Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter wants to live with her father and stepmother

194 replies

parismorin · 04/09/2023 13:48

Hello,

This is my first time posting and I feel upset, so please be kind (even though I may be in the wrong). Also English is not my first language.

My ex-DH and I divorced two years ago. I instigated this as I realised I did not truly love him anymore. We have four children - DS 23, twins DDs 21, and our little one DD11.

Since then he has bought another flat where he is living with his new partner, a younger woman who does not have children but I understand had previously always wanted them.

Originally our daughter DD3 continued to live with me and my DM in the family house. This always worked because my DM would provide childcare and stability in addition to me & my ex-DH; I work long hours in a senior position with a lot of travel. However, my DM sadly died recently.

After a lot of discussion and tears, my DD admitted to her father she wanted to move out and live with them. It is true she does not have enough parental presence at home, I know that. Whereas my DH has regular hours, can WFH, and his new partner is freelance and not working so much. I know it makes sense. But I feel like my little girl is leaving me and I'm so sad.

For context, my DH is a different nationality to me (we live in my home city) and his new partner is the same nationality as him & doesn't speak my language, so I also worry my DD will be in a little bubble of their nationality, or is rejecting my background... I know that is irrational.

I feel somewhat jealous of the new partner - I don't want to be with my DH any more but she is a little over 10 years younger than him, very pretty, funny, kind. He is a very good man and devoted father, we just are not as compatible as we once were.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Anxioys · 04/09/2023 18:16

I faced it and my ex had made this woman pregnant in a year. It did not work out, and I now have to keep this woman at arm's length out of a reasonable and real concern that her need to be a mother overwhelms her judgment. If I was not careful she would claim my children as her own.

Emotionally it is a minefield because you do not know if things will last, what is the motivation of former partners etc

Take it slow, incrementally, and test. Do not make radical changes.

parismorin · 04/09/2023 18:10

Anxioys · 04/09/2023 18:08

Yes. This would bother me and I would be thinking carefully about the next five years. It will all change and probably not in this child's favour.

This is also something I have been thinking about, but I really don't believe she is going to pursue this anymore ... without disclosing what I know about her situation [she and my ex-DH has shared what is necessary for me to know], there would have to be some medical intervention, she is late 30s, he is 50, he definitely does not want more children, she has had some losses.

OP posts:
Anxioys · 04/09/2023 18:08

Strawberryboost · 04/09/2023 18:03

She’s younger than him
She wants children

any promises she makes before having children re where she is happy to live and raise them should be regarded as very tentative only

Yes. This would bother me and I would be thinking carefully about the next five years. It will all change and probably not in this child's favour.

parismorin · 04/09/2023 18:06

Thank you both. A few posters have said I am being very generous to my ex-husband and hard on myself. That is funny because in real life I really can be very unfair, judgemental, demanding, etc., and on here I am trying to be more reflective.

Believe me, I could complain about my ex-DH here! but if the new partner wants a slightly grumpy, reserved, paunchy Tory who is otherwise a very nice man, she is welcome to him ... ;)

OP posts:
Strawberryboost · 04/09/2023 18:03

She’s younger than him
She wants children

any promises she makes before having children re where she is happy to live and raise them should be regarded as very tentative only

EarringsandLipstick · 04/09/2023 17:57

OP, I agree with PP that you sound very self-aware, generous about your ex and his new partner, and focused on what's best for your DD, which is lovely.

However, I would be a bit cautious of being so praiseworthy of your exH DP, while denigrating yourself.

I would also be really careful about making significant changes to access and living arrangements.

I agree, your DD spending more time at your exH's house might be practical and helpful to her at the moment. But like a PP said, I would set this as a trial period, with a clearly defined review date.

I would also do my utmost to facilitate shared access - as close to 50:50 as is practicable. At the moment, he sees her every 2nd weekend with a midweek contact at times - are you sure she (and they) are ready for a more like full-time arrangement?

Also, she is at such a crucial point in terms of needing her mum.

For me, I would do what I could to be more available for her, if that is at all possible with work (and I know it's challenging).

Secondly, I would make a plan to as you suggest, sell your current home to be closer to exH.

Thirdly, I'd work through as many scenarios as possible and discuss these with your DD and exH / his DP, don't rush to 'DD will move to live with exH' as the only option.

