Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to consider homeschooling a 13 year old on a very small budget?

87 replies

Imustbecrazy123 · 04/09/2023 13:42

My son is about to enter year 8 and really doesn’t want to go back despite his younger sister starting year 7.
He has ADHD and dyslexia and has struggled his way through primary school, not just academically but also socially he has never ever made a solid group of friends and we hoped so much that this would change come secondary school but it hasn’t - in fact it’s got worse as he’s so aware of being left out / laughed at for being in the bottom sets now.
He isn’t motivated at all so I’m really worried I would struggle to get him to do any work at home and with GCSEs only a few years away this is a real concern
Financially, I’ll be ruined as will need to give up my job but I need to help his self esteem 😢

OP posts:
Boo1321 · 04/09/2023 22:34

“Why do people act like every child needs to do GCSEs?”

Erm, because it’s the most straightforward pathway to a good job and higher education. Even if you don’t want to use them having them provides opportunity and freedom. Or you can squander the opportunity your children would otherwise have, it’s up to you. 😉

Thethuthinang · 04/09/2023 20:49

I live in a part of the world where for various reasons there are many secular homeschoolers (child actors, ballet dancers, sick kids, gifted kids, LD kids...). My son, who was a square peg in a round hole in the school system, was homeschooled starting age 12. He thrived and was very happy. He had a mix of online school, group classes, and parent-taught classes using quality materials. We spent much less than we would have on private school. I know there are free classes (MIT for example) and used curriculum for sale cheap, so one can homeschool on a small budget. However, it was critical to son's happiness that he had other kids to hang out with. Lots of them. Also, it has affected my career, and even now that he has graduated I will not easily be able to restart my earning. In your situation I would proceed with caution.

Outnumberedbyboys2 · 04/09/2023 20:35

I think a lot of posters don't understand that being socially isolated at home is 1000x better than being socially isolated at school.
I don't know anything about home education but it's something I'd consider to protect my child from being damaged by regular school.

MrsLeonFarrell · 04/09/2023 20:35

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 20:15

It's also important to note that only 15% of autistic people work because it's very very hard to not burn out and become mentally ill. And nobody should be made to feel that they are worthless because of this.

I completely agree with your last sentence, and it's great that your daughter has found a career path that suits her. That is the sort of situation I alluded to in my post.

I was speaking about the OP's situation which is different. Teaching someone with dyslexia can be difficult at home without support and if the OP is already worried about expense it felt only fair to warn her that exams are expensive to take privately.

None of that is to say she shouldn't home educate but I have seen far too many take their children out of school without thinking everything through or doing research to not point out a couple of potential issues

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 20:15

It's also important to note that only 15% of autistic people work because it's very very hard to not burn out and become mentally ill. And nobody should be made to feel that they are worthless because of this.

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 20:13

@MrsLeonFarrell if you aren't able to get GCSEs then there is an alternative qualification that you can get. And some people will never pass GCSEs. It doesn't make them unemployable.

My daughter was unable to sit her SATS - the school didn't think she was reasonably able to do them. I took her out of school because the vast crowds of people was destroying her mental health. She doesn't lack intelligence - she just can't learn in a classroom and school.

She spends a lot of her time at a riding school because it turns out that she's naturally very good at riding horses. She is able to take an NVQ in Equestrian studies and won't need any GCSEs for this. And then she'd be able to work on a yard which will be an ideal path for her.

ThisIsMyHappyFacee · 04/09/2023 18:17

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 15:08

Why do people act like every child needs to do GCSEs?

It's not the right route for everyone. I can tell there are very few HE people on this thread.

100% this! People are so conditioned to believe it's the only way, it's a failing system that is failing many. Best thing you can do for your child is remove them

parietal · 04/09/2023 18:12

in this context, HE will mess up your job and your family budget. and DC will still be socially isolated and won't get much of an education.

so I think HE is a non-starter.

either look for other schools or help him learn to deal with the school he is in. being in the bottom set does not mean being laughed at, and if it does, then school should crack down hard on the bullies who are laughing.

MrsLeonFarrell · 04/09/2023 18:00

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 15:08

Why do people act like every child needs to do GCSEs?

It's not the right route for everyone. I can tell there are very few HE people on this thread.

Whilst it is true that you don't need the vast number of GCSEs schools encourage it is very hard to get anywhere these days without Maths and an English GCSE, unless you can pull strings to get a job and that isn't as easy for most people. The OP talks about having a small budget and GCSEs are very expensive to sit as an external candidate and it's often hard to find somewhere that will accept externals, unless you can get to the centre in Hampshire.

Speaking as someone whose children were home educated. Things have got a lot harder in recent years to manoeuvre outside the system unfortunately.

Singleandproud · 04/09/2023 15:41

Make life about more than school, instead of deregistering him get him involved in something he can thrive at to see that he is good at it, somethi g working with animals or with his hands would be great. Our local wildlife Trust has young wardens and they get taught how to safely use hand tools etc and really contribute to the conservation of the area. Hell make friends and no one needs to know his school group. Once school becomes a smaller part of his day it won't feel so bad.

Get him focused in the future and his choices so he has a realistic flight path to work towards. Apprenticeships, work experience etc etc it can take the pressure off and motivate if he knows what he needs to get to move forward and what alternatives there are.

Lucyintheskywithcubiczirconia · 04/09/2023 15:38

I would try posting on HE boards where you will get advice from people who’ve been there and done it. It’s horrible watching your child’s self esteem slowly crumbling. There are a few Facebook discount groups for home ed families which have been so helpful for us. I had to give up my job to do it and am on a tight budget - I’m not sure I’d have been able to do it without the Facebook groups and purely use fb for home ed purposes now. We are lucky that our local area has a huge amount of home ed families, clubs and classes. It’s a scary leap of faith and important to do a lot of careful research first. Whatever you decide, I hope things improve for your son.

Stompythedinosaur · 04/09/2023 15:37

I think I'd pursue other options first. I'd look for opportunities to meet friends with similar interests outside school. Also, I'd be pushing the school to do more.

I think you run the risk of going from a dc struggling academically and socially to a dc struggling academically, socially and financially, in a family that is under significant pressure.

OvertakenByLego · 04/09/2023 15:30

Rather than deregistering I second requesting an EHCNA. Then, if school is inappropriate you can pursue EOTAS. A good EHCP can fund far more than the vast majority of parents can afford to fund via EHE.

ToBrieOrNotToBrieThatIsTheQuestion · 04/09/2023 15:18

Would a non-selective private day school, at the more budget end of the market, be an option?

It's never cheap, but the cost certainly cheaper than giving up work, if it's just one child - the one near me which is non selective and has a reputation for being good with dyslexia etc charges £15,600 per year including exam fees and extra curriculars.

Foxesandsquirrels · 04/09/2023 15:15

I know this is easier said than done OP but I wouldn't be suggesting anything to your 13 year old. My very dyslexic 15 year old is moving to a specialist school this week. She has a very similar profile to your son and no, she's not kicking and screaming but she's not over the moon. Frankly, I am the adult and I know this will be better for her. I would never imagine burdening her with that choice at such a young age. It's not a choice. It's what I believe is best for her and she can make her own post 16 choices.
If this doesn't work out she can blame me, not herself. That's a very stressful thing to put on a child.

Seashellies · 04/09/2023 15:15

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 15:08

Why do people act like every child needs to do GCSEs?

It's not the right route for everyone. I can tell there are very few HE people on this thread.

Because they give you options. Sure exams aren't the be all and end all, and they're not a fair representation of someone's abilities; but rightly or wrongly they're needed to access further training and jobs. There are some you can get without a formal education or any grades, but realistically its going to limit someone- and not just in terms of academic jobs and careers. It's a huge decision to make when they're young as whilst they can go on to do exams when they're older it's harder to find the time tbh.

Numbersarefun · 04/09/2023 15:13

Could you keep him at home for this year and maybe next and really concentrate on reading, writing and maths so that he could go back next year or in Y10?
Find out what he really enjoys and help him to learn through that.

beeswaxinc · 04/09/2023 15:12

@Tambatamba Yes that's absolutely a fair point. You are right personally I have no experience of this so OP ignore my post apart from the solidarity.

If you don't think he's going to do well academically then that's fair enough but I'd make sure I discussed everything at length with the school and see if you can find some support; he is only 13 after all and doesn't have the same understanding of implications on his future etc. I'm sure lots of kids who struggle to fit in would jump at the chance of leaving school but is it always the right choice? I honestly don't know but will follow the thread to hear from more experienced posters as it may help my niece.

I genuinely didn't even know it was an option to not do GCSEs if HE, I thought it was required!

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 15:11

CurlewKate · 04/09/2023 14:32

"“he’s so aware of being left out / laughed at for being in the bottom sets” well, he will have to get over that.
No he bloody doesn't!!

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Pinkdelight3 · 04/09/2023 15:11

i suggested trying another school but he is convinced that will be even worse as nobody will know him / dislike him and everything will be brand new so a doubly blow

He doesn't know that and he's a kid so I wouldn't put that decision on him. Of course he's afraid of the unknown and scarred by past experiences but to write off all other schools because of his limited experience doesn't set him up well for trying new things in future. This school sounds like a bad fit but there'll be others where they're better with SEN or have more activities he likes or a more inclusive approach. It isn't homeschooling or this school or nothing. Don't leave it up to him to set the tone. Take the lead and give it much more of a shot before giving up on formal education when you're not well set up for it and it might exacerbate his issues and fears.

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 15:08

Why do people act like every child needs to do GCSEs?

It's not the right route for everyone. I can tell there are very few HE people on this thread.

beeswaxinc · 04/09/2023 15:07

Sounds really difficult OP :(

My mum is having to consider home schooling her grand daughter (my niece) and the cost alone is quite prohibitive.

One thing I would say about his schooling is, he can't be sitting alone in the classroom in his bottom sets! I was very bright and got all A* - B GCSES, but I was in bottom sets in year 7 and 8 solely predicted on SATS scores in primary school.

I would genuinely consider myself home schooling once my kids get to secondary if they are really struggling, but I'd also look at trying to maybe work with the school and really push for support socially and academically.

Even if it takes you hours a week of effort with the school, it will still be less than home schooling him especially if he is only just started Y8 now; that's a long road ahead.

At the end of the day though mental health and wellbeing come first. What you need to consider is if HS is the answer to that problem though, or if you can teach him things like managing anxiety, resilience etc to help him cope with MS school.

Foxesandsquirrels · 04/09/2023 15:02

You're far better off applying for an echp and using your time to fight for that than home ed. Esp if it leaves you in a precarious financial situation.
Please try to apply for DLA as well.

LorW · 04/09/2023 15:01

Is there a specialist school near you (I know these are hard to get a place in) or another school with good SEN department? my SS goes to one and has ADHD, he finally has some friends after a really bad time at primary, and he can read now when he left school not being able to, gets plenty of support and all the other kids are like him, he won’t do GCSEs but will do equivalent while being supported so may be an option.

Imustbecrazy123 · 04/09/2023 14:55

Thank you for the replies
Socially he is immature compared to other children his age but he has no trouble making friends In social settings such as skateparks / karate but literally not one friend at school
They are all generally bright children in the local primary here ( I worked there so o know the intake ) which I thought would change come secondary but it just hasn’t
I can’t see how he will cope or pass GCSEs even in school so I’m not sure it’s doing him a disservice taking him out of somewhere that’s knocking his self esteem when the end result is white possibly going to be the same.
i suggested trying another school but he is convinced that will be even worse as nobody will know him / dislike him and everything will be brand new so a doubly blow

OP posts: