Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to consider homeschooling a 13 year old on a very small budget?

87 replies

Imustbecrazy123 · 04/09/2023 13:42

My son is about to enter year 8 and really doesn’t want to go back despite his younger sister starting year 7.
He has ADHD and dyslexia and has struggled his way through primary school, not just academically but also socially he has never ever made a solid group of friends and we hoped so much that this would change come secondary school but it hasn’t - in fact it’s got worse as he’s so aware of being left out / laughed at for being in the bottom sets now.
He isn’t motivated at all so I’m really worried I would struggle to get him to do any work at home and with GCSEs only a few years away this is a real concern
Financially, I’ll be ruined as will need to give up my job but I need to help his self esteem 😢

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Melissa1771 · 05/09/2023 16:20

Such a tough spot… I think it’s worth exploring. Can you work from home and/or reduce hours? With an older independent child HE might not be so impactful on your work as you think. You don’t need to teach a full day, one to one learning is much more efficient and you can set more appropriate goals. As others said, it doesn’t need to be forever and a college setting might be a better fit for him later down the line.

dressedforcomfort · 05/09/2023 15:41

10 GCSES cost £440 and 4 ALevels cost £420, adding to what goneroundthetwist is saying. Professional tutors cost a lot. If you don’t think you will need them then that’s just setting your child up for failure.

I think this is missing the point. If the child has ADHD and dyslexia, sitting 10 GCSEs may be completely overwhelming and not be in his best interests at all. Trying to fit neurodiverse kids into a system designed for neurotypical kids definitely has consequences on their mental well-being. Providing a curriculum that's appropriate for his developmental stage and SEND needs really be what he requires at this point. (Assuming the Op has the skills and knowledge to deliver that.)

I have a DS with ASD and (as yet I assessed but likely) ADHD and there's no way he will fit into the '10 GCSEs by age 16' box. He's bright but struggling so much with sensory stuff and focus that he will probably need longer to complete his education. Why are we so inflexible about kids academic journeys in this country?

Objectionhearsayspeculation · 05/09/2023 13:29

Home Ed Mum to 13 and 8 year olds both with dyslexia and 1 with ADD and ASD. We are also not one bit well off right now. It's not all sunshine and roses but it is definitely the right decision for the kids.
So the first thing with GCSEs is you don't have to do them at a certain age, you don't have to do 8, 9 or 10. You can Home Educate and do 1 or 2 or none or 20 depending on what your child is ready for. You can sit them at 10 or 100 or any age in between. As he's not motivated you can see if things change when the school trauma is behind him for a while and if not you can work towards other qualifications that better suit his career goals, these also don't have to she decided right now. You don't have to follow the curriculum and you don't have to do any qualifications if you don't want to (obviously that isn't ideal but it is the truth.) You can do IGCSE or alternative qualifications instead.
You do however have to demonstrate you are providing an education suitable to his age and ability, so by tailoring to his ADHD, dyslexia and social anxiety you will be doing this, there's no more bottom set so his confidence will grow and he will be able to see where his strengths lie and his own personal ways of learning that aren't possible in a classroom can kick in. There is no peer pressure from others who can do things "better" and no time pressure to move on to the next topic before he understands that one which also gives that time to breathe and absorb the learning. (You can also tailor what you teach and skip things he absolutely won't need if he's not doing that particular exam or subject).
Costs don't have to be sky high. There are a lot of resources online, groups on Facebook etc for help and yearly subscriptions that while they cost maybe a just over a hundred to £150 in total if you watch for discounts they are worth it. Textbooks and workbooks you can source very reasonably on marketplace or sometimes the Home Ed groups and many free printable resources too. There are also apps and games which are useful ways to engage him with learning and also demonstrate progress. To keep track take plenty of photos and keep a diary either on your phone or written down, it doesn't have to be detailed but will come in handy when you need to write a report for your Local Authority. There are great guides on sites like Education Otherwise or Home Education for All.
Socialising is up to what he is comfortable with, there are plenty of Home Ed groups so look for those in your area, there's often trips to educational places at discounted rates or just picnics and hobby meet ups. If that's too much for him there's often zoom classes (my eldest is doing a language one at £2 per lesson or £10 for 6 week block including materials) and there's also a private WhatsApp and social media group for the students. There's a similar online course for Harry Potter themed and you can pay as much or as little as you can afford and they also have an online community plus optional meet ups.

bridgetreilly · 05/09/2023 10:56

You do not need to be a qualified teacher to be a very successful home educator. You do need to be patient, to be willing to take an entirely different approach, not to be constantly comparing with his peers in school, and to have the motivation to seek put the resources and support which will help him most.

