Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who’s Ridiculous idea that stupid piece of Plastic was…

157 replies

RingsOfSaturnn · 02/09/2023 17:02

Yes you know the one I’m talking about. I don’t even have to mention the bane of my existence! Whenever you see anybody drinking from one of these, it’s awkward and unintuitive. What a ludicrous and quite frankly futile exercise in trying to save the planet.

I am of course talking about the piece of plastic on bottle lids for soft drinks, meaning you cannot easily drink out the bottle anymore without it snapping back in your face or grating over your skin. It’s like we are being guilted and shamed for this, plastic water bottles don’t contain it, just soft drink ones.

I personally can’t stand them! And don’t know anybody who sits and says they are a good idea…

OP posts:
Orbitold · 02/09/2023 21:45

No but hang on - all the plastic recycling bins say you can’t recycle lids! How’s this going to help save the planet?!

Alopeciabop · 02/09/2023 21:45

As someone who is from a touristy place, I can tell you this is actually a great idea - fair enough maybe it’s annoying and needs some re-engineering to stop it poking you in the face - but my lord bottle lids everywhere is such a pain.

JustKen · 02/09/2023 21:37

Robinbuildsbears · 02/09/2023 17:22

I hate it too. Also the patronising "see if you can open this wrapper in one piece" thing they put on KitKat's now, because apparently it makes the plastic wrapper easier to recycle. Ignoring the fact that the paper and foil wrapper was much easier to open and to recycle.

Kitkats taste weird in the new wrapping. Chemical/plasticky. I've gone right off them.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 02/09/2023 21:22

GuardiansPlayList · 02/09/2023 17:24

Push it right back and it stays fixed out of the way. I like them. No more dropping the lids.

This.

Baffling the number of people who haven't figured out that it's designed to lock under the lip around the bottle and stay completely out of the way when you are drinking. 🤔

CKL987 · 02/09/2023 21:16

I just twist it round a few times until it breaks off. I agree that it is annoying though.

12345change · 02/09/2023 21:09

@LucyLoopyLu interesting information thanks. I still personally think it’s greenwashing and it certainly does nothing to help those with disabilities or illness that make opening bottles like this even more difficult.

Personally I’m disappointed they’re not pushed more by the EU and governments to do more to reduce their plastic pollution and make their products more accessible and more green.

Crochetpenguin · 02/09/2023 21:09

I find these tops hard to screw back on. I've always recycled the bottles by squeezing the air out and replacing lid in order to save room in the bin.

LucyLoopyLu · 02/09/2023 20:52

12345change · 02/09/2023 20:05

@LucyLoopyLu as pp has said it might appear it's being done for a good reasons... but it feels more like an example of greenwashing to be honest. You've only got to read the majority of comments on here about people just ripping the lips off - so I question whether this will make any difference at all.

Whether you think it's greenwashing or not, it hasn't been implemented as part of a PR stunt. It has a tangible benefit in terms of increasing recycling rates of food grade plastic. It's also been implemented by coca cola ahead of the EU directive on tethered caps, which are to become mandatory in the EU in summer 2024 for drinks bottles 3l and under. It's also been part of proposed UK legislation but as far as I know it's currently TBC - not likely to be summer 2024.

However what is relevant to all producers of plastic bottles in the UK is the current plastics tax. All producers or importers of plastic packaging in the UK now have to pay tax of £X per tonne of plastic used that does not include at least 30% recycled material. But in order to make this possible (and aim to exceed the 30%) we need to drastically increase the amount of food grade recycled plastic available to purchase and make into new bottles. Hence the need for a closed loop recycling system, of which tethered caps are a part of the solution.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/introduction-of-plastic-packaging-tax-from-april-2022/introduction-of-plastic-packaging-tax-2021

RingsOfSaturnn · 02/09/2023 20:39

LucyLoopyLu · 02/09/2023 19:59

This is the whole point of the tethered cap OP is complaining about. It keeps the caps tethered to the bottle which makes sure it doesn't fall through the gaps when separating recycling. The idea is to reduce the amount of virgin plastic we use by creating a closed loop recycling system. It will increase the amount of food grade plastic recycled material available for manufacture, meaning less virgin plastic, so less oil.

OP -
If you can't bear the minor inconvenience of a tethered cap then just switch to cans. I sympathise with those who have concerns due to arthritis, etc., but it's being done for a good reason, even if you personally don't like it.

And what good reasons might that be???

OP posts:
ThePlantKiller · 02/09/2023 20:07

RingsOfSaturnn · 02/09/2023 17:08

I wasn’t really asking for feedback on how many bottles of coke I drink thanks!

Also you can never properly screw the lid back in with this piece of plastic still attached.

Agree, we ended up with a big puddle of coke under our fridge and washing machine after the bottle leaked. Lid seemed to be screwed on properly, but obviously not...

12345change · 02/09/2023 20:05

@LucyLoopyLu as pp has said it might appear it's being done for a good reasons... but it feels more like an example of greenwashing to be honest. You've only got to read the majority of comments on here about people just ripping the lips off - so I question whether this will make any difference at all.

delphi13 · 02/09/2023 20:04

They are awful, I'm absolutely certain there is a better way of doing it so that it doesn't scratch your face, make it hard to shut so it wastes the drink or make it impossible for people with disabilities to open. It's a question of R&D as someone said but they clearly haven't done theirs properly. I generally do not buy the bottles now and have massively cut down on buying it at all as it's so over priced in the cans.

For the person that said it's bad for you anyway so the environmental issues are not even the point - I imagine you are tremendous fun at parties....

LucyLoopyLu · 02/09/2023 19:59

MrHopsPortal · 02/09/2023 18:05

I thought plastic lids weren’t recyclable- something about them being too small for the recycling machines? I always separate mine and recycle the bottle and chuck the lid!!

Or I am about 15 years out of date?

This is the whole point of the tethered cap OP is complaining about. It keeps the caps tethered to the bottle which makes sure it doesn't fall through the gaps when separating recycling. The idea is to reduce the amount of virgin plastic we use by creating a closed loop recycling system. It will increase the amount of food grade plastic recycled material available for manufacture, meaning less virgin plastic, so less oil.

OP -
If you can't bear the minor inconvenience of a tethered cap then just switch to cans. I sympathise with those who have concerns due to arthritis, etc., but it's being done for a good reason, even if you personally don't like it.

Undecicive · 02/09/2023 19:58

Apparently it's quite expensive to manufacture those lids. I have no idea how their recycling works. When I was younger I used to unscrew and squash everythinf as I was advised. I still leave lids off so I can squeeze everything in the recycling bin.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 02/09/2023 19:51

I wonder if it'll actually lead to more waste of the drink. I had a bottle of tonic water go flat because it hadn't lined up properly and I hadn't realised. I'm more careful now, or remove it if I just can't get it to line up while it's attached.

TheBarbieEffect · 02/09/2023 19:50

I just rip it off and refuse to recycle it.

user1469908467 · 02/09/2023 19:47

We are farmers.

In the past we have bought municipal compost made from green waste that you put out in your wheelie bins. We stopped buying it as it was full of bits of plastic that were the caps and safety seals of drinks bottles. The processing line could pick out the bottles themselves but not small bits of plastic like the lids.
Of course, no plastic should have been in the garden waste bins in the first place!

12345change · 02/09/2023 19:38

Universitynewbie · 02/09/2023 19:36

It is such a tricky issue, hopefully they are looking at easier to open options and the tops will evolve to allow easier opening and closing.

Agree and here's hoping.

NeedTheSeaside · 02/09/2023 19:36

MrHopsPortal · 02/09/2023 18:05

I thought plastic lids weren’t recyclable- something about them being too small for the recycling machines? I always separate mine and recycle the bottle and chuck the lid!!

Or I am about 15 years out of date?

@MrHopsPortal

ours has been taking the lids for a while now as long. As they're screwed to the bottle (making them not 'a small thing'. I was told loose lids jam in the machinery.

we used to separate out the type of lids/colour and they'd raise money for a charity, but now we all reattach them to the bottles (place no longer recycles them for charity). It still feels weird putting them (attached!!) but SO much easier.

@RingsOfSaturnn Are they on the 500ml bottles too? It says 1.5l bottles and I wouldn't be swigging out of those.

i suppose it's like many other things, fecking frustrating, but we get used to it in time.

Universitynewbie · 02/09/2023 19:36

12345change · 02/09/2023 19:29

That's interesting thanks - I did not know that about glass - but I can see practical issues also with glass. But as you they should be doing something to reduce their pollution and not putting the onus on the general public. They should be using some of their profits to sort this!

In addition, I get fed up of companies who neglect those with disabilities - my MIL likes the occasional glass of pop but unfortunately has Parkinson disease so has no hope in open these bottles now.. it was difficult enough before.

Edited

It is such a tricky issue, hopefully they are looking at easier to open options and the tops will evolve to allow easier opening and closing.

TheYadaYada · 02/09/2023 19:32

I just twist it until it comes off. I agree it's stupid and annoying.

EsmeSusanOgg · 02/09/2023 19:29

Oysterbabe · 02/09/2023 17:08

I just pull it off.

Same. It gets in the way of drinking.

12345change · 02/09/2023 19:29

Universitynewbie · 02/09/2023 19:24

The issue with using glass instead of plastic is that the glass production process emits a massive amount of CO2 and glass is heavier than plastic so transport carbon emissions are also huge compared to plastic. Re-use models are great and something that all companies will be looking at right now but they are incredibly complicated and expensive to run and there is obviously a limit to how many times a glass bottle can be re- used so there are a huge amount of complications as CO2 emissions need to be reduced significantly due to climate change. The Reduce, Reuse, Recycle phrase is important here. We need to look at reducing use of packaging as our first point of call- buying bulk packaging is better as the ratio of packaging to product is better for the environment. Drinking tap water is even better as no packaging involved.
As an aside, there is no production benefit to these lids so they aren't saving money (I don't work for Coca Cola by the way)

That's interesting thanks - I did not know that about glass - but I can see practical issues also with glass. But as you they should be doing something to reduce their pollution and not putting the onus on the general public. They should be using some of their profits to sort this!

In addition, I get fed up of companies who neglect those with disabilities - my MIL likes the occasional glass of pop but unfortunately has Parkinson disease so has no hope in open these bottles now.. it was difficult enough before.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/09/2023 19:27

I have more of an objection to how narrow they've made the lids now, as it's impossible to open with slightly reduced grip strength. I was bought one by somebody and I had to get the IT guy to open it for me - he faithfully promised to not tell anybody that I'm a weak and weedy old woman now on pain of death 😂

chocorabbit · 02/09/2023 19:25

Riapia · 02/09/2023 18:56

Pour the drink into a glass.
Children need to be taught in school how to drink from a glass.
Obviously they can’t expect their feckless parents to do it.
Bottle fed into adulthood. FFS.

The lid is on the way and prevents you from pouring it without spilling it!