Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Italy tour ..we don't have enough cash?

393 replies

LaDolceVitafor200 · 02/09/2023 13:13

Afternoon!

I have been reading alot of holiday threads here recently which has prompted my own dilemma

Me and friend booked a very cheap Italy tour for 9 days 8 nights leaving next week. It's staying in 4 different Italian cities in basic B and B accommodation, local taxes and breakfast not included. B and B are all outside main towns we are visiting so an hour's travel.

We also have to pay for transport from airport each way , tour is self guided and just includes flights, coach transfers between 4 different cities and B and B

My friend is taking 200 euros and says she won't spend more, I'm getting worried this won't be enough, we also have to pay B and B local taxes etc

AIBU to tell her we both will need more cash , or has anyone been to Italy and found it cheap?!

OP posts:
rookiemere · 02/09/2023 17:15

LaDolceVitafor200 · 02/09/2023 16:51

Thanks everyone, interesting

For those who asked it was an offer on a site like travelzoo, Italy tour 399 each

Land Rome , 2 nights there, then to Venice Verona and Milan 2 nights each.

Your best bet OP is to start a new thread in Travel asking for cheapest restaurants and sightseeing recommendations in those places.

My own top tip is go for a drink around 5-7 pm in Italy and there is. selection of snacks you can help yourself to. When we were in Bologna there was one bar that basically put out all the salads and tortillas and other quite substantial things that hadn't sold at lunchtime. We drunk a bottle of wine and stuffed ourselves for about 30 euros- except we forgot about third friend having a nap so had to pretend we hadn't eaten and go out for dinner anyway Grin.

I think one of your main issues will be location of the B&notbs. I'd be working out your bus routes into town especially for Rome which has a lot of walking. Borghese park in Rome is free and worth seeing.

ActDottie · 02/09/2023 17:14

She could maybe get away with it if you didn’t have all the hotel taxes to pay but even then it would be a very tight budget and probably not fun.

rainbowripples · 02/09/2023 17:12

menopausalbloat · 02/09/2023 16:13

@rainbowripples
You should be fine with that.

Thanks and thanks to Womencanlift too. I don’t drink alcohol so will only have to pay for water and the odd diet coke with lunch when out and about. Hot drinks are also included during the day when at the hotels.

IcedPurple · 02/09/2023 17:03

LaDolceVitafor200 · 02/09/2023 16:51

Thanks everyone, interesting

For those who asked it was an offer on a site like travelzoo, Italy tour 399 each

Land Rome , 2 nights there, then to Venice Verona and Milan 2 nights each.

4 of the most expensive cities in Italy.

Apart from food, won't you want to go sightseeing? It would be a pity to go to Rome or Verona and not get to see inside any of the historic buildings. One entrance fee and a cappuccino drunk standing at the bar and there's your daily budget gone.

Theroom · 02/09/2023 16:59

No.

I travelled in Italy as a student 25 years ago. My budget was £20/day and I only just scraped by (and that was with many things free entry for under 18s, eating supermarket bread and peanut butter for breakfast and lunch, and sharing a cheese pizza for dinner).

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/09/2023 16:58

Venice, Verona, Rome and Milan - not the cheapest areas of Italy then! Yeah .... you are going to need at least 100 - 200 euros a day.

ClickAndCollecting · 02/09/2023 16:55

Italy is so expensive. We are in Paris right now and are saying how much cheaper it is that when we went to Italy in August. We love Italy but are fed up of how much more expensive it is than other European cities.
Your friend needs to bring more cash.

almostoverthehill · 02/09/2023 16:53

If I’m scrimping and scraping it’s not an enjoyable holiday (hence I’ve not been away for 4 years)!

Longagonow96 · 02/09/2023 16:52

Highlyflavouredgravy · 02/09/2023 13:14

200 euros a DAY would be enough

HOW much? Bloody hell there are some spendthrifts on here...

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 02/09/2023 16:52

How much did the holiday cost? It sounds like it's gonna be awful and you might be better off cutting your losses?

Did you not look at the itinerary before you agreed to it?

€200 for 8 days is impossible. Which airports are you landing at/leaving from? I would be wanting €200 a day for myself.

This holiday seems to have been organised backwards. I wouldn't be bailing her out, you won't get your money back.

