Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did I do the right thing leaving my husband?

34 replies

Namechange448 · 03/09/2023 20:29

Have left my husband recently and am having second thoughts.
So basically I'm asking was I unreasonable to have left?

Pros, He is a hard worker, pays the mortgage while I'm a SAHM
He is not a womaniser and i would never be worried that he would cheat.
He isn't emotionally or physically abusive.

Cons. It's clear he has an alcohol dependency/functioning alcoholic but he won't admit to it
He's stingy with money
He's moody
He can be bitchy about people which is very off-putting
He has a very complex and strained relationship with his family which affects his mental health
He's paranoid and secretive
Doesn't like most of my family
Never takes our daughter out anywhere
Never sees his friends or has any hobbies, he literally just works and comes home and drinks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Slitherr · 29/02/2024 13:44

The grass certainly can’t be much darker than it was!

The pro’s list are basics.

The cons list is not good!

Good decision.

Ponoka7 · 29/02/2024 13:33

Really reason out your guilt because you have none. It's him and his reluctance to address his addiction that has ended your marriage. He has changed the person you would have been, the position the family would be in and the Mother you would have been. I was the child of functioning alcoholics. Find your anger.

Orroroar · 29/02/2024 09:05

@Ponoka7 thank you. I am relieved that I have got my point across & it's all out. But that's the thing no matter what I say, it's always brought back to either he only gets on like that when I start to be cold to him or he has had a bad two years, family bereavements. Guilt trip.... But I have stated, the drinking and slurs started well before the bereavements. It's hard just to switch off any feelings I had for him, 24 years worth. Two teen-agers also which I'm hoping we can both explain the situation to them, I have read so many articles that this is the best way to explain. I literally get knots in my stomach thinking of this stage. Fingers crossed, thank you for replying, it helps.

Ponoka7 · 29/02/2024 08:31

@Orroroar you're focusing on him and his intentions. You should be focused on your DD's quality of life. He's an alcoholic, he wants a housekeeper and to be able to drink. He isn't giving you that much thought. Why are you even trying to speak to him while he is drinking? How long are you going to flog that dead horse? You might be kidding yourself that this isn't affecting your DD, but it will be doing massive damage.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 29/02/2024 08:22

Its telling that your pros are all things he is not. So he works hard, that's good...but hardly unique. The other pros are that he us not a cheat and not abusive. These are not reasons to stay!

HomeTheatreSystem · 29/02/2024 08:15

You haven't made a mistake at all. You're still grieving the loss of what your relationship with him should have been but wasn't. You're getting used to a new and unfamiliar life at the same time. Just take it a day at a time but know that you most definitely made the right decision.

Alwaysgoingforit · 29/02/2024 08:07

orroroar I really hope for your sake he leaves. 'sleeping on the streets, doesn't care anymore' he won't and he does, total guilt trip what a drama queen! Shut the door behind him and enjoy your new life away from a total waste of space.
He'll soon find another woman to trample over. poor cow

Alwaysgoingforit · 29/02/2024 08:03

Another well done for getting out, I was in similar situation but he was high functioning alchoholic, who didn't work, played the system like a pro, debts and loans.
I divorced him, he hated that, best thing I ever did.
You know deep down you did the right thing.

Orroroar · 29/02/2024 07:48

I had put a thread up months ago and just need some advice again....so we have plodded along, in more or less silence between eachother. Until last night I eventually got it all out in the open.....his drinking, talking down to me and some off the horrible words I have been called. Much more but I'll leave it at that. He agrees I shouldn't be treated like this, apologies and then starts to turn things around i.e. only is like this as I am so cold with him, doesn't have a drinking problem etc etc...i don't get into this type of debate, been here before and it just goes back and forth. Then says he is moving out (today) will sleep on the streets, doesn't care anymore. I said about buying his half off the house from him, to which I got, I want nothing from you, I don't need your charity!!! Really, it's not me giving you money it's what's owed to you. Is this all a ploy to make me feel more guilty than I already do? This was all said with beer on his part and I have a feeling he will come home tonight and back to silence....any tips for my next steps?? Anyone else slightly lost with taking charge of this whole situation. Thanks for reading....

Malapataraso · 04/09/2023 23:16

He might not be emotionally abusive but he’s certainly emotionally negligent. Good riddance and good job getting out! Woot!

KievLoverTwo · 04/09/2023 03:27

Nah

I left an emotionally abusive alcoholic husband when I was 24 who also wouldn't admit to/deal with it. I think he had a lot of emotional trauma and abandonment issues, but this was well before the days of any sort of awareness of this, and he was never the sort of guy to go to a doctor or therapy anyway.

13 years later I discovered he died of an 'accidental overdose' aged 42. Took a long time for me to remember he once offered me cocaine when he got home wasted. Had been with him six years, didn't realise he had a drug problem. It explained why we were always broke despite him earning 2k a week in 2001.

He also had the nasties. I think it was an alcohol thing.

Glad I didn't allow myself to be dragged along on that trip.

Probably the worst thing was the lies. It was impossible to tell where the truth began and the lies ended. Not to mention constant gaslighting.

Enjoy your newfound freedom and your kid.

Namechange448 · 04/09/2023 01:59

Thanks so much everyone, I really needed to hear every single word of all of your replies.
I'm just feeling vulnerable and scared for the future on my own, which is making me second guess my decision. The grass is greener and all that.
Reading the replies and how sure everyone is that I did the right thing has made me feel so much better and more confident.

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 03/09/2023 23:41

100% the right choice.

Individually any one of those cons would be enough to want out. Even being generous and you could ignore one of them, a second one added wound be more than enough - and you've listed half a dozen.

suburbophobe · 03/09/2023 22:52

^Cons. It's clear he has an alcohol dependency/functioning alcoholic but he won't admit to it
He's stingy with money
He's moody
He can be bitchy about people which is very off-putting
He has a very complex and strained relationship with his family which affects his mental health
He's paranoid and secretive
Doesn't like most of my family
Never takes our daughter out anywhere
Never sees his friends or has any hobbies, he literally just works and comes home and drinks^

Why the fuck are you even asking?

Single motherhood is great. Hard. Yes. But so much better than that shit....

You and your daughter really deserve better.

Hankunamatata · 03/09/2023 22:48

If your not happy then that's a good enough reason

Turnthelightoff · 03/09/2023 22:46

You’ve done the right thing and this may seem harsh but when it comes to formalising in a divorce I’d go for getting as much as you can upfront so as to have a clean financial break and not be reliable on maintenance payments from him

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 03/09/2023 22:27

I mean, you could have put in the pros that you love him and he loves you?

If even that isn't there, with all the other issues, then you definitely did the right thing.

AmazingSnakeHead · 03/09/2023 21:52

2 out of 3 of the pros you've listed aren't really pros, they're just the most basic standard you should accept. They're preconditions for having a relationship at all, not actual positive points.

It sounds to me like you made the right call!

SummerInSun · 03/09/2023 21:43

Good grief - read your own list back - literally the only good thing about him is paying the mortgage and not being abusive?!?! And all those negatives sound utterly miserable to live with.

OF COURSE you did the right thing.

DustyLee123 · 03/09/2023 21:38

You say he’s not emotionally abusive, but he’s ignoring you when you ask him to address his drinking, and saying you’re wrong. He works and drinks, that’s it.
No wonder you ended it. Do you really want to go back to it ?

AutumnFroglets · 03/09/2023 21:35

So he works hard but doesn't cheat. Ummmm....they should be the basic requirements of a half decent partner.

But you are forgetting that it is (or will be) cheating on you, just not with women but with alcohol. He will put alcohol before you, before the child, before his own life. It's an addiction which he has to admit before he can change.

You say he isn't emotionally or physically abusive but you have overlooked him being financially abusive.

In short if you had stayed you would have subjected yourself and child to utter hell. Be glad you escaped.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 03/09/2023 21:33

Beezknees · 03/09/2023 21:31

You made the right choice. Doesn't do anything with his child, drinks, stingy...

The bar is so low for women that we've been conditioned into thinking that we should be grateful if he's faithful and not physically abusive. No way.

I agree. Well done for leaving op.

Beezknees · 03/09/2023 21:31

You made the right choice. Doesn't do anything with his child, drinks, stingy...

The bar is so low for women that we've been conditioned into thinking that we should be grateful if he's faithful and not physically abusive. No way.

Mummy08m · 03/09/2023 21:27

The alcoholic thing on its own sounds like reason enough.

But also: moody, stingy, paranoid, doesn't hang out with dd. I think I could put up with maybe one out of these four. But all of them in one man?

Doesn't your day to day life feel a bit easier now?

Acornsoup · 03/09/2023 21:23

You made the right choice. It's normal to feel like this after the relief of leaving. Don't doubt yourself.