Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you to tell your teens to read the f*****ing question!

261 replies

BorrowedThyme · 03/09/2023 19:15

I'm spending hour and hours and hours combing through GCSE papers back from the exam board cos mum says Jonnie has told her he had written loads of high quality answers and should have got higher than a 5...

YES! Jonnie has written loads and loads of very high quality content, showing excellent understanding, recall and application of the subject

NO! his answers don't in any way match the question that was asked, so no! he gets no marks for said answers.....

FGS - what a total waste of time and energy for everyone.

And I have spent my entire weekend on these wastes of time

OP posts:
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 03/09/2023 22:42

FrippEnos · 03/09/2023 22:13

I always used to get the pupils to read the question and either underline or highlight the keywords on every practice paper.
The amount of practice papers that came back in with none or the keywords underlined or highlighted was a high percentage.

You can lead a horse to water etc.

In y6 the highlight everything, or start making pretty patterns or colouring in. Grin

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 03/09/2023 22:38

Why on earth are people saying the OP isn't a teacher?
Quoted from OP's post on about p4:

None of the papers I have reviewed are my own students, in line with school policy. And I have taught endlessly about reading the questions, as have other teachers.

Zara147 · 03/09/2023 22:38

AngryLegend · 03/09/2023 19:17

Maybe you shouldn't be doing that job, OP.

Doesnt sound like it's for you...

Teachers are realising that, actually, yes, they shouldn’t be doing that job (as in a task, or at least not doing a task to the extent we’re seeing now) and the job isn’t for them. Then leaving the profession in droves precisely because of the expectation they should spend their holidays or start of a busy academic year spending hours doing tasks like this.

The martyr narrative with teaching in insidious and too many suck it up without complaint. These teachers burn out fastest and leave first in my experience as a teacher who has seen too many talented colleagues leave to be treated better in another profession.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 03/09/2023 22:34

BellaJuno · 03/09/2023 19:26

I’m guessing you’re a teacher and therefore assume some of the responsibility for Jonnie’s poor exam
technique? 😂

Oh, come off it. Our teachers dinned in to us 'read the question' 'ANSWER the question'. Thing is, under exam pressure, things go out of your head.

Hankunamatata · 03/09/2023 22:34

Schools don't seem to teach revision technique very well - possible there is no time.
I'm having to go through with dc about different revision techniques and actually answering the question not just writing what they know about subject. One of mine finds its helpful to underline parts of question then jot down quick bullet point list then expand on that

DuplicateUserName · 03/09/2023 22:31

Inkpotlover · 03/09/2023 22:20

She said she's not a teacher but works in a school.

She's not actually a teacher? I don't know why but I thought she was.

There was a poster years ago who came across in exactly the same angry, sanctimonious, self-important way that the OP has on both threads and this morning I thought I'd instantly recognised them, except the poster I was thinking of wasn't actually a teacher. Turned out she worked in the school office.

Couldn't possibly be the one I'm thinking of anyway as she got a ban in the end.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 03/09/2023 22:30

Teachers just mentioning "read the question" a few times when the kids are in years 10 or 11, and have spent the earlier years getting good marks in more informal tests/markings, just doesn't have the same impact.

Isn't that what mocks are for?

Moglet4 · 03/09/2023 22:26

TheMoth · 03/09/2023 22:09

Just the one?

Our text isn't the first one on the paper. Many students don't bother to turn the page and FIND the text they have studied. Then some parents complain that we haven't found the page for their child.

Students also spend the same amount of time on 5mk questions as 10 marks.

Students skim the question.

Students give up after a couple of questions.

Students ignore the advice you thought you'd drilled into them.

Students don't turn the page.

Students don't understand many of the words in the question. This is increasingly the case at A Level, where all the vocab sheets in the world will not make up for actually reading and absorbing language.

All very true, I know! This particular student just stands out in my memory because he was such an otherwise bright kid and annoyingly, actually did quite well on the question 🙄

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/09/2023 22:23

TotalOverhaul · 03/09/2023 22:21

My tutor t uni said reread the question after every paragraph to make sure you don;t wander off the subject. I did. And the amount of times I was about to write something entirely unrelated to the question was surprisingly high. that advice was so helpful for keeping on track.

Gosh, me too! The amount of rubbish I would have written without that advice!

oknowimscared · 03/09/2023 22:23

Extra message to parents (and students) - turn the last page over! Make sure you’re not missing questions because you think you’ve finished (absurdly) early! (And yes - then carefully read the bloody questions you’ve just discovered)

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/09/2023 22:22

@Inkpotlover She's deffo said she's a teacher

TotalOverhaul · 03/09/2023 22:21

Meredusoleil · 03/09/2023 19:18

I always tell all the children I teach, tutor and am raising to read the Q at least twice, including after you've answered it as well!!!

My tutor t uni said reread the question after every paragraph to make sure you don;t wander off the subject. I did. And the amount of times I was about to write something entirely unrelated to the question was surprisingly high. that advice was so helpful for keeping on track.

grumpycow1 · 03/09/2023 22:21

AngryLegend · 03/09/2023 19:17

Maybe you shouldn't be doing that job, OP.

Doesnt sound like it's for you...

🙄🙄🙄

(not a teacher, btw)

Inkpotlover · 03/09/2023 22:20

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/09/2023 22:06

OP is not a paid examiner who marks for an exam board. She is a teacher, who is being forced to quality-check the marking on her students' exam papers, which have already been marked by professionals, quality-checked by professionals, moderated by professionals and assigned scores and grades. The marks and grades have subsequently been given to the pupils: AKA GCSE results.

Her school is forcing her to do this in the hope that she can find a disputed mark or two, which might go in the student's favour.

Because of the rigorous marking process described above, it is highly unlikely that she will find a mark that she can dispute. It's like panning for gold, not worth the effort. Even if she does find a mark, it has to be enough of an increase to get the student across a grade boundary.

She's being forced to do this work in her designated holiday time, when she should be resting and unavailable.

She said she's not a teacher but works in a school.

HagoftheNorth · 03/09/2023 22:19

Just for balance, one remarked paper I saw turned up an extra SEVEN marks. Sadly markers are not infallible, so I can understand why unexpected results will be queried.
But yes - read the question is pretty much the best advice for any exam candidate!

Trevorton · 03/09/2023 22:17

Meredusoleil · 03/09/2023 19:18

I always tell all the children I teach, tutor and am raising to read the Q at least twice, including after you've answered it as well!!!

You’re a teacher?

FrippEnos · 03/09/2023 22:13

I always used to get the pupils to read the question and either underline or highlight the keywords on every practice paper.
The amount of practice papers that came back in with none or the keywords underlined or highlighted was a high percentage.

You can lead a horse to water etc.

TheMoth · 03/09/2023 22:09

Moglet4 · 03/09/2023 21:48

I had one idiot in my class who decided he would answer on a text he’d never read because he ‘preferred the question and had seen the movie’. Seriously, you can’t make it up sometimes!

Just the one?

Our text isn't the first one on the paper. Many students don't bother to turn the page and FIND the text they have studied. Then some parents complain that we haven't found the page for their child.

Students also spend the same amount of time on 5mk questions as 10 marks.

Students skim the question.

Students give up after a couple of questions.

Students ignore the advice you thought you'd drilled into them.

Students don't turn the page.

Students don't understand many of the words in the question. This is increasingly the case at A Level, where all the vocab sheets in the world will not make up for actually reading and absorbing language.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/09/2023 22:06

CosyNightsOnTheSofa · 03/09/2023 21:50

You don't have to mark papers though do you? It's something you sign up for to make extra cash. My husband is a secondary teacher (science), he knows a couple of people who do it, they do it for the money (they made a fair bit out of it), not all teachers mark exams, my husband doesn't as he doesn't have time in work to do it so it'd mean it'd all be done on our time, taking him away from his own children. He also said he wasn't aware of his colleagues who mark having to do remarks currently, he assumed only senior markers have to remark papers. I'd assume you must be being compensated for spending your weekend marking? Maybe next year don't sign up to do it if it's too time consuming, no one is making you do it!

OP is not a paid examiner who marks for an exam board. She is a teacher, who is being forced to quality-check the marking on her students' exam papers, which have already been marked by professionals, quality-checked by professionals, moderated by professionals and assigned scores and grades. The marks and grades have subsequently been given to the pupils: AKA GCSE results.

Her school is forcing her to do this in the hope that she can find a disputed mark or two, which might go in the student's favour.

Because of the rigorous marking process described above, it is highly unlikely that she will find a mark that she can dispute. It's like panning for gold, not worth the effort. Even if she does find a mark, it has to be enough of an increase to get the student across a grade boundary.

She's being forced to do this work in her designated holiday time, when she should be resting and unavailable.

Upanddownthemerrygoround · 03/09/2023 22:05

My maths teacher would write on the blackboard during our GCSEs…

RTQ
RTQ
RTFQ.

Fuckthatguy · 03/09/2023 22:01

Haven’t read the full thread but based on my limited experience of ‘some of’ the teachers/education provision in the UK, I’m not surprised these children don’t understand basic exam techniques.

The childish ranting in the OP doesn’t garner my support either.

YBVU

Moglet4 · 03/09/2023 21:53

FailWhale · 03/09/2023 20:13

Not unreasonable.

Loved the comment earlier about students marking one another's work at university.

How practical would a session like that be with your students? I'd have LOVED something like that when I was a student. My ego wouldn't have enjoyed it but it's exactly how I learn from reading and understanding where others have gone wrong and where others have done a better job than me.

I wonder also if a session for parents might help where you invite them in to grade mock exams. Suspect that requires more free time and will power than teachers or parents have right now.

Good luck to everyone over the next few weeks of returning to routine! 😬😬🤞🤞❤️❤️

It’s fairly standard in classrooms to have peer assessment

Truffles15 · 03/09/2023 21:52

I tutor and mark several GCSE examinations including English Language and Literature. I agree with you. It is frustrating that so many, in my opinion nearly half, ignore the question. Highlight the key points within the question and address them, also include the AOs (Assessment Objectives). There were some truly excellent literature responses this year, but I had to reduce the marks when candidates ignored the question. Gutting.

CosyNightsOnTheSofa · 03/09/2023 21:50

You don't have to mark papers though do you? It's something you sign up for to make extra cash. My husband is a secondary teacher (science), he knows a couple of people who do it, they do it for the money (they made a fair bit out of it), not all teachers mark exams, my husband doesn't as he doesn't have time in work to do it so it'd mean it'd all be done on our time, taking him away from his own children. He also said he wasn't aware of his colleagues who mark having to do remarks currently, he assumed only senior markers have to remark papers. I'd assume you must be being compensated for spending your weekend marking? Maybe next year don't sign up to do it if it's too time consuming, no one is making you do it!

Moglet4 · 03/09/2023 21:48

Angrycat2768 · 03/09/2023 19:43

I would imagine ( as someone who once did the cursed exam marking) that virtually everyone who has read exam papers at one stage or another wants to smash their head through the nearest window when they read the hundredth ' this is everything I know about x' or some other mistake that the pupil has in all probability been told about 1000 times. Years ago, one of my students forgot to turn over the paper to the last question. It's stupid things like this that is do frustrating.

I had one idiot in my class who decided he would answer on a text he’d never read because he ‘preferred the question and had seen the movie’. Seriously, you can’t make it up sometimes!