Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blazing row with SIL tonight!

265 replies

User10932 · 04/09/2023 00:58

Sorry, it’s a long one!

DH and I invited my DM and his Dsis over for a BBQ today.
I have a very strained relationship with DM (alcoholic, drinking even more heavily since losing DSD a couple of months ago). I removed myself for a bit after a particularly difficult conversation with DM, she left, and I then came back. Said to DH it would have been nice if he had checked if I was ok in the 40mins I was gone - his answer was he was BBQing and hosting and thought I just wanted to be left alone. Ended up in us being a bit cross with each other, but was squashed and all fine. SIL on the other hand was sympathetic and understanding.

I went to the kitchen after clearing everything away by myself, to do the washing up but could hear SIL in the garden saying to DH that I’m psychotic, mental, she feels sorry for him having to live with me (we never row, we’re married happily 99% of the time, raising our family, both just trying to make everyone happy all the time).
I came out, said I could hear her and told her if she was going to be disrespectful to me in my own house having fed her and waited on her hand and foot all night then she could leave. She then said to DH “see, psychotic! Listening in to what I’m saying to you!”. Our garden table is next to our open kitchen door!
she completely lost it with me in front of mine and DHs children - called me a cunt, a slag, a dirty fucking tramp, to get back in the gutter where I’d be if it wasn’t for her brother etc. DH shouting at her to stop. I sent the DCs away, and repeatedly told her to stop disrespecting me and to leave. She got very aggressive and was threatening all sorts (she’d smash my face in etc). Not proud to admit but at that point a threw water in her face but I’d just got so angry at that point. DH grabbed her, called her a cab and kicked her out.
I then started to get abusive texts from her (I’m a fucking bitch etc). DCs very upset, I’ve had to stay with them in bed and calm them - they have school tomorrow. Just awful for them!

DH has said to me to leave it and he will speak to SIL tomorrow and make her apologise and then everything will be fine again. I’ve told him she’s crossed a massive line tonight and I’ll never be around her again. He says it’s his Dsis and we have to get along. AIBU?!

OP posts:
CoteDOpale · 04/09/2023 10:40

Jesus. That’s not a human being. Don’t let that ‘thing’ anywhere near your home or kids again.

I’m sorry you had to deal with it, but good for you keeping it together and not reacting. DH needs to accept that ‘happy families’ is not going to work out.

girlfriend44 · 04/09/2023 10:37

Get rid she dosent care about her brothers happiness or she wouldn't have spoken about you like that.
Your lives will be much better without her in.it.

Dolores87 · 04/09/2023 10:33

Tbh I think it's disgusting your DH wants to continue having a relationship with her after this.

TenderDandelions · 04/09/2023 10:30

I'm not surprised you were having trouble sleeping OP. I hope you managed to get some sleep in ready for today and I hope today is an easy first day back with plenty of coffee!

In terms of your SIL, I could never, ever forgive that. To have upset and scared your children, and threatening you with violence. I'd be more on the side of calling the police than ever letting her apologise and be part of my life again.

Cutting her off is the easy part. Getting your DH to understand that it's your right to do so is what is going to be difficult. He should be on your side. You and your children are his family now. Your children are now going to be anxious every time they see their Aunt and wonder if she'll yell and scare them again.

My god, if someone ever said anything like that to me, my DH would have been absolutely raging and would be the first one to cut them off.

PMum09 · 04/09/2023 10:28

I also have trouble with my SIL. She listed all the things wrong with me in an email and sent to the family alongside all the 'horrible' things that my DH, MIL and FIL have done that has affected her upbringing and how all this still affects her even today - i.e. never takes responsibility for her own life. My DH and in-laws have remained loving/supportive and sometimes go to the ends of the Earth to keep her happy despite all of this but I refuse to do the same. Never has she apologised to anyone and I don't expect her to either.
I have also spent time in our bathroom away from everyone when she's been too much for me and come down and pretended everything was fine - and no one really noticed, so I empathise with you on that one!
DH also expects me to have a relationship with her (also saying she's his Dsis/family/etc). For the sake of family, I keep things civil, I'm present but not very interactive, keep my distance, don't ask questions, mind my own business when they're around but only because I can't completely avoid her. Believe me, I would if I could and I don't think it's unreasonable if you wanted to cut her off especially after the way she spoke to you (regardless of whether it's in front of the kids or not, although it does make it a lot worse). If you do have to compromise because of DH, then I'd say meet at a restaurants/park etc, never at your house or even hers (this way you can leave whenever you want and she's less likely to make a scene in public, I hope). But you def need time and distance to cool off/talk with DH about what you feel in terms of your relationship with SIL/set boundaries.

Bibbitus · 04/09/2023 10:27

Your SIL seems toxic she was called a cab was she drunk? What she did was abusive to your family especially the children who are less able to understand. I would cut all contact -we can tolerate this abusive behaviour from family too easily as we feel obligated. DH can see her away from your home if he has to but she is not good for him either. You all should feel safe in your home.

Yo describe DM as alcoholic. You can find help with coping with alcoholic family members here.https://al-anon.org/

Home

Who Are Al-Anon Members? Al-Anon members are people, just like you, who are worried about someone with a drinking problem. Family members have the opportunity to learn from the experiences of others who have faced similar problems. Read More Teen...

https://al-anon.org/

Abhannmor · 04/09/2023 10:17

Lots of New Puritan comments about demon drink. Some people can't handle it , no doubt. But for most the old 'drink was taken ' excuse doesn't wash anymore. Food was , presumably , taken too at a barbecue. This wasn't some girls / boys night on the lash after all.

OP had a barbecue on a Sunday - so what ? Next ppl will be asking why she wasn't in church ffs.

diddl · 04/09/2023 10:15

SIL was absolutely in the wrong with her language.

Did you really complain to her about her brother or was it just your mum?

Why didn't you ask your mum to leave?

TiredMotherMum · 04/09/2023 10:10

You did well because I would have knocked her the fuck out.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/09/2023 10:07

you should also work on your hosting

Oh for goodness sake. There is zero justification for the language the SIL used.

Lilithlogic · 04/09/2023 10:07

Is there a chance she maybe taking drugs

AnnieSnap · 04/09/2023 10:06

Pottedpalm · 04/09/2023 07:54

Forty minutes sulking and then confronting your drunken SIL? I think you played a part in this Jeremy Kyle drama. A teacher you say…

40 minutes taking some quiet time after difficulty dealing with her alcoholic mother’s behaviour, then challenging her SIL after hearing her insulting her in her own home. I suppose you think she’s in the wrong because she isn’t a door mat! 🙄

enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/09/2023 10:06

EvilElsa · 04/09/2023 01:04

That would be it for me. I wouldn't be abused in front of my children in my own home, I wouldn't be accepting any apologies and she wouldn't be seeing my kids again. There's not really any coming back from threatening to smash someone's face in and calling them a cunt in front of their primary school age kids is there.

I agree. Nobody uses that word in my presence (not more than once, anyway) and definitely not aimed at me in an aggressive way.

In front of children is a whole new form of inappropriate.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/09/2023 10:05

WrongWayApricot · 04/09/2023 08:43

You managed to get the hump with 3 people in one evening. Your sil had just watched you sulk about your mum, come back and pick a fight with her brother. Then, to her mind, you pop out of the door and start with her. Yeah, what she said was out of order but I'd probably be super tense and defensive after all that.

YANBU to never talk to her again. But, you should also work on your hosting.

Your husband managed to host and watch the kids (including 40 mins on his own) without starting on 3 people.

All this too. What’s the point in allowing it all to build up and fester? Recipe for disaster

AnnieSnap · 04/09/2023 10:04

I’m sorry you went through that YANBU at all. If this is how she behaves at times when she’s drunk, I’d consider letting it go if she offered a fulsome, genuine apology and undertook never to use alcohol at your house, or before coming to your house. Otherwise, she would never cross the threshold again.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/09/2023 10:03

oh just seen you threw water at her! Whoah!

you should’ve done what I did and disengaged.

Gettingbysomehow · 04/09/2023 10:00

What a complete fishwife. She sounds like the dregs of society and I'd never have her in my house again.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/09/2023 09:59

Nope line drawn there.

I had an argument with SIL (DB’s DW) when we all went on holiday together with her parents. She’d been on off moody all week and called a waitress who’d done nothing wrong a bitch. Then we were all out for the day but I realised I needed to go get travel money from hotel. We got back slightly late but only because it was a slight distance from where they were. She screamed at me in front of her parents (her DF is a paraplegic) and just lost it. At that point i didn’t even engage just left and went straight back to my hotel (thank god not theirs). It was our last day the next day..Refused to back down until she apologised as there was no way I was going to be treated like that by her. She never did it again!

AliasGrape · 04/09/2023 09:37

Honestly I can’t get past a teacher choosing to host a boozy gathering with relatives that they have a difficult relationship with on the Sunday before going back to work. Is that part of the keeping everyone happy you mentioned?

Nightsku · 04/09/2023 09:34

You sound as bad as each other to be honest.

RedHelenB · 04/09/2023 09:33

Throwing water at her? As a teacher I'd expect better from you, regardless of the provocation. You're prepared to have your mum around despite her previous behaviour so I agree with your dh that if your SIL apologises she should be welcome too.

IStillWonder · 04/09/2023 09:30

Sounds like she has been holding all of that anger in and really does not like you for some reason

this is exactly what I thought.

That is a huge anger reaction you describe. It's a deep seated long standing feeling. No one reacts like that from a one-off incident do they?

What's the history between you? Was she drunk? What had happened with your MiL? was she angry with you because you'd said stuff to her mother she regarded as offensive?

Sometimes if you think that a partner is bad for/emotionally abusive to your sibling, it turns to hatred of them that is concealed by the practical day-to-day need to rub along. I've seen this before. Could it be that? That for a long time she hasn't liked you because she thinks you are destroying her brother's life/making him unhappy? (not saying it's true of course - but wondering if that's how she sees it for some reason?) is there a history?

Billben · 04/09/2023 09:15

He says it’s his Dsis and we have to get along.

No Op, you really don’t. My biggest issue here would be that she has done all of this in front of your children. There would be no going back from that for me.

tommyhoundmum · 04/09/2023 09:14

Your sister-in-law's behaviour was unforgivable,block her. She will behave badly again if you forgive her. People like her see restraint as weakness.

Stand your ground and stand firm.

Tracker1234 · 04/09/2023 08:57

What a horrible situation. I strongly suspect alcohol is to blame here for all of you and sorry but you seem to be having rows with almost everyone!

Having said that she had no right in using that language but again perhaps alcohol is to blame here.

I would explain to your husband that you cannot come back from this bearing in mind it was in front of children and you cannot mix with her any longer.

I am honestly sick and tired of alcohol being treated like a God, you will be grumpy if you dont have a few drinks, you cannot really be a tee totaller, you are really missing the 'feeling' if you dont have alchohol. A friend of mine has a partner who goes 3-4 times abroad with the lads... (they are pushing 60) they drink themselves silly, joke their exercise is walking to the pub opposite, they always buy the very cheapest plane ticket and stay in the least expensive hotel possible. Why not just stay at home and have a few tinnies in the garden??

Swipe left for the next trending thread