Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask you who has right of way?

95 replies

allswellthatends · 04/09/2023 13:40

Please settle a family argument, especially since our eldest has finally nabbed a driving test date and this could come up.

Near our house is a mini roundabout we pass almost every day. If car A and car C arrive at the roundabout at the same time, and car A is signalling a right turn, who has right of way? Who has to yield?

I have drawn a diagram under MN rules, but cannot see how to link it??

Yes, of course I have my own view (which doesn’t correspond to my husband’s view). I would like to hear what others think, so I am putting this out here and will come back to it in 24 hours to tell you what I think and why. It’s clear that not everyone agrees with me because this location gets a lot of near-collisions and angry hooting!

OP posts:
PoshPineapple · 04/09/2023 15:33

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 04/09/2023 13:45

Car A has right of way as they are coming from the right, car A doesn't need to give way to car c as they are not passing their entrance point so nothing to give way to.

This answer is on the nail. Mini roundabouts are buggers because drivers don't have the luxury of time and space as you would at a normal roundabout. They are generally too small for the 'give way to your right' rule to work. As an ex driving examiner (but many moons ago, so if things have changed now I stand corrected), we would always expect an instructor to have taught extreme caution and common sense at a mini roundabout. If common sense is in short supply at the time, the rule of thumb of "who has to cross whose path" would apply. Car A needs to cross the intended path of car B, so they should give way. Car B won't be crossing the route or path of car A, so technically they have right of way.

Dwappy · 04/09/2023 15:33

Scaredycatttt · 04/09/2023 15:25

Yes if its a mini roundabout, its not big enough to both go at the same time so if someone is coming from the right of me, they go first (assuming we get there at the same time)

I have to turn right on a mini roundabout on a busy road to get into my own street and the other cars always give way. It's not that complicated, I think some people are over thinking it

This. In real life everyone just gives way to those indicating right even if you arrive at the same time.

akkakk · 04/09/2023 15:33

There really is a lot of over-thinking this 😄

If cars stop opposite each other on any type of roundabout - neither has priority!

You gain priority if you are onto the roundabout first and even then priority only means that other cars without priority give way which means don't go if it affects you - they are still absolutely allowed to go if not affecting you (bigger roundabouts / they are faster / etc.)

the Highway code is very clear - and equally clear that roundabouts are not the simplest road junctions so never make an assumption that you are in the right - always allow for others who are positioned badly etc.

So:

  • if in doubt pause and let them go first
  • otherwise just go and get on with life
  • if they 'cut you up' don't get on your high horse / establish your rights / report them to the Daily Mail - just be tolerant and patient and back off and let them go

Accidents happen when drivers are unaware of other road users / believe themselves to be in the right and assume that everyone else will bow down to them and let them proceed up their red carpet unhindered 😄

patience, tolerance and be aware of everyone else and you will be fine.
priority is not a static / fixed thing - it is fluid and continually changing... they might technically have priority over you, but if they sit there checking the highway code before making a decision and you go first - you will acquire priority - so drive confidently but with courtesy

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/09/2023 15:29

This made me chuckle. 😂

Dwappy · 04/09/2023 15:29

RomeoandJomeo · 04/09/2023 15:25

But by the same logic, why does C not have priority now? My point about the cars being in different positions was simply that it changes the symmetry of the situation and makes it more likely that both cars couldn't go together, in which case the car to the others right does have priority. In the situation given both cars probably could go at the same time without issue, but if a lack of space etc meant that this wasn't possible the rules about priority to the car on the right would be no help and the drivers would have to work out out between themselves.

Edited

If car C was in road D turning left into road A technically no one has to give way to anyone as no one is cutting across anyone path. If car C was in road D going straight on into road B then it changes to C having priority as he is now cutting across As path from the right.

Scaredycatttt · 04/09/2023 15:25

WhatapityWapiti · 04/09/2023 15:19

So you regularly give way to other cars that are not yet on the roundabout?

Yes if its a mini roundabout, its not big enough to both go at the same time so if someone is coming from the right of me, they go first (assuming we get there at the same time)

I have to turn right on a mini roundabout on a busy road to get into my own street and the other cars always give way. It's not that complicated, I think some people are over thinking it

RomeoandJomeo · 04/09/2023 15:25

Dwappy · 04/09/2023 15:17

If car A would have priority if C was on road B then why does A not have priority now? A is still approaching from Cs right. (Again I'm not taking into account the whole not on the roundabout yet thing). You don't have to just give priority to cars in the road directly to your right. It's cars approaching from the right. A will always be coming from Cs right whether he's on road B or the one he's on originally. So C needs to give way still.

But by the same logic, why does C not have priority now? My point about the cars being in different positions was simply that it changes the symmetry of the situation and makes it more likely that both cars couldn't go together, in which case the car to the others right does have priority. In the situation given both cars probably could go at the same time without issue, but if a lack of space etc meant that this wasn't possible the rules about priority to the car on the right would be no help and the drivers would have to work out out between themselves.

Dwappy · 04/09/2023 15:25

WhatapityWapiti · 04/09/2023 15:19

So you regularly give way to other cars that are not yet on the roundabout?

I've been driving 25 years and in my experience people normally do do this at mini roundabouts yes. If I'm approaching one and intend to go straight on or left, and I see another car approaching opposite at similar speed and distance to me and they are indicating right which will cut across my direction of travel then yes I give way to them. If they are miles away or dithering about then I will go first. I've also had plenty of drivers slow and stop if they see me coming and indicating right etc. If a car is not indicating I will also slow/stop as even if I technically can go I don't really want an accident and some people are idiot drivers who don't know what indicators are.
The whole priority/ not yet on the roundabout thing in real life doesn't really seem to be an issue most of the time in my experience. Most people seem to just give way to someone turning right approaching from their right.

SaltyGod · 04/09/2023 15:23

I had a similar scenario on my driving test, arrived at a mini roundabout at the same time as a car that was directly opposite. I waited for them and was given a minor as I didn’t need to wait, although the examiner said ‘I understood why you did’.

Happyhappyeveryday · 04/09/2023 15:23

But OP said they arrive at the same time? Car A has priority.

ohboohoo · 04/09/2023 15:22

Exactly the same time? No one has to give way to anyone. Both would be entering the roundabout at exactly the same time. By the time A got to the point where it would require being given way to, C would be past the point of it being an issue

Happyhappyeveryday · 04/09/2023 15:22

Car A. 100%

WhatapityWapiti · 04/09/2023 15:19

Scaredycatttt · 04/09/2023 15:15

Car A goes first, I've never had a problem with this, I had no idea it was so complicated 🙃

So you regularly give way to other cars that are not yet on the roundabout?

SaladBarNanny · 04/09/2023 15:18

@VintageTuppence that's why I said theoretically Grin
In practice if you genuinely arrive at the same time, you sort it out with politeness and common sense, one of you gesturing to the other to indicate they can go ahead

WhatapityWapiti · 04/09/2023 15:18

eurochick · 04/09/2023 15:14

Car C should give way to car A.

The fact that so many on this thread don't get this is terrifying.

But that’s not correct unless A is already on the roundabout or very close and approaching it at a speed that would make it unsafe to stop. In OP’s scenario both cars arrive at their respective lines at exactly the same time.

Mysleepisbroken · 04/09/2023 15:18

Talipesmum · 04/09/2023 13:50

If neither car has moved onto the roundabout, and the cars are (as in the diagram) directly opposite each other, then “you give way to the right” doesn’t help, as they are both to the right of each other. If one is already edging onto the roundabout then the non-edging car should give way as then there is someone “to their right” but before that happens I would just try to be courteous.

This surely.

For all the people of who say its A, because 'they are on the right', have you tried turning the screen upside down?

Dwappy · 04/09/2023 15:17

RomeoandJomeo · 04/09/2023 15:13

I don't think the fact that car A is indicating to turn right head any relevance here. The cars are directly opposite each other, and arrived at roundabout at same time, so there is no need for either car to give way on this situation. If car C was on road B, then A would have priority, and if it was on road D then it would. I'm totally confused by all the posters saying car A had right of way because of priority to cars approaching to the right.

