Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why she wants to go to the funeral

114 replies

Kraemerz · 04/09/2023 17:42

My DM has invited herself to the funeral of DMiL which is in 4 days time. She didn’t ask me or my dh if it was ok that she come she just said she’d see us there. For context my DM has probably spoken to my DMIL ten times in the 20+ years that me and my DH have been together. However it’s the fact that I asked my DM for help (for my DMiL) a few weeks ago and even though my mum could help she said no and now expects to come to the funeral is what is boiling my piss.

I also don’t have the kind of relationship with my DM where I feel comfortable crying in front of her so that’s another reason I don’t want her there. My older two adult kids also don’t want her there although they said it’s ok but you can tell they’re not comfortable with it. I know she doesn’t need permission to go to the funeral but AIBU to think she should have at least asked us if it was ok out of courtesy?

OP posts:
comedownwithme · 05/09/2023 09:18

On the face of it it does seem normal for her to attend. That said there seems to be a huge backstory involving your mum not lending a wheelchair to your MIL whilst she was dying?

If there was no reason for that other then she was being cunty then I would also be annoyed at her wanting to 'pay her respects' as pejole are putting it. If on the other hand she needed the chair herself (even part time) and couldn't lend it that's very different.

You clearly have a bit of a difficult relationship with her but it's hard to judge on little information whether you are justified in your thoughts

Dascha · 05/09/2023 09:16

Turning up at a funeral is a kindness. It can be an immense comfort to the grieving family to see they are not the only ones there, that their loved one made a wider impact on the world. I've been on the receiving end of this kindness and it has really stuck with me.

I know things are more complicated here, because mothers can be, but I do wonder if you are reading in more negatives than there are here.

Xrays · 05/09/2023 09:12

I find the whole funeral etiquette on Mumsnet odd. There is no way I’d publicly announce a funeral and I’d be really annoyed if someone who didn’t have much to do with someone when they were alive just decided to invite themselves along. Personally if you didn’t want your Mum there I just wouldn’t have told her when it was or say you haven’t made arrangements yet and then let it happen and whoops no one told her. Tough. 🤷‍♀️

Thats what we did when my Mum died. We had a direct cremation for her, some people came out of the woodwork persistently asking when the funeral was (my Dad, who she divorced when I was 13 and hadn’t spoken to properly in 30 years and my ex Mil and ex fil who seemed to think it was just etiquette to go even though they would barely speak to her). I made the decision that we would just scatter her ashes privately, me, dh and the two dc. Whenever anyone asked about a funeral I just said I hadn’t made any arrangements yet and then after it had been done I just said I’d decided to do it privately. That was that. They’ve got over it. I am not particularly close to any of them so don’t really care what they think. (My relationship with my Mum was difficult and complex too so the last thing I wanted was a fancy funeral to go to).

Lengokengo · 05/09/2023 09:04

I think if you had a narc mum, and people are replying on the basis of a normal mum, a lot of the answers won’t make much sense to your situation.

As a funeral is a public event, you can’t control whether she is there or not (unless she needs a lift etc.) I know what you mean about crying etc, that is harder for you. I think you are best mentally accepting that she has (for whatever incomprehensible reason) chosen to go. On the day acknowledge her presence, then leave her to it. Try not to engage or analyse too much as this will make you more upset. Detach.

PurBal · 05/09/2023 08:55

Tbh I think it would be weird for her not to go. My mum and my SIL parents both attended my late FIL funeral. And neither of us were married to his sons at the time.

I have been to numerous funerals where I didn’t know the deceased. The last one was the father of DH best friend. I went for the friend, so he knew he had friends around him. Funerals are for the living not the dead.

MyGardensAMess · 05/09/2023 08:54

I think it's normal. Families go to show support for each other. If my sonIL's mother died, I'd go to the funeral in a show of support for him, because I care about him. Just as my daughter's MIL came to a close family funeral to show support for her. That's what families do. If he doesn't want your mother there he can say, but that would be a bit mean.

TheNoodlesIncident · 05/09/2023 08:50

While there's nothing out of the ordinary for people to go to the funerals of people they didn't really know - usually because it feels right they should, or they want to help support the bereaved, or other well-meaning reason - in this case there is a backstory of your mum being unhelpful to the deceased and unsupportive to you/your DH.

I can understand why you would feel that it's inappropriate that she will be there. I would have found it harder to bear my in-laws' funerals if there had been people present who were there for self-centred reasons (ie to try to focus attention on themselves) rather than showing respect to the dead or support for the grieving.

I don't think you can stop her attending but I would blank her out as much as possible, and focus on being there for your DH. Behave with dignity throughout, even if your mother doesn't.

TheMerryWidow1 · 05/09/2023 08:35

I remember your other thread and thought her behaviour was awful and petty. If you don’t want her there one of you is going to have to say something. Sorry for your loss.

2chocolateoranges · 05/09/2023 08:14

I think it’s perfectly normal of the daughter in law or Son in laws parents to go to the funeral.

my mum went to my fil and mil’s funeral and my sister in laws mum, dad and sister all went to it too. Isn’t that what families do, support each other.

they only saw each other and birthdays or parties.

it’s called showing support and respect.

ColleenDonaghy · 05/09/2023 08:10

Boomboom22 · 04/09/2023 21:25

I've never heard of going to someone you don't knows funeral in England.

But you'd go to a close friend's parent's funeral surely, for example?

UsingChangeofName · 04/09/2023 22:25

Greyfoot · 04/09/2023 17:58

I think on normal circumstances it would be usual to pay respects at the funeral of an extended family member you don't see much if. My parents went to DSis MILs funeral. They weren't close and met only every few years at events at DSis' House, but still normal to go and show support to the family IMO.

Your relationships sound different though.

Fwiw, I don't think an "invitation" to a funeral is really a thing. Usually the funeral is announced publically and open to anyone. I know that changed during covid, but normally you don't need an invitation.

This.

In terms of the question you are asking on this thread, YABVU.
It isn't down to you to dictate who does or doesn't go to anyone's funeral.
If people feel they want to go to someone's funeral, then that is up to them. You don't 'invite' people to funerals, they are open to whoever feels they need to go.

I mean, clearly you've got a difficult relationship with her and people are referring to other threads, so there is clearly a back story BUT most posters can only answer the question that is there, not memorise other things described.

Ineedasitdown · 04/09/2023 21:48

so Im Irish background and have been to a few funerals of people I don't know.
However, I would be going to support the person I do know. I think its very bad form for someone to go to a funeral knowing they will upset the close relatives there. I've seen funerals used as an opportunity to cause a bit of drama a fair few times. Its not always a benign act.

I think on the back of not being supportive when dmil was alive it is unreasonable to go.

CurlewKate · 04/09/2023 21:40

@Kraemerz "be. I think it’s rude for people to rock up to a funeral when they haven’t had anything to do with the deceased for years or even worse they didn’t know at all"
It's not often that someone is unequivocally wrong-but in this case you are!

whathappenedtosummer23 · 04/09/2023 21:38

It’s pretty normal behaviour. It would be more unusual if she didn’t come

bridgetreilly · 04/09/2023 21:34

She doesn’t have to ask. Just make sure you spend your time supporting your in laws, not talking to her.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 04/09/2023 21:33

Boomboom22 · 04/09/2023 21:25

I've never heard of going to someone you don't knows funeral in England.

I'm in England and have heard of it plenty of times...

CrabbiesGingerBeer · 04/09/2023 21:31

Kraemerz · 04/09/2023 19:19

They’re not no but in my opinion they should be. I think it’s rude for people to rock up to a funeral when they haven’t had anything to do with the deceased for years or even worse they didn’t know at all.

It’s not rude if they have some connection to the deceased or his / her family. Some churches even see it as polite for church members who don’t know either to show up if they think there may be a low turnout. You may not like it but that’s not the same thing.

Obviously if the family says ‘family only’, that’s different. Even then, chances are one or more people won’t get the message and will show up anyway.

It sounds like there is a massive backstory with your mother but as a stand alone question, the answer to ‘AIBU to think my mother should have asked for permission’ is that yes, bearing in mind current funeral etiquette, you are being unreasonable. If you don’t want her there, since that goes against the commonly understood rule that distant connections of the deceased may attend to show respect / support the family members they do know, I think it’s for you to raise the subject.

Boomboom22 · 04/09/2023 21:25

I've never heard of going to someone you don't knows funeral in England.

givemeasunnyday · 04/09/2023 21:18

Snugglemonkey · 04/09/2023 20:36

I am Irish. We go to funerals for neighbours, very good friends grannys, all friend's parents, etc. So I may well be biased. But for me, the absence of your mother at your mil's funeral would be v weird.

Exactly this. I'm not in Ireland, but it is the same here. You go to the funerals of people you know, or the close relatives of people you know. A man came into work once and told me he was on the way to the funeral of the mother of the woman he dealt with at the bank. Not for a moment did I think that was odd.

AnneElliott · 04/09/2023 21:14

I think in general it would be normal. My in laws came to my dads funeral, but they hadn't refused to help out so it's a different situation.

Not sure what you can do other than maybe tell her it's a small close family funeral only?

givemeasunnyday · 04/09/2023 21:13

I would find it odd if my DM didn't go to my MIL's funeral, not that I would judge, but people here generally go to the funerals of their family's relations, and I've never heard of anyone asking permission to go to a funeral.

As for her planning to go "boiling your piss", that is extremely weird. Only on MN have I seen all this nonsense about not wanting people to go to funerals - most people are grateful to those who make the effort to turn up. They plan a funeral and people turn up - end of. None of this trying to police who attends. Bizarre indeed.

Raggammuffin · 04/09/2023 21:10

Funerals in the UK must often be very sparsely attended. I've never felt, should I go, will I wonder if they feel I have the right to go? If I feel I want to show my respects, I go.

I went to my friend's Dad's funeral a few weeks ago. I'd never met him. I went to show my friend I respected her loss. I saw her grief.

I don't get this attitude of being ''angered'' distant cousins might want to attend.

Raggammuffin · 04/09/2023 21:07

I can''t believe what I'm reading.

AnIndianWoman · 04/09/2023 20:55

Get a couple of friends to manage her at the funeral - to keep her away from family, ensure she isn’t allowed to join entorage / any memorial or events afterwards. Some people have no shame.

NoTouch · 04/09/2023 20:50

I have attended the funerals of friends and work colleagues parents I have never met. It is traditional and completely normal to do this to show support for the bereaved.

Work colleagues, friends and some of dh's family attended my dads funeral to show their support. Attending the funeral of a son in laws parent is not at all unusual, it would be seen as more usual not to attend. Trying to control attendance at a funeral is very unusual.

Sorry for your loss.