Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu unreasonable for calling out my sister for her poor attitude towards my pregnancy

81 replies

DWSDB · 02/09/2023 10:49

Let me explain cause I know I will get a mixed response. I told my sister I was pregnant as she was miscarrying (I didn’t know this at the time). It was early pregnancy. She had a horrible time, me and my family helped out a lot with her other so her partner could be with her. Barely mention my pregnancy to her or the complications I have had and she rarely mentions it. She has told her friends and other members of outside family that I’m a regnant which I did not agree to so a lot of them congratulate me at events and I didn’t even know they knew. She’s not told her children so if any of my family speaks to me about being pregnant and congratulate me I have to shut it down as to not upset her. This confuses a lot of my family as they want to talk about my baby and I have to act dismissive. My family thinks she’s going too far but nobody dares say anything to her.

She has also told me other people stories of their late miscarriages and babies dying in the womb and getting stuck whilst, tbf unknown to her, I was really worried about mine at the time but I didn’t say anything and let her speak.

This happened in August, it’s now September and I’m 26 weeks pregnant.

Since her miscarriage she has become demanding and bitter towards my mum and dad and others in her family. My mum and dad do their best for her but aren’t as emotionally available as some parent but it doesn’t stop them trying their hardest for her. She says horrible things to her children and step children and shes become so swallowed up in what happened she doesn’t realise how she is acting towards people who are trying to help her. I’ve tried to be there for her but I get I’ve got what she desperately wanted and she doesn’t really reach out to me which I get.

Aside from what happened she has a wonderful life, a partner who is very supportive and loves her deeply, a lot of children already (biological and step), a beautiful house, no money issues and I get that doesn’t stop the pain of what happened she seems to have forgotten about it.

A few weeks back, out of the blue she offered to throw me a baby shower, I agreed but she’s not mentioned it or my pregnancy for weeks. She’s brought it up out of nowhere when I’m really busy demanding to know what I want and I’ve said I’ll speak to her about it later as I’m busy. Shes then told my mum that I was mean to her as I said I’ll let you know in a few days?

After my mum told me she sent me another message asking what I want to do and I’ve said I’ve not given it much thought as she’s not really mentioned it since she asked and she’s not really showed much interest towards the baby.

Boom, she’s gone off on one. Saying that I need to be very careful what I say and how nasty I am for saying this to her as she’s made an effort to ask about the baby etc. The effort was asking the gender.. I’ve clapped back and said it would of been nice to have a sister to help when it got hard and it’s been hard for my immediate family, such as my little boy, been told not to mention it to her and I’ve tried my best for her. She’s said I have said insensitive things to her but I genuinely have racked my brains and come up with nothing. I’m so so careful what I say as to not upset her I can’t think of one thing except saying she’s still got time to have another and she’s had healthy children before. (I know she’s trying again)Then she’s called me names, I’ve called her a brat and she’s blocked me.

Am I the arse here? My mum and dad told me just to leave it and their not getting involved but she’s now deleting me off platforms and I don’t think I deserve this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ginandtonicwithlimes · 02/09/2023 17:27

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 02/09/2023 14:23

I agree that the OP is not at fault here.

Yes, it's said, her sister miscarried. But bloody hell, it was at 6 weeks! I grieved less when I had a missed miscarriage at 13 weeks!

So? Everyone is different.

Gnomegnomegnome · 02/09/2023 15:13

She’s grieving, she’s going to be all over the place and taking it out on those that she loves. Grief makes people say and do crazy things.

Saying nothing is probably kindest at the moment. You can’t control how she acts but you can can control how you respond.

DWSDB · 02/09/2023 15:08

Thanks everyone who posted helpful comments - not the ones who question us as parents because… what.. anyway.

I think both my sister and I have made some mistakes. I think we both need to calm down and give each other some space, when we speak I will apologise for my part.

thanks x

OP posts:
Mamai90 · 02/09/2023 14:54

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 02/09/2023 14:23

I agree that the OP is not at fault here.

Yes, it's said, her sister miscarried. But bloody hell, it was at 6 weeks! I grieved less when I had a missed miscarriage at 13 weeks!

I've had one at 5 weeks and one at 12 weeks, the grief was the same, I don't get your comparison.

Lilolilibet · 02/09/2023 14:49

I don't think this thread is going to help you op.

There is a list of things you shouldn't say to someone experiencing a miscarriage and your responses are on it. I know you meant well but they're just not helpful to hear. You'll know due next time.

You know now it was passive aggressive to mention that she hadn't seemed interested in your baby in the conversation about the baby shower and you're planning to apologise. I would buy a card, write that and ask to move on.

She's going to be in pain for a while or until she's pregnant again. She may act poorly out of that. Cut her some slack if you can. If not, don't engage.

Don't mention the pregnancy in front of her. Good luck.

Mamai90 · 02/09/2023 14:49

Hufflepods · 02/09/2023 12:08

I say that as someone who has experienced a miscarriage trying for my 3rd child, I saw it as a minor bump, we just tried again

How incredibly patronising.

Came on to say the same!

DWSDB · 02/09/2023 14:48

Yes it wasn’t my best move @Skinthin but it was out of frustration of her telling my mum I’d done something wrong when I literally said quote from WhatsApp —-
Are you still sure you want to do it? I know it might be hard I will completely understand if you don’t want to. I’m up to my eyeballs at the moment with a commissioning report 😩 and got to collect (my son) by 8 so I don’t have time to organise anything or write a list at the mo but I’ll let you know as soon as in next few days ❤️xx

Following this a phone call from my mum asking what I’d done to upset her and another message saying along the lines of you better tell me soon.

I will apologise for what I said but I’ve seen and spoken to her multiple times since she has offered with no mention. Either way from this I’ll either not have one or get someone else to help.

OP posts:
TheRealLilyMunster · 02/09/2023 14:44

Your sister is hurting. Having a miscarriage is a painful, lonely and isolating experience. Even if it is an early miscarriage, all your hopes and dreams are gone, and only someone who has gone through that experience can truly understand.

Its not your fault, but the fact that you are pregnant will be really difficult for her. Saying things like 'she's still got time to have another' will only add to her feelings of loneliness because it highlights that you don't understand. She wanted that baby, the one she lost, not a future baby that she might have.

It's probably really painful for her to be around you at the moment. Again, not your fault, but I think you need to give her space, and be there for her when she does come to you.

In an ideal world it would be great if your sister could be happy for you, but after what she's just been through, I think you need to accept that understandably that's not going to happen right now.

Skinthin · 02/09/2023 14:38

I’ve said I’ve not given it much thought as she’s not really mentioned it since she asked and she’s not really showed much interest towards the baby

another one who thinks you sound just as bad as each other. While your sister may have been acting out after the miscarriage, I think it was the height of meanness of you to be so dismissive of her offer to throw you a baby shower, and to take that opportunity to accuse her of not showing enough interest in your pregnancy! I mean , come on.

Zebedee55 · 02/09/2023 14:36

You both sound like drama llamas, but cut her some slack.

A nice house and existing children probably isn't helping her much at the moment.🙄

Soontobe60 · 02/09/2023 14:32

OP, your sister is having to stand by and watch your pregnancy progressing knowing that had she not miscarried her pregnancy would have been at a similar stage. I know that if this were me, Id probably want to hide away from everyone for the duration of the pregnancy. You’re a literal reminder of what shes lost. And always will be.
Cut her some slack, shes grieving.

Whattodo112222 · 02/09/2023 14:27

Well you are both as bad as each other.. but it's not a competition. You could just leave it and be the better person but you're just carrying on.

It's your parents I feel sorry for.

AllOfThemWitches · 02/09/2023 14:26

And regardless of grieving, trying to put a downer on someone else's pregnancy IS malicious.

AllOfThemWitches · 02/09/2023 14:24

JaiynDough · 02/09/2023 12:11

except saying she’s still got time to have another and she’s had healthy children before.

I'm not surprised she's blocking you. These are disgusting comments.

Really depends on context though, doesn't it...

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 02/09/2023 14:23

I agree that the OP is not at fault here.

Yes, it's said, her sister miscarried. But bloody hell, it was at 6 weeks! I grieved less when I had a missed miscarriage at 13 weeks!

primoseyellow · 02/09/2023 14:18

@ginandtonicwithlimes of course not, that goes without saying surely?
But do you think it's acceptable/normal to tell horror birth stories or behave like that?

Its about basic normal behaviour not minimising anyone else issues/suffering.

moose62 · 02/09/2023 14:00

I'm going to disagree with the majority. I don't think the OP is in the wrong. Yes, her sister miscarried and I'm sure she was devastated but at 6 weeks most people don't even know they are pregnant.
I miscarried 3 times at about 12 - 14 weeks and I was completely devastated but I never made it difficult for friends or family who were pregnant. After all it is not your pregnancy and although it is sad for you as the person who miscarried, other people should be able to be happy.
I think you should both clear the air, sit down together and talk about it. After all, you are sisters and you say you love her!

Flakey99 · 02/09/2023 13:24

You both sound like drama lamas.

She needs to stop blaming others for anything that's gone wrong in her life and you need to stop worrying about her feelings all the time and second guessing what to say.

Brefugee · 02/09/2023 13:22

ok so OP had a miscarriage at 10 weeks, so she knows what it's like. And her sister had one at 6 weeks and many of us know what both of those things are like.

They are grown ups. It is perfectly normal, especially approaching what would have been your due date, to mourn the loss of a pregnancy. Even if it was very early. At whatever stage. It can be devastating. Which is why i think the OPs sister needs to get some therapy, because she simply cannot ban all mention of anyone's pregnancy around her. Her sister is playing along with it among family - but someone less close would tell her to get a grip (even sympathetically)

And OP needs to understand that we all have different feelings and needs to shut down the absolutely horrible talk of late miscarriages and stillbirths. That is vile - no matter what the OPs sister is going through.

Talk of shower needs to be put to bed. Decline - be firm but kind - and both of you need to be kinder to each other generally.

readingismycardio · 02/09/2023 13:21

Sorry, pressed send too soon. However, I know that her behaviour comes from a place of grief. I don't think that the fact that she already has children helps, or a beautiful house. Grief is messy and can act weird.

readingismycardio · 02/09/2023 13:19

She has also told me other people stories of their late miscarriages and babies dying in the womb and getting stuck whilst, tbf unknown to her, I was really worried about mine at the time but I didn’t say anything and let her speak.

Even if she didn't know you were worried, I believe it's common sense you don't tell pregnant women about late miscarriages. I get grief - I had a MMC last November and it was the shock of my life, but this is too far and malicious.

HelterSkelter224 · 02/09/2023 13:13

I'm sorry OP but you are in the wrong here.

Your sister is still clearly grieving. It doesn't matter that she already has "lots of" children, or can try again. Her baby died and she is watching you grow a healthy pregnancy. You should never minimise the loss experienced through miscarriage by saying "but you can try again" or "you already have children". She wanted THAT baby but that baby died and she'll never get to meet them. But you can bet that she will always think of them, wonder what they were like, secretly mark their birthday etc.

The fact that she even offered to throw you a baby shower is enormous and would have been so difficult for her to do, and just organising this event will bring her immeasurable pain at every step of the way. It doesn't matter that you were busy in work, you need to understand what a huge thing this is that your sister who experienced the death of her baby just a few month ago is doing for you.

It doesn't matter that her miscarriage was in early pregnancy.

Honestly I think you owe your sister an apology.

DWSDB · 02/09/2023 13:12

@Whattodo112222 considering you were saying both of us weren’t fit to be parents a minute ago it’s nice to know you’re now defending my sister?

OP posts:
ActDottie · 02/09/2023 13:10

slithytoveisascientist · 02/09/2023 11:51

You both sound so dramatic 😂

This!

MintJulia · 02/09/2023 13:09

FarmGirl78 · 02/09/2023 11:24

You both sound as bad as one another. Your poor parents being trapped in the middle of this. Neither of you sound mature enough to be parents.

This.

It isn't a competition for God's sake. You don't say how far gone she was but she's clearly grieving and sad. Just leave her alone and show a little sensitivity. Or keep out of her way for a couple of months if you find her hard to cope with.