Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a car one - with diagram!

93 replies

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 17:54

NC just in case and AIBU for traffic. This has already been swiftly sorted out, but I'm curious for opinions on what happened.

Winding, wooded, country A road, line of cars all doing about 40.

About 30 yards ahead van goes fully into oncoming lane and and pauses.

Road at this point curves around a bend to the right. Road markings are long dashes with arrows to stop overtaking from oncoming direction.

Van turns left, fully across, at right angles, left lane to go into private side road on left.

Car hits van in centre of its body.

  1. The private road entrance and width all the way is enough for more than two cars.
  2. The road was a bend at this point, so while in oncoming lane, cars could have hit van.
  3. The corner was not that sharp. If the van had slowed almost to a stop in its own lane and turned left, it would have made it without even swinging out into the oncoming lane, let alone putting 100% of itself over there.

What do you think? Diagram attached. If you want to vote, say YABU for Van being in the right, YANBU for Van being in the wrong.

It's a car one - with diagram!
OP posts:
ColleenDonaghy · 04/09/2023 21:29

Car at fault, it shouldn't have undertaken the van in that scenario and should have slowed.

Zwicky · 04/09/2023 21:20

Car at fault. Maybe van driver swung out unnecessarily far or paused abnormally long but it should have been obvious that they were up to something so the car driver should have slowed down enough to stop and definitely shouldn’t have undertaken the van. Van could have taken the corner better but being a bit hesitant is not wrong in the same way as undertaking. You have to account for dodderiness, people driving unfamiliar vehicles, people being lost, people thinking “shit, this corner is tighter than I thought”, people seeing things in the road that op are out of your line of vision. That’s what patience and stopping distances are for.

Snittle · 04/09/2023 21:17

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:12

Interesting. Thanks for opinions!
I suppose timing was everything really as ordinarily when something is odd ahead you would slow right down but there wasn't time to get to a stop.
Collision didn't result in airbags so was a slow one.

Impossible - if the van had time to pull into another lane, stop and partially make the turn before being hit the second car must have had time to stop, unless it was driving unsafely.

The van is able to use the whole road to drive provided it is safe to do so. No vehicle should ever undertake another (not least if the van is on the wrong side of the road in what you imply is an unsafe bend as you should give them space to pull back in).

Car driver definitely at fault.

Blanketpolicy · 04/09/2023 21:06

I would say the car driver was not paying full attention to the van drivers movements/the road and needs to anticipate potential hazards better so they can react better and/or not drive as close.

No idea how insurers would see it.

Silvers11 · 04/09/2023 21:04

FOJN · 04/09/2023 19:15

If there was a three second gap between the vehicles and the van had slowed to a stop why didn't the car have time to stop?

I agree - if it really was 3 seconds gap, then the car should have had time to stop.

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 04/09/2023 20:58

ChristmasCurry · 04/09/2023 20:49

When making a left or right turn swinging out into the opposite lane is an illegal move by any vehicle. If the van was indicting left then it may go 50/50 if not then the van was in the wrong, but either way will be hard to prove unless the people in the car behind saw the if the van was not indicating.

Happened to a friend of mine a few years ago and it went 50/50 by the insurance companies.

If the side road goes back on itself as per the diagram and it’s a long wheelbase it might be the only way to make the turn.

Silvers11 · 04/09/2023 20:58

I would say the car is at fault. If I had been in the car I would have stepped on the brake to slow right down - and everyone else would have had to do the same. I don't think either of the drivers were on the ball, but legally, pretty sure the car will be the one that was at fault

At the end of the day, the van was in front and it was up to the cars behind it to anticipate there might be a problem

Rainbowshit · 04/09/2023 20:53

Car definitely at fault.

To get our van into our driveway we have to swing out wide and several times cars have tried to undertake even though we are signalling.

ChristmasCurry · 04/09/2023 20:49

When making a left or right turn swinging out into the opposite lane is an illegal move by any vehicle. If the van was indicting left then it may go 50/50 if not then the van was in the wrong, but either way will be hard to prove unless the people in the car behind saw the if the van was not indicating.

Happened to a friend of mine a few years ago and it went 50/50 by the insurance companies.

thenightsky · 04/09/2023 20:37

Whole situation hinges on if the van was signalling to turn left in plenty of time and slowing down too.

literalviolence · 04/09/2023 20:33

The van was clearly turning. The car driver is completely at fault and was not keeping their distance.

ShowOfHands · 04/09/2023 20:23

I was taught when learning to drive (and it's in the theory test) that I should consider that a car moving into the opposite lane coming up to a left hand turn could be/probably is, turning left. The multiple choice answer for said question is "slow right down and prepare to stop".

Our driveway is a v tight left turn and to do it in one move, you have to swing out into the opposite lane by a couple of feet or manoeuvre and reverse. Once in a blue moon, an inattentive driver will fail to recognise my indicator and make a silly mistake. I slow down, give warning, stop if it's unusually busy (unusually busy being more than 3 cars on our road) etc, but people zone out and drive too close and occasionally, get a bit of a shock once they realise what I'm doing. Thankfully, I live rurally and it's a v quiet road so I've never actually been hit.

OP, you were in the wrong.

BIWI · 04/09/2023 20:19

Was it you driving the car, @Sandydonut?

SaltyCrisps · 04/09/2023 20:15

Sounds 50/50 to me. The van should not have turned until checking that it was safe to do so, and the car should not have attempted to undertake. Even without an indication it must have been obvious that the van might turn to the left, as it had moved into the other land oppose a lane on the left and stopped.

Howdoesitworkagain · 04/09/2023 20:12

The first car in the line after the van should have slowed down to a stop when the van went over to the other side of the road and slowed to a stop. It’s a highly unusual manoeuvre and any decent driver should have recognised it as such and proceeded very very carefully.

The car that hit the van is the one at fault for the accident.

Takacupokindnessyet · 04/09/2023 20:11

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:53

@aandrainwillmaketheflowersgrow if it had stopped in own lane cars would have braked. As it was, it went right, stopped, in that time, cars had caught up.

The cars should still have stopped in response though, the van being on the other side doesn't change that.

LosingMyPancakes · 04/09/2023 20:10

If there was enough time to stop when the van was in the left lane, there should've been enough time to stop if the van changed into the right. It does sound like car driver wasn't paying adequate attention - especially if the van driver reckons they were indicating and you claim that you didn't see it...

Oysterbabe · 04/09/2023 20:04

Of course it's the car's fault. Where did they think the van was going?

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 04/09/2023 20:03

FOJN · 04/09/2023 18:46

I can't vote because the van was not in the right but neither was the car.

This really. The van behaved oddly, and obviously didn't look/use mirrors before effectively crossing a lane, but the car should have been far back enough to stop. I always leave room when behind vans because they're often looking for addresses and can be erratic.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 04/09/2023 20:02

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:53

@aandrainwillmaketheflowersgrow if it had stopped in own lane cars would have braked. As it was, it went right, stopped, in that time, cars had caught up.

But the cars saw the van manoeuvre across the lane, so in their line of sight before during and after the van stopped, and should have perceived the potential hazard? Or else how would they have known what happened (they’d have just thought it was a random van parked on the other side of the road). Therefore it should have been obvious there was an unusual manoeuvre occurring and would be incumbent upon them to wait until they were certain what was happening. The way it’s been written just sounds like an impatient car driver thought, well you’re on the other side of the road now, I’ve got right of way on my side so I’m going to keep going and you’ll have to wait. Except that didn’t work out well for them.

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 04/09/2023 19:57

Whoever was driving the car (you?) was not paying attention. If a vehicle pulls into the opposite lane, you know this is a hazard (and you can usually tell from the position on the road that they’re turning) and need to slow down.

Sandydonut · 04/09/2023 19:53

@aandrainwillmaketheflowersgrow if it had stopped in own lane cars would have braked. As it was, it went right, stopped, in that time, cars had caught up.

OP posts:
ChocolateCakeOverspill · 04/09/2023 19:48

I think we’re destined to never find out the outcome and who OP is.

I also don’t understand why the vote results are as they are when so many people are saying it’s the car at fault.

MichelleScarn · 04/09/2023 19:43

Definitely car in wrong, as per pp is that whole point of stopping distance?

KrisAkabusi · 04/09/2023 19:40

Definitely car. It should have realised the van was doing something.