Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you to tell your teens to read the f*****ing question!

261 replies

BorrowedThyme · 03/09/2023 19:15

I'm spending hour and hours and hours combing through GCSE papers back from the exam board cos mum says Jonnie has told her he had written loads of high quality answers and should have got higher than a 5...

YES! Jonnie has written loads and loads of very high quality content, showing excellent understanding, recall and application of the subject

NO! his answers don't in any way match the question that was asked, so no! he gets no marks for said answers.....

FGS - what a total waste of time and energy for everyone.

And I have spent my entire weekend on these wastes of time

OP posts:
givemeasunnyday · 03/09/2023 20:31

Gerrataere · 03/09/2023 20:24

As others have asked, do your really need two threads within a space of days of each other about exactly the same thing? I actually don’t disagree with your point but needing to go on about it twice in a week on what must be a very rare break this close to school starting again seems like a huge waste of your energy…

Not nearly as much a waste of OP's energy as all the time she is having to go through the papers because Jonnie and his ilk can't be bothered to do the obvious thing when sitting exams. How do they think they are going to cope in the work force?

OP can write ten threads a day on the same subject if they want to - no-one is forcing you to read them. At least it makes a change from the ridiculous posts from people who can't seem to make a decision about the simplest little thing without asking for advice (and half the time then ignoring it).

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/09/2023 20:31

It's pretty shocking to be dragged into work without pay when you are meant to be unavailable.

OP, next year, you should book a holiday abroad for the last two weeks of the summer holiday, so you are not expected to work outside of your contract.

(or at least pretend)

jallopeno · 03/09/2023 20:31

DameCurlyBassey · 03/09/2023 20:27

Trust me, teachers have to do many things that they really don't want to do but which they are forced to do because of government policy etc. The thing most teachers love to do most is to actually teach.

Yes, but teaching is only part if the job. Not saying its right but if OP isn't happy doing it they can stop.

Goldenbear · 03/09/2023 20:31

PattyDukeAstin · 03/09/2023 20:25

I totally support what you are saying OP. We now live in a world where there is a tendency to place blame somewhere and in your case it is teachers and examiners - it is never because the child might have messed up on the day. Therefore we have endless demands for remarks which is why you are snowed under with work. You have every right to post about it - 2,3,4 times if you want...and yes students should answer the question if they want good marks.
Unfortunately this is MN and plenty of people seem to be looking to make the snarky remarks tonight.

Once again, this is not everyone's experiences though, it is consistently being overlooked as doesn't suit the narrative of these threads made by the OP but some of us aren't pursuing this, the school are pursuing us to pursue it. No one looking to blame anyone here. My DS was surprised that the teacher is so insistent on pursuing this as he doesn't feel he revised enough to answer the question correctly- that's on him. So some schools are taking this approach it and making you feel like there is a good chance things will change. No doubt this post will be overlooked as doesn't suit the wind up merchant narrative of the 'little Jonny' is hard done by.

Badbadbunny · 03/09/2023 20:30

I do think teachers should be teaching exam technique right from the start of year 7 and giving proper past exam questions (parts thereof according to knowledge taught at that time) as homework etc., and marking them strictly in accordance with marking scheme. Or if no appropriate past papers, make up questions on the same basis.

That will really hammer it home to students that they won't get the marks if they don't properly answer the question. It's no point teachers telling students in passing a few times during lessons. "To listen is to forget, to do is to understand!".

It's what some of my son's teachers did (particularly history), and the entire class got very poor marks the first time, which was a valuable lesson learnt - well it certainly was for him as he was accustomed to getting good marks and it was quite a shock when he got something like 25% on a homework question he thought he'd get top marks for. 5 years later when it was time for GCSE, he read the questions and got his well earned grade 9!

Teachers just mentioning "read the question" a few times when the kids are in years 10 or 11, and have spent the earlier years getting good marks in more informal tests/markings, just doesn't have the same impact.

I smiled when I saw an earlier poster mention that spoof test paper where the last question just says only answer question 1 - that's exactly what one of my son's teachers did in one of his first lessons in year 7! They don't forget that!

Symphony24 · 03/09/2023 20:30

Good point. Sorry though I did accidentally click 'you are being unreasonable'. Ironically I didn't read the answer.

BungleandGeorge · 03/09/2023 20:29

Some teachers really do need a lot more education about specific learning disabilities and how these present (whether diagnosed or not). Many students can read the question and misunderstand because of the way their brain works, what they actually need is a lot more help, understanding and skilled teaching interventions. But usually they just get ignored and blamed

DameCurlyBassey · 03/09/2023 20:28

If every teacher who got so frustrated that they needed two posts to vent was to give up teaching, as suggested by PPs there would be nobody left.

WedRine · 03/09/2023 20:28

Goldenbear · 03/09/2023 20:22

Yes, the contempt for pupils from the OP with not one post but two on the topic does appear to reflect a disproportionate frustration.

The teachers who genuinely don't care about the job or the kids, are not the one getting frustrated on a parenting forum trying to improve things. They're the ones who won't put in any effort regardless.

Truemilk · 03/09/2023 20:28

Yes parents can have influence but this is ultimately the teachers job to teach children how to properly read, understand and answer exam questions

Not a pop at you op as these are not your students, but not all teachers are good at their jobs

Hawkins0009 · 03/09/2023 20:27

i myself made that error

NoDoorHooks · 03/09/2023 20:27

Kids and adults who sit exams often don’t read the question properly and lose marks. Or they do read it but shoehorn in the only info they actually know. It happens and has always happened. This is hardly big news!

It is like a doctor writing a post about telling people not to smoke or they will get lung cancer. I mean it’s true, but people know this stuff already and I am not sure an angry rant will achieve much!

DameCurlyBassey · 03/09/2023 20:27

jallopeno · 03/09/2023 20:01

It might be frustrating but OP doesn't sound like she wants to do the job

Trust me, teachers have to do many things that they really don't want to do but which they are forced to do because of government policy etc. The thing most teachers love to do most is to actually teach.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 03/09/2023 20:26

CaveMum · 03/09/2023 20:09

I remember as a teen (mid 90s) being given a practice paper to drum home the vital importance of reading all the questions in full before you start answering anything. I can’t remember it exactly but it was something like 20 questions, very simple stuff like “what’s your name?” And “draw a circle in the middle of the page”. However as you moved down the questions they started to contradict each other until you got to the very last one which simply said “Only answer question 1”.

Learned a valuable lesson that day!

I remember that paper too - I think I was about 12 at the time (mumblemumblefortyeightmumblemumble years ago).

givemeasunnyday · 03/09/2023 20:26

NotQuiteHere · 03/09/2023 20:17

Perhaps if they do it again and again, it's time to think why they do it?

It's easy to assume that they are stupid or lazy or just don't listen, and yes, they are all of those. However, there are other reasons, and teachers should reflect about those rather than write angry posts on MN. Don't you tell the students to write what they know hoping to get some marks when they can't answer the exact question?

Oh for goodness sake!! I know a lot of people, adults, who don't read things properly.

In fact I was on a course from work once and we were asked a question which we had to solve in pairs. We were all tearing our hair out, until I took another look at the question and realised the answer was simple. My team-mate and I were the only ones who gave the correct answer, everyone else had made the mistake of reading the question once and not taking a second look to see the obvious answer. It's quite common to not actually read things well - and if kids are sitting exams then they need to slow down and read properly. But no, too easy just to blame the teachers.

PattyDukeAstin · 03/09/2023 20:25

I totally support what you are saying OP. We now live in a world where there is a tendency to place blame somewhere and in your case it is teachers and examiners - it is never because the child might have messed up on the day. Therefore we have endless demands for remarks which is why you are snowed under with work. You have every right to post about it - 2,3,4 times if you want...and yes students should answer the question if they want good marks.
Unfortunately this is MN and plenty of people seem to be looking to make the snarky remarks tonight.

WedRine · 03/09/2023 20:24

PoshPineapple · 03/09/2023 20:18

Second post isn't it? Although this time you sound even more angry and resentful.

My dear old Dad was very fond of this phrase "Piss, or get off the pot" It sounds like you need to get off the pot, it's obvious that at least some elements of your job are making you unhappy.

Name me a job that doesn't have drawbacks.

Also, the OP is doing someone else's job for them, on top of her own job, for no extra money and no TOIL. She has a right to be upset. The fact that she's doing it anyway probably means she is in the right job because she's putting the kids before her own needs.

Gerrataere · 03/09/2023 20:24

As others have asked, do your really need two threads within a space of days of each other about exactly the same thing? I actually don’t disagree with your point but needing to go on about it twice in a week on what must be a very rare break this close to school starting again seems like a huge waste of your energy…

TheAloe · 03/09/2023 20:23

Johnnys parents are deluded. Quite a few of them about.

jallopeno · 03/09/2023 20:23

Goldenbear · 03/09/2023 20:22

Yes, the contempt for pupils from the OP with not one post but two on the topic does appear to reflect a disproportionate frustration.

Yes exactly this

Goldenbear · 03/09/2023 20:22

givemeasunnyday · 03/09/2023 20:18

Ignore the idiotic comments on this thread OP - some people seem to have very limited lives and get their kicks from writing rubbish on MN.

Even when I was sitting exams, nearly 50 years ago, it was drummed into us to read the questions properly. It's not difficult.

Yes, the contempt for pupils from the OP with not one post but two on the topic does appear to reflect a disproportionate frustration.

smooththecat · 03/09/2023 20:20

Stripeypyjamas · 03/09/2023 20:11

Do you wish you could give better marks? I'm a lecturer and we often get very very good essays that have not quite answered the question but are brilliantly put together nonetheless. I will often mark these highly, knock a few off for missing the question but I wouldn't necessarily hammer them for it. But I make up my own marking criteria and will discuss cases like these with the moderator directly. I do like having that freedom to apply a bit of flexibility.

Edited

If you’re a lecturer in HE, it’s appropriate that the criteria are broader, as the scope is much broader. For national exams, I think it’s appropriate that everything is fairly standardised, particularly at GCSE level. There will be exemplar responses, but you’re not looking for them to reproduce that exactly and you can reward appropriate answers that don’t appear on the exemplar. At A level, they might try to formulate more complex arguments of their own and evidence them. There’s room to start developing a voice. I know it sounds like it lacks creativity, but many many students are still struggling with the basics at this age (such as answering a question).

NoDoorHooks · 03/09/2023 20:19

Goldenbear · 03/09/2023 19:29

And as it is your second post on it, you do sound angry and maybe not the job for you.

Agreed.

PoshPineapple · 03/09/2023 20:18

Second post isn't it? Although this time you sound even more angry and resentful.

My dear old Dad was very fond of this phrase "Piss, or get off the pot" It sounds like you need to get off the pot, it's obvious that at least some elements of your job are making you unhappy.

givemeasunnyday · 03/09/2023 20:18

Ignore the idiotic comments on this thread OP - some people seem to have very limited lives and get their kicks from writing rubbish on MN.

Even when I was sitting exams, nearly 50 years ago, it was drummed into us to read the questions properly. It's not difficult.

Swipe left for the next trending thread