I admit, I am a bit biased in this matter as I'm also a single parent and my DC have only ever lived me with, had limited and now no, contact with their father, due to his treatment of them. I couldn't imagine them spending the majority of the time away from me.

Just be careful about your plans, particularly in this time of bereavement (I'm sorry for your loss).

MsWazowski · 04/09/2023 17:53

And I’m so sorry you’ve lost your mum. Your head must be all over the place.

parismorin · 04/09/2023 17:51

MsWazowski · 04/09/2023 17:50

OP, you sound both very self aware and like you are putting your daughter first. I’ve not been in your position, but sympathise. This thread is descending into a bit of a bunfight, so don’t get distracted by that.

I think you could suggest a 6 month trial period, but make sure you set your contact time with your daughter and stick to it. Review after the trial so everyone is aware the arrangement isn’t set in stone and you can adjust things if needed.

Thank you, that is what I am planning to do now.

OP posts:
MsWazowski · 04/09/2023 17:50

OP, you sound both very self aware and like you are putting your daughter first. I’ve not been in your position, but sympathise. This thread is descending into a bit of a bunfight, so don’t get distracted by that.

I think you could suggest a 6 month trial period, but make sure you set your contact time with your daughter and stick to it. Review after the trial so everyone is aware the arrangement isn’t set in stone and you can adjust things if needed.

parismorin · 04/09/2023 17:50

Strawberryboost · 04/09/2023 17:08

You only divorced two years ago?

he moved pretty quick.

Ha, yes, I have made that point. It was something of a cliché at the start.

Divorced man with younger woman. But I was the one who instigated the divorce. And they the relationship was accelerated somewhat (his words) by her visa situation. But they seem very happy and well suited.

OP posts:
NonMiDispiace · 04/09/2023 17:48

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 04/09/2023 14:47

There is no English stiff upper lip when it comes to admitting you don’t want to prioritise your child 🙄 it’s not something the vast majority of British people agree with. We put our children first, before our own lives and careers. We love our kids more than ourselves.

Pompous crap, what a pretentious statement to make to a mother who’s clearly trying to do the best for her child.

parismorin · 04/09/2023 17:47

parismorin · 04/09/2023 17:44

Actually, the partner is from another country in the U.K.

He made it clear to her he would have to stay in Paris for his children, and although it's a new city for her she has committed to this.

Actually, I'm the one who has to travel to different places around the world and have been offered jobs in various Francophone / Anglo countries - he is more stable

I mean, he and his partner don't have a natural 'base' to return to in the U.K because they are from different countries.

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 04/09/2023 17:46

ActDottie · 04/09/2023 17:42

Sorry you lost me when you said your career is important to you. It sounds like it’s more important than your daughter which is sad.

She’s a single mother - how else is she going to support herself and her daughter ? And as has been said numerous times, men prioritise their careers as the norm. Why is it so wrong for a woman to do the same ? And given that the OP is doing her best to ensure her DD has what she needs, why is it sad ?

parismorin · 04/09/2023 17:46

SpringViolet · 04/09/2023 17:40

This is something to consider. If your DD lives quite your ex for a period of time, he would be primary carer and could try for sole custody if he decides to return to the UK. DD is only 11 so quite some time before she’s an adult. Not sure of the legalities of that and I presume DD is a citizen of your home country? Does she have dual citizenship which might complicate matters. Would he have to have your permission to move into a different area even within your country?

Something to consider the legalities of with professional legal advice before making any decision.

If that’s not an issue, I would let her go in the knowledge she can change her mind at any time. Obviously ensuring there is properly scheduled time with you. She may well flip back and forth through her teenage years. Also a good idea to move closer to him, so you’re both close by?

The fear that you may be usurped by the new partner is a valid one and totally understandable but you can’t let that dictate your decision on your DD’s wellbeing as you say yourself, you’re not around much. She may well not like the new partner when they’re living together day in day out! Or the relationship may break down later down the line. Nothing is set in stone. Just continue being a great mum to her. She’ll benefit from both of you in her life if the new partner is as nice as you say she is.

I do feel confident he will stay in Paris - he has some friends who he takes the Eurostar to see, but his parents died a few years ago, and he wants to be close to his children, and he likes his job here. I don't think it would be in his character to just take her!

OP posts:
parismorin · 04/09/2023 17:44

Strawberryboost · 04/09/2023 17:09

Both him and his partner are British.

i would be Petrified re their future plans to return. Petrified

Actually, the partner is from another country in the U.K.

