Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blazing row with SIL tonight!

265 replies

User10932 · 04/09/2023 00:58

Sorry, it’s a long one!

DH and I invited my DM and his Dsis over for a BBQ today.
I have a very strained relationship with DM (alcoholic, drinking even more heavily since losing DSD a couple of months ago). I removed myself for a bit after a particularly difficult conversation with DM, she left, and I then came back. Said to DH it would have been nice if he had checked if I was ok in the 40mins I was gone - his answer was he was BBQing and hosting and thought I just wanted to be left alone. Ended up in us being a bit cross with each other, but was squashed and all fine. SIL on the other hand was sympathetic and understanding.

I went to the kitchen after clearing everything away by myself, to do the washing up but could hear SIL in the garden saying to DH that I’m psychotic, mental, she feels sorry for him having to live with me (we never row, we’re married happily 99% of the time, raising our family, both just trying to make everyone happy all the time).
I came out, said I could hear her and told her if she was going to be disrespectful to me in my own house having fed her and waited on her hand and foot all night then she could leave. She then said to DH “see, psychotic! Listening in to what I’m saying to you!”. Our garden table is next to our open kitchen door!
she completely lost it with me in front of mine and DHs children - called me a cunt, a slag, a dirty fucking tramp, to get back in the gutter where I’d be if it wasn’t for her brother etc. DH shouting at her to stop. I sent the DCs away, and repeatedly told her to stop disrespecting me and to leave. She got very aggressive and was threatening all sorts (she’d smash my face in etc). Not proud to admit but at that point a threw water in her face but I’d just got so angry at that point. DH grabbed her, called her a cab and kicked her out.
I then started to get abusive texts from her (I’m a fucking bitch etc). DCs very upset, I’ve had to stay with them in bed and calm them - they have school tomorrow. Just awful for them!

DH has said to me to leave it and he will speak to SIL tomorrow and make her apologise and then everything will be fine again. I’ve told him she’s crossed a massive line tonight and I’ll never be around her again. He says it’s his Dsis and we have to get along. AIBU?!

OP posts:
Haugh · 05/09/2023 18:42

I’m not understanding why we have so many deleted texts.
please explain xx

DrJackDaniels · 05/09/2023 18:33

Wow this place is crazy sometimes! How many posts do we see where DH has made arrangements without checking it’s ok / convenient and there’s a tonne of posts saying ‘take yourself off out / check into a hotel and leave him to it - he can host’ and yet here the OP takes some time out to get over it and compose herself and is being chastised.
yes throwing water in someone’s face isn’t great but come on, how many people would accept being called all those names in front of their family and not react in some way? Some would be calm and walk away where as some with knock them out, throw water, call names back. If the OP said she calmly ask her to leave I swear there’d be some posters not believing her.

Anyway, for me, I wouldn’t ever have her in my house again. I’ve never had an altercation like that with family and could never imagine it. I would accept an apology, draw a line but say that’s it, I don’t want anything further to do with her.

Itick8outof10boxes · 05/09/2023 18:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

AnneValentine · 05/09/2023 18:21

I would be very suspicious re what your DH has been saying behind your back. People don’t just come out with stuff like that, plus he’s not irritated with her…

amispeakingintongues · 05/09/2023 17:58

DH is being naive, obviously.
prob also in denial as to how awful her behaviour is and what an impact it will have. Hope your first day back was okay and get an early night tonight. you don’t need to discuss it with DH or justify your feelings to quietly quit on your SIL. Will she really apologise anyway? She sounds nuts.

LizzieOc · 05/09/2023 17:48

No return from these horrid comments

Theblacksheepandme · 05/09/2023 13:52

Bibbitus · 05/09/2023 08:34

Further to my other post on this. Having read the responses and on reflection. I would say alcohol abuse is the common factor exacerbating deep seated familial tensions. So both tensions and the alcohol feed each other have to be addressed. As mentioned previously try Al anon

The OP was stressed about going back to teaching so has a family barbecue perhaps to take her mind off things or prove herself to her relatives who she struggles to satisfy. This provided an opportunity for relatives to make matters worse, the OP never will satisfy these people they only care about alcohol and justifying their drinking. The OP clearly doesn’t approve of them and resents her husband’s tolerance of their addiction. So she has to be attacked as a threat to their addiction.