If car A would have priority if C was on road B then why does A not have priority now? A is still approaching from Cs right. (Again I'm not taking into account the whole not on the roundabout yet thing). You don't have to just give priority to cars in the road directly to your right. It's cars approaching from the right. A will always be coming from Cs right whether he's on road B or the one he's on originally. So C needs to give way still.

Scaredycatttt · 04/09/2023 15:15

Car A goes first, I've never had a problem with this, I had no idea it was so complicated 🙃

eurochick · 04/09/2023 15:14

Car C should give way to car A.

The fact that so many on this thread don't get this is terrifying.

RomeoandJomeo · 04/09/2023 15:13

I don't think the fact that car A is indicating to turn right head any relevance here. The cars are directly opposite each other, and arrived at roundabout at same time, so there is no need for either car to give way on this situation. If car C was on road B, then A would have priority, and if it was on road D then it would. I'm totally confused by all the posters saying car A had right of way because of priority to cars approaching to the right.

CharlotteBog · 04/09/2023 15:12

Can a driving instructor come and answer please.

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/09/2023 15:06

akkakk · 04/09/2023 13:57

neither has right of way - the concept doesn't exist in UK traffic law - the only mention of it in the Highway Code is to state that it doesn't exist :)

Instead we have a concept of priority - which is similar to the idea of 'first dibs' so when you get to a place where you have priority you get first dibs - but if you are not quite there yet, or a bit slow there is no issue with another car using it...

when you have two cars opposite each other on a mini roundabout - you give way to the right - so a car already on the roundabout to the right of you has priority - but if neither of you are already on the roundabout then technically neither of you has priority - the first onto the roundabout acquires priority...

also - the Highway Code is very clear - on a roundabout esp. you have to allow for other drivers doing the unexpected - so the best approach is definitely to be cautious and if in doubt pause and let someone else past...

if you are in the situation above - you need to be looking for the clues as to what the other driver is about to do - do they seem to be an aggressive driver / are they a learner / elderly / do they drive a battered or new car / slow or fast - these things will all give you a clue as to whether you go or let them go - if in doubt, either be confident and go - they will be questioning and give way - or polite and let them know they can go...

This. I normally just go whilst the driver opposite is dithering tbh. My car is modern and moves. The only time I’ve ever had an issue (not an accident) was on a largish mini roundabout on the main road through a large village. A small van was turning right, me straight on. The driver went anticlockwise over / around the roundabout and was gesticulating for me to get out of the way... whilst on the wrong side of the road. Maybe he thought we were in France. Had he respected the roundabout, we would have missed each other by a car length. Idiot.

Dwappy · 04/09/2023 15:02

WhatapityWapiti · 04/09/2023 15:00

I know it wasn’t the original question @Dwappy , I was just continuing the chat out of curiosity as you seemed to know what you were talking about, sorry you felt the need to be defensive.

Edited

Sorry I didn't mean it to sound like that. I'm really bad at judging my tone when writing. Sorry! I was even trying to make a joke about all sitting looking at each other but I don't think it worked well! 😬😊

NameNew · 04/09/2023 15:02

Car A has right of way

Piony · 04/09/2023 15:02

The indicators are a red herring. Indicators don't change who has priority and they are not 100% reliable - car A cannot assume from the fact that car C is not indicating that it is not planning to turn right.

For both of them it's a judgement call of can I clear it before the other car needs the space I'm about to occupy? If so then I can go, if not I need to wait because as soon as they are on the roundabout, I do need to give way to them.

It's also important in a driving test (and in life) not to dither too much. So it's pause to judge if they are going and give them a chance, and if they don't go, then you do. And this applies whether you are A or C. I and another girl once both failed our tests because we ended up facing each other on a narrow bit of road, and we both took too long waiting for the other to go.

What is your answer OP?

Swipe left for the next trending thread