He made it clear to her he would have to stay in Paris for his children, and although it's a new city for her she has committed to this.

Actually, I'm the one who has to travel to different places around the world and have been offered jobs in various Francophone / Anglo countries - he is more stable

OP posts:
ActDottie · 04/09/2023 17:42

Sorry you lost me when you said your career is important to you. It sounds like it’s more important than your daughter which is sad.

SpringViolet · 04/09/2023 17:40

Strawberryboost · 04/09/2023 17:09

Both him and his partner are British.

i would be Petrified re their future plans to return. Petrified

This is something to consider. If your DD lives quite your ex for a period of time, he would be primary carer and could try for sole custody if he decides to return to the UK. DD is only 11 so quite some time before she’s an adult. Not sure of the legalities of that and I presume DD is a citizen of your home country? Does she have dual citizenship which might complicate matters. Would he have to have your permission to move into a different area even within your country?

Something to consider the legalities of with professional legal advice before making any decision.

If that’s not an issue, I would let her go in the knowledge she can change her mind at any time. Obviously ensuring there is properly scheduled time with you. She may well flip back and forth through her teenage years. Also a good idea to move closer to him, so you’re both close by?

The fear that you may be usurped by the new partner is a valid one and totally understandable but you can’t let that dictate your decision on your DD’s wellbeing as you say yourself, you’re not around much. She may well not like the new partner when they’re living together day in day out! Or the relationship may break down later down the line. Nothing is set in stone. Just continue being a great mum to her. She’ll benefit from both of you in her life if the new partner is as nice as you say she is.

Baconisdelicious · 04/09/2023 17:38

Your career is important to you but giving your DD a stable home environment isn’t? Fuck me she should definitely go live with her father

jesus wept. Kick a woman whilst she’s down, why don’t you? Unfortunately, providing a stable home environment when you are a single parent often means having to make sure work is a priority.

We put our children first, before our own lives and careers. We love our kids more than ourselves

wtf? Loving our children is not the sole domain of British people. Every nationality out there loves it’s children and wants what is best for them. Lucky you that you’ve never had to face such a challenging situation and work out what is best.

OP, do ignore the idiots. I am sorry you are going through this. No easy answers for any of you.

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 04/09/2023 17:37

harriethoyle · 04/09/2023 17:31

Congratulations. You managed to be vile, goady and full of tosh within one sentence. Quite the feat!!

Add racist, xenophobic, misogynistic and smug, and you’ve summed it up nicely !!

Viviennemary · 04/09/2023 17:36

This does happen sometimes and it's sad. But maybe she will want to come home to you after a short time with them. The grass is always greene r

MrsPerfect12 · 04/09/2023 17:33

Strawberryboost · 04/09/2023 17:09

Both him and his partner are British.

i would be Petrified re their future plans to return. Petrified

ex DH and partner returning to the UK is something you have to consider and have. It's maybe not planned for but in 2 years who knows.

Rosscameasdoody · 04/09/2023 17:33

Motnight · 04/09/2023 16:26

I am not outraged. I agreed with a post, and as I said would have whether the Op was male or female. Why are you outraged at this?!

Not outraged at all. Puzzled as to why you would agree with such a misogynistic viewpoint though. Are you a man ?

Mirabai · 04/09/2023 17:31

OP - are you sure that you’re not feeling hurt that your DD suggested it, which has made you feel insecure - seeing yourself as a shit mum focusing on your perceived flaws and seeing this other woman as some kind of superior domestic goddess who can give DD something you can’t?

You’re come across as super detached here but you say you’re very emotional in real life. So what has happened? Are you in some kind of shock?

Or are you just trying very hard to be pragmatic and be the bigger person and put your DD first?

harriethoyle · 04/09/2023 17:31

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 04/09/2023 14:47

There is no English stiff upper lip when it comes to admitting you don’t want to prioritise your child 🙄 it’s not something the vast majority of British people agree with. We put our children first, before our own lives and careers. We love our kids more than ourselves.

Congratulations. You managed to be vile, goady and full of tosh within one sentence. Quite the feat!!

Mari9999 · 04/09/2023 17:24

@parismorin
Your daughter is fortunate to be surrounded by love and acceptance. Not many children in split environments or so fortunate If you all work together to bring out the best in the transitions this can be a great example of best practices in co parenting. Let this be a collaborative rather than a competitive experience for all of you.