Far better to have gone for a walk and meal with husband and kids to relax before returning to work rather than organise a party for alcoholics who hate you.

Husband is in the middle and worries he should be harder with his relatives but just wants a peaceful life if only OP would play the game like him?

Going off for 40 mins only stoked the fire and risks alienating husband. SIL initially sympathetic because OPs upset puts the focus on mothers drinking not SiLs but OP not receptive to colluding and took herself away so SIL had to punish her as OP not playing the game to SILs benefit.

So SiL verbally assaults threatens OP. OP physically assaults SIL. SIL continue to harassment by text abuse. All criminal offences but SIL the worst offender. Police would calm things down and issue advice about behaviour suggest cab for SIL.

The solution for the OP rests with the OP setting boundaries to keep herself and her children safe. Not easy with so much pressure to conform to happy families and collude with alcoholism. And of course the OP has her own worries to deal with and teaching is very stressful. But the OP has to draw the line within the family.

Wow, it's amazing how you manage to get inside people's heads. It really is a gift you have.

Bibbitus · 05/09/2023 08:34

Further to my other post on this. Having read the responses and on reflection. I would say alcohol abuse is the common factor exacerbating deep seated familial tensions. So both tensions and the alcohol feed each other have to be addressed. As mentioned previously try Al anon

The OP was stressed about going back to teaching so has a family barbecue perhaps to take her mind off things or prove herself to her relatives who she struggles to satisfy. This provided an opportunity for relatives to make matters worse, the OP never will satisfy these people they only care about alcohol and justifying their drinking. The OP clearly doesn’t approve of them and resents her husband’s tolerance of their addiction. So she has to be attacked as a threat to their addiction.

Far better to have gone for a walk and meal with husband and kids to relax before returning to work rather than organise a party for alcoholics who hate you.

Husband is in the middle and worries he should be harder with his relatives but just wants a peaceful life if only OP would play the game like him?

Going off for 40 mins only stoked the fire and risks alienating husband. SIL initially sympathetic because OPs upset puts the focus on mothers drinking not SiLs but OP not receptive to colluding and took herself away so SIL had to punish her as OP not playing the game to SILs benefit.

So SiL verbally assaults threatens OP. OP physically assaults SIL. SIL continue to harassment by text abuse. All criminal offences but SIL the worst offender. Police would calm things down and issue advice about behaviour suggest cab for SIL.

The solution for the OP rests with the OP setting boundaries to keep herself and her children safe. Not easy with so much pressure to conform to happy families and collude with alcoholism. And of course the OP has her own worries to deal with and teaching is very stressful. But the OP has to draw the line within the family.

TawnyLarue · 05/09/2023 00:48

What kind of Jeremy Kyle shit is this?

I would love to hear the other side of this one.

Theblacksheepandme · 05/09/2023 00:26

@MzHz
What made you think throwing water at SIL diffused the situation? It was her brother that grabbed her and removed her.

Theblacksheepandme · 05/09/2023 00:20

MzHz · 04/09/2023 23:04

Sheesh, the lengths people go to, trying to make an op look unreasonable.

I'm trying to make OP realise that everyone at that barbecue behaved unreasonably including her and except the children. The children were probably the only ones behaving themselves. I feel absolutely sorry for these children.

Theblacksheepandme · 05/09/2023 00:15

MzHz · 04/09/2023 23:03

Self defence is perfectly justifiable

@User10932 didnt hit anyone, she merely threw water to shock and stop the onslaught. It worked. It diffused the situation, especially when young kids were in the midst.

no police officer would do anything about it. There were enough witnesses to back up @User10932 anyway.

but do of course carry on with your version of the law

In terms of legal ramifications, throwing water onto someone is an assault. A person is guilty of common assault if they either inflict violence on another person – however slight this might be – or make that person think they are about to be attacked.

MzHz · 04/09/2023 23:04

Sheesh, the lengths people go to, trying to make an op look unreasonable.

