Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a car one - with diagram!

93 replies

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 17:54

NC just in case and AIBU for traffic. This has already been swiftly sorted out, but I'm curious for opinions on what happened.

Winding, wooded, country A road, line of cars all doing about 40.

About 30 yards ahead van goes fully into oncoming lane and and pauses.

Road at this point curves around a bend to the right. Road markings are long dashes with arrows to stop overtaking from oncoming direction.

Van turns left, fully across, at right angles, left lane to go into private side road on left.

Car hits van in centre of its body.

  1. The private road entrance and width all the way is enough for more than two cars.
  2. The road was a bend at this point, so while in oncoming lane, cars could have hit van.
  3. The corner was not that sharp. If the van had slowed almost to a stop in its own lane and turned left, it would have made it without even swinging out into the oncoming lane, let alone putting 100% of itself over there.

What do you think? Diagram attached. If you want to vote, say YABU for Van being in the right, YANBU for Van being in the wrong.

It's a car one - with diagram!
OP posts:
andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 04/09/2023 19:38

Who was found at fault then?

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 04/09/2023 19:33

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:28

Road bendy. All doing 40. Slowed to 25ish.

Too close or too fast, even at 25 then, for unexpected hazards. I get why the car driver might feel aggrieved but it’s still their fault.

MaggieFS · 04/09/2023 19:32

So how was it resolved?

If the van was indicating, the car should have stopped.

And I think that even if it wasn't, the car should have slowed down to proceed with caution given the odd behaviour of the van.

That said, regardless of which lane the van was in, it should have checked wing mirrors before turning.

Both at fault.

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:28

Road bendy. All doing 40. Slowed to 25ish.

OP posts:
andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 04/09/2023 19:26

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:12

Interesting. Thanks for opinions!
I suppose timing was everything really as ordinarily when something is odd ahead you would slow right down but there wasn't time to get to a stop.
Collision didn't result in airbags so was a slow one.

Surely if the van had time to pull over and come to a stop, the car had time to do the same thing?

What would have happened if the van needed to slam on the brakes for a deer or something?

Takacupokindnessyet · 04/09/2023 19:25

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:12

Interesting. Thanks for opinions!
I suppose timing was everything really as ordinarily when something is odd ahead you would slow right down but there wasn't time to get to a stop.
Collision didn't result in airbags so was a slow one.

Ordinarily being when the car behind has left a sufficient gap.

SocialLite · 04/09/2023 19:19

FOJN · 04/09/2023 19:15

If there was a three second gap between the vehicles and the van had slowed to a stop why didn't the car have time to stop?

This...

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 04/09/2023 19:19

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:12

Interesting. Thanks for opinions!
I suppose timing was everything really as ordinarily when something is odd ahead you would slow right down but there wasn't time to get to a stop.
Collision didn't result in airbags so was a slow one.

If the car didn’t have time to stop it was going too fast / travelling too close.

Hercisback · 04/09/2023 19:19

Cars fault for sure, undertaking. Car should have slowed as soon as the van swung out.

Crappy if the van didn't indicate. But still cars fault.

FOJN · 04/09/2023 19:15

If there was a three second gap between the vehicles and the van had slowed to a stop why didn't the car have time to stop?

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:12

Interesting. Thanks for opinions!
I suppose timing was everything really as ordinarily when something is odd ahead you would slow right down but there wasn't time to get to a stop.
Collision didn't result in airbags so was a slow one.

OP posts:
Judashascomeintosomemoney · 04/09/2023 19:09

No question it’s the car drivers fault. Even if there was no indication from the van, it was obvious he was doing an odd manoeuvre and the car should have waited at a safe distance until the manoeuvre was completed or they were certain of the vans intentions.

PuppyMonkey · 04/09/2023 19:09

Van was on the wrong side of the road.
Car should have slowed down.

Tell us how it panned out now OP.

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 04/09/2023 19:03

Car is at fault, even without indicating or knowing the road it was obvious what was happening

Takacupokindnessyet · 04/09/2023 18:58

Surely if the van had time to pull to the side and stop, the cars also had enough time to stop.

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 04/09/2023 18:58

Car completely at fault. It would be obvious the van was about to perform a manoeuvre such as swinging wide into the left hand turning. You wouldn’t expect the van to stop in the right hand lane, so you should anticipate it’s doing a manoeuvre. Sounds like the car driver was impatient.

I’m presuming you’re the car driver? Also, initially you say the van stopped, then in your second post it paused. Also who is disputing the indicators, are other drivers saying the van was, or is it just you and the van driver disagreeing?

Either way I’d say car fully at fault.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 04/09/2023 18:57

The car should have stopped when he saw the van manoeuvre, but the van should also have checked before driving across. IMO it's 50/50.

Many vans need to go onto the wrong side of the road to make turns safely, so he wasn't necessarily in the wrong or doing some kind of weird manoeuvre.

TolkiensFallow · 04/09/2023 18:47

The car is at fault. It comes across as an impatient car driver trying to undertake.

I remember being taught in driving lessons that larger vehicles can sometimes do this when they need to make a hard left turn and to give them space to complete the manoeuvre.

FOJN · 04/09/2023 18:46

I can't vote because the van was not in the right but neither was the car.

DrFoxtrot · 04/09/2023 18:45

What was the outcome OP?

DrFoxtrot · 04/09/2023 18:44

I still feel the van is more at fault, completely stupid manoeuvre and then crossed the lane of moving traffic they'd just left.

Cherrysoup · 04/09/2023 18:44

Could the car driver not see that the van was performing a manoeuvre?

Sauvblanctime · 04/09/2023 18:44

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 18:40

All cars moving in same direction.
Van had moved into oncoming lane and stopped there. Was room to turn without that. Van about the size of a camper.
Indicating is disputed.
Cars all about 3 second gap.
If van had not stopped, there would have been time for cars to stop. But it stopped, giving long enough for cars to catch up and then went across without looking.
No cars in private road to complicate it.

Unless there’s numerous independent witnesses saying van wasn’t indicating, car at fault as should have slowed down due to vans incorrect road placement

LosingMyPancakes · 04/09/2023 18:44

So the van pulls over into the right hand lane (may or may not be indicating) and stops. The car thought it was a good idea to keep driving forward at speed? The obvious thing is to slow down and prepare to stop if necessary.

FOJN · 04/09/2023 18:42

I think the car is at fault as the van had undertaken a strange and dangerous manoeuvre and the car didn't hang back to see what was happening.

The van is lucky that another car wasn't coming round the bend from the opposite direction.