Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a bit out of order

105 replies

teaforme33 · 04/09/2023 17:32

I've seen loads of people going on holiday today. Obviously prices will have gone down as the kids go back to school but aibu to think this is a bit shitty for the kids? I'm not against term time holidays and have taken mine out before but never right at the start of a new year.

I think it's massively unfair for kids who are moving up to a new school to totally deprive them of those first few weeks of meeting new friends and settling in to a brand new environment. I would say it's also quite unsettling for those who are just moving up a year in the same school. It's still a change of dynamic, teacher, routine. By the time they get back everyone will have settled down and it just feels like they are starting the year on a disadvantage.

And yes we're in a cost of living crisis and people do what they need to but I honestly can't imagine having 6 weeks off then choosing to whip my kids out of the first week of school just to go to center parcs or something. I would rather find a cheaper holiday during the time off.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lizzieregina · 06/09/2023 16:27

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/09/2023 15:58

But I do also think it is possibly to legislate to prevent the holiday companies etc having such starkly different prices for holidays and term time

I can’t even imagine how this would be possible. It sounds from this conversation, that many people are traveling out of the UK during school time to avail of cheaper accommodations and air fare. The British government would not be able to tell resorts in Spain, France, the US etc that they can’t charge market rate during busy season. It’s economics, supply and demand.

My DH and I love a resort about 2 hours from our home. In the winter, a weekend night is $100, this summer, it was $350. They aren’t going to sell rooms for $100 until they can’t fill them. We are peeved, but won’t be going until it gets cheaper.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/09/2023 15:58

But I do also think it is possibly to legislate to prevent the holiday companies etc having such starkly different prices for holidays and term time

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/09/2023 15:53

YANBU

Generally speaking you’re right - I get that some people might feel they have to take their kids out of school for a holiday, but this isn’t the week to do it. Especially if they’re yr 7. Do it in July or something if you must.

There will obviously be some exceptions - some kids will have disabilities that mean this is the only or best time for them to be away - but broadly YANBU

Especially if parents expect the teachers to go over things again for their DC (which they will)

BeMoreBarbie · 06/09/2023 14:28

Children bring taken out of school is one of them, people do it and it doesn't matter what others think or if fines are involved - it still happens.

I don't think it matters too much in established classes so moving from year 5 to 6. And in the long run it probably doesn't matter when changing to high school (middle etc if you're three tier) but DD started high school yesterday and there is no way I would take her away at this time. It's such a big step and forget education wise, I think it's a really important time for groups and friendships to form. Some of DDs friends are starting late because of holidays (mostly back to home country) and I was surprised to hear because it is such an important time but again, in a year, they will have forgotten who was there in the first week and who wasn't.

Chanel05 · 06/09/2023 07:54

With my teacher hat on, I feel taking children out of school in the first week or two of September is very disruptive to them, not only academically but socially also. Not every class goes up with the same children year on year in primary. They are often mixed up! Imagine a child arriving in their new classroom on 10th September to a number of faces they don't know, with friendships already established. That would be very unsettling.

I'm not against term time holidays - I appreciate that parents use them in order to save a lot of money. If I wasn't in the job I am in I would too, though I have no choice. I do feel there are other weeks of the year that could be used though.

The first week isn't about just "settling in". The first day certainly is but from then on, it's maths, English and others. In secondary, children begin the new curriculum from day dot.

Flipbopboop · 06/09/2023 04:49

We're currently in a caravan park with the IL's and I'm surprised just how busy it is with school age children.
We won't be returning.

YourApplePie · 05/09/2023 23:19

As this thread demonstrates, they always have an excuse 😄

Lizzieregina · 05/09/2023 20:01

Barbiesback · 05/09/2023 16:32

@Lizzieregina woah 11 weeks off in summer. Our yearly UK school holidays total up to around 13 weeks for the entire school year. Massive difference how many weeks in total do the kids get off where you are?

Kids here get 2 weeks at Christmas, a few days at Thanksgiving and a week in the spring/Easter.

So probably almost 15 weeks with random days off (similar to UK bank holidays).

teaforme33 · 05/09/2023 17:48

@Fightyouforthatpie have a little read of the thread and you'll see.

OP posts:
Ijustdontcare · 05/09/2023 16:43

My aunt took my cousin out of school for a holiday the first two weeks of year 7. By the time she actually started her new school, kids had made friends and settled in, and she really struggled.

Fightyouforthatpie · 05/09/2023 16:40

Hufflepods · 04/09/2023 20:35

I've seen loads of people going on holiday today

Have you camped out in an airport?

Aye, OP from where have you "seen" all these holidaymakers?

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 05/09/2023 16:38

Ive been on loads of term times holidays as a kid, usually June or July. One was the first two weeks of September. I was going into year 3 and I remember vividly how lost I felt coming back to school and everyone had their own places set and friends and I was a bit lonely. I was actually in my sisters class who went into year 4, this was when mixed years classes was a thing at school.

Barbiesback · 05/09/2023 16:32

@Lizzieregina woah 11 weeks off in summer. Our yearly UK school holidays total up to around 13 weeks for the entire school year. Massive difference how many weeks in total do the kids get off where you are?