In your circumstances you might consider home education with the possibility of a return to school later, e.g. in year 10 or year 12. But for now, I would do some serious research and think about it realistically.

Singleandproud · 05/09/2023 10:35

Wanting to protect your child from what is causing them distress is a very natural instinct but HE when you have no teaching background and when you are not financially comfortable is the nuclear option. There are several steps to take before you go down this road.

  1. Ring the GP / Adhd professional and have a chat about options, medications, therapy. Music therapy especially drum lessons is great for teens with Adhd.

  2. Ring or email the SENCO, you need a face to face meeting. Make a bullet point factual list of what he is struggling with and include any adjustments you can think of to help him. I presume he has a one page profile, this needs reviewing if it is not meeting his needs. If school have done everything they can to no avail then you or they apply for an Ehcp.

  3. Look into structured extra curricular groups that can give him a resilience boost, in year 8 he can join cadets and that can be great for children who need structure and boundaries but with physical elements too, they don't have to join the military etc after but it can be a fantastic place for personal development.

  4. Support him in developing friendships outside of school. DDs school friendship group really flourished by the end of Yr 8 but they were a bit rubbish at coordinating meet ups to begin with but have organised many park, cinema and trips to the local theme park over the yr8-9 summer which they definitely weren't able to be yr7-8 summer holidays.

  5. Support him with learning but in a different way at home. DD has different challenges she is academically able but has ASD and struggles in the school environment, she hates reading fiction with a passion. I found out which books she'd be reading in English next year and she's done some over learning this week going through the books and highlighting all of the words she does not know or are in a different language and then written the meaning in the margin. It gets her brain ready for going back to school, she hasn't actually read the book but is more mentally prepared. That's just an example but there are lots of things you can do, if he is doing Shakespeare this year take him to see the play before hand - far more likely to keep his attention than a film then he will have an idea of the story line when they discuss it in class.

Againlosinghope · 05/09/2023 10:29

@Seashellies
Yes some good options but also lots of posters saying GCSEs and social is too important and how will she teach 9 GCSE subjects.

Many people are left with no choice but to HE because while some LA can make the necessary adjustments and give the needed support many won't. That's not a privilege and many are going it despite the financial hardships and personal preference of the parents because they have no choice.

I hope OP is able to resolve this and it's worth exploring all options

Conkersinautumn · 05/09/2023 10:21

He's more likely to make genuine friends interested in things he is if he attends local home Ed groups and classes, talks etc. But it does take deep pockets to home Ed well.

Seashellies · 05/09/2023 10:13

Ironically perhaps it's also a privilege to be in a position financially to homeschool.

Seashellies · 05/09/2023 10:11

Againlosinghope · 05/09/2023 08:32

Wow this thread demonstrate perfectly why it's so difficult for families with children that have SEN and/or mental health struggles.

HE was a definite possibility as in order of importance GCSEs are not more important than their mental health and ultimately their life.
We changed schools because it was a last resort before home education route. It has helped in as far I'm not currently worried that my child will kill themselves which was a daily worry previously
They get more support, aren't suicidal but I wouldn't say they are happy and while doing better with school work due to support it's still so hard for them and they are unlikely to pass any exams. Their self esteem is ruined from previous school.

It shows a type of privilege that many focused on HE meaning child not getting 9 GCSE, not being isolated (you can be surrounded by people and still be isolated)
I also know a young adult with great GCSE results but.unable to work due to the mental toll school took. Do you really believe those results were worth it?

Mental health and well being comes first every time

Good luck with what you decide OP. No one outside of the situation realizes how difficult this is for families x

People aren't saying that though are they, they're giving advice and some ideas of avenues to explore to an OP who can't really afford to homeschool- surely they are valuable to at least look into and might be things OP hasn't been aware of. Yes of course mental health is important and if a family can homeschool and it helps then that's bloody brilliant, I don't think many are debating that at all. It is important to think of their future too though, sure the short term is most important if they are severely struggling with their MH, but an adulthood with limited opportunities is also not going to do them any favours. Some schools can flex, DS' friend does just English, maths, science and then has free periods to decompress, even go home if needed and agreed with his parents or have a safe space in school to revise etc; some schools suit children better etc. For someone not sure what to do I'm not sure why its bad to go through these.

Halfemptyhalfling · 05/09/2023 09:51

He needs to concentrate on maths and English only, to stop doors closing for him after GCSE. Don't worry too much about anything else.

Bottom sets often have small classes so can be helpful. Make sure he understands dangers of county lines and vaping as some will see bottom sets as easy prey.

Agree with others that he should get involved in clubs and activities in and out of schools. Social skills will be very useful for him work wise in future. Music can help maths skills if he has any ability musically.

unlimiteddilutingjuice · 05/09/2023 09:40

I pulled mine out of school for similar reasons, albeit at a younger age.
If a child is stressed and unhappy, they're unlikely to learn.
I'm not a trained teacher but any disadvantage my child suffers from that is more than offset by the advantage of a quiet environment with one to one attention and as many movement breaks as he needs.
I'm currently looking into secondary education for him, but if the LA isn't able to provide anything suitable (after we've exhausted the tribunal process) then I'm more than happy to continue to home ed all the way through. It will be challenging but doable.
There are so many resources available for home ed these days. From free stuff (Oak Academy, BBC Bitesize, Teach your Monster to Read) to relatively cheap subscription apps (Night Zookeeper, IXL, Reading Eggs), right through to expensive online "schools".
A lot of people use Toe to Toe or TTRS for dyslexia.
A well meaning friend of mine recently told me I couldn't home ed at secondary level because I would have to pay £50 per hour for a separate tutor in each subject. I don't know of anyone who does it that way! My own child has lessons on the £2 tuition hub, which is priced as the name suggests!
Having to give up work is a real difficulty and you're right to consider this aspect carefully. I manage by claiming DLA (as PP have helpfully suggested) and shelf stacking on evenings and weekends.
If your DS sits exams, you'll need to pay for him to be entered as a private candidate which is expensive.
I'd recommend joining the Facebook group H.E.F.A (Home Education for Everyone) and having a chat with some of the home educators on there.
Also search in Facebook for (your town) plus Home Education to see what kind of groups and meet ups you can connect with locally.

Spendonsend · 05/09/2023 08:51

You may be able to do some work whilst home schooling. It depends in the work.

We were forced to homeschool for a while (no school place available for sen child) and its liberating not being tied to the standard school day which meant I could still do some work.

I think your biggest issue would be socially he would need a solid group activity as that is an area you say he needs support. Would cadets be an option?

Againlosinghope · 05/09/2023 08:32

Wow this thread demonstrate perfectly why it's so difficult for families with children that have SEN and/or mental health struggles.

HE was a definite possibility as in order of importance GCSEs are not more important than their mental health and ultimately their life.
We changed schools because it was a last resort before home education route. It has helped in as far I'm not currently worried that my child will kill themselves which was a daily worry previously
They get more support, aren't suicidal but I wouldn't say they are happy and while doing better with school work due to support it's still so hard for them and they are unlikely to pass any exams. Their self esteem is ruined from previous school.

It shows a type of privilege that many focused on HE meaning child not getting 9 GCSE, not being isolated (you can be surrounded by people and still be isolated)
I also know a young adult with great GCSE results but.unable to work due to the mental toll school took. Do you really believe those results were worth it?

Mental health and well being comes first every time

Good luck with what you decide OP. No one outside of the situation realizes how difficult this is for families x

itsawildwildworld · 05/09/2023 08:23

Have pm'd you

motherofawhirlwind · 05/09/2023 08:13

Tambatamba · 04/09/2023 15:08

Why do people act like every child needs to do GCSEs?

It's not the right route for everyone. I can tell there are very few HE people on this thread.

Agreed.

OP there's lots of options. Look on FB for your local HE group and get some support there.

He could do GCSE's one or two at a time. You could use tutors, he could self learn, he could use a online school.

The expected path of bricks and mortar school, 8 GCSE's at 16 and written exams do not suit every child.

We've turned around a complete ASD burnout at a very pushy grammar into Maths and English GCSE's and onto college in just over a year, via 6 months off.

Good luck!

