Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think paramedics are patronising

115 replies

dontbeunreasonable · 04/09/2023 11:28

First of all I think paramedics are absolutely amazing and I have so so much respect for the job they do. I personally know three and think very highly of them all.
However, when I watch 999 shows like 'Ambulance' etc the way they speak to elderly patients makes me cringe.
For example: last night I saw one where they went to home of an almost comatose man and the woman was all 'hello darling hold my hand' all perfectly fine and suitable as kindness is needed. But then she kept saying 'ooh Harold it's been a while since somebody has touched my knee' then kept repeating it to his family members who were coming in and out. Saying again 'ooh, don't disturb us he's touching my knee'!
I find this so disrespectful as the man was unable to speak but conscious and he may not have appreciated that kind of nonsense.
I know when my father was dying of cancer he would have absolutely hated all that carry on.
I keep seeing stuff like that when they talk to the elderly calling them sweetheart and 'oh I bet you still have all the lads after you' etc and I really think it's not on.
Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London. But there's a time and place isn't there?

OP posts:
NC19879 · 04/09/2023 23:17

I think you have to be able to read people
I've worked as a carer and a dispatcher and both are hard jobs in totally different ways. You learn how different people want to be spoken to as a carer but as a paramedic you're only getting a brief minute to assess everything

People on here would be horrified if they had heard how I spoke to some people on the phone. I've told someone to act like an adult before and get a grip - their child wasn't breathing and I didn't have much time to get them to stop screaming and start CPR. They wrote me a lovely letter thanking me for shouting at them Blush
Sometimes you have to comfort and sometimes be quite forceful and sometimes you have to try every single tool you have to get someone to do what you need them to do

olderbutwiser · 04/09/2023 23:12

I watch paramedics at work a lot, and DH is a paramedic. Some are really quick to pick up the right tone for the patient, be it respectful or jokey; some are professional but stay detached; some are well meaning but a bit tone deaf; a very very tiny minority (and fewer and fewer as time goes by) are right arseholes.

If you have a bad experience report it to the ambulance trust - it will get through to their managers. Similarly if you have a good experience report it - it will absolutely make their day, they don’t tend to get that much feedback.

UsingChangeofName · 04/09/2023 23:07

Agree with @melj1213 and @lapsedbookworm and also @ItWasAllFields in the post before.

lapsedbookworm · 04/09/2023 22:59

melj1213 · 04/09/2023 12:08

I'll preface this with the fact that I'm no paramedic but I am a first aider and have more than once been in a situation where the casualty has been badly hurt and I'm trying to keep them conscious and/or responsive whilst also trying to calm any family/friends who are with them.

The easiest way to do so is to keep it light and so a few jokes/light-hearted comments keep things ticking over while waiting for help to arrive. Yes it can seem patronising but when you're busy trying to save someone's life you're not really thinking much about how deep the conversation is so you use anything to keep your monologue/the discussion going.

Agreed. In this situation you are using only a tiny bit of your brain to run the "chat" while you're focusing on lots of other factors

(Not a paramedic but done a fair amount of first aid aid including a number of times with my own child who had anaphylaxis but also had anxiety for a a while and the symptoms are easily confused so chatting to him while assessing the situation was important)

ItWasAllFields · 04/09/2023 22:47

If I was in agony and terrified, I wouldn't care how a paramedic spoke to me, as long as they stopped the pain.

WillyWhale · 04/09/2023 22:40

sadaboutmycat · 04/09/2023 20:36

No.

I think people who start threads about life saving professionals are unpleasant though.

Attended any gruesome deaths yourself recently, all in a day's work?

They do a great job, but nobody is above criticism because of their profession! How does this thread make anyone unpleasant? Silly thing to say

Gnomegarden32 · 04/09/2023 22:29

I think society generally has quite a patronising attitude to older people

I agree with this. I don’t blame the paramedics but as a society we infantilise the elderly. They’ve lived a whole life and should be treated with respect. I think it’s something cultural to do with not wanting to face up to death and old age.

saraclara · 04/09/2023 22:22

jolaylasofia · 04/09/2023 22:05

calling someone sweetheart north of watford gap is absolutely normal and appreciated. As is duck, hun, love etc

My mum and my in-law auntie (both 90 and living considerably north of Watford) would beg to disagree. Both have had repeated hospital stays over the last year or two, and both cling desperately to their dignity during those stays. They have both been very unhappy at being called pet names when feeling vulnerable.

BertieBotts · 04/09/2023 22:15

I find it reassuring when I've been in that situation, and I find humour does help me relax and not be so afraid. So I think it's great that they are allowed to do and say those things. No, you shouldn't be doing innuendo around someone who isn't aware of what's happening or able to respond, but it can be light hearted and I think sometimes it can be the right thing to get someone smiling and not worrying.

jolaylasofia · 04/09/2023 22:05

calling someone sweetheart north of watford gap is absolutely normal and appreciated. As is duck, hun, love etc

LolaJug · 04/09/2023 22:00

The final time my mother was taken into hospital before dying from a short battle with cancer we had an extremely unpleasant experience with the paramedics. She was in a lot of pain and, granted, she was a little confused and asking what was going on. The male paramedic spoke to her without any compassion or patience. He repeatedly said ‘Well what do you want to do love we can’t keep hanging around.’ He moved her into a portable chair and when she cried out in pain kept sighing and said we’ve got to move this is taking too long.She was scared and I will never forget this moment. We were already in shock because of how quickly the cancer had progressed. diagnosed end of October and had died first week of December. I know not all paramedics are like this but some definitely require more training.

Itslosenotloose · 04/09/2023 21:50

Oh my god OP, I’ve thought this for ages but I’ve never actually spoken to anybody about it. I too think paramedics are really nice people. Truly genuine but I’ve always found no matter what situation they use far too much humour. I know it comes from a good place but I dunno…… I guess the situations just aren’t funny. I ended up calling them whilst giving birth unexpectedly at home and I just wished they would all stop joking by the end of it all. It wasn’t overly funny and I was quite traumatised.

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 21:46

jolaylasofia · 04/09/2023 21:14

oh give it a rest.

Very helpful thanks

NannyGythaOgg · 04/09/2023 21:35

YABU

thorneyislanddoris · 04/09/2023 21:18

I've had to call an ambulance four times in the last two years once for myself once for my dad and twice for my mum and every time the paramedics were absolutely fantastic. They do an absolutely brilliant job in very difficult circumstances and none of them were like that with us at all.

jolaylasofia · 04/09/2023 21:14

oh give it a rest.

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 04/09/2023 21:09

The thing is, they don't know the patient from Adam when they meet them. If they were purely matter of fact then that may not be the right approach for a patient who would feel more comfortable with the joking around approach that you highlighted. They have to just go into a situation and judge the best approach to take. They may have done so in your example and decided to take the jokey approach.

Did the patient seem uncomfortable with the interaction? And if so, did the paramedic change their manner?

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 21:06

sadaboutmycat · 04/09/2023 20:36

No.

I think people who start threads about life saving professionals are unpleasant though.

Attended any gruesome deaths yourself recently, all in a day's work?

Who's got your goat?!
I didn't say anything nasty, it was just a conversation.
As you asked, I witnessed my friend's partner die of a knife attack a few months ago and helped the best I could.
This wasn't about dismissing the work they do if you'd read the post.

sadaboutmycat · 04/09/2023 20:36

No.

I think people who start threads about life saving professionals are unpleasant though.

Attended any gruesome deaths yourself recently, all in a day's work?

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 20:25

Topofthemornintoya · 04/09/2023 19:01

The only time I've ever had any interaction with a paramedic was in Manchester. I'm from Northern Ireland and mentioned it as we were going to the hospital. He started asking me questions from a form.

Nationality? British?

I said 'no, Irish'.

He smirked at the other paramedic and said 'yeah, same thing'.

I didn't think there was any need for it.

Ha! Well that's definitely ignorance. I would hope most people know the difference Grin

Dontbeamenace · 04/09/2023 20:24

Oblomov23 · 04/09/2023 19:34

That tv programme does paramedics no favours. I work for an ambulance company and all our paramedics are utterly professional.

All of yours may be perfectly professional and a lot of them are.
But as the thread shows from other comments what I described does happen a lot. The show was only an example.

Oblomov23 · 04/09/2023 19:34

That tv programme does paramedics no favours. I work for an ambulance company and all our paramedics are utterly professional.

catin8oots · 04/09/2023 19:25

Totally agree OP. And they get automatic hero status, like GPS.

If I spoke to somebody like that in my job (support/charity) I'd be up for misconduct.

Topofthemornintoya · 04/09/2023 19:03

Oh, I tell a lie. I had a drunken accident in Liverpool and kept apologising to the paramedic. He said I was the nicest girl he had ever met. Obviously a lie but I thought it was sweet.
The plot thickens!

Topofthemornintoya · 04/09/2023 19:01

The only time I've ever had any interaction with a paramedic was in Manchester. I'm from Northern Ireland and mentioned it as we were going to the hospital. He started asking me questions from a form.

Nationality? British?

I said 'no, Irish'.

He smirked at the other paramedic and said 'yeah, same thing'.

I didn't think there was any need for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread