Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit sad my Dc isn’t having a British childhood

131 replies

Remembervoguingatschool · 03/09/2023 16:38

Just looking at the Instagram pics of friends in the U.K. from their holidays, from places like Wales & Cornwall. Just remembering the caravan stays of my childhood, the windy, rainy beach walks, finding little coves with fishing nets, having chippy for tea most might, arcades etc etc.
We live overseas and my dd has a wonderful life, but it’s very different to the one I had, she’ll have very different memories. Is it weird to feel sad she don’t experience the same things we did? (Dh is from the same area and had a similar childhood)

OP posts:
Lastchancechica · 04/09/2023 17:57

🍧😂

Lastchancechica · 04/09/2023 17:57

*desert

Lastchancechica · 04/09/2023 17:57

We lived in Europe think of somewhere warm and Mediterranean.
We also did an early stint in Australia, which was worse in the ugly prefab type houses, incredibly unbearable heat and a total culture deficit. It felt like a cultural and an academic dessert. Its redeeming feature being the lovely people that are so warm and engaging. We spent less time outside than in the U.K. as it was too hot to do anything! Despite it being billed as an outdoorsy country. It has a long way to catch up, particularly the men and their view of women and racism etc.

There is so much more to life.

Remembervoguingatschool · 04/09/2023 17:50

@Lastchancechica Gosh, I can understand so so much of what you’ve written. Can I ask where you were and where you returned to in the U.K.

OP posts:
Lastchancechica · 04/09/2023 17:24

I find it so hard to put into words but I felt my own life overseas (not speaking for everyone ofc) felt very one dimensional. I enjoyed everything about it - it was a place with beautiful beaches and warm weather most of the year.

We had an amazing quality of life. Literally a dream, cycling by the sea every day, swimming after supper, minimum working hours and not a care in the world.

Nothing felt real, I wasn’t ‘invested’ in where I lived, the local politics etc was a mystery to me, I felt I had no say or right to say how things could be improved. I always felt very low level like an outsider, it was unsaid, but I guess it was there, despite speaking fluently and having many local friends and being settled for 8 years.

I felt different to my local friends and women, like they always expected me to go home one day. Our traditions were different, our outlooks, our history and culture. We muddled through with both.

My expat friends were fantastic and we are still in touch, some stayed, most didn’t. The lifestyle for me lacked the other dimensions like grit, difficulty, deep study, edge, cold snowy days. There was no other side to life - just endless sunshine and pools, and a vacuous existence.

I craved studying and learning, the type you can do in the U.K. that is really rigorous and academically demanding, having a voice in my community, investing in something I knew my great grandchildren might enjoy or appreciate. I felt like I didn’t matter much, I was a passing feather.

When we had kids it magnified - I then felt we had no family safety net. My bil died unexpectedly and I feared that happening to me and being alone with tiny dc - relying on friends. I felt vulnerable in a way I didnt before, I would wake up screaming at night. I wanted snowy days, family roasts with gps, cozy nights, family Christmases, British TV with the rain hitting the windows and feeling snug, wholesome farms, picnics, small villages and more than anything else I wanted to feel safe.

We came back when dc were 6 and 4.
We had had enough, and wanted to go home. I was done with the plastic feeling life, sick of the sun and realised belatedly how much we were missing at home with both sides of the family. Ultimately that matters more to me than anything else. The look on my mothers face stays with me still when I broke it to her. I haven’t regretted it at all, my dc love the stability and security, family relationships and don’t remember our lives there now. We travel a lot, and it’s right for us.

Ozgirl75 · 04/09/2023 08:31

Remembervoguingatschool · 03/09/2023 23:18

@Ozgirl75 Have things changed since you lived in the U.K. before or you’ve just been spoilt by a better life in Oz?

Both really. Some things are definitely worse - it’s much more expensive and busier than it used to be and I horribly fear getting ill in case we can’t see a Dr.
Equally having lived in Aus I can see that somethings are just objectively better and easier. Mainly I think just from having a smaller population in a bigger space but there’s also much more of a feeling of friendliness and people wanting to do a good job.

Stokey · 04/09/2023 07:53

Mustthinkofausername · 03/09/2023 16:57

I could've written you post but from the other perspective. I grew up overseas and moved around a lot but am now back in UK. My children are born and raised here and I often feel like I've let them down having to grow up here as it's so lacking compared to the memories of my childhood. We travel overseas as much as possible so they can experience some of the things I did at their age. The thing is they just don't really know a different childhood than the one they have had but I feel like my childhood was so much better. I mostly feel bad they have lived in one place/country their entire lives and by their age I had lived in several places and loved moving around a lot. They don't feel they've had a bad childhood which is good. I am hopeful they leave the UK for Uni so they can experience more.

Hopefully it's normal to feel this way!

I have a similar experience but have a different conclusion. I'm actually glad my DC are having the stability that I never had as we moved around so much. I did get to grow up in incredible places but was always quite envious of people who had friends they'd known all their lives. My DC have that, we live in a nice community and we've lived in our house since they were babies.

I did used to want to live abroad with them but now I do think they can see enough of other countries through travel and holidays. And I guess because I'm used to traveling, they have been exposed to quite a lot of different cultures.

phoenixrosehere · 04/09/2023 07:44

middler · 04/09/2023 04:01

Remembervoguingatschool I don't think it is weird at all but I get it being in the US. I really felt it about nativity plays for some reason.

I think that as your kids progress through school you get this sense that you are more permanently connected to the country and you can have mixed feeling about this if you never intended to settle permanently in a place. It'sa form of homesickness I think.
Easter may be celebrated in the US but we do not get a day off work here which is so odd.

Easter may be celebrated in the US but we do not get a day off work here which is so odd.

Think that may be because the US is a purposely secular country. It is stated in the US Constitution the separation of church and state and no religion should be favoured over another. Easter is considered a religious holiday therefore no work day off unless you request it. There is no national religion there like there is here in the UK.

middler · 04/09/2023 04:01

Remembervoguingatschool I don't think it is weird at all but I get it being in the US. I really felt it about nativity plays for some reason.

I think that as your kids progress through school you get this sense that you are more permanently connected to the country and you can have mixed feeling about this if you never intended to settle permanently in a place. It'sa form of homesickness I think.
Easter may be celebrated in the US but we do not get a day off work here which is so odd.

PostMasting · 04/09/2023 00:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 04/09/2023 00:04

I don't think it's the British experience that you're sad that your DD isn't having, but the lack of shared experience with yourself and maybe with the wider family.

There's nothing particularly magical about a British childhood, what makes it magical is it's YOUR childhood. You share it with your DC my getting out photo albums and reminiscing and laughing about it.

Remembervoguingatschool · 03/09/2023 23:18

@Ozgirl75 Have things changed since you lived in the U.K. before or you’ve just been spoilt by a better life in Oz?

OP posts:
Ozgirl75 · 03/09/2023 23:12

When I was in Australia what I thought I was missing was a very idealised idea of the U.K. that has not happened or been realistic at all!

Ozgirl75 · 03/09/2023 23:10

So I reckon even when we were on the cusp of moving I was regretting it, but I made myself look at all the good things. Ever since we came here, I’ve had the feeling of “I know why we moved to Australia in the first place” - so honestly, I kind of always knew.

What cemented it was that the kids basically said “we like it but we miss home and life in Australia, we like the U.K. for a holiday but living here isn’t as good”

Then on top of the “feelings” there’s also the practicalities that it’s so much busier, greyer, I miss the blue sky, everything is SO much more expensive and so much more hassle. I miss the “can do” attitude of Australia, miss how easy it is to do things like go to events or even drive places.

I do like lots about the U.K. - love the countryside, the national trust, love London, love Europe etc but all those things we do when we’re on holiday here.

So I feel that it has answered the question of where I want to live for the next few years at least.

Remembervoguingatschool · 03/09/2023 23:01

@Ozgirl75 How long did it take you to realise you want to go back to Oz, was it a huge difference to the way you felt in Oz (living back in the U.K.?)

OP posts:
Remembervoguingatschool · 03/09/2023 23:00

@Lastchancechica Where do you live now?
How old were the kids when you moved back?
I do get what you’re saying about it not really being *Real, I can’t really explain it though…can you elaborate a bit more?
Also, what did you wake up in the middle of the night in a panic about?
Do you feel more secure in the U.K.? Do you wish you’d gone back sooner? So many questions! 🙈

OP posts:
mynamechangemyrules · 03/09/2023 22:12

My children were born and raised in a 'holiday destination' and we moved back to the U.K. when they were late primary school due to my parents aging and other issues.

They have a far better lifestyle here than in the tropical paradise 😂 Outdoors all weathers is genuinely good for the soul/ mind I believe. Where we lived the weather was the same every day and super hot allllllll the time. It was draining and boring.

I'm pleased they experienced it, met amazing people and are open minded and culturally aware (I also grew up abroad) but also pleased they are near family and having, in my opinion, a more rounded lifestyle now.

However- I'm also pleased we still know lots of people worldwide from those years so we can still go for tropical breaks after shit weather summers like this one! 😂☀️☀️☀️

RitaFromThePitCanteen · 03/09/2023 21:50

Lastchancechica · 03/09/2023 21:11

Except where we live it’s precisely like that. The air is full of a woody scent, the autumn mist hangs in the trees, the hot chocolate is delicious, the leaves fall like snow and delight the children and we toast chestnuts and marshmallows on the fire before fireworks. It’s not some strange fairytale to us, but real life October to winter or the first snow fall.

Where is this in the UK, and can I move there??

Lastchancechica · 03/09/2023 21:33

Perception is always relative. Snow falling on Christmas Day, log fires, blossom in the spring, long summers in the fields, elderflowers and buttercups might be enjoyed by any child, and the reverse can be true. Children enjoy safe and loving childhoods wherever they are.

PoshPineapple · 03/09/2023 21:31

I think those memories that we hold so dear are more a reflection of who we spent that time with, rather than where we were or what we were doing. Some of my fondest holiday recollections are taking part in the Pontin's Donkey Derby with my Dad in the pouring rain and wind, and being stuck in a tiny, steamy caravan for a week of torrential rain somewhere in Wales. The best damn holidays I've ever had according to my nostalgic mind!

I'm sure your DC will hold the same precious memories as you - albeit in different surroundings, but no less special to them.

Mustthinkofausername · 03/09/2023 21:30

Favouritefruits · 03/09/2023 18:21

Americans don’t celebrate Easter? Well you learn something new everyday!

Its the first I've heard of Americans not celebrating easter. It is a religious holiday though so maybe not everyone celebrates? I lived in the US for 10+ years and hubby is American. Definitely celebrate easter!

Ozgirl75 · 03/09/2023 21:28

But everyone has their own “things” from their childhood - those of us who grew up in the U.K. will have memories and traditions. For my kids, their ingrained memories are BBQs, the beach, hanging out with friends in their pools, the scent of eucalyptus and jasmine on a spring morning, the sound of magpies and kookaburras. They aren’t missing out on a British childhood any more than they’re missing out on a Chinese childhood or a Swiss one. They’re just having their experience and it’s different to mine and I am now fine with that.

Having spent nearly a year in the U.K. now and having them firmly say that they want to go home, I’m so pleased we did this and they have this experience and it’s taken away a lot of that FOMO that the “British experience” is somehow better, which I always kind of felt.

Lastchancechica · 03/09/2023 21:11

Bananaspliff · 03/09/2023 21:02

Sounds like rose tinted glasses tbh. Bit like those stupid ‘Hello Autumn’ posts you see on social media wittering on about cosy nights, hot chocolate, stepping on crunchy leaves etc when the reality of autumn in the U.K. is a permanently grey sky, dark at 4pm and wet dirty pavements.

Except where we live it’s precisely like that. The air is full of a woody scent, the autumn mist hangs in the trees, the hot chocolate is delicious, the leaves fall like snow and delight the children and we toast chestnuts and marshmallows on the fire before fireworks. It’s not some strange fairytale to us, but real life October to winter or the first snow fall.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 03/09/2023 21:11

@SleepingStandingUp

They do celebrate Easter it's just not big where we live.

Also they eat pancakes so regularly that Pancake Day is bizarre to them haha.

Swipe left for the next trending thread