Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable to want FIL to STOP buying rubbish!!

62 replies

depressionpitofdoom · 04/09/2023 09:03

I understand that he is doing a nice thing and that he enjoys buying things for my children, but the things he buys are unusable and awful and a waste of his money, a waste of my time because I then have to get rid of the things, a disappointment to my children because they think they're getting new things and they're not (they are young children and don't understand fully yet) and frankly he's taking away from someone who could use those items.

For example, the latest things he has bought is a jumper from the charity shop that is a boys jumper in 9-12m. My daughter is 4 years old. (She is tiny but not quite that tiny). I don't know anyone with a baby that young I can't give it to someone else and I don't have time to take it back to another charity shop. And 12 pairs of very, very old fashioned school knee high socks that are far too large for my eldest. I really struggle with keeping my home manageable and all that's happening is I'm accumulating a mountain of absolute rubbish. I've been told I'm unreasonable and nasty if I tell him to stop buying things because it brings him happiness - but it's driving me insane.

I'm the one who has to get rid of it all, I don't have space in my home for all of this tat that won't get used and can't be sold because its in terrible condition or so old fashioned that nobody would use it and I don't drive. For me. Taking something to a charity shop takes 2 hours out of my day, I dont want to just throw things in the bin but I feel like I have no choice. Someone else could have used those things and its obviously not brilliant for the environment but I don't have space to store it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MaggieFS · 04/09/2023 15:13

Does your DH have a car? I'd start using his boot to store all of these things in because the house is full.

MitchellMummy · 04/09/2023 15:03

Any local jumble sales you could donate the stuff to? Some of the groups even collect from houses if you let them know.

GrandHighPoohbah · 04/09/2023 14:56

It's odd that your FIL doesn't actually want to give the gifts directly to the children if it gives him such pleasure? Does he ever ask about them once he's given them to your DH? If not, then I think there are limits to the extent of your duty to the environment, and they just go in the bin.

Curseofthenation · 04/09/2023 14:47

Ah, my DM does this. She bought a party dress for a 3 year old. I have a 2 year old DS and a baby on the way...she can't resist a bargain at a bootfair.

I try to give my DM things to look for, then it's like a fun bargain orientated scavenger hunt. It seems to work as she is extra pleased with herself when she gets something off the list. The dress stayed with my DM. I've said that she can give it to me if second DC is a girl, on her second birthday 😂.

Cherry2456 · 04/09/2023 14:01

Put it in the boot of car and when it gets full
tell DH to take it to the charity shops it’s not your problem. Or give it straight bk to the grandfather.

Workawayxx · 04/09/2023 13:36

No problem @BIossomtoes , I think they also take kitchen items and small electrical items. It has helped me so so much with decluttering!

InSpainTheRain · 04/09/2023 12:43

Just put a box in the boot of DH's car. Put it in there and drop it back to the charity shop. Doesn't need to enter the house.

BIossomtoes · 04/09/2023 11:55

Workawayxx · 04/09/2023 09:39

Anglo collections are your friend here. They pick up black bags of clothes/toys - you just leave on your doorstep and they come monthly or twice a month. You sign up here. They donate to charity (you can choose from a few which you want to support) but do also make money I believe. At least the stuff isn’t going to land fill.

Thank you so much. I’ve just booked a collection. Amazing.

Adelaff · 04/09/2023 11:53

Yes, love the idea of the crap living in the back of his car. Then it's out of sight for you and you won't be annoyed with him ignoring it for weeks at a time

CruCru · 04/09/2023 11:49

Yes, I agree. Tell your husband that you don’t have headspace to sort out any more crap and it lives in his car boot until
he’s dealt with it. Although, if you share a car, this isn’t very helpful.

The problem with people suggesting to donate it to charity is that charity shops are inundated with unsellable crap. None of the shops near me will take children’s clothes for that reason.

Adelaff · 04/09/2023 11:38

All the stuff in a bag-for-life placed somewhere strategically annoying for your husband. His to deal with. If he chooses to chuck it, that's a shame (and I do mean that, I hate waste). But it's his problem. If he gets final say on this behaviour continuing, he can take responsibility for the clear up too. Just repeat, repeat, repeat every time.

Edit to add, I don't mean this to be a passive aggressive act, you tell him this is what you are doing. Tell him you don't have capacity to manage it any longer so if he wants to keep enabling his dad, he needs to sort it out.

zingally · 04/09/2023 11:36

VintageTuppence · 04/09/2023 09:14

Can you repurpose items? The jumper could fit a doll or a teddy and the socks could be sent to a school or kindy to make puppets from. If you are going to tell him not to buy any more, phrase it very carefully and don’t suggest what he could be buying instead.

All well and good, nice ideas, but it's still something that the OP has to sort out.

What school? Where? How to get the items there? Do I need to ask if they would like them first? Who do I contact? Where do I find those contact details? Does the school have a website?

All just more mental labour that isn't needed.

OP, I know you don't really like the idea, but just throw it all away. The charity has had their money, so no-one is losing out. If your DH isn't going to step up and tell FIL to stop, then you've done all you can. See the act of throwing it away as a small act of mercy to yourself.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 04/09/2023 11:28

Make it your DH’s problem. He’s bringing the stuff home and issuing edicts that you can’t speak to FIL about it. So put a flea in DH’s ear. Mention it daily. Three times daily: have you got rid of X thing yet? No, not in the bin. Text him about it. Put the pile of accumulated crap in his car/wardrobe/WFH desk/side of the bed/top of his PlayStation/golf bag. Make him see the problem.

thecatsthecats · 04/09/2023 11:22

Yes, my MIL is all about the gift pile being nice enough/gifty enough/cute by her definition.

She just can't articulate it in her head that "thecats asked for X when I asked her, so I'll get X".

It has to be "X from a cutesy shop" (with cutesy added features that make it unusable), or "that book I wanted, but the 3" thick paperback instead of the Kindle edition because it's nice to have something to unwrap".

But nothing compares to the hoodie my husband gets annually from his aunt. He has sixteen just from her. We do not live in some sort of rapper's mansion to facilitate this level of wardrobe. We don't have a soft-lit closet with each hoodie angled on a hanger and sorted by colour by the maid. But my husband won't just chuck them as they're gifts.

The annual scarves I get (December birthday plus Christmas) all go to the charity shop or replace ones I'm tired of.

BMW6 · 04/09/2023 11:22

Put it in your husbands car boot.

WhatNoRaisins · 04/09/2023 11:02

I think some people get a real dopamine hit from gift giving to the point where it's all about them rather than the recipient. Same with those people who'd rather do a pile of tat presents for Christmas than smaller more suitable gifts.

You need to be making this your DPs problem if he won't talk to his dad.

lljkk · 04/09/2023 10:59

Can you sell it to your H. as wouldn't it be lovely to have useful stuff instead, FIL shouldn't be wasting his money, and the gifts could be appreciated?

I'd be looking at how to steer FIL into buying stuff that you could actually use & would be appreciated. You could suggest a list, on Google Keep, of "random useful things we need to buy sometime". Invite your FIl to be able to view the list. On the list, put links to specific products or very specific descriptions, not just "Clothes for Beth". Make sure you do buy stuff for yourself from the list, and then remove from the list, so it doesn't look obviously targetted at FIL.

BiscuitsandPuffin · 04/09/2023 10:54

Yes we have one of these. PILs go down the Aldi asile of crap every week it seems, and they grab anything that looks like it's for children. This has meant the children have ended up with random kitchenware quite frequently because it's plastic and colourful so PILs assumed it was for children. We've also had stuff that's completely age-inappropriate.

They have also kept loads from when DH and his sister were babies in the 70s, half of it has decayed from improper storage e.g. holes, mouldy, gone a weird colour from damp stains. It's all truly awful stuff as well. MIL got really offended when I put DH's childhood Duplo (which was 90% those old windowframes with no windows or doors) through the dishwasher after she gave it to DS (age 1 at the time, so putting everything in his mouth) and it was absolutely filthy. She got even more angry that I binned all the broken pieces.

The really annoying thing is they won't bloody communicate about what they're getting the kids for Christmas, so every year we get duplicates of things the kids already have. I am a bit of a minimalist and hate unnecessary waste. Why should I have to take on the mental load of facilitating someone else's shopping addiction and hoarding tendencies?

But the difference is DH is supportive and very firmly tells his parents to take the crap back home 3 times out of 4. So we only get deluges of total rubbish every few months.

MonumentalLentil · 04/09/2023 10:48

Put it all in a bag and offer it on Freecyle, you can leave it outside to be picked up.
Or, round here people leave stuff on top of their walls or larger items propped against them and they get taken.

TeenMum87 · 04/09/2023 10:41

I had this with my DM. I asked her to subscribe to a children’s magazine then kids news magazine, which stemmed the flow of crap for quite a few years. But in fairness to your FIL, he will be getting a lot of pleasure from shopping for the kids.

SausageAndEggSandwich · 04/09/2023 10:39

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/09/2023 09:56

Don't let your DH even bring it into the house he has to keep it in his own car and get rid of it. The eco anxiety if he chooses to bin rather than charity shop or recycle isn't on your shoulders

This

He's making it into your problem to deal with

If he doesn't want to ask FIL to stop buying unsuitable things then he's the one that needs to get rid of them, not you

Elspethelf · 04/09/2023 10:33

My in-laws to this! They love a sale so buy things that are cheap but totally inappropriate like books for a 10 yr old when my son is an infant, a snowsuit when it doesn’t snow where I live, four cheap diaper bags plus one of those net drapes you hang over your bed - to name a few recent weird purchases. They’ll then ask us for money whenever they are in a bind after spending a bunch on this junk.

My husband did step in and tell them to stop. He explained that we want to keep gifts to birthday and Christmas only and that it should be a limit of one gift at a time. His Mum was a bit confused and maybe disappointed but as she’s a grown adult, I think it’s ok to set healthy boundaries. Your FIL isn’t the only one who matters here. Your husband should say something

Jamjarcandlestick · 04/09/2023 10:29

My MIL is exactly the same.

I find it borderline offensive that she puts zero thought into these ‘gifts’ just that she gets a thrill out of getting a bargain (she doesn’t care that clothing won’t fit/things are damaged/absolutely not our style etc).

At least my DH keeps all these ‘gifts’ in the boot and drops them off at the nearest charity shop.

Tourmalines · 04/09/2023 10:26

Just tell your boyfriends father to stop buying things .

Chamomileteaplease · 04/09/2023 10:21

Some great suggestions here. Love jellybabies' idea. You have to make it your husband's problem if he won't let you talk to fil and stop him.

Also, the idea of having some sort of box in the hallway is brillliant. Straight in it goes! Or the garage. Perfect!

I do get though that if space is scarce it is much more tricky. Don't give up!