Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think paramedics are patronising

115 replies

dontbeunreasonable · 04/09/2023 11:28

First of all I think paramedics are absolutely amazing and I have so so much respect for the job they do. I personally know three and think very highly of them all.
However, when I watch 999 shows like 'Ambulance' etc the way they speak to elderly patients makes me cringe.
For example: last night I saw one where they went to home of an almost comatose man and the woman was all 'hello darling hold my hand' all perfectly fine and suitable as kindness is needed. But then she kept saying 'ooh Harold it's been a while since somebody has touched my knee' then kept repeating it to his family members who were coming in and out. Saying again 'ooh, don't disturb us he's touching my knee'!
I find this so disrespectful as the man was unable to speak but conscious and he may not have appreciated that kind of nonsense.
I know when my father was dying of cancer he would have absolutely hated all that carry on.
I keep seeing stuff like that when they talk to the elderly calling them sweetheart and 'oh I bet you still have all the lads after you' etc and I really think it's not on.
Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London. But there's a time and place isn't there?

OP posts:
Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 13:43

Just to reiterate, I am not bashing paramedics! Comments from people saying things like 'well they saved my life so I don't care what they said' etc... I agree!
Of course they do a fabulous job and I am in awe of them.
It was just an observation, and as some others have mentioned there are many professions where people speak to the elderly this way.
I was curious to hear other opinions. No hate or disrespect intended.

Aquaphant · 04/09/2023 13:42

Yes, I noticed this as well whilst watching one of those ambulance shows. What got me was how the 999 dispatchers speak to people on the phone. The constant "alright?" at the end of every sentence as though speaking to a small child gets on my last nerve. It's not soothing, it's patronising and irritating.

FlamingoYellow · 04/09/2023 13:37

It is not paramedics, it is people in general.

I found it incredibly jarring when my dad became frail very suddenly and strangers changed completely in the way they spoke to him. They were all being very kind and helpful towards him, but also incredibly patronising - it was embarrassing to watch. I did wonder how confusing it must be for my dad as well, who I don't think was aware of just how frail he had become, to suddenly be treated like a child.

Setting the right tone with patients is tricky though and you have to be very skilled socially to get it right every time.

BathingBeauty · 04/09/2023 13:35

I’ve found them a mixed bag like any profession.
we called an ambulance shortly after DH had an extended stay in hospital. He was on some medication that made him slow and speak very slowly but had all his faculties. They quickly decided he was a time waster . They were furious I wouldn’t come with them (it was 3am and I had small children asleep in the house and no one to call). They then seem to have told A&E he was a time waster and was ignored for hours and the main doctor was rude to him, it was only due to a junior doctor he was eventually properly assessed and treated for something incredibly serious.

The last lot we had were amazing and pushed DH to go in, if only for a blood test just to be sure. They told me coming was a waste of time as he would probably go to a ward fairly quickly and I wouldn’t be allowed in, so I should stay at home and not panic.

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 13:30

cheezncrackers · 04/09/2023 13:17

I think you should take the word 'paramedics' out of your OP, but I agree with you that older people are often spoken to in an utterly patronising way by just about everyone and it's awful. I can't stand hearing older people called 'My love' or 'My darling' by all and sundry. Why can't people speak to older adults in a normal way? They're not children. I really hope this becomes socially unacceptable before I get old or I'm liable to tell the first person who does it to me to F off!

Absolutely agree. You're right, I should take 'paramedics' out of it as it does seem to be a lot of professionals that speak to the elderly this way. It's embarrassing. My mum is in her 70's and if anyone spoke to her in that condescending manner she would not be pleased.

pompomdaisy · 04/09/2023 13:30

It may be cultural. Paramedics in the north will probably crack more jokes and be chattier because we are more sociable up north 😉

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 13:28

Alargeoneplease89 · 04/09/2023 13:15

Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London

Yeah, London lacks humour 😂People like to be light hearted , especially in stressful times. I's a British thing the same as a cuppa tea cures everything.

You can be light hearted and friendly without sounding like a carry on matron character as someone else mentioned.

iamnottoofatiamjusttooshort · 04/09/2023 13:28

This is a tricky subject .. as a health professional it's a real skill to be able to read the room at very short notice

Depending on the level of illness/ incapacity/ serious of condition/ etc

There are times when a " you are ok sweetheart " is just what's needed
There's other times when it's " you are ok sir , we'll look after you "
There's other times when ok " come on you old codger " works just fine and brings a smile, a cheeky response and gives you a really good idea on the capacity , pain threshold and general condition of the patient

I'd not be offended if someone didn't get it right first time
Kindness costs nothing and id rather be called sweetheart with a smile than madam from a cold individual , especially if I was feeling scared and unwell.

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 13:26

Cinateel · 04/09/2023 12:14

My husband is 79 and in very poor health. He has had to be taken to hospital a couple of times, and picked up from the floor after falls. He's never been treated like that. I do know that if my Dad had been treated like that he'd have been really embarrassed. He was never flirty, always very respectful to women. In fact when I attended a Regimental Reunion with him and my Mum, he suddenly said he was just going back to their room for something. He'd spotted the official photographer coming in with two "Bunny Girls". He didn't want to have them on his knees for photos, but didn't want to embarrass them by refusing.

Oh that sounds awful! My dad would have hated that too and probably told them so!

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 13:24

PrincessHoneysuckle · 04/09/2023 12:11

There's a bit of light banter but the Carry On Matron stuff is a bit off.Yanbu.

Ha! Yes, definitely the carry on matron attitude is what I was referring to!

Shopper727 · 04/09/2023 13:21

Only experience as a parent I’ve had is a very dour humourless pair who took my v poorly son to hospital after an asthma attack. They weren’t very nice at all tbh a&e was crap too, he became much worse as they just left him, I had to keep asking for them to come to see him. However I don’t know what job they’d been to previously but their manner wasn’t great. I felt like they couldn’t be bothered.

However, as a nurse I’ve met many lovely paramedics and techs been on many transfers with them, they’ve taken me back to my base hospital and just been kind and lovely. I couldn’t do their job and I think it’s relentless just now.

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 13:20

Dogsitterwoes · 04/09/2023 11:52

I wouldn't say paramedics specifically, but yes there is definitely a patronising manner some health/Care professionals adopt with elderly people

It used to make my mother furious. Both on her behalf but also when it happened to my Dad, who had dementia, as he was always a very dignified man and it was demeaning.

You can be kind, reassuring, etc without talking to grown adults as if they are toddlers.

Absolutely agree

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 04/09/2023 13:18

Yabu. If they are all correct and po faced it will make a potentially scary situation more frightening. They do it to keep people around them relaxed and calm.

That said, it really really mattered to my grandma when the staff at the nursing home she was sent to after horrible neglect at a failing NHS hospital called her Mrs Fitzdotterel instead of by her first name. It was part of an overall package of treating her with respect. But perhaps being infantilised a bit by people with whom you feel you are in safe hands is qualitatively different from being infantilised by someone who is also neglecting and not listening to you. In the latter case it feels more frightening rather than less.

cheezncrackers · 04/09/2023 13:17

I think you should take the word 'paramedics' out of your OP, but I agree with you that older people are often spoken to in an utterly patronising way by just about everyone and it's awful. I can't stand hearing older people called 'My love' or 'My darling' by all and sundry. Why can't people speak to older adults in a normal way? They're not children. I really hope this becomes socially unacceptable before I get old or I'm liable to tell the first person who does it to me to F off!

Alargeoneplease89 · 04/09/2023 13:15

Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London

Yeah, London lacks humour 😂People like to be light hearted , especially in stressful times. I's a British thing the same as a cuppa tea cures everything.

Catpuss66 · 04/09/2023 13:09

I can remember as a very young nurse back in the 80’s I looked after a lady who was none communicative after a stroke, I can remember saying to her ‘let’s sort out that hair otherwise she’ll never get a boyfriend’ or somthing similar, well after having no communication she burst out laughing proper belly laugh, this was the beginning of her regaining some speech. It has stayed with me all these years. Sometimes in the most dire circumstances humour & normality is readily appreciated. I hope I made a difference.

Rewis · 04/09/2023 12:43

My grandmother passed away a while ago in her late-90's. She was very sharp and independent till the end. However needed some support due to sudden partial blindness. Some healthecare employees were really condescending and talked to her like she was a child. Some understood to adjust immediately to talking to an adult. Some did not.

My experience with ambulance has wither been neutral (which I count as a positive) but unfortunately my friend was treated terribly. She was having a stroke but I think they assumed she was drunk and on drugs so they did not have an ounce of sympathy until rest of us told them off. But when I've been a patient they have read the situation and how to act very well

Phos · 04/09/2023 12:30

I suppose you can't please everyone. Maybe some people wouldn't appreciate the humour we see on Ambulance but many do seem to. Better than being dour and poe-faced I suppose.

faffadoodledo · 04/09/2023 12:16

Last year when both my parents were dying and saw a lot of paramedics and other medical professionals I have to say the paramedics were the shining light. At times I could have wept for their kindness and professionalism. Not so all of the other nurses and doctors we saw. But paramedics were amazing across the board.

Cinateel · 04/09/2023 12:14

My husband is 79 and in very poor health. He has had to be taken to hospital a couple of times, and picked up from the floor after falls. He's never been treated like that. I do know that if my Dad had been treated like that he'd have been really embarrassed. He was never flirty, always very respectful to women. In fact when I attended a Regimental Reunion with him and my Mum, he suddenly said he was just going back to their room for something. He'd spotted the official photographer coming in with two "Bunny Girls". He didn't want to have them on his knees for photos, but didn't want to embarrass them by refusing.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 04/09/2023 12:11

There's a bit of light banter but the Carry On Matron stuff is a bit off.Yanbu.

TarquinOliverNimrod · 04/09/2023 12:10

Only ever had extremely good experiences with paramedics, every one has been an amazing human being when I’ve been at my most scared and vulnerable. I cannot say the same about nurses, many of which have been cold and heartless, no idea what made them want to ‘care’ for the sick, they clearly don’t have an aptitude for it Confused

gogomoto · 04/09/2023 12:09

Yabu, they will be taking clues from the family and the individual and will adapt their manner accordingly - most of us who work with the elderly learn that it not one size fits all, some families you have light hearted banter with, others it's more professional. There's also regional differences

melj1213 · 04/09/2023 12:08

I'll preface this with the fact that I'm no paramedic but I am a first aider and have more than once been in a situation where the casualty has been badly hurt and I'm trying to keep them conscious and/or responsive whilst also trying to calm any family/friends who are with them.

The easiest way to do so is to keep it light and so a few jokes/light-hearted comments keep things ticking over while waiting for help to arrive. Yes it can seem patronising but when you're busy trying to save someone's life you're not really thinking much about how deep the conversation is so you use anything to keep your monologue/the discussion going.

Hufflepods · 04/09/2023 12:06

YABU
I actually think comedy and light bedside manner is so important.

Swipe left for the next trending thread