Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think paramedics are patronising

115 replies

dontbeunreasonable · 04/09/2023 11:28

First of all I think paramedics are absolutely amazing and I have so so much respect for the job they do. I personally know three and think very highly of them all.
However, when I watch 999 shows like 'Ambulance' etc the way they speak to elderly patients makes me cringe.
For example: last night I saw one where they went to home of an almost comatose man and the woman was all 'hello darling hold my hand' all perfectly fine and suitable as kindness is needed. But then she kept saying 'ooh Harold it's been a while since somebody has touched my knee' then kept repeating it to his family members who were coming in and out. Saying again 'ooh, don't disturb us he's touching my knee'!
I find this so disrespectful as the man was unable to speak but conscious and he may not have appreciated that kind of nonsense.
I know when my father was dying of cancer he would have absolutely hated all that carry on.
I keep seeing stuff like that when they talk to the elderly calling them sweetheart and 'oh I bet you still have all the lads after you' etc and I really think it's not on.
Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London. But there's a time and place isn't there?

OP posts:
Goldcircle · 04/09/2023 18:56

The ones who attended my daughter were horrible

ThinWomansBrain · 04/09/2023 18:53

I don't have a huge amount of interaction with the medical profession, and don't recall any with paramedics, but at all ages I've had experience of Nurses/GPs/Hospital consultants be extremely patronising - and others in the same grade being thoroughly professional.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/09/2023 18:48

From experience, whilst Police will stamp around and shout at people & Firefighters concentrate upon planning things well away from you - the paramedic is the one who crawls under the vehicle with you, and stays with you when you're trying not to scream, reassuring you that they're there and you're going to be looked after.

I'm fine with them taking the piss a bit when it's not immediately life threatening - if it gets a reaction, they can use that to see how you are in terms of consciousness, stress, etc. It's when they don't joke or banter that you know you're in the shit.

PostItInABook · 04/09/2023 18:36

MsRosley · 04/09/2023 17:19

I think there needs to be training for all NHS professionals/care staff on how to address patients kindly without being patronising. Especially older patients, who often have to endure people talking to them like they are a child. There's no need to add indignity to old age and illness.

There is. There is training in all areas of the NHS on person centred care, privacy, dignity, etc etc nowadays but what we have, particularly in the paramedic world, is a kind of half and half workforce……half that were trained years ago and remain enmeshed in the ‘old school’ way and the other half who are trained in modern paramedic education. One is not necessarily better than the other and there are overlaps and a kind of grey area in between, but each brings slight differences in culture and approach to the job.

MsRosley · 04/09/2023 17:19

I think there needs to be training for all NHS professionals/care staff on how to address patients kindly without being patronising. Especially older patients, who often have to endure people talking to them like they are a child. There's no need to add indignity to old age and illness.

Laiste · 04/09/2023 17:01

Talking to the elderly in a different way to how you'd talk to someone in their 20s/30s/40s ....

It's hard to generalise, but the love, sweetheart, holding hand, speaking a bit more slowly and being that bit more gentle - yes. But what age it is ok to start with the sexual inuendo jokes?

60? 70?
Or maybe just don't. In any profession!

CoffeeCantata · 04/09/2023 16:56

I think what many pps are complaining about is a style of communication which has become standard in so many professional medical settings in the last few decades. Yes, I know what they mean - some HPs do talk to you as though you are a child - even younger doctors do this now - which must be how they're trained. I've never found paramedics (in the sense of ambulance people/first responders) to be guilty of this, though. My experience with them has been very dry 'blokey' humour - and that includes the women. Not patronising at all.

Thinking about it, yes, I've been irritated by doctors using words like 'tummy' (which apart from being babyish, is very imprecise!) and assuming I have a 7 year-old's knowledge of the human body etc, but actually it's been docs rather than paramedics who I notice this with. Just my personal experience.

Clefable · 04/09/2023 16:56

I find it all a bit uncomfortable too. My grandad was an eminent professor who even into his 90s was being asked to contribute to research in his field. It did feel a bit infantilising when he became suddenly unwell to have him spoken to like he was a child when he was an incredibly intelligent man in command of all his faculties. No one would speak to my 38yo husband like that, and it wasn't a type of interaction my grandad would have had with anyone in any other sphere. No one would address him like that otherwise.

But the paramedics don't know him, they don't know anyone, and for some people I suppose that might be really comforting and soothing for them. I think there's probably a middle ground somewhere, but when you have different personalities etc. then I think there will also be vast differences in interactions with people.

But I do find that show difficult and tend to skip the elderly sections because some of it just is too much, that kind of humour/banter isn't for me nor any of the older people in my family. But I understand it comes from a good place

My mum went to a make-up and hair session for women with cancer many years ago and came back frustrated by how patronising she'd found the people offering it but feeling like she couldn't complain because they were obviously trying to do a good thing.

UsingChangeofName · 04/09/2023 16:54

YABU, hugely so.

On some of their shifts, I am amazed they have the energy to be pleasant at all. I like watching those sorts of programmes occasionally and am regularly reminded of how paramedics (and nurses and other staff in the A&E programmes) are so infinitely patient and compassionate with so many of the people that they treat.
Humour and distraction are a big part of getting people to relax which helps medically in so many cases, too.

LivStanshall · 04/09/2023 16:52

YANBU I agree op, it makes me cringe.

ZadocPDederick · 04/09/2023 16:47

I don't think it's just a paramedic thing. There is a tendency to talk to the elderly as if they were children in all sorts of contexts. When my mother was talked to like that, she invariably pointed out that she wasn't 3 years old and would really quite like to be treated as an adult, which seemed to come to quite a shock to a few people.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 04/09/2023 16:38

I had an awful experience with some paramedics a good number of years ago now which has made me worry about ever needing to call them.

I was in town on a night out and found a passed out young lad (maybe 17/18?). He had no phone, no wallet, was lying in his own sick and completely non responsive.

I told the closest doorman who said he couldn't do anything as wasnt a patron so my friends and I ended up sitting with him and calling 111.
No taxis would take him and we obviously didn't know where to send him anyways. 111 kept asking for details that we just didn't know on the phone (name, DOB, what he'd ingested etc) and in the end we practically had to beg for some help.

When the paramedics came they were clearly pissed off that they were responding to a drunken lad and kept telling us off for him being in that state. We had been drinking as well but definitely not stupid drunk and had been trying to help!

Eventually they took him in an ambulance and I called the hospital the next day to see if he was okay but they wouldn't tell me anything (obviously).

saraclara · 04/09/2023 16:29

My highly intelligent mum had a stroke 14 years ago. She's now paralysed but as sharp in her conversation as ever. Over those years I've watched her be treated and spoken to as if she's was a toddler SO many times. She hates it, and I'm afraid she takes no prisoners when it happens.

This is by carers, nurses and doctors. I haven't seen paramedics with her, but who knows. I hope I can stand up for myself when it starts to happen to me.

CoffeeCantata · 04/09/2023 16:19
  1. Even if they were, I wouldn't care because by definition, what they do is so urgent and demanding that their tone of voice is totally irrelevant, surely.

  2. But in fact I've always found paramedics to be at least as amazing as they're portrayed on TV dramas. We've had a few incidents with them and their competence, their cool, calm demeanour, the way they keep you or your relative talking to distract you from unpleasant sights or distressing procedures etc is so skillful. I'm in awe of them as a profession. Especially when you consider that some morons actually target them while they are attending an incident.

  3. They can do no wrong in my eyes!

Echio · 04/09/2023 16:05

@PostItInABook it sounds like you've got a good head and heart on you - thanks for sharing.

Echio · 04/09/2023 16:04

I'm with you OP - I'm kind of amazed this hasn't been beaten out of people with training on professional standards. I think when you're in a situation when you're feeling vulnerable and scared, someone just using your name is an incredibly powerful force to help reassure you- there's no need for the sexual innuendo, the 'sweetheart' or 'pet' or whatever, all of that nonsense. My grandfather suffered a stroke - he was a headmaster for 40 years, with old fashioned values and used to being called 'Mr Brown' by people - he'd expect this of his doctors for sure. The way all the health professionals called him 'love' etc- he would have hated it - totally alien to his sense of self (sadly he was unable to communicate, but if there was anything of him there, it would have had some blood boiling!). You might say 'get over it' but I'd say when you're in your last few months of life, now's not the time to change him, it's the time for people to accommodate some old fashioned curtesies that meant a lot to him.

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 15:45

BeachHutCornwall · 04/09/2023 14:09

They are great, but I had one come out to me, and she spent more time talking to my husband than me - expressed surprise that he is 10 years younger, told me I look like his mother - and then continued attempting to flirt with him, until he told her to grow up

It was OK, I was only having a heart attack

Shock that is disgraceful!

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 15:43

PostItInABook · 04/09/2023 13:45

I’m a paramedic and know the exact type of colleague you are referring to and it really irritates me, to the point where I will engineer things so I can step in and take over. It’s usually older, female colleagues who are mothers. The other one that annoys me is when colleagues shout at older patients, assuming they are all deaf. 🙄

For what it’s worth I always ask my patients of any age what they would like me to call them….I.e. Mr Jones, first name etc. and then stick to that. Or I will ask a person who knows them. If there’s no one around and I cannot find out their name I just avoid calling them anything.

I do hold people’s hands though or place a hand on their arm or shoulder. A simple act of physical contact like that can be very calming, especially if you can’t speak. And I do sometimes use silly humour but you need to keep that within an appropriate context / boundary and work out if the patient will appreciate that approach or not. That’s hard sometimes, especially as I’m autistic, so I only do that if it’s quite obvious.

The response you gave is absolutely perfect in my opinion and I respect you for your work.
I completely agree that kind words and physical touch are important. But as you said, it's done in a respectful way without the demeaning tone and silly comments.

BeachHutCornwall · 04/09/2023 14:09

They are great, but I had one come out to me, and she spent more time talking to my husband than me - expressed surprise that he is 10 years younger, told me I look like his mother - and then continued attempting to flirt with him, until he told her to grow up

It was OK, I was only having a heart attack

Crimblecrumble1990 · 04/09/2023 14:08

Just by reading your title I knew exactly what your post was going to refer to! I agree it's infantilising. Nothing against the care being provided by paramedics and the like, huge respect to them. It's just this way of talking to older people by some that really irks me.

If someone spoke to my husband like that it would be ridiculous, so what difference does it make in 30 years time when he's elderly?

Similarly, my grandmother is also called Dorothy. Always has been known by her full name as is her preference for the last 90 years. However staff at her care home insist on calling her Dotty, no matter how many times we asked her to be called Dorothy. They are doing it affectionately and she is very well cared for. It's just odd, if she was 40 years younger and someone was calling her a name she didn't like in the work place then it wouldn't be acceptable.

Whatswhatwhichiswhich · 04/09/2023 14:08

Never had anything but respect and care from paramedics, they know how to use humour to diffuse a situation and keep everyone calm is the biggest thing about them I’ve found. DC has ASD, extremely avoidant to most textures. Getting medication into him is near impossible. A very bad bought of croup led to him turning blue and badly struggling to breathe yet it still took two paramedics to restrain him enough to get steroids into him. They saved his life, cracked jokes throughout, were calm and explained everything they were doing and even managed to get DC to laugh once his breathing was stabilised. The guy told DC he had the strength of Hulk and he hoped never to meet him down a dark ally…. DC was 4 and over the moon. YABU to generalise anything at all from a TV program. Go out and interact with the real world.

Conkersinautumn · 04/09/2023 13:49

Some carers do use this curious approach and it isn't how we are trained or selected. But we are expected to build a rapport very quickly, I can't pull off this weird inappropriate jokeyness but probably because that wouldn't be natural for me. Some people are patronising, we also do ask people and prompt people a lot - so talk someone all the way through getting dressed which can sound patronising. We know they know what's going on, but keeping a stream of consciousness keeps the client and us on task, when they're paying by the hour they'd usually rather we get through the mundane bits and spend more time on getting cushions just so, finding the charger cable, letting them know choices for meals or double checking med changes. The talking someone through a task as well helps with consent/ touch/ expectation. The obvious is coming but by saying ' could you just lift up your arm so I can get this bra ... rather than standing there saying and your bra, I'm always clear where I'm going to be touching, moving a client with a constant stream of asking there's no surprise for the client, helps with trust.

PostItInABook · 04/09/2023 13:45

I’m a paramedic and know the exact type of colleague you are referring to and it really irritates me, to the point where I will engineer things so I can step in and take over. It’s usually older, female colleagues who are mothers. The other one that annoys me is when colleagues shout at older patients, assuming they are all deaf. 🙄

For what it’s worth I always ask my patients of any age what they would like me to call them….I.e. Mr Jones, first name etc. and then stick to that. Or I will ask a person who knows them. If there’s no one around and I cannot find out their name I just avoid calling them anything.

I do hold people’s hands though or place a hand on their arm or shoulder. A simple act of physical contact like that can be very calming, especially if you can’t speak. And I do sometimes use silly humour but you need to keep that within an appropriate context / boundary and work out if the patient will appreciate that approach or not. That’s hard sometimes, especially as I’m autistic, so I only do that if it’s quite obvious.

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 13:44

Aquaphant · 04/09/2023 13:42

Yes, I noticed this as well whilst watching one of those ambulance shows. What got me was how the 999 dispatchers speak to people on the phone. The constant "alright?" at the end of every sentence as though speaking to a small child gets on my last nerve. It's not soothing, it's patronising and irritating.

Completely agree, so irritating!

Riapia · 04/09/2023 13:43

If it had been a male para medic touching a female patient’s knee and making lewd comments would it have been classed as merely patronising.