Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Italy tour ..we don't have enough cash?

393 replies

LaDolceVitafor200 · 02/09/2023 13:13

Afternoon!

I have been reading alot of holiday threads here recently which has prompted my own dilemma

Me and friend booked a very cheap Italy tour for 9 days 8 nights leaving next week. It's staying in 4 different Italian cities in basic B and B accommodation, local taxes and breakfast not included. B and B are all outside main towns we are visiting so an hour's travel.

We also have to pay for transport from airport each way , tour is self guided and just includes flights, coach transfers between 4 different cities and B and B

My friend is taking 200 euros and says she won't spend more, I'm getting worried this won't be enough, we also have to pay B and B local taxes etc

AIBU to tell her we both will need more cash , or has anyone been to Italy and found it cheap?!

OP posts:
saffronsoup · 02/09/2023 14:53

You can do it, you just have to travel on a shoestring budget. Public transportation, minimal siteseeing that costs money, cheap supermarket meals. If you have a 'poor backpacker' mentality, you can swing it but it will be tight and you might be doing a lot of hikes, beaches and parks! If you want a step up from that, you will need to put out more cash.

goingtotown · 02/09/2023 14:50

Childbendivision1 · 02/09/2023 13:24

What is it with people on here insisting on going to a foreign country with fuck all money!?? For gods sake!! It’s stupidity at its best!!

Exactly.

jays · 02/09/2023 14:49

That’s not enough spending money at all. It also can be done on a budget, its. Not as expense as many make out, Rome is London prices at the moment. She’ll struggle on that budget unless you can find a Lidl and eat in, walk everywhere and visit free attractions. I mean, I could do that and enjoy it but realistically you’re not going to be able to ‘live a little’ at all on that budget.

Cynicaltheorist · 02/09/2023 14:47

Me and friend booked a very cheap Italy tour for 9 days 8 nights leaving next week. It's staying in 4 different Italian cities in basic B and B accommodation, local taxes and breakfast not included. B and B are all outside main towns we are visiting so an hour's travel.

It's not a very cheap holiday. It seemed very cheap because, if you had read the small print and thought about it, they've not included all the basics that you would expect to be included in a package. What does a similar tour that includes local taxes, transfers, breakfast etc cost? That's the sort of money you need to add to cover the basics.

On top of that you need money to enjoy yourself. Do you want to do anything while you're there or are you happy just to walk everywhere and not go into the Forum (16 euros) or the Colosseum (16 euros) in Rome or not eat out in any of the cities you visit? Are you happy to live on bread and cheese every day and fill up your water bottles at public fountains? If so 200 euros might be enough to survive.

Janieforever · 02/09/2023 14:47

shes got this very wrong. Tourist tax will depend on where you’re staying, you can Google that. Then obviously work out your transport costs. If you can get trains it will be better, taxis are like London and extortionate.

then food. Max she will have ten euros a day left, if she’s very lucky and you use trains a lot. And that ten euros will need to do 3 meals and drinks. Water as well. I doubt she can afford even a glass of wine.

personally I’d now be doing my research, transport, and tax, work out what’s left daily and then present it to her. As she will be lucky if she can buy a sandwich for each meal.

cittigirl · 02/09/2023 14:47

You can usually find cheaper back street places to eat...where the locals go. What cities are you visiting?

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/09/2023 14:47

Italy is not a cheap country, some popular cities in the North and Amalfi coast can be eye watering.

We were in the South of France in a cheaper area (eg not the Cote d'Azur!) this summer and a typical day of expenditure (for one) would be:

6 euros for breakfast (pasrty, orange juice and a coffee)

8 euros for lunch (a meal deal in a bakery - so a cold drink, a filled baguette and a desert)

8 euros for entry to an attraction (museum/historic site etc..)

40 euros for dinner (inc wine)

25 euros for pre/post dinner drinks

Some days we went on excursions you would add 10/15 euros or so for public transport.

So pretty much 100 euros a day. We would spend extra some days for say a nicer restaurant or more attractions.

You could cut that down a bit by not drinking or going to cheaper evening restaurants, but 200 euros for over a week is insane. Most Western European countries are a similar in cost to the UK. Would your friend think that was enough for a holiday in the UK?

Ozziedream · 02/09/2023 14:47

I’m still stubbornly stuck on the fact that the “bed and breakfast” accommodation does not provide…breakfast

cittigirl · 02/09/2023 14:46

No it's definitely not enough. However taxes aren't alot and bus and train travel is cheap too. Bare minimum would be 400.

Beautiful3 · 02/09/2023 14:45

I would take 1000 euros each for the week, Italy is very expensive.

Mirabai · 02/09/2023 14:43

LaDolceVitafor200 · 02/09/2023 13:51

Very cheap package trip

I only realised when I looked at the map!!!

Surely you’d look at the map before you booked the b&b.! Just cancel them and rebook city b&b. It will save a lot of time and money.

Cosyblankets · 02/09/2023 14:42

hapus2023 · 02/09/2023 14:40

You will also have to pay the tourist tax on departure which is €100 I think

You might pay City tax but not departure tax.
It's usually something like a euro per star per person per day

hapus2023 · 02/09/2023 14:40

You will also have to pay the tourist tax on departure which is €100 I think

Crikeyalmighty · 02/09/2023 14:39

I think she will need 750 euros and even then will need to watch it

regularbutpanickingabit · 02/09/2023 14:38

Sadly, Italy is no longer the cheap option for a holiday. You can do it more cheaply or not, but it is never cheap!

OK, I think she needs to see in black and white what she's in for:

  1. Use the Rome2Rio website to put in the location of your B&Bs in each place and the main town/city/attraction you want to visit. It will give you all the travel options with costs and you can link through to the public transport options for that area.
  2. Where are you getting the one hour suburb bit from? Could it be that there is a more direct walking route that isn't so far away?
  3. Go to tripadvisor for each area and search for cafes/restaurants at the lowest price point. Check out their menus. That will give you a reasonable guid to what to expect.
  4. Are any of the B&Bs equipped with shared kitchen or food prep areas? You can pick up reasonably cheap food at markets and local bakeries/supermarkets so could factor that in, but they aren't as cheap as you might expect.
  5. If you have a big breakfast then you don't need lunch. Pick up some fruit from the market to keep you going.
  6. Pizza tends to be the cheapest dinner, but also depends on where in the country you are. In the South you can get a simple margherita at a restaurant for around 5-6 euros. But you have to usually pay a table tax and for water.
  7. Buying a simple slice of pizza will be a lot cheaper from a hole-in-the-wall place but even decent size sandwiches will be 5 euros plus.
  8. Ice cream/gelato is super cheap and really good. But probably not cheap enough or good enough for 3 meals a day...
  9. Can you list the actual areas you are visiting so people can help with inside knowledge if they have it?
friendlycat · 02/09/2023 14:37

I just don’t understand why people book this type of holiday if they can’t afford it. It’s just madness. It’s not doable in any way that will be enjoyable.

You need far far more. You’re going to have to sit her down and explain the basic costs per day and add them up and then make a plan for how you are BOTH going to cover these costs including eating and basic refreshments.

Godlovesall26 · 02/09/2023 14:36

knobkopf · 02/09/2023 14:29

You will need a lot more than that. The transport into the cities will cost a bit. Then you need three meals a day - it's not even as if you can have a big breakfast at the accommodation and then skip lunch. You need drinks too. Then entrance fees to museums etc which can be expensive.

You could save money by buying breakfast and lunch food as well as drinks in supermarkets. Use public transport instead of taxis. Check out how to get from the airport to the town. One meal out a day in the evening.
But you will definitely need to up your budget. 200 Euros for 9 days is totally unrealistic. You need at least 50 per day and that's if you really scrimp and save, but it's going to be more like 100 if you actually want to do anything or see anything beyond just wandering around the streets because that's free.

Why all these threads at the moment with people going on holiday to foreign countries with fuck all spending money??

Ah yes i should have mentioned in my post just above buffet breakfast was included in the accommodation (which I excluded in the budget), so we definitely filled up generously on it as it was really nice, and we did slip quite an also generous amount of cheese jam butter fresh bread little rolls etc into our bags during breakfast to be honest so lunch and snacks were sorted (waiting staff didn’t seem to mind really)

BarbieKew · 02/09/2023 14:36

“The suburbs” is not an hour out of town. There will be buses, metro and trains so using taxis would be wasteful. Which cities are you going to?

£200 is not enough, but if you’re happy to grab a pastry for breakfast, a sandwich or pizza slice to takeaway for lunch, then you’ve only got dinner and drinks to think about. I anticipate she’ll run out of money on day 4 of living frugally though, not ideal.

Proudgypsy · 02/09/2023 14:35

You need to have an awkward conversation now to save a worse one later.

That is not enough money.

Make a list of the costs for travel in and out of the city and airport transfers etc alone. Ask her how she's going to survive on the remainder.

pontipinemum · 02/09/2023 14:35

So she is bring €200 spending money total, not just wondering that enough cash to bring. No it will not be enough. That's €22 per day. (I have done holidays like that as a backpacker is S.E. Asia a decade ago!)

We are going to Italy soon, 2 adults 1 baby for 1 week. I have booked what we want to visit online and we plan to spend 4/5 days just chilling in the resort which is self catering. I am putting aside €1,000 for it so €500 per adult for a spending money (we don't drink). Although we can spend more if we want. I won't be taking the spending money in cash, I plan on tapping my card/phone or using and ATM if needed.

StuckintheUSA · 02/09/2023 14:34

Can you take public transport to and from the airports, or will you have to rely on taxis? The two transfers alone could eat up half of her budget. If she can't take more money and you have to take a taxi, try and get her to pay for the transfer from the airport to the first B&B when you land, and say that you'll pay for the trip to the airport when you leave. At least that way she'll know how much she has to budget for the rest of the trip.

Maddy70 · 02/09/2023 14:33

That's a daily limit

Escalateandcreate · 02/09/2023 14:31

I’d just say to her that you do not believe 200 is enough for transport and all food. Say you are concerned and that you cannot lend or cover food etc for her while you are away. If necessary, head on out by yourself for the day.

Blondewithredlips · 02/09/2023 14:31

Amim · 02/09/2023 13:17

Not enough and Italy isn’t cheap!

This

Alldressedup · 02/09/2023 14:29

Just back from Italy. Been many times. Where are you staying and which cities are you visiting? Public transport is easy to use but an hour’s journey won’t be very cheap.
As others have said, her budget is absolutely ridiculous. After transport to and from airport and city tax, she’ll be going very hungry.
I don’t find Italy overly expensive, you can buy slices of pizza/ sandwiches for good prices from take away places. Ice cream/ gelato is 2 euros. Pizza is usually less than 10 euros in a restaurant but remember they charge a ‘cover charge’ of approx 2 euros in sit down restaurants and you pay for water.
It will end up being a bit of a disaster and very much a disappointment of a trip to be honest. Sorry.