MzHz · 04/09/2023 23:03

Theblacksheepandme · 04/09/2023 16:20

Would you assault someone if they threatened you? If the Police were called, what would you say? She/He threatened me so I hit them? The Police would then say, perfectly acceptable and walk away. 🙄

Self defence is perfectly justifiable

@User10932 didnt hit anyone, she merely threw water to shock and stop the onslaught. It worked. It diffused the situation, especially when young kids were in the midst.

no police officer would do anything about it. There were enough witnesses to back up @User10932 anyway.

but do of course carry on with your version of the law

ImNotWorthy · 04/09/2023 21:43

DNLove · 04/09/2023 13:31

I think there is a lot more to this story than being told. You said your SIL said to your husband "I told you she was psychotic" which would indicate there have been many conversations between her and you DH about your behaviour.

Sounds more like vitriol from the SIL to me.

AliasGrape · 04/09/2023 19:01

I think we have to remember that teachers are indeed supposed to set an example - to their students!

It wasn’t the morality I was taking issue with - it’s just I never slept anyway the night before going back when I was teaching, and I’d never have planned a family gathering that was likely to get both boozy and fraught for the night before - and I can’t imagine any of the teachers I know doing that either. That’s why the teacher thing stood out to me.

Theblacksheepandme · 04/09/2023 18:13

GolgafrinchamB · 04/09/2023 16:24

All the women involved sound to blame.

Having an argument with your recently bereaved alcoholic mother so that you sulk off out of your own BBQ for 40 minutes until she leaves is childish and rude.

Then you picked a fight with your husband in front of his sister, expecting him to simultaneously host on your behalf and check how you were. Unreasonable and petty.

Then you came out all guns blazing when she was empathising with her brother about how you treated him (and possibly your mother?)

Yes, she was spectacularly rude, but the common denominator in all these fights - in front of your children - is you. By all means cut her out of your life, but recognise your own behaviour was awful.

I don't think he's innocent either. He shouldn't have allowed his sister to talk badly about his wife. He should have instantly shut that conversation down.

JoanOfAllTrades · 04/09/2023 18:05

Charlize43 · 04/09/2023 17:47

I think you have to take some responsibility for the way your evening turned out: Inviting people over and then leaving them for 40 minutes is extremely bad form - appalling hostessing. Think of the message you are sending out to them...one of 'I can't be bothered with you.'

If you know you have a strained relationship with your alcoholic mother all the more reason to be alert and ready to navigate the situation to the best of your ability. Sometimes it is better to grit your teeth and smile, especially since you'd invited them as your guests. Sometimes you have to be an adult and you have to rise above it.

Your husband was right to stay and host. I imagine your rude, lengthy disappearance was extremely embarrassing for him. You don't seem to have considered anyone else's feelings but your own or thought about the rude impression you were making.

Then you say you cleared everything and went to do the washing up - WHILE you still had guests! Or at least, one guest - your SIL. How rude!

Her language was unforgivable, but you could have calmly apologised, told her that you didn't feel well and then asked her to leave.

Do you think that throwing a glass of water over her was an appropriate way to handle an already volatile situation?

Perhaps spend some time thinking about your actions. It also wouldn't be a bad idea to invest in a book on successful party hostessing, how to make sparkling conversation, and Emily Post's Etiquette, the Centennial Edition, which has been modernised, but probably won't deal with being called a cunt or throwing water over people.

Lastly, as a teacher aren't you supposed to set an example?

I think we have to remember that teachers are indeed supposed to set an example - to their students!

When a teacher is at home, amongst family members, are they still supposed to be in “teacher” mode? Of course not! Teachers are human after all.

There was a lot of bad behaviour but the one thing that puzzles me, is that OP invited her DM, who is recently bereaved and has an alcohol problem and she also invites her SIL, who is well known to be badly behaved when drinking, and she still had alcohol of some sort, at her BBQ!

I totally understand wanting to make the most of the last day before school starts, but with all the issues that this family seems to have around alcohol, I think I would have provided lemonade or alcohol free wine!

JoanOfAllTrades · 04/09/2023 17:57

MarshyMcMarshFace · 04/09/2023 16:48

The whole afternoon sounds fraught and emotionally high octane.

Did your SIL hear you say you were upset with him that he didn’t check on you?

Did everyone need to know you had had an upsetting conversation with your Mum? And could that not have been de-escalated / diverted, at a family BBQ with kids around?

How was your DH responding when SIL was slagging you off? Her behaviour was outrageous but tbh I would not have gone out and confronted her with kids present. I would have taken it up with DH (and her) later.

But none of that excuses her truly horrible and thoroughly unacceptable behaviour. And if she really believes those things and doesn’t like you, how does DH think it can be happy families?

Sorry if I have misunderstood, but is your DH recently bereaved and lost a child? In which case why is your Mum drinking and creating drama around it? And I do feel sorry for your DH if this is the case, he is devastatingly bereaved and surrounded by everyone else in an emotional state.

The OP’s mum is bereaved, having lost OP’s Dear StepDad

Charlize43 · 04/09/2023 17:47

I think you have to take some responsibility for the way your evening turned out: Inviting people over and then leaving them for 40 minutes is extremely bad form - appalling hostessing. Think of the message you are sending out to them...one of 'I can't be bothered with you.'

If you know you have a strained relationship with your alcoholic mother all the more reason to be alert and ready to navigate the situation to the best of your ability. Sometimes it is better to grit your teeth and smile, especially since you'd invited them as your guests. Sometimes you have to be an adult and you have to rise above it.

Your husband was right to stay and host. I imagine your rude, lengthy disappearance was extremely embarrassing for him. You don't seem to have considered anyone else's feelings but your own or thought about the rude impression you were making.

Then you say you cleared everything and went to do the washing up - WHILE you still had guests! Or at least, one guest - your SIL. How rude!

Her language was unforgivable, but you could have calmly apologised, told her that you didn't feel well and then asked her to leave.

Do you think that throwing a glass of water over her was an appropriate way to handle an already volatile situation?

Perhaps spend some time thinking about your actions. It also wouldn't be a bad idea to invest in a book on successful party hostessing, how to make sparkling conversation, and Emily Post's Etiquette, the Centennial Edition, which has been modernised, but probably won't deal with being called a cunt or throwing water over people.

Lastly, as a teacher aren't you supposed to set an example?

Beautiful3 · 04/09/2023 17:27

I'd honestly never have her over again. It's not fair on the children, they were probably scared and worried. He can see his sister outside the home, but never in our house.

MarshyMcMarshFace · 04/09/2023 16:49

Oh, sorry, DSD is your step Dad not step son.

MarshyMcMarshFace · 04/09/2023 16:48

The whole afternoon sounds fraught and emotionally high octane.

Did your SIL hear you say you were upset with him that he didn’t check on you?

Did everyone need to know you had had an upsetting conversation with your Mum? And could that not have been de-escalated / diverted, at a family BBQ with kids around?

How was your DH responding when SIL was slagging you off? Her behaviour was outrageous but tbh I would not have gone out and confronted her with kids present. I would have taken it up with DH (and her) later.

But none of that excuses her truly horrible and thoroughly unacceptable behaviour. And if she really believes those things and doesn’t like you, how does DH think it can be happy families?

Sorry if I have misunderstood, but is your DH recently bereaved and lost a child? In which case why is your Mum drinking and creating drama around it? And I do feel sorry for your DH if this is the case, he is devastatingly bereaved and surrounded by everyone else in an emotional state.

GolgafrinchamB · 04/09/2023 16:24

All the women involved sound to blame.

Having an argument with your recently bereaved alcoholic mother so that you sulk off out of your own BBQ for 40 minutes until she leaves is childish and rude.

Then you picked a fight with your husband in front of his sister, expecting him to simultaneously host on your behalf and check how you were. Unreasonable and petty.

Then you came out all guns blazing when she was empathising with her brother about how you treated him (and possibly your mother?)

Yes, she was spectacularly rude, but the common denominator in all these fights - in front of your children - is you. By all means cut her out of your life, but recognise your own behaviour was awful.

SerafinasGoose · 04/09/2023 16:21

JoanOfAllTrades · 04/09/2023 16:05

She left out gin! A well known depressant!

ALL alcohol is a depressant.