Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To pay for private school?

107 replies

dancingqueen19 · 02/09/2023 19:34

Just had an argument with a friend and feeling very uneasy.

DS has just started primary school, seems to be settling in well. Met up with a group of university friends earlier who I haven’t seen in a while, and one friend in particular who I’ve always got on well with had made lots of snide comments about private schools, tories etc which I tried to let slide, but after multiple jabs I asked if she had a problem.

In return I got a speech about not being leftist, shouldn’t buy education, I think my kids are better than her kids (certainly not the case). I explained that my boy was late in all his milestones, and I waited until he was 5 to send him to school, not 4 like her boy, as I felt he wasn’t ready.

We are very fortunate and can afford the school, and seeing as the other schools in the area were at capacity, my partner and I felt the smaller class sizes would be better for him, and if there are any issues then hopefully will be picked up quicker. If the local school had classes then he’d have gone there. There is also a local catholic school but I didn’t want him going there - nothing personal just we are not religious at all. I did say to her these reasons, however I did say that I don’t need to justify it, it’s my money and I can send him wherever I want.

Friend went on a big rant as I said calling me a Tory, that I’ve changed (always been left leaning) and he’s not going to be street smart at all (it’s not the poshest of private schools and we live in the city). And that he will be bullied by the local kids.

She knows I attended private school for my last two years (on a scholarship, I grew up VERY working class). My partner grew up quite well off but we both have good jobs and work hard. Neither of us drink much and we’ve only been abroad a few times - we are not frivolous with money at all and private school is something we spent a lot of time discussing.

I’ve never once mentioned that he was going to private school before this meet up, it was only mentioned when someone else commented on the uniform being smart that it came up - I live in a different city to the other friends so they wouldn’t automatically know. And I’m the last of our kids to start school, so they were asking how he was getting on - I wouldn’t have brought it up otherwise as I’m aware how touchy a subject private school is.

I did say to friend that private schools are such a mixed bag, it’s not all snooty folk and some of the mums I’ve chatted to at the school gate all seem perfectly fine - I know two of them from the same nursery DS was at which is nice. I made it clear I didn’t want to discuss this further as I felt I was being attacked, and she ignored me the rest of the afternoon.

It was uncomfortable with none of the other friends saying anything, but I have had a few texts tonight saying they thought she was out of order for picking on me. Im annoyed though as nobody said anything at the time.

however, I’m now questioning a lot about us, class, can I call myself working class if I went to private school and so did my child? Does that make me a Tory even though I’ve always been Labour or Green? Are we bad people? My partner has told me to shush and we pay our taxes and give to charity, that we are good people and we can spend our money where we want. I don’t know whether I’ve let friend into my head too much but I had a cry when I came home as I felt like I was made out to be a terrible person!! Though maybe that was the few wines and I’ll be fine when it’s all out my system.

I know private school is a touchy topic but am I being unreasonable for sending him? Or am I being unreasonable for getting upset about this? Really confused about how I feel

OP posts:
Ireolu · 03/09/2023 09:30

I voted YABU for letting her affect you so much. People grow apart and you don't need to stay friends. Park the friendship she shd have no say in what you decide to do with YOUR child!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/09/2023 09:28

CurlewKate · 03/09/2023 09:09

The point is that you can make any personal choice you like. But there are some personal choices that mean you can no longer say you adhere to certain principles. You can't use private education and still call yourself of the Left.

I disagree with this.

As stated above, I'm not a fan of private education and in an ideal world, I don't think it would exist. I sent my dd to a state school, but tbh, I knew that she was the kind of kid who would do well in any school environment. If she had been a different kind of kid, and if I had felt that private school would have really helped her, I would have paid for it without hesitation.

You can want to do your very best for your own child within an imperfect system while simultaneously believing that the system itself should be changed and improved. Some parents might choose to do this by paying for private education. Others might do it by moving to a better catchment or paying for private tutoring. People don't have to sacrifice their own children on the altar of their political beliefs.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/09/2023 09:21

I'm not a fan of private education, and in an ideal world, I think it wouldn't exist. I also think it's a waste of money for many people, though not always.

Regardless of that, I think your friend was incredibly rude. You are doing what you believe is best for your child, which is what every parent should do. Nothing else matters. It is not your friend's place to judge your choices, it is really none of her business.

I don't think I would want to bother much with this friend in the future.

ApoodlecalledPenny · 03/09/2023 09:18

All the middle class people I know who do this, simultaneously use their sharp elbows to move into catchment areas with outstanding state schools. I’m not sure I really see the difference between using your money and privilege to do that, or paying for schooling.

NashvilleQueen · 03/09/2023 09:18

I fundamentally disagree with the concept of private schools and would happily see them abolished. But equally I don't judge anyone who sends their child to one (quite a lot of my friends do - I don't). They didn't make the system and it's up to them how they spend their money.

CurlewKate · 03/09/2023 09:09

The point is that you can make any personal choice you like. But there are some personal choices that mean you can no longer say you adhere to certain principles. You can't use private education and still call yourself of the Left.

dancingqueen19 · 03/09/2023 09:01

It’s all given me food for thought!

once the wine wore off last night I felt a bit better. It’s interesting as a lot of the comments have made me think.

I suppose growing up very working class and the town I’m from has given me a certain mindset of ‘us vs them’ which I’m conditioned to. Hate the concept of class generally but think it’s pointless not to acknowledge it. but I clearly have issues over being defensive over being seen a certain way politically, probably because of upbringing and social circles. My mum isn’t here anymore but funnily enough my dad has never made comments about us choosing this school, he’s always said it’s about what’s best for DS within our budget - but then again he pushed for me to go to a ‘better’ school I was lucky to attend.

I understand the comments about if you had a left leaning friend who’d used private school you’d be a bit surprised, and very vocal lefties - however I still see it as although I’m now in a fortunate position others aren’t and I shouldn’t change all my political views for that. But I do understand where it’s twisted. I guess I’ve not thought too much about it which is why it threw me. Lots of other friends In this group have made pretty right wing comments before, and the particular friend has right wing views herself regarding immigration and abortion, which is her choice and I’ve never pulled her up for this. I have social media but rarely use it, more for messaging, so I’m not posting on it and sharing leftist sentiments all the time etc, could understand how that could grate like the comment above.

Not heard anything from said friend yet - she’s entitled to her views of course but just felt like she was attacking me for the sake of being nasty. If she apologises then I hope we can move on, I’d be gutted to lose her after knowing her for so long.

found reading the comments to be a mix, which I expected! I guess like the poster above I’ve always considered myself working class but aspirational, as someone said above, but realising now it’s more than that - it’s just I’ve never really thought about it. As we’ve worked hard for years, big savers etc. If one of us lost our jobs we would have to pull him out of this school - so I’ve never put myself in the same category as people with generational wealth etc. and I’ve been very close minded to think it’s as black and white as that (us vs them). It’s food for thought!

OP posts:
gillygeey · 03/09/2023 08:44

I don’t believe in the class system.

It is a thing though...

gillygeey · 03/09/2023 08:41

In all honesty if I met an old university friend who had always been a lefty who would tell me they had put their kid into private school I would definitely swallow hard

One of my relatives is proper lefty leaning & really dislikes private schools. They overlook the fact family wealth meant they could buy a 1.2m house in the catchment in an excellent state school. 🙄

gillygeey · 03/09/2023 08:39

All of the "we are lucky we are able to afford it" is part of the problem. It comes across as disingenuous. You have made choices and prioritised the decision you've made - you need to own it.

That's true.

gillygeey · 03/09/2023 08:36

I do think that there are many parents who think that another parent’s choice of school is a clear judgment of their own child’s education. It’s odd. I can’t think of anything else where the choices we make are seen as a veiling criticism of others.

parenting in general is like this! starts with the bf vs ff debate

gillygeey · 03/09/2023 08:35

Private schools are very divisive tbh so I think you will come across those views.

It’s jealousy and she would do the same if she could. You are doing the best thing for your child.

This side of the argument is just as unhelpful.

The OP is not wrong for choosing private school equally someone criticising their existence is not automatically jealous.

SweetieLie · 03/09/2023 08:19

I find the whole private/state school debate in this country really weird.

Your money, your child, you spend how you see fit. Middle class families spend fortunes buying houses in the right catchment area, suddenly finding god for a few years, tutoring for years to get into the grammar school and that’s ok, but you are a terrible person who is driving state education into the ground if you choose to go private.

My experience is the most vocal “opponents” tend to be people who could have afforded it (often with sacrifices such as smaller house/less holidays/not having a SAP) and have chosen not to - I’m sure subconsciously trying to justify their choices.

OP you did what you felt was best for your child. Your “friend” sounds obnoxious.

Another76543 · 03/09/2023 08:07

I’ve always found it strange when people are so bothered about school choices which others make. I think part of it is them trying to justify to themselves why they’ve made their own decisions, perhaps because they’re not entirely confident in their own choice.

When we decided to send ours private, we did have people questioning why we weren’t choosing the local school and telling us it was a waste of money. Funnily enough, the most vocal parents about this have since removed theirs from the local school and sent them private. It’s amazing how many people are ideologically against private education but suddenly change their views when their financial situation changes. I’ve also been told it’s cruel making children go to school on a Saturday, despite the children being perfectly happy with it.

Some of my best friends have very different political views from my own and use the state system. We never discuss politics or private Vs state education because it doesn’t matter. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. People who comment on others’ choices are rude.

It’s strange that we don’t have the same strong divides on healthcare decisions. People don’t tend to be as vocal when others choose to use the private healthcare system.

CurlewKate · 03/09/2023 08:06

I think it's not so much a class issue, but that you can't really continue to call yourself of the Left if you're using private education. Obviously it's a personal choice, but you can't have it both ways.

