a teen with zero manners

36 replies

Pink39tree · 04/09/2023 18:51

I know this is going to come across very snobby but I’m mortified with my young BIL manners from a recent family gathering at my families home.
DH is one of 4, three of them are the most well mannered people you would ever meet. However there is a large age gap between them and the youngest brother who seems the issue.
They all have the same parents, who clearly must of done something correct with the first three children.
Examples of his bad manners from this weekend :
1)Burped on the table
2)Licked the plate clean
3)Doesn’t say please or thank you EVER. Even when I challenge him.
4)There was a cultural celebration, my family kindly ensured he was included with gifts he refused to get up and say thank you. When I pushed him to do so as I was mortified he just said “maybe if I got the same amount of money as the others I would have said thank you”. I wanted the ground to swallow me up.
5)I explained to him before we went that culturally, the elders take their food first. Yes it might be backwards, but when you’re a guest at someone’s house you respect their rules. Well clearly not darling BIL who grabbed a whole platter of food, put it on his plate before everyone sat dow and when challenged that’s meant for everyone proudly said “we’ll your mum should of made more”.
6)Licked his knife, when my grandad explained that’s bad manners and could hurt himself, he licked it again.

My DH and I are so embarrassed, his mum just said “he’s young he doesn’t know”, surely that’s not an excuse I know toddlers that are more behaved. I’m worried about him entering adulthood without learning these manners as I just think they are so important in society/work/university/etc? I think we need to set some sort of intervention about his manners, my DH and siblings agree but the mum is adamant he will learn. Do say if I’m being dramatic and to just leave him.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IncompleteSenten · 05/09/2023 07:55

Well I wonder why it is.

His parent excusing it with that he's young he doesn't know bullshit springs to mind.

I'd stop inviting him to any event where there's anyone else there apart from your household and his parents . And I'd be very clear why.

MeridianB · 05/09/2023 07:52

You mention Uni - is that what he wants? Is he buckling down academically? If not, it's possible he'll 'fail to launch' and double-down on the princeling position at home.

I'd be happy to be labelled a snob for not included him socially. It's a perfect time to disengage and set your own boundaries now.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 05/09/2023 07:27

It sounds like he's attention seeking and behaving his way on purpose.

The comment about the money - did he get less than everyone else? I wonder if he feels like the black sheep/left out and is playing up as a way of trying to hide his upset.

Thelonelygiraffe · 05/09/2023 07:26

It's very unusual for a DC not to pick up on social norms and genuinely not to care what people think of him.

If he is NT, then his parents have done a terrible job of bringing him up.

Isthisexpected · 05/09/2023 07:23

Yesterday I observed a teen of this age actively try to injure younger female children at a park. So personally I'd be particularly concerned about his responses to you OP (assuming you're female). Male entitlement and violence against women and girls starts in childhood.

CoffeeCantata · 05/09/2023 07:20

OP - that sounds awful. From what you say, I would think it's more than just not having manners - he sounds deliberately offensive.

My teens, for example, had to be told 'Family Hold Back' at social events - let guests go first, don't take too much from the buffet, hand things round etc etc, but they were never obnoxious - just a bit socially inept and thoughtless sometimes.

I'd get your OH to deal with this problem, because it does sound like a problem and I'm sorry if your relations were upset by his behaviour.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 04/09/2023 23:03

Doesn't sound like bad manners to me. Sounds like purposeful defiance - he's going against you out of choice and to get a reaction.

Maybe he feels left out because of the large age gap?

ThereIbledit · 04/09/2023 22:51

What does your DH think? I'd tell his family that in your house you expect your rules to be followed, and so what if they call you uptight, it's your house, you can tell them they all have to wear pink tiaras if that's what you want to do. But you're not asking that, you're asking that he observes basic table manners, says please and thank you, and that he is parented appropriately if he fails. IF they wont' agree to that, they don't visit your home.

BreadInCaptivity · 04/09/2023 22:35

He's not your problem to worry about though in reality.

It's up to his parents and to a far lesser degree your DH.

I think you need to step away from the drama tbh.

Put boundaries in place re: your family, visiting your home, presents etc and stick to them.

If he behaves badly in his home when you visit just ignore him. Grey rock - no reaction.

I'm sure he'll manage at Uni without his mum when he has to and will refine his behaviour when other students find him revolting and don't want to hang out with him. Basically when it's in his interests to remember his manners.

He sounds like he's getting a kick out of it, so don't give him fuel for his fire.

Anxioys · 04/09/2023 22:29

Nah. He will be at home with his mum, making her feel awful. He's never leaving her if he can help it.

Pink39tree · 04/09/2023 22:25

The thought of him even going to university baffles me, his mum does everything for him. A conversation from when they were staying over.
Him: “Mum where is the towel”
MIL: “On your bed”
Him: “Where on my bed”
MIL: “On the right closest to the wall”
Him: “Where on the right side”
MiL: “At the bottom right corner by the feet of the bed”
Him: “I can’t find it”
MIL runs up to give it to him, it was right in front of him.

All his siblings at his age had to get part time jobs to pay for their social things, the thought of him having a job makes me laugh he wouldn’t be able to at all.

He plays the mental health card (I say card with my chest because the amount of money that has been poured into his therapy only for even the counsellor to say he’s admitted to him he’s fine and he thinks mental health is a joke)

Honestly I’m worried he’s just going to be a bum.

OP posts:
Craftycorvid · 04/09/2023 22:18

He’s well aware he’s getting a reaction. Is there any back story, resentment perhaps? He seems to be deliberately acting out to annoy people. It’s quite acceptable to make it known he’s not welcome if he can’t behave. If there’s anyone he’s closer to, is there a way of trying to find out what he’s so angry about (he seems very angry).

Pink39tree · 04/09/2023 22:14

My DH hates it but is under the impression when he goes to university, social norms will kick in. I think by that point it would be too late and he will find himself isolated

OP posts:
Pink39tree · 04/09/2023 22:13

Anytime I challenge him my MIL says I’m being snobby. Not being snobby it’s just repulsive behaviour.

He is like this in school also.

I feel sorry for him because I think his parents are to blame and it’s got to do with him being spoilt as the youngest but come on.

OP posts:
drinkuptheezider · 04/09/2023 22:08

I'd take the piss, tell him and his parents at least the gene pool will stop with him. No self-respecting girl will want him.

MeridianB · 04/09/2023 22:07

If your ILs won’t visit you without him then don’t invite them, and tell them why.

Presumably he knows how to eat/behave properly (at school etc) but chooses not to and has zero consequences. There’s no way I’d put up with this. He’s laughing at you all and getting a kick out of it.

Pink39tree · 04/09/2023 22:04

Is it too late to be fixed?

OP posts:
Pink39tree · 04/09/2023 22:03

It’s hard to stop inviting him to things when he’s part of the family.
Most definitely won’t be coming to my families house again, funnily enough when the conversation of Christmas came up and I said “DH and I will be hosting Christmas” MIL was shocked when I said they are not invited also because my family will be coming and I’m not going through that embarrassment again for him to be there.

However when we go to see the in laws or they come to visit he will be there. Sometimes I’m put off my food when he’s on the dinner table licking his plate 🤢

I know he is not my kid to parent but I feel so sad for him that people will think badly of him when he enters the real world, and I don’t blame him because clearly his parents are not parenting him.

it’s a shame, the first thing people would say about DH when they meet him would be “wow your parents did a great job with you”

OP posts:
Saz12 · 04/09/2023 21:33

His behaviour doesnt need to be your problem.
Dont invite him to your get togethers /celebrations. Dont bother with gifts for him.
If he asks, tell him bluntly. Dont expect him to rethink his behaviour as a result- "you dont seem to appreciate what we give you, so it seems wasteful to continue" or "you werent interested in our family celebration the last tine, so I didnt think youd want to come".

Gymmum82 · 04/09/2023 21:33

Stop inviting him to anything. If you have to be around him and he’s rude I would tell him he’s the rudest person you’ve ever met and you dislike him immensely.
Don’t include him in anything your family does. He’s a spoilt brat who is about to become an entitled adult. It’s probably too late for him tbh

MeridianB · 04/09/2023 21:29

No more invitations and avoid having to see him at any events or meals. Your DH should ask his parents why they’re allowing him to offend people and behave like an oaf.

“He’s young” is a lame excuse if he was 6 but at 16 they are creating a monster.

BorrowedThyme · 04/09/2023 21:24

He is being deliberately oppositional - why?

Does he feel like he is being picked on?

If there is no good reason behind this, just leave him out altogether in the future

BreadInCaptivity · 04/09/2023 21:21

It's not your job to parent him, but neither do you have to put up with his awful behaviour in your home.

Neither do you have to "reward" him by giving nice gifts etc.

Frankly I'd back off (including sending birthday presents, inviting him to family events you host etc) and tell his mum why.

She doesn't think it's an issue - fine. Maybe she will think differently when people start saying they are not putting up with that level of rudeness at his age.

He sounds like an entitled little shit and I'd be mortified if my DS behaved that was at any age never mine as an older teen.

He's way past the point of he should have grown out of it because he's been allowed to behave that way for too long.

NeedToChangeName · 04/09/2023 19:14

Reward the good behaviour, ignore the bad

Not your responsibility to parent him

Acknowledge to your family that he was rude

He probably will mature and be more polite in future

saltinesandcoffeecups · 04/09/2023 19:10

All the normal things… Stop inviting him, call him out if you are with him, don’t let others invite him, apologize on his behalf if forced, and finally make yourself unpleasant for him to be around by doing all of the above.