Foxesandsquirrels · 05/09/2023 08:11

@Velvian The op hasn't got a budget to even home ed but you think she can afford an independent school?

gogomoto · 05/09/2023 08:10

Also he may turn a corner - my dd struggled until year 8, really poor reading and writing due to dyslexia (she probably has adhd too but not diagnosed) but she turned a corner that year and by the end of year 9 was about ready for GCSEs, then she surprised us by not only scraping English but getting a 6! Honestly beginning of year 8 writing one side of a4 wasn't possible, or rather it was so littered with spelling mistakes you couldn't read it

Velvian · 05/09/2023 08:05

I agree with looking for a non selective private day school. The closest to me is a Steiner School, which I know is not without controversy.

However, the kids wear their own clothes, the is a broader range of ages in classes and they have a lot of practical lessons.

I have considered for my ND DC, I have so far discounted due to some of the ethoses I've heard about Steiner Waldorf more widely, but it is still in the back of my mind as an option.

gogomoto · 05/09/2023 08:04

It would be better looking at supporting him by finding extra curricular he can excel at and make friends rather than removing him from school. Potentially also hire a tutor to help him after school but you stay in work. Homeschooling does work for some kids but it's a huge risk not to be taken lightly. Speak to the senco first about enhancing his support

Defiantjazz · 05/09/2023 07:58

He has ADHD and dyslexia and has struggled his way through primary school, not just academically but also socially he has never ever made a solid group of friends and we hoped so much that this would change come secondary school but it hasn’t - in fact it’s got worse as he’s so aware of being left out / laughed at for being in the bottom sets now.

You’d be better off teaching him resilience and social skills.
I mean one day he may have to do a job that doesn’t make him happy, he’ll have to either get a new one or just keep going and find happiness from other sources. There will always be jerks lurking somewhere in the background so you have to learn to deal with that to.

The ADHD complicated things I know but no, I don’t think him just hiding away at home is the answer.

WoooahNelly · 05/09/2023 07:45

I do think that pushing children who are struggling at school to do 8-9 subjects at GCSE is unfair when they may stand a better chance of getting better results focusing on fewer.

TiredRetired · 05/09/2023 07:42

Imustbecrazy123 · 04/09/2023 14:55

Thank you for the replies
Socially he is immature compared to other children his age but he has no trouble making friends In social settings such as skateparks / karate but literally not one friend at school
They are all generally bright children in the local primary here ( I worked there so o know the intake ) which I thought would change come secondary but it just hasn’t
I can’t see how he will cope or pass GCSEs even in school so I’m not sure it’s doing him a disservice taking him out of somewhere that’s knocking his self esteem when the end result is white possibly going to be the same.
i suggested trying another school but he is convinced that will be even worse as nobody will know him / dislike him and everything will be brand new so a doubly blow

Are GCSEs needed in every subject? Will he want to go to UNI? If he's numerate and literate enough to balance the books of everyday life then I wouldn't worry about it too much.
Does he have a particular interest or talent you could focus on? That's one of the strengths of home schooling, concentrate your fire power on IT or woodwork or whatever floats his boat. He stands a better chance of making friends if he's with like minded people. That will give him a better life than trying to force him down the mainstream track when he doesn't fit.

JussathoB · 05/09/2023 07:38

Must be very difficult as your son is struggling. However I really don’t think it’s a good idea to take on all the responsibility for his education on yourself, that’s what school is there for after all. I think you also said you worry about whether you can get him to do any work at home after school …. So this could be a problem if you try to home school him as well?? You also have yourself and your job and income to consider. So I feel home schooling in your situation should perhaps only be if there is no alternative.
Do you think the situation is heightened by you and your son feeling trepidation at the first week back? I would try to encourage him, try to ensure some relief and diversion after the school day and perhaps take up other PPs suggestions about discussing the situation with head of year etc to make sure school are giving support.

morellamalessdrama · 05/09/2023 07:35

I've not home schooled myself but my sister did following her DS being horribly bullied at school.

He's in his late teens now and just finished his A Levels. My sister home schooled him for a couple of hours a day - as it's 1:1 it doesn't need to be for eight hours a day like in a school.

He moved to a college setting at 14 to do his GCSEs, he took five rather than the usual nine though.

ZadocPDederick · 05/09/2023 07:33

Does your son have an EHCP, and is he getting any professional help for his anxiety?

Swipe left for the next trending thread