Lizzieregina · 05/09/2023 16:09

Personally I wouldn’t take my kids out at the beginning of the school year as there’s so much going on. However, I’m in the US and things must be different here as if your kids miss more than 9 days (and even if the holiday isn’t that long, you might need sick days etc) then they fail the classes (and that would be 7 classes) and will have to repeat it (and that would be a whole term at least). It could really delay their academic progress. It’s really not something that people can do here. Also they get 11 weeks off in the summer.

As for things costing more in the summer, well that’s just supply and demand. The travel industry discounts in their off season to try and fill the space.

CardiganBardigan · 05/09/2023 15:25

My camping stuff is under my bed, and only taking up less than half the space there

I would not fit camping equipment for five adult-sized people under my bed. Nor would I want to spend the money buying it all in the first place. I'd rather spend the cash on a nice week abroad in the sun - which I could afford if I went out of term time.

Carebearstare12e · 05/09/2023 15:22

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 15:18

you dont need much equipment, and it lasts decades, and storage isn't really a problem. My camping stuff is under my bed, and only taking up less than half the space there

A tent. Air mattresses. Sleeping bags. Chairs. Maybe a table. Cups, plates, cutlery. Cooking equipment. A cool box or fridge to store food. That's just off the top of my head.

That takes up less than half the space under your bed?

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 15:18

Carebearstare12e · 05/09/2023 15:15

I hate camping but that's irrelevant 😆

But camping isn't a cheap and easy holiday if you're not a camping family and don't already have all the equipment.

Plus, not everyone has the space to store all the camping stuff once the holiday is over either.

you dont need much equipment, and it lasts decades, and storage isn't really a problem. My camping stuff is under my bed, and only taking up less than half the space there

Barbiesback · 05/09/2023 15:17

@BorrowedThyme Richest 15%? Oh behave will you 🤣🤣

Carebearstare12e · 05/09/2023 15:15

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 04:11

not if they had been brought up camping, if you have always done it, kids love it. It was our normal holiday when I was bringing my kids up, and they still say nothing compares to it. As adults, they still want to come camping if they are free when we go. Many families we are close to, camp too, and are still bringing their kids up with regular camping trips, they let family friends know when and where they are camping, and we often get several families together at one site.

In lots of courtiers it is the normal family holiday. If you bring your kids up telling them luxury travel to foreign destinations is somehow their right, then obviously they will grow up with incredibly skewed ideas of what is normal, what is an immense privilege and luxury, and what is a human right!

I imagine that is what has happened to some of the posters on here, people with money to burn on foreign trips, complaining they are not getting quite as much bang for their buck as thbey feel entitled to, and ignoring the fact that most people in the world can't afford foreign trips at all, ever.

I hate camping but that's irrelevant 😆

But camping isn't a cheap and easy holiday if you're not a camping family and don't already have all the equipment.

Plus, not everyone has the space to store all the camping stuff once the holiday is over either.

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 15:10

Barbiesback · 05/09/2023 14:46

People want a different holiday to you. Why are you arguing about other people's choices? Live and let be FFS.

People can go on any holiday they want! I am not making any comment about that. I am commenting on people who are burning money by the thousand, and at the same time complaining they are hard done by!

A poster is paying £1600 on a holiday for just her and one child, and doesn't seem to be able to see that they are in an incredibly privileged position to have that money to burn - they are actually complaining about not having luxury and choice! 😂

They must surely be among the richest 15 % of the worlds population and yet are complaining about being hard up! And someone else is claiming that having access to the immense luxury and privilege of international travel is necessary for their mental health! Makes you wonder how on earth the human race survived the 100 millennium before holiday flights became available, doesn't it - they must have all been deeply depressed at all times

Barbiesback · 05/09/2023 14:46

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 13:21

I've camped for decades, so have my children, so have many of my friends, it is hard work and takes getting used to, but is an amazing experience - and if it isn't for you, there are many other cheap uk or near alternatives, nobody has to spend £1600 on a holiday. You can if you want to, obviously, but to then claim to be hard done by is utterly tone deaf

People want a different holiday to you. Why are you arguing about other people's choices? Live and let be FFS.

Barbiesback · 05/09/2023 14:44

@teaforme33 I live in the North. I don't drive so in order for me to get to Butlins my nearest was Skegnessa which is a cost and then all the food. There's having an opinion and then there's arguing about others choices. This debate seems to have fallen off track, like usual people moaning about others spending its all relative isn't it. It costs to travel to UK holidays it isn't always cheaper like you are making out and lastly some of us want good weather. I couldn't really give a hoot if you see this as luxury or not. I deem it as shallow to assume so much based off a holiday which one has saved for!

BorrowedThyme · 05/09/2023 13:21

CardiganBardigan · 05/09/2023 11:00

You're obsessed with camping.

I've camped for decades, so have my children, so have many of my friends, it is hard work and takes getting used to, but is an amazing experience - and if it isn't for you, there are many other cheap uk or near alternatives, nobody has to spend £1600 on a holiday. You can if you want to, obviously, but to then claim to be hard done by is utterly tone deaf

BitOutOfPractice · 05/09/2023 11:38

Well it might be happening now has it?

teaforme33 · 05/09/2023 11:15

@BitOutOfPractice but confused by the verified by Facebook comment. Are you suggesting they aren't really on holiday?

I mean some people do lie and exaggerate on Facebook but sharing photos on planes and on Spanish beaches is pretty conclusive I'd say...

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread