Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable to want FIL to STOP buying rubbish!!

62 replies

depressionpitofdoom · 04/09/2023 09:03

I understand that he is doing a nice thing and that he enjoys buying things for my children, but the things he buys are unusable and awful and a waste of his money, a waste of my time because I then have to get rid of the things, a disappointment to my children because they think they're getting new things and they're not (they are young children and don't understand fully yet) and frankly he's taking away from someone who could use those items.

For example, the latest things he has bought is a jumper from the charity shop that is a boys jumper in 9-12m. My daughter is 4 years old. (She is tiny but not quite that tiny). I don't know anyone with a baby that young I can't give it to someone else and I don't have time to take it back to another charity shop. And 12 pairs of very, very old fashioned school knee high socks that are far too large for my eldest. I really struggle with keeping my home manageable and all that's happening is I'm accumulating a mountain of absolute rubbish. I've been told I'm unreasonable and nasty if I tell him to stop buying things because it brings him happiness - but it's driving me insane.

I'm the one who has to get rid of it all, I don't have space in my home for all of this tat that won't get used and can't be sold because its in terrible condition or so old fashioned that nobody would use it and I don't drive. For me. Taking something to a charity shop takes 2 hours out of my day, I dont want to just throw things in the bin but I feel like I have no choice. Someone else could have used those things and its obviously not brilliant for the environment but I don't have space to store it.

OP posts:
JellyBabiesSaveLives · 04/09/2023 10:17

You need to put it somewhere where it inconveniences your partner until he deals with it. So if he has his own car, the stuff stays in the boot. If it comes in the house, it goes on his desk or in his wardrobe or if all else fails, on the floor by his side of the bed. You don't even open the bags to look what's there - it's your partners job to sort through the junk. If your partner complains about the stuff being in his way, remind him that his dad gets pleasure from buying it all and tell your partner he is being unreasonable and nasty ...

CuriousPixie · 04/09/2023 10:17

Ah gift anxiety! I feel your pain. FIL is doing something that makes him feel good without putting any thought into it whatsoever. So it’s really all about him than the kids.
tge shite I’ve been given over the years by people who I thought knew me and the fact they got me so ‘way off the mark pressies makes me feel unseen and invalid. I think that’s the crux of it, particularly if I’ve said I don’t want anything or if I’ve been specifically asked and then my response is completely ignored. It’s infuriating.
as it’s stuff from a charity shop it’s not quite so bad but must be disappointing for the kids nonetheless.

SafferUpNorth · 04/09/2023 10:15

So your DH does not want to mention to his dad to stop buying useless stuff? And doesn't want you to raise it either? Well, then tell your DH he can be the one that checks every item (for size, suitability etc) before presenting to the children. And he can be the one who takes unsuitable items to a charity shop/clothing bank.

Like you, I would be deeply uncomfortable with just binning it all - such as waste. Tell DH it's his job to find somewhere to donate unsuitable stuff.

HearMeSnore · 04/09/2023 10:14

My MIL does this. I keep a carrier bag hanging under the stairs and all the crap goes straight in there. Then as soon as the next charity collection bag comes through the door (about once a week round our way) out it all goes.

Feverly · 04/09/2023 10:07

Don’t allow your boyfriend to make it your problem. He accepts the trash, it gets put in to a bin bag and left in his car/his side of the bed. Spread the ‘joy’, it’s an act of kindness.
No need for you to give it a moments thought.

jlpth · 04/09/2023 10:03

I would just shove it all in the bin. There’s only so much you can do if it’s a 2 hour mess about to get to a charity shop.

Soverymuchfruit · 04/09/2023 10:00

Is your FIL clearly being told that these things are not useful? If he hands them to his son who says thank you, he may not realise. If your DH is not happy with you saying that he should buy nothing at all, how about, every time, you send a message like this: "thank you so much for the lovely thing! Unfortunately we will have to hand it on as it is the wrong size. The DC are sizes x, y and z. Would be lovely if you could get them some new trousers if you see any as we are short of those."

If he gets that message every time, instead of just being thanked by his son, then he may clock on and start being a useful source of nice things.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/09/2023 09:57

An app called olio is also good for giving stufff away for free but it's not your job to admin this

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/09/2023 09:57

Stormydayagain · 04/09/2023 09:51

I know how you feel, MIL loves a bargain, so will buy clothes in the sale (just supermarket stuff) years ahead of dd age. We live in a tiny cottage with no attic space, bedrooms in the attic where we can't have proper wardrobes due to low ceiling, DH taking up one room as office for WFH etc. I've said over and over that we don't have space to store much stuff. But she can't stop herself.

It is also always on me to declutter and me to do charity shop runs. It drives me bonkers. I try to live fairly minimalisticly, partly by choice and partly out of necessity and then end up feeling like I'm hoarding by proxy due to MILs behaviour.

I would put a box in his office and anything of his or his family's that needs to go goes in there- he can either live with the box/pile or get rid. If he chooses not to recycle that's on his conscience not yours

Soverymuchfruit · 04/09/2023 09:56

Have you checked out how you might give stuff away to people who pick it up from yours? Eg locally here there is a hand me on group for parents, run through facebook.

Have you tried to redirect FIL to buy what you do want? Tell him in detail what size your DC are and what they need? That might work out easier than asking him to buy nothing at all.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/09/2023 09:56

Trenchfootinthescottishhighlandstoday · 04/09/2023 09:54

Shove it all in dh's car boot or wardrobe..

Yup

June628 · 04/09/2023 09:56

Just bin it. Don’t feel bad, it’s not your fault! My FIL is the same, maybe slightly less useless stuff but still unnecessary, unwanted charity shop junk. I just get rid of it as soon as my child forgets about it.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/09/2023 09:56

Don't let your DH even bring it into the house he has to keep it in his own car and get rid of it. The eco anxiety if he chooses to bin rather than charity shop or recycle isn't on your shoulders

Trenchfootinthescottishhighlandstoday · 04/09/2023 09:54

Shove it all in dh's car boot or wardrobe..

Stormydayagain · 04/09/2023 09:51

I know how you feel, MIL loves a bargain, so will buy clothes in the sale (just supermarket stuff) years ahead of dd age. We live in a tiny cottage with no attic space, bedrooms in the attic where we can't have proper wardrobes due to low ceiling, DH taking up one room as office for WFH etc. I've said over and over that we don't have space to store much stuff. But she can't stop herself.

It is also always on me to declutter and me to do charity shop runs. It drives me bonkers. I try to live fairly minimalisticly, partly by choice and partly out of necessity and then end up feeling like I'm hoarding by proxy due to MILs behaviour.

thecatsthecats · 04/09/2023 09:44

I have a new rule that unwanted gifts don't get further than the hallway. There's a regifting/recycling/charity shop/clothes bin right next to the front door.

I thank the recipient, and it goes straight in the box for going out again. No dithering over whether it gets house room.

MintJulia · 04/09/2023 09:41

I sympathise. My dm used to work in a charity shop and did this. It drove me crazy until I put an extra recycling box in the garage. Everything she bought went straight in the box, and then into the Salvation Army collection box at Tesco on a Saturday morning.

The longest any of her 'bargains' spent in my house was 7 days.

She enjoyed buying them, I dropped them off on my regular routine. She had a free hobby for two minutes of my time.

Workawayxx · 04/09/2023 09:39

Anglo collections are your friend here. They pick up black bags of clothes/toys - you just leave on your doorstep and they come monthly or twice a month. You sign up here. They donate to charity (you can choose from a few which you want to support) but do also make money I believe. At least the stuff isn’t going to land fill.

UtterlyUnimaginativeUsername · 04/09/2023 09:39

jannier · 04/09/2023 09:38

Tell dp to stop at a charity clothes collection bin on his way home he he must pass one

Yup. He's accepting the stuff, it should be his problem, not yours.

Jellycats4life · 04/09/2023 09:39

I can’t believe you’re getting so many replies suggesting that you waste your valuable time and mental energy repurposing and regifting the piles of unwanted CRAP your FIL is foisting upon you.

Fuck that.

Your FIL has a problem. Call it compulsive spending, call it a form of hoarding, call it whatever you like. He doesn’t get to feel good about himself for treating the grandkids when the stuff he buys is totally useless.

If I were you I’d refuse to take it. Especially the grotty clothing.

jannier · 04/09/2023 09:38

Tell dp to stop at a charity clothes collection bin on his way home he he must pass one

msbevvy · 04/09/2023 09:35

If it is such a long way to a charity shop is there any chance there is a container for clothes at a local recycling centre? There is an one at our local supermarket and also at the fire station.

In your shoes I would be furious with your partner for not trying to stop you getting lumbered with things and also for wanting to just chuck unwanted items in the bin.

Kucinghitam · 04/09/2023 09:35

FiL does this all the time. He can't resist a jumble sale or charity shop or anywhere he thinks will have bargains.

Some of the treasures he's given DDs in recent years are: a toddler's wooden abacus, mobile of cute little cartoony characters for hanging over a baby's cot, baby board books and highly technical textbooks on random topics (both from a library sale), little handbags with Mickey Mouse on them, bottles of foundation in very pale colour, eyebrow makeup palettes, some sort of eye-bag cream...

DH has repeatedly (but nicely and with gratitude) asked FiL not to do this but he just can't resist. Eventually we gave up and just accept the gifts with copious thanks, then charity shop or bin it all immediately.

depressionpitofdoom · 04/09/2023 09:35

My only thing about the charity shop is that someone who's struggling for money could have made far better use out of some of those items than I can.

OP posts:
depressionpitofdoom · 04/09/2023 09:33

When I say new I mean to them! I BUY them bits from charity shops that not the issue. The issue is: here's a present - they're excited - it doesn't fit them or is totally unsuitable for them (a crop top for a 5 year old was another questionable purchase). Believe me I would be happy with nothing. I don't care if somethings new or not - I just care that its more work for me when I'm already drowning in things that need doing.

OP posts: