Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think paramedics are patronising

115 replies

dontbeunreasonable · 04/09/2023 11:28

First of all I think paramedics are absolutely amazing and I have so so much respect for the job they do. I personally know three and think very highly of them all.
However, when I watch 999 shows like 'Ambulance' etc the way they speak to elderly patients makes me cringe.
For example: last night I saw one where they went to home of an almost comatose man and the woman was all 'hello darling hold my hand' all perfectly fine and suitable as kindness is needed. But then she kept saying 'ooh Harold it's been a while since somebody has touched my knee' then kept repeating it to his family members who were coming in and out. Saying again 'ooh, don't disturb us he's touching my knee'!
I find this so disrespectful as the man was unable to speak but conscious and he may not have appreciated that kind of nonsense.
I know when my father was dying of cancer he would have absolutely hated all that carry on.
I keep seeing stuff like that when they talk to the elderly calling them sweetheart and 'oh I bet you still have all the lads after you' etc and I really think it's not on.
Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London. But there's a time and place isn't there?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dontbeamenace · 07/09/2023 17:54

GabriellaMontez · 05/09/2023 07:32

Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London

I didn't know know this. How do you know this? And what way is it different?

If you didn't know this, then I'm assuming you must not be from England? The north/south divide of humour and mannerisms is very well known.
Northerners are more brash/vulgar/ open whereas southerners more reserved and probably more tactful, plus maybe a bit more 'cool' in our attitude.
Not saying this is gospel. Loads would disagree with me.
But a general consensus would describe it is as such.
You asked how I know... I am from London, wend to boarding school in York so am familiar with different humour.

nimmu · 05/09/2023 15:57

My aunt ((late 60s) had a spell in hospital recently for her hip. She objected (complained to us that is) to one particular nurse who would speak to her and the elderly patients in a baby voice, and would repeat her first name over and over, almost every sentence.

I don't think she liked the informal use of her first name, but I think that's more usual now. More that it was repeated so much. I said i thought that must have been an attempt to establish a rapport and appear friendly.

nimmu · 05/09/2023 15:52

jolaylasofia · 05/09/2023 12:39

@saraclara they would object to being called sweetheart??? i mean my home towns are split between west midlands and liverpool. Everyone gets called darling, sweetheart, hunny, chuck etc no matter what age or gender it's polite and not condescending.

I wouldn't object to that.

Those terms are used for all ages, and aren't related to not speaking in a condescending baby voice to the elderly.

ParentingSolo · 05/09/2023 14:54

Posted too soon! - Enjoy being the one 'in charge' around people who are in a vulnerable state. This is, I'm 99% certain, why an ex-friend became a nurse. She doesn't have a compassionate bone in her body and gets a real kick out of being around people who she is better off than - in any way shape or form, not just financially. Of course there are also some wonderful people who work in healthcare too

ParentingSolo · 05/09/2023 14:46

Unfortunately there's quite a few people who work in the healthcare sector not because they want to help people but because they enjoy the e

jolaylasofia · 05/09/2023 14:09

@saraclara i should imagine you are right about it being the tone. I do understand that older people shouldn't be treated like children but a lot of them love it and act very baby like because they love the attention- having not much attention at home iyswim. My dad absolutely revelled in it and i've had 3 aunts and uncles that passed away in 2020/2021 with dementia (and they say it's not genetic) and covid and you had to talk to them like it because otherwise they would just not cooperate or listen.

saraclara · 05/09/2023 13:28

jolaylasofia · 05/09/2023 12:39

@saraclara they would object to being called sweetheart??? i mean my home towns are split between west midlands and liverpool. Everyone gets called darling, sweetheart, hunny, chuck etc no matter what age or gender it's polite and not condescending.

In hospital, yes.

As an equal, no.

They will happily wander round a market where everyone they know and most of the stallholders will call them love, duck, sweetheart etc.
But apparently it feels very different when you're vulnerable and powerless, and seems less like affection or a verbal habit, than patronisation.
I see how that doesn't sound logical, but having experienced their real distress and frustration, it's clearly real to them.

Like I say, their not related to each other and they're quite different people. So it's not a familial learned thing, and maybe more of a subconscious need to hang on to their sense of self and be respected as competent independent adults.

Or maybe it's simply the tone of voice of the speaker than changes with the two environments? I don't know, but I've learned to empathise with them both.

jolaylasofia · 05/09/2023 12:39

@saraclara they would object to being called sweetheart??? i mean my home towns are split between west midlands and liverpool. Everyone gets called darling, sweetheart, hunny, chuck etc no matter what age or gender it's polite and not condescending.

nimmu · 05/09/2023 10:58

Some HCPs, but not specifically paramedics really. Probably staff in care homes actually the most. IME

Though you'll find a minority of people, HCPs and the general public, speak to the elderly like they're babies. It is demeaning and not treating them with dignity.

Issummernearlyover · 05/09/2023 08:12

I'm still seething from earlier this year when DH called 999 as I had collapsed with a heart problem.

Male paramedic sneered at me and asked how long I had had health anxiety.

Grudgingly took me to hospital. It's a long journey from where I live so he was complaining that it was unnecessary and wouldn't believe my DH that I'd been unconscious on the floor.

Dumped me in a waiting room in a wheelchair whereupon I collapsed again and frightened the other patients who called for help.

At least the ED staff realised I was there for a genuine reason.

I still wish I'd make a complaint about his attitude.

I'd have much preferred the kindly banter we see on tv programmes and being called love or darling to being told I was a hypochondriac.

Newbutoldfather · 05/09/2023 07:52

When I watch these shows I always think what nice people they are. OTOH, they are definitely patronising, especially to older people.

I do think that this is a bit of a problem with the whole ‘free at the point of service’ NHS. It is remarkable the difference in the way you are treated by the same medical staff when you are using them privately. You get treated as a paying client, rather than someone they are doing a favour to (there are exceptions to this in the NHS, particularly when they realise you have a decent graph of scientific vocabulary).

i do think that training should emphasise that the patients are paying customers, even if they do it collectively through taxes, and should be treated accordingly.

But it is a tough one and I would just grin and bear it if I felt that a paramedic was doing their best to be nice.

OrlandointheWilderness · 05/09/2023 07:40

I'm a student nurse, and I've seen a wide range of approaches. It's actually fairly tricky to judge - some people love being addressed in a familiar fashion and some hate it and find it disrespectful. You do just slip into your normal way of interacting with your patients, and humour is a really effective way of getting people to relax and trust you.

GabriellaMontez · 05/09/2023 07:32

Side note: it often seems to be the ones from the north of England where I know the humour is very different to London

I didn't know know this. How do you know this? And what way is it different?

user07327944 · 05/09/2023 06:26

I've had paramedics talk about me as if I'm not in the room when I've been rolling around in pain. I remember a specific occasion where they were talking amongst themselves saying I have BPD as I'm faking my pain.

Another time I was vomiting and rolling around in pain. When one female paramedic was asking things like my address my partner answered for me as I was constantly vomiting. The paramedic was then very condescending and said I needed to answer myself and get over myself.

I've had paramedics come in and start touching and interfering with my furniture and household items. This particular paramedic switched off both my fan and my clothes heater. Then complained it was hot and asked if I could put the fan on (the one he just switched off)

I've had paramedics constantly asking how much I've had to drink and not accepting I'm sober and just ill.

I've had tons of experience with them and yes, I've often found your opinion to be true. However, I've found it no more true than for anyone else in Healthcare. They can all act that way and often do.

Dontbeamenace · 05/09/2023 03:29

Brightandshining · 05/09/2023 02:51

You cannot do right for doing wrong working as an emergency healthcare worker. Every single person you come across will have different values and ideas about what constitutes politeness and warmth... so you'd need an incredibly high level of emotional intelligence and people skills to be getting that right constantly... and even if you had that level of social skill you are also extremely tired working non stop 12 hour shifts sometimes at night.
I mean give them a break. One person's 'patronising' is another person's 'warm and friendly' They are used to being around terrified people and sometimes a bit of humour can be so calming and beneficial in calming people. No they don't always get the tone exactly right. But id personally rather have the attempt than coldness

You're right and there was no disrespect meant.
As I said in my original post this wasn't about bashing people. But as others have said and even a paramedic themselves said that it's cringing to hear that way of speaking.

sadaboutmycat · 05/09/2023 03:17

@Dontbeamenace erm... the OP got my goat? That's why I replied? 🤷🏻‍♀️

Brightandshining · 05/09/2023 02:51

You cannot do right for doing wrong working as an emergency healthcare worker. Every single person you come across will have different values and ideas about what constitutes politeness and warmth... so you'd need an incredibly high level of emotional intelligence and people skills to be getting that right constantly... and even if you had that level of social skill you are also extremely tired working non stop 12 hour shifts sometimes at night.
I mean give them a break. One person's 'patronising' is another person's 'warm and friendly' They are used to being around terrified people and sometimes a bit of humour can be so calming and beneficial in calming people. No they don't always get the tone exactly right. But id personally rather have the attempt than coldness

OCaptain · 05/09/2023 02:30

FOJN · 04/09/2023 12:02

I think society generally has quite a patronising attitude to older people and people with disabilities. I cringe when I hear the way some people speak to people in either of those groups.

I think perhaps the paramedics try to joke and be light hearted to reassure people in situations which are often stressful and worrying and maybe the joking doesn't always land well.

Edited

I have a doctorate and used to work fairly high up in the corporate world before I had to retire due to my disability making it more difficult for me to work.

On occasion, the way I am spoken down to when I am occasionally in a wheelchair or in need of medical assistance is eye-opening. It is assumed I cannot understand simple instructions. I am talked to like I'm a toddler: "You'd - like - a - drink?" Sometimes people just stand to the side with awkward, you-poor-thing smiles.

I used to lead departments of 200 people, FFS. I'm not the suddenly the village idiot because I'm sitting in a chair!

TawnyLarue · 05/09/2023 02:20

Loads and loads of people speak to the elderly like they are very small children. It is not a trait reserved to the healthcare professions.

It drives my 85 year old grandmother round the bend.

melj1213 · 05/09/2023 01:15

lapsedbookworm · 04/09/2023 22:59

Agreed. In this situation you are using only a tiny bit of your brain to run the "chat" while you're focusing on lots of other factors

(Not a paramedic but done a fair amount of first aid aid including a number of times with my own child who had anaphylaxis but also had anxiety for a a while and the symptoms are easily confused so chatting to him while assessing the situation was important)

Exactly, sometimes you have someone who is clearly in pain and/or close to the edge of consciousness and you know that the second you stop talking they are just going to drift off which is not what you want ... but you can't start having a deep conversation because you're also assessing the situation - what supplies do I need, what supplies do I have, who is around to help, what do I need them to do, who else needs help, has anyone called 999, does anyone know the information the 999 operator requires so I can hand the phone to them and concentrate on keeping the casualty as comfortable as possible etcetc - as well as trying to keep everyone else calm and keep control of what is happening, all in the span of a couple of minutes.

During all of this you need to keep up a stream of information between you and the casualty - initially you can focus on the facts "Can you tell me your name? Can you tell me what happened? Has anyone called an ambulance yet? Can you tell me where it hurts etc" but then you get to the point where you have dealt with the immediate danger, you have all of the facts but you are still waiting for the ambulance to arrive. In those cases you need to keep the casualty talking and responding but the problem is this is a relative stranger and you have no idea what things they're interested in or what their life experience is etc so it's easy to just make light hearted conversation based on what is happening at the moment.

A couple of weeks ago I was called at work to an elderly gentleman who had fallen outside our store, he was a bloody mess when I arrived and his wife was hysterical ... I managed to talk to the gentleman and found out he was on blood thinners so whilst it looked awful he actually wasn't as badly hurt as it first appeared but still needed an ambulance as he was feeling a bit woozy due to the blood loss and needed to be stitched up in hospital and checked over but we weren't top priority for the ambulance list. Because of where he had fallen and the size of his injury it was too dangerous to try and move him far so I managed to get him sitting up and then we had screens put up to shield us from anyone gawking while we sat and waited for the ambulance.

By this point he was massively embarrassed at the whole situation and kept trying to say he was fine and just needed to go home but by making little light hearted comments I got him chatting, and the comment "You're going to have some impressive looking bruises, I hope you've started practicing your story about how the other guy turned out" etc got him talking about the fact he was a champion boxer when he was in the army back in the day and then lead on to a natural conversation which filled the time until the ambulance arrived, let me keep an eye on how alert he was (whenever he started trailing off I could ask him questions about what he'd just said to keep him going), took his mind off the injury and also calmed his wife as we could include her in the conversation... All of which was achieved from a jokey opening comment.

sezzer87 · 05/09/2023 01:01

I agree somewhat. I don't like it when anyone treats an elderly person like they're stupid and I don't care how many lives you've saved, etiquette and respect still apply to you.

NorthernLights5 · 05/09/2023 00:12

I work in elderly care and when you've done it for a while (this will be my 12th year), you get to read people very quickly and speak to them accordingly. I've worked with people who really respond well to calling them sweetheart (for example) and some who really respond to very business like talk. If you haven't done the job you won't get it. Yes some paramedics are better than others but I can only think of maybe 5 who I'd never want back.

Dontbeamenace · 05/09/2023 00:02

Calling someone sweetheart or hun is not an issue. I don't have a problem with that at all.
It's not what my original post was about. I have no issue with those terms at all. I think it's kind and lovely.
I wish people would read what I actually said.

IdaPrentice · 04/09/2023 23:33

I think using humour is often a good approach, as long as it's not insensitive, so no problem with paramedics being jokey. But I have also watched those programmes like Ambulance, and thought how patronising they often are to older people - talking to them like they're small children. One thing I particularly hate is when they use someone's first name in every sentence. "Come on then Vera, move your legs. How old are you Vera? Thanks Vera." It makes me dread getting old, to be honest - to find yourself being infantilised. I feel like telling the paramedics, you'll be old yourself one day (probably), and find yourself being talked to as if you're three years old (unless things have changed by then).

MsRosley · 04/09/2023 23:25

Gnomegarden32 · 04/09/2023 22:29

I think society generally has quite a patronising attitude to older people

I agree with this. I don’t blame the paramedics but as a society we infantilise the elderly. They’ve lived a whole life and should be treated with respect. I think it’s something cultural to do with not wanting to face up to death and old age.

I think it's just plain old ageism. Younger people assume they're superior to older people, who are just decrepit and foolish.

Swipe left for the next trending thread