LaDolceVitafor200 · 02/09/2023 16:51

Thanks everyone, interesting

For those who asked it was an offer on a site like travelzoo, Italy tour 399 each

Land Rome , 2 nights there, then to Venice Verona and Milan 2 nights each.

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 02/09/2023 16:51

I know this is somewhat missing the major point - but I just want to point out that pot noodles using the accommodation bedroom kettle is probably not going to be possible because it's unlikely there will be a kettle...

We were in Italy in July. There's no point going if you can't afford entrance fees and reasonable food.

beatrix1234 · 02/09/2023 16:44

200 euros for 9 days that's like 21 pounds a day (aprox), should be enough for a coffee in the morning (not the fancy type), few packs of noddles soups in the local supermercato to help her during the day and a cheap can of beer at night.

Good news is that with all this heat plus the sweating she'll loose one stone at least!

IcedPurple · 02/09/2023 16:44

SoIinvictus · 02/09/2023 16:36

For some things yes! Every time I go to the UK I wonder round supermarkets going "god, look at how cheap that is compared to Italy!"

In my experience 'stuff' is cheaper in Britain and there's a lot more variety. However, basic groceries and eating out are considerably cheaper in Italy.

SoIinvictus · 02/09/2023 16:36

Lovelybeansfromnextdoor · 02/09/2023 16:10

Italy is expensive

Compared to where? The UK?

For some things yes! Every time I go to the UK I wonder round supermarkets going "god, look at how cheap that is compared to Italy!"

Stoic123 · 02/09/2023 16:34

regularbutpanickingabit · 02/09/2023 14:38

Sadly, Italy is no longer the cheap option for a holiday. You can do it more cheaply or not, but it is never cheap!

OK, I think she needs to see in black and white what she's in for:

  1. Use the Rome2Rio website to put in the location of your B&Bs in each place and the main town/city/attraction you want to visit. It will give you all the travel options with costs and you can link through to the public transport options for that area.
  2. Where are you getting the one hour suburb bit from? Could it be that there is a more direct walking route that isn't so far away?
  3. Go to tripadvisor for each area and search for cafes/restaurants at the lowest price point. Check out their menus. That will give you a reasonable guid to what to expect.
  4. Are any of the B&Bs equipped with shared kitchen or food prep areas? You can pick up reasonably cheap food at markets and local bakeries/supermarkets so could factor that in, but they aren't as cheap as you might expect.
  5. If you have a big breakfast then you don't need lunch. Pick up some fruit from the market to keep you going.
  6. Pizza tends to be the cheapest dinner, but also depends on where in the country you are. In the South you can get a simple margherita at a restaurant for around 5-6 euros. But you have to usually pay a table tax and for water.
  7. Buying a simple slice of pizza will be a lot cheaper from a hole-in-the-wall place but even decent size sandwiches will be 5 euros plus.
  8. Ice cream/gelato is super cheap and really good. But probably not cheap enough or good enough for 3 meals a day...
  9. Can you list the actual areas you are visiting so people can help with inside knowledge if they have it?

This is good advice. I've travelled on local trains in Italy and they are reasonably good value and efficient.

I went to Rome on my own for a few days. Wasn't on a tight budget but didn't necessarily want to sit down at a restaurant on my own all the time. Snacking (pizza, bread, cheese, gelato etc) and picnics meant that I ended up spending much less than anticipated.

200 Euros is still too little.

Cramlington567 · 02/09/2023 16:34

@VickyEadieofThigh

Variations in this:
Cringey if it doesn't work.

Who Doesn't Love Free McDonald's? 🍔🇬🇧

Who Doesn't Love Free McDonald's? 🍔🇬🇧

https://youtu.be/ylHD-KICkqU?si=nHpcoKDXCO-Hh1wv

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/09/2023 16:32

Not sure if this is still a thing (haven't been to Italy since Covid) bit some cities do a card you can buy from the tourist office that can be uses for museums/historical sites and public transport. It's worth it if you are using a lot of public transport and want to see all the sights. But it will blow a hole in the 200 euro budget.

As others ha e said aperitivo hour in cities like Turin and Bologna can be a cheaper way to eat. Bars will charge a bit more for a drink in this period but there will be food - some fancier bars will supply dainty plates of tiny sandwiches or canapes, more down to earth and studently places may may have a carby buffet or even just a big communal dish of pasta or risotto on the bar.

Therealjudgejudy · 02/09/2023 16:27

@Lovelybeansfromnextdoor in general. Many of people have pointed that out so not sure why you tagged me.

HTH

Janieforever · 02/09/2023 16:20

I just googled, it’s 3 - 7 euros per person per night in Rome and 2 -5 euros in the other cities. So they should budget forty to fifty euros for the tax.

airport transfers they will need to catch a train or bus. And make sure they know how to navigate to the b&b. They may not find much English in the burbs , so hopefully they speak some Italian.

im also really surprised anyone would book this without understanding what’s involved or the costs. This is far from a cheap holiday. Staying an hour outside the locations they wish to be in will be beyond painful.

it would be fine if they know what they are doing, are knowledgeable on local transport and areas, and have enough money to travel round and enjoy themselves, but the friend will barely be able to afford to eat. And she certainly can’t afford to visit any main attraction that’s got a cost,. They also need to buy water.

id drop out. Unless the op pays for her, it will be utterly miserable.

VickyEadieofThigh · 02/09/2023 16:19

Cramlington567 · 02/09/2023 16:15

I suppose if you were in a backpacker type mindset you could:

Coffee and croissant standing up 3 euros each

Lunch split a baguette and one or two of ham/cheese/olives from supermarket 6 euros each.

Dinner: bottle of cheap wine, pizza al taglio, maybe some fruit. 10 euros each. Sit in the park or beauty spot and watch the sunset.

Take a refillable water bottle and fill throught the day.

That is 19 euros.

Do all sightseeing on foot and no attractions with entry fees. Walking everywhere will make you hungry though.

Doesn't sound like so much fun. Every meal would be a makeshift picnic, no gelato, only one coffee a day.

Reminds me of Simon Wilson and his no money youtube videos. His fallback option was to go to McDonald's and blag a free burger. I would be too embarrassed to try it but if needs must.

How do you "blag a free burger" from McDonalds?

Sgtmajormummy · 02/09/2023 16:16

In a restaurant, pizza, fizzy water and a dessert is €20 MINIMUM.

RadishAndTwiglet · 02/09/2023 16:15

I am honestly baffled by these posts and feel like it's 1995 again where holiday options in Southern Europe were cheap.

Things have moved on. People need to travel much further afield if they want 200e lasting much more than a day.

I agree. I said it would need 100 a day, but I know DH and I would never manage it for that, or even try. We are not on a tight budget and holidays, for us, are not times to economise. I don't for a minute think it can't be done for much less than we'd spend, but you'd have to plan well, make very different choices on restaurants, use local buses instead of taxis or car hire, forego a cocktail or two before dinner.

But there comes a point where if you aren't prepared (or able) to spend what it realistically costs to get a great experience then it's a complete waste of time even going. And stressful. No-one wants to go through the hassle of travlling to a foreign country just to sit in a budget hotel room night after night eating supernoodles from the hotel kettle, and standing outside famous tourist attractions wishing you could afford the ticket to enter. You'd have a better time by staying at home.

Cramlington567 · 02/09/2023 16:15

I suppose if you were in a backpacker type mindset you could:

Coffee and croissant standing up 3 euros each

Lunch split a baguette and one or two of ham/cheese/olives from supermarket 6 euros each.

Dinner: bottle of cheap wine, pizza al taglio, maybe some fruit. 10 euros each. Sit in the park or beauty spot and watch the sunset.

Take a refillable water bottle and fill throught the day.

That is 19 euros.

Do all sightseeing on foot and no attractions with entry fees. Walking everywhere will make you hungry though.

Doesn't sound like so much fun. Every meal would be a makeshift picnic, no gelato, only one coffee a day.

Reminds me of Simon Wilson and his no money youtube videos. His fallback option was to go to McDonald's and blag a free burger. I would be too embarrassed to try it but if needs must.

Womencanlift · 02/09/2023 16:14

rainbowripples · 02/09/2023 16:05

That’s definitely not enough. I’m going on a 9 day trip to Italy where all transport, breakfast, dinner and evening drinks are included and I was thinking about taking 450 euros - does that sound enough to people? It’s travelling to various locations on the Italian riviera so there won’t be expensive museum entrance fees etc. I’ll just need money for lunch, daytime drinks and souvenirs.

That’s €50 a day, manageable but tight. You will likely be about €20 for lunch (even McDonald’s is more expensive than UK), about the same again for drinks (it is hot so we were buying bottles of water every couple of hours) and then you will have money for souvenirs too