WhoopsyDaisySugar · 03/09/2023 05:03

Our 8yo DS with SEN nearly got excluded from his state primary school as incidents eventually got out of hand due to the school not dealing with bullying he experienced for over one year. As a result of being suspended for standing up to the bully, DS was finally put on a two year waiting list for an Autism/ASD Assessment with CAHMS via the school. We could seek a private assessment, but there’s
a chance it won’t be recognised if it’s not via the NHS.

12yo DD took the 11+ and another private school entry exam which was based on the 11+. DD was offered places at two private schools. We did not apply for any grammar schools as we do not live near any. After much deliberation, we decided to send DD to a new local academy school. DD is doing really well there and is also excelling at the wide range of sports on offer. A pupil from one of the private schools that DD got into joined DD’s academy school at the end of last term.

Both DC currently attend London state schools, but we’re seriously considering private secondary for DS due to his SEN. All three of our DC have/are receiving private tutoring. Eldest DC attended state schools, Uni and got promoted to management in their mid 20’s.

We’d never vote Tory. Both DH and I were brought up on council estates and attended University. DH owns multiple businesses and we have access to private healthcare. I work in the Public Sector in a role related to my Social Sciences degree. Most people consider us to be Middle Class due to our lifestyle. I don’t believe in the class system. We are aspirational.

If crumbling schools, hospitals, etc are not a wake up call re. this Tory Government, I don’t know what else to say.

You do the best you can do for your child and it’s nobody else’s business.

Your so-called friend was out of order as she is jealous. Time to distance yourself.

VintageTuppence · 03/09/2023 04:36

Why does it matter what class you are? Is the class system really so rigid?

Live within your means, do the best you can as a parent and don’t cause harm to others.

If that school suits your child better than another and you can afford it, why would you question yourself on an archaic principle of class?

edited: or early political views?

wannabetraveler · 03/09/2023 04:25

Your friend was incredibly rude and you don't have to justify your choices to her (or to anyone).

That said...I have a friend who is a very public leftie - think lots of unnecessary guff on social media after diversity, immigration, social justice, etc. Very proud of living in the city and not joining the white flight by fleeing to the suburbs.

Her child started middle school last week and she posted a photo proudly on FB. A friend identified the school from the uniform and said, "I didn't know "Lily" was going to Posherton Private School? How great! I've heard great things about it". Posherton fees are about $36k in middle school; moreso in high school.

Friend pulled the photo from FB about 3 minutes after she was "outed".

Happyhappyday · 03/09/2023 03:41

We’re sort of in the same boat, our DC had a really hard time at her first preschool, initially we shouldered all of the responsibility but it became clear it was largely the school responding to her more challenging traits very poorly which led them to get worse (behavioral psychologist opinion after working with DC and them) but as part of the process we also discovered she tested very highly for gifted ness (recommended also by psychologist who felt some behaviors were because she was bored out of her mind and not being redirected well). The last few months have left us very anxious as parents, it’s preschool for goodness sakes and it already went very wrong, as well as concerned that at FOUR DC is already showing problems that are apparently common to gifted kids. So we are looking into private schools for gifted kids because we were left feeling like the local school ( which is highly rated) just won’t work for her and we just don’t want her to hate school… long story short, a couple good friends I confided in have been really dismissive of our concerns with a lot of “well I was fine…”, implication being it was good enough for me… why isn’t it for your kid? We all grew up very well off but went to great state schools (not UK). It’s felt like there is no understanding of what it’s like to see your small child who loves to learn, struggling so much… I don’t WANT to pay $35k/year!! But mainstream school doesn’t work for everyone!

CurlewKate · 03/09/2023 02:57

@Neodymium "unfortunately in my area the public schools are pretty rough."
I assume you're not in the UK?

dcbc1234 · 02/09/2023 23:16

YANBU and your friend should be an ex-friend. I say this as an ex-Labour party member who now cannot stand the way lefties bring their kids up to be so intolerant of other reasonable viewpoints (see also the 'gender identity ideology' nonsense for why I can no longer vote for them.)
Any sensible parent does what it is best for their particular child in their particular circumstances.
They are simply jealous at the end of the day and hiding behind their lefty virtue-signalling of being anti-private education.

Tambatamba · 02/09/2023 23:16

It's not her business.

Neodymium · 02/09/2023 22:58

My kids go to private school. I work at the same school, and am a labour supporter and union member.

unfortunately in my area the public schools are pretty rough. The government bureaucracy is insane, and it seems like they spend all their time on that rather than teaching and behaviour. Only kids who don’t get aggressively bullied are those that can form a tight knit pack to stick with. It’s literally like a prison. My asd (loner) son would be eaten alive. It seems like part of a wider youth crime problem in my area too, there is no accountability they get arrested and then straight back out. Every day there is posts about gangs of kids bashing other kids at the train or shoplifting, breaking into cars ect.

Forgotmylogindetails · 02/09/2023 22:30

One of mine went to private school , situations changed and the other 3 haven’t.

makes no difference to what class you are and your friends an idiot x

saltinesandcoffeecups · 02/09/2023 22:27

Hmmm… she sounds nice