Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pretend to be my husband?

60 replies

pontipinemum · 04/09/2023 17:03

I've been trying to sort an issue with an online supplier. I decided to just pretend to be my husband in order to make sure they would talk to me. Gave my name ''David'' think very much so a mans name.

The guy on the phone clearly didn't believe me, (there is no mistaking I am a woman by my voice), and said, can I confirm this is MR DAVID Smith which I just said yes. He couldn't really say well I don't believe you are a man so he had to proceed with the call as if I was DH.

More so a what do you think not an AIBU

YABU - That's bad to pretend like that
YANBU - Got the job done. No harm

OP posts:
TheGirlFromTomorrow · 04/09/2023 22:20

It's absolutely fine. Although at work I once had the most hilarious conversation with a man pretending to be his wife and putting on a lady's voice. He got more and more angry and abusive, all while trying to keep up this high pitched voice.

In the end, he said he was going to come down to the office to try and do me in, and I had to warn reception. I had a picture of him I'd got online (he had a long history of abusive behaviour, including to a judge so there was lots about him to find), and I had to say he looks like this but he might come in a wig and lipstick!

He didn't show up, alas.

IAmAnIdiot123 · 04/09/2023 22:13

I do it all the time when I call EE. No idea why I set my phone up under his account (probably a deal years ago) but to speak to them, I have to put on a man's voice and pretend to be DP.

pontipinemum · 04/09/2023 22:11

@Globules it was the 1st time I've done it. I had always previously said no it's his wife he wants me to sort it. Which often didn't work.

@EffortlessDesmond and @Missedmytoe they really do need processes in place. Surely they are situations that come up frequently enough.

OP posts:
Karwomannghia · 04/09/2023 22:10

I can honestly say I don’t have this problem, my name comes first because I’ve set everything up! In fact dh used to get called Mr my maiden name before we got married.

lorelairoryemily · 04/09/2023 21:53

I do this all the time. I always say I am my husband and they usually pause for a second and then ask an additional security question and proceed.

Genericusername2 · 04/09/2023 21:45

In my work (call centre) we are not allowed to assume anyone's gender. If they pass security then that's it, it's fine, you carry on with the call.

Could be trans and you cause offence, could be a medical reason they don't wish to discuss.

Be aware though if you do this with the bank, they may flag it to their fraud department for investigation (and listen back to any previous calls) and you may find your bank account blocked or closed.

fisherhatesgravel · 04/09/2023 21:01

You should have told them you are a trans man, they wouldn't have dared question you then 😂

AnIndianWoman · 04/09/2023 20:59

HSBC UK does this a lot with joint accounts - assumes the man is the lead applicant even when they’re only the secondary card holder.

Missedmytoe · 04/09/2023 20:54

I'm sure I've posted about this before but years ago a close relative died. As next of kin I was trying to sort things out, and contacted one of their service providers to advise of the death so I could get a final bill.
They refused to speak to me. Wanted to speak to the account holder. Despite me saying multiple times that they were dead (obviously a quite distressing conversation). In the end I suggested that they had a seance as that was the only way that the person was going to be able to speak to them.

Newuser75 · 04/09/2023 20:36

I took my car to the garage as there was an issue with it. Told them what the issue was and left the car.

They proceeded to ring my husband up (had his number on file) to discuss what was wrong with the car.

  1. I'd already told them
  2. It's my car that he never drives
  3. He didn't have a clue what was wrong with it!!

Maddening

Globules · 04/09/2023 20:23

You sound like this is the first time you've done it.

Pretended to be XH phoning companies several times during our 20 yr marriage. It was easier than continuing to nag him to do whatever needed to be done.

"Yes, this is Mr Glo Bules" "Like I said, I can confirm this is Mr Glo Bules"

I felt for the people speaking to me. They knew I was lying but could do nothing about it.

gibegobble · 04/09/2023 20:18

Yes we bought a house in DH's name (reasons why) and we dealt with an online solicitor, I did the whole conveyancing process pretending to be him 😂 I even set up an email address [email protected] o m
So that I could have full access and the emails wouldn't get mixed up with anything in his own inbox, I answered every email and uploaded and sent back every document signing all the emails off Mr Husbands name 🤣

It still makes me chuckle now!

Duttercup · 04/09/2023 20:09

We've bought and sold two houses with me signing everything as my husband so I think yours is a fairly minor incident.

EffortlessDesmond · 04/09/2023 20:05

I quite often claimed to be DMIL after she was diagnosed with dementia to deal with utility companies. It was simpler than explaining powers of attorney to a Philippino call centre. On the odd occasion it didn't work, I escalated and escalated the calls until I hit a level of competence, at which point I explained that they needed a bypass system for family members managing contracts for people with dementia. DMIL latterly could not manage an automated caller menu with three choices, much less carry out the reset tests to reinitialise lines and signals. I must have wasted a 40 hour working week all told trying to get her phone sorted. I will never, ever deal with TalkTalk, ever again. Never encountered such unhelpful customer service teams.

pontipinemum · 04/09/2023 19:26

FeatherBlack · 04/09/2023 17:48

One of our utility bills has dh and my name on it. All the bills forever have had both our names on. I set up the account, I manage it. I have my phone number on it, my email. They ring me looking for him. I say no you can't speak to him. If you want to deal with this household you can speak to me.
They look at the bills, say sorry, decide they will speak to me after all. Then we sort out whatever needs sorting. Then next year, same thing happens again.
I only stay with them because they have the best offers.

I recently applied for a gov scheme thing. I put my name as adult 1, followed by DH, DS. The cards were issued under DH's name. I was not impressed!! We also recently changed electricity company and I specifically asked for both our names to be on the bill so I have an easy to get proof of address, guess who's name is not on the bill.

Stupidest one was my aunt phone a utility company after gran died. They said they could only deal with the account holder...... they were so unhelpful. My aunt just called back, pretended to be gran and closed the acc.

OP posts:
Davros · 04/09/2023 18:23

I've done this before. I just said I was him and thought "go on, challenge over whether you think I'm a man or a woman". Not allowed these days...

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 04/09/2023 18:01

I have never done this myself but I have worked in call centres. We were always told that if someone said it was them and passed other security questions then we just had to take their word for it that it was them 🤷‍♀️. So if the account name was under Mrs Susan Potts and the person on the other end with the deep voice said it was them then there was nowt we could do 🤷‍♀️.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 04/09/2023 17:54

FeatherBlack · 04/09/2023 17:48

One of our utility bills has dh and my name on it. All the bills forever have had both our names on. I set up the account, I manage it. I have my phone number on it, my email. They ring me looking for him. I say no you can't speak to him. If you want to deal with this household you can speak to me.
They look at the bills, say sorry, decide they will speak to me after all. Then we sort out whatever needs sorting. Then next year, same thing happens again.
I only stay with them because they have the best offers.

It's both unfathomable - and utterly outrageous isn't it, that this still happens in 2023?! Shock

FeatherBlack · 04/09/2023 17:49

Meant to answer your actual question, I say, in those circumstances, whatever gets the job done...

FeatherBlack · 04/09/2023 17:48

One of our utility bills has dh and my name on it. All the bills forever have had both our names on. I set up the account, I manage it. I have my phone number on it, my email. They ring me looking for him. I say no you can't speak to him. If you want to deal with this household you can speak to me.
They look at the bills, say sorry, decide they will speak to me after all. Then we sort out whatever needs sorting. Then next year, same thing happens again.
I only stay with them because they have the best offers.

SmudgeButt · 04/09/2023 17:48

I have the opposite problem in that I have a fairly deep voice for a woman coupled with a name that most people assume is one for a man. I've had a few phone calls go dead silent when I correct them about my name and say that I am NOT Mr Butt but Ms. They prob think I'm mid trans or something.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 04/09/2023 17:47

Comedycook · 04/09/2023 17:35

Will they though? Who do you mean? If they have to speak to both account holders, than fair enough...but I'm struggling to believe they will only deal with your husband?

I have to admit, in 35-ish years of being with my DH, I have never been asked to speak to him only - when it's been anything 'joint.'

Laiste · 04/09/2023 17:36

The guy on the phone clearly didn't believe me, (there is no mistaking I am a woman by my voice)

YANBU - Got the job done. No harm

It didn't in itself ''get the job done'' though, did it? If he didn't believe you.

Comedycook · 04/09/2023 17:35

DustyLee123 · 04/09/2023 17:10

Well done. I hate the fact that the people we pay money too will only deal with DH. Why is it beyond them to deal with two people who can be named on an account 🤷🏼‍♀️

Will they though? Who do you mean? If they have to speak to both account holders, than fair enough...but I'm struggling to believe they will only deal with your husband?

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 04/09/2023 17:33

This is fine @pontipinemum of course, as long as you're not pretending to be your husband for nefarious purposes - to find out personal and private information that he would not want you to know etc. But if you're just trying to sort something out, (that's something to do with the two of you, or he has asked you to sort,) then of course, you're not being unreasonable to pretend to be him.

I have got quite a deep voice, (think a Rula Lenska type voice,) and I can switch to sounding exactly like the man at the drop of a hat. And I have pretended to be my husband numerous time to try and sort stuff out for ourselves and for him. I do quite a lot of the life admin, but sometimes the person/company I am talking to wants to get his permission to discuss something with me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread