Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to consider homeschooling a 13 year old on a very small budget?

87 replies

Imustbecrazy123 · 04/09/2023 13:42

My son is about to enter year 8 and really doesn’t want to go back despite his younger sister starting year 7.
He has ADHD and dyslexia and has struggled his way through primary school, not just academically but also socially he has never ever made a solid group of friends and we hoped so much that this would change come secondary school but it hasn’t - in fact it’s got worse as he’s so aware of being left out / laughed at for being in the bottom sets now.
He isn’t motivated at all so I’m really worried I would struggle to get him to do any work at home and with GCSEs only a few years away this is a real concern
Financially, I’ll be ruined as will need to give up my job but I need to help his self esteem 😢

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 05/09/2023 07:23

I agree there is a lot of narrow thinking on this thread. I've been there with a child crying and begging and becoming a shadow of their former self. It's not easy to get help, CAHMS etc are now so overwhelmed. OP in the immediate moment, try and get him in but explain you are looking at options. If he knows there may be light at the end of the tunnel it may be enough to help him cope for now. In the meantime, be a total pain in the arse to his tutor and head of year (I'm a teacher by the way). Ask for a meeting with specific outcomes in mind about what they can do to mitigate his situation . Would he join clubs or go to the library? That's often a sanctuary for these kinds of situations. Others have given excellent suggestions re home ed, different provisions etc. There's a v v small school near me, private, but only about 5k for the whole year. They're hard to find but do exist and may be the right thing.

lepopo · 05/09/2023 07:08

That's really tough OP, in your situation I would contact the school before doing anything, I think people will disagree but I wouldn't send him in until a meeting was arranged to discuss all of this with his HOY/pastoral team, I would send an email today explaining what is happening and wait for the school to get back to you, you would take the risk of being fined here though.

Are apprenticeships still available at schools or is it not the done thing anymore?

RedHelenB · 05/09/2023 07:06

Does he know why he isn't making friends with the others in his set? Whether it's bottom or top shouldn't matter, you are still with the same people most of the day.
Most schools have an SEN room where kids can sit together at breaks/lunch and make friendships that way, often with other year groups too.

LIZS · 05/09/2023 07:06

What support os he getting fir his additional needs? Maybe tackling that will put him in a better place. Even if you homeschooled that would be a barrier to his learning that you would need to address, but it may be easier to do so in a school environment. Contact the sendco and explain how it is impacting his confidence.

Britneyfan · 05/09/2023 07:00

I understand why you’re considering it but I’d think very carefully before doing it if it would mean you can’t work and would put extra pressure on your finances if they aren’t great already during this cost of living crisis. I would definitely have a meeting with his current school to ask how they are going to help support him both academically and with the bullying issue. Also really consider other schools with potentially better SEN support etc, sometimes kids this age won’t want to move even if things are bad because it’s what they know but it doesn’t mean they wouldn’t be happier elsewhere. I agree about trying for an EHCP as well maybe. And yeah talk to other home educators here too.

determinedtomakethiswork · 05/09/2023 07:00

@Tambatamba are you saying your mental health would have been fine if you hadn't done GCSEs and A-levels? Do you mean it was damaged because of the particular school or because of the curriculum?

Letmeoutnow · 05/09/2023 06:53

Lessonstobe · 04/09/2023 13:44

You need to think carefully about whether or not you’re capable of teaching 8/9 subjects to GCSE level or have the resources to get help to do so. Not easy teaching your own kids, esp with SeN issues

You don’t need to teach 8 to 9 subjects to gcse. Most homeschoolers concentrate on a smaller number of subjects.

Hairyfairy01 · 05/09/2023 06:51

I personally found year 8 was when my dd finally found a small group of friends. Year 7 was a bit of a disaster and I very nearly took her out many times. Going into year 9 she is also in the bottom set for most things but someone has to be in the bottom set and she has many other skills that aren't academic which we really focus on at home. I'm also pleased that in year 10 her school offers some courses such as animal care, beauty therapy etc which I suspect she will not only enjoy but also be good at. I'm all for home ed and have seriously considered it many times. You don't even have to do GCSEs of course. But it sounds as if as a family you would struggle. Maybe see how things go and review at Christmas?

Wildhorses2244 · 05/09/2023 06:50

I would ecco pp question about medication.

If he isn’t currently on adhd medication then I would try that first- it makes a huge difference to concentration and behaviour.

If he is on medication I would go back to the doctor with him and discuss how he’s feeling- it may be that a tweak in medication improves things.

I would also suggest a tutor to help him progress out of bottom set before you start thinking about he. Ask him to choose whether he prefers maths or English and get the tutor to work with him on that for the whole of year 8, reasses at the end of the year.

This will be expensive- especially if you have to go private for the medication- but will be a lot cheaper than giving up your job

sashh · 05/09/2023 06:47

Children over the age of 14 can attend an FE college.

If he is in bottom sets for everything it might be worth taking him out for a year, work on English and maths and prepare for an FE course in something vocational.

He doesn't have to do GCSEs at all, but if he goes to an FE college he will be expected to do GCSE English and maths alongside whatever he does.

Nappyvalley15 · 05/09/2023 06:43

I would send him back to school for y8. I would push for better support in school (and adhd medication) and investigate alternatives in case you do have to remove him. I would push for a ECHP.

I would research UTCs (that he could move to in Y9) and other specialist provision and HE. Also online or small private schools. I would also find out more about how to support learners with dyslexia.

I would let him know that he needs to give it another try but you are investigating alternatives so he won't be stuck there if y8 doesn't work out. These things take time to plan properly. Also he may make a friend or two this year, get better teachers or SEND support and decide to stay. You also need time to plan the financial side of a radical change.

I would also look for ways to boost his self esteem outside of school.

Singleandproud · 05/09/2023 06:37

Are you a single parent, or if you give up your job will you still have n income coming into the house? This is important because if you willingly give up working I don't believe you are eligible for out of work benefits.

Home Ed can work brilliantly when parents can afford to access HE groups to provide the social stimulus that children need and to access resources to support them but if you are going to be on a very low / no income you won't be able to do this. You would be better off booking an appointment with the SENCO and then possibly looking at other schools in the area that have a more holistic approach if available and then focusing on outside hobbies and groups to make the school day a smaller part of his day.

Tambatamba · 05/09/2023 05:03

Boo1321 · 04/09/2023 22:34

“Why do people act like every child needs to do GCSEs?”

Erm, because it’s the most straightforward pathway to a good job and higher education. Even if you don’t want to use them having them provides opportunity and freedom. Or you can squander the opportunity your children would otherwise have, it’s up to you. 😉

Um, well I've got good GCSEs and A levels, all at the expense of my mental health. And I ended up not using them because it was the wrong path for me.

It astounds me how blinkered and narrow minded some folk are.

Tambatamba · 05/09/2023 05:01

I was speaking about the OP's situation which is different. Teaching someone with dyslexia can be difficult at home without support and if the OP is already worried about expense it felt only fair to warn her that exams are expensive to take privately.

Oh 100% - I was not sure if he had other ND as well but I agree that dyslexia is another ball game

HeyThereDelilahhh · 05/09/2023 00:53

Follow ‘Hannah Home Educates’ on TikTok / YouTube. She gives some great tips, advice on home education to ND children. She’s a single parent and works from home so she has an income and talks about how she hasn’t given up work but still home educates her three kids using a number of resources. My kid hasn’t started school but I still find her videos interesting! https://www.tiktok.com/@hannahhomeeducates?_t=8fQ8GKK3Trk&_r=1

Hannah Home Educates (@hannahhomeeducates) | TikTok

Hannah Home Educates (@hannahhomeeducates) | TikTok

Hannah Home Educates (@hannahhomeeducates) on TikTok | 5.1M Likes. 231.5K Followers. ❤️ Your Home Education HYPE Girl! 💗 Gentle Parenting Tips 🌎 Family Travel.Watch the latest video from Hannah Home Educates (@hannahhomeeducates).

https://www.tiktok.com/@hannahhomeeducates?_t=8fQ8GKK3Trk&_r=1

Saracen · 05/09/2023 00:49

Saoirse82 · 04/09/2023 14:27

Being ridiculed doesn't usually build strength of character, it tends to go the other way and can destroy your life with long lasting effects way into adulthood.

Starting at the bottom isn't the same as being in the bottom sets for everything and it being nigh on impossible to ever catch up with the other children. I couldn't bear to watch my child's self esteem be ruined either.

You are so right about that!

My teenaged daughter has a learning disability and has never been to school. Because she wasn't in that competitive environment where the skills she lacks are the ones which are most prized, she was never ridiculed for being unable to do things. The result is that she's confident and happy.

She is not afraid to learn new things, because she does not associate being a beginner with being taunted or classed as a failure.

junbean · 05/09/2023 00:46

I apologize if this is unhelpful, but I’m a single mom and I’ve homeschooled for years on no budget. I’m in the US though, so the laws vary I’m sure. I’ve heard it’s much harder elsewhere. We have a government program now that allows a nice sum for curriculum so this year I’ve been able to outsource everything with online teachers and tutors. The platform we use is called Outschool and it’s used globally and can be inexpensive actually. I would check it out for ideas, especially supplemental, social, and tutoring. We really love it. I can’t help with advice on funds or legalities, but I do think you should research local homeschooling groups for advice instead. Facebook groups in your area is a good place to start, and hopefully you can find other mothers who can guide you. Homeschool parents are usually very inclusive because there is a lot of judgment thrown at us, so we tend to support and stick together. YOU know what’s best for YOUR child, you just need some guidance on the details of it all. It will seem daunting at first, but you’ll figure it out in no time. Just put blinders on to the naysayers!

Edited to add: 3 of my kids are teenagers, one is going into computer science (nowadays no university needed), one is going to culinary school next year, and the other has ASD and is pursuing writing and animation, and I’m mentoring her on business to make her art profitable although I might be supporting her as an adult because of the ASD. She’s seeing a mentor weekly on Outschool too. Even though my kids excel academically they don’t need formal education records for their career paths, just drive and motivation to continue. Culinary school needs massive loans though and I’m feeling queasy about that. But overall nowadays non-traditional routes are the way to go.

Saracen · 05/09/2023 00:37

Neither of my home educated kids did GCSEs at 16. One of them followed an alternative path to university and is doing very well there. The other would never have managed GCSEs, and instead is learning practical life skills. She may one day do the more accessible and relevant Functional Skills exams, but she isn't ready for those either yet. Because I don't have Ofsted breathing down my neck to increase my setting's pass rate, I can give her what I can see she actually needs.

Imustbecrazy123 · 05/09/2023 00:36

He has only just gone to sleep after crying and begging me not to send him tomorrow.
I feel like the worst parent in the world.
I want to help him out of this but equally I am terrified of doing him a disservice by letting him leave education when I’m not a qualified teacher.
We will struggle financially unless I could possibly work part time but this would limit my time available to home school as I also have another child in primary school who will need to be dropped / collected.
Do schools refer to childrens services once a child is deregistered from school?
Ive seen posts on another site saying that the school referred them because the child was deemed missing from education!

OP posts:
Saracen · 05/09/2023 00:31

I think you are right to consider it, and I agree with posters who have suggested you speak to people who have home educated to learn more about the options. You may be able to put something together which would suit your son reasonably well. For example, some colleges have 14-16 provision, sometimes alongside vocational courses, which could form part of the picture - and it's free. Some home educating families cannot afford to pay for GCSEs or are not ready for them at 16, and therefore do some GCSEs at college after 16. This is unlikely to suit a highly academic child because college won't offer the range of GCSEs which schools or home ed parents can, but it would be a good option for the essential ones anyway.

It is a tough situation when you may have to give up your job. Is it the sort of job which can be done part-time? If your son cannot be left alone at all, you might use a childminder to keep an eye on him while you are at work; some home educating parents would welcome a job like that which is compatible with looking after their own kids.

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/09/2023 23:11

Sorry, I didn't mean he would drive you crazy! I just mean putting yourself in that position and having no money and no job and just being in a one-to-one situation with your child who doesn't want to do what you want him to do would drive me crazy!

determinedtomakethiswork · 04/09/2023 23:01

Is he on any medication?

I really wouldn't advise it. I think it will drive you crazy.

JoanCandy · 04/09/2023 22:56

Before going the HE route for my DD, around 13 years ago, we made contact with a couple of local HE groups (yes, there are hundreds of local HE groups to meet other families, socialise, study in small groups etc. for anyone on here thinking wrongly that HE kids are 'isolated' and have no social interaction once they deregister). They invited us along to a couple of meet ups and that was enough to show me that it would be the right thing for her.
GCSEs aren't the be all and end all, many of the HE young people we know applied to college via other methods at the discretion of the FE institution or just went straight into apprenticeships or employment.

Junobug · 04/09/2023 22:56

Please talk to some other parents who actually home ed, there is a lot of misinformation and assumtion on this thread. Join a couple of home ed groups and start there. Nothing has to be permanent but don't underestimate how important your childs mental health is at this age.
As for your job, is it something that you can change or adjust? Loads of us work and home ed with the help of childcare, friends and family, working from home or different times to partners.
It is not an easy option and it is a complete lifestyle change but I know very few that go back on their decision.

Boo1321 · 04/09/2023 22:38

Stompythedinosaur · 04/09/2023 15:37

I think I'd pursue other options first. I'd look for opportunities to meet friends with similar interests outside school. Also, I'd be pushing the school to do more.

I think you run the risk of going from a dc struggling academically and socially to a dc struggling academically, socially and financially, in a family that is under significant pressure.

🙌👏👏

Swipe left for the next trending thread