Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to agree to a visit from husband’s female friend

160 replies

Namechangedforthis222 · 02/09/2023 09:10

I just need to check if I’m being unreasonable here. Happy to be told I am. I have changed my username, but am a regular user.

My DH and I have 2 children. The youngest is 4 months old. All is going well. We have the occasional row, but mostly care for the kids 50:50.
Most family members have met the new baby, except my DH’s grandmother (kid’s great grandmother). She’s frail and we worry that she hasn’t got long to go.
This week, I randomly thought that we should really go visit the great grandma as it has been 4 months now. She lives 2.5 hours away by car and I’ll be doing all the driving as DH has a driving phobia (even though he has a licence). The whole thing was my plan and I knew I’d be doing all the driving and was happy to.

Here’s the issue. After agreeing to the trip today, yesterday husband suddenly remembered that his friend is visiting from Canada and staying in London for a week roughly. It seems he has made plans for her to visit the house this evening, after I would have spent 5 hours driving to see his grandma.
From the moment he mentioned it, I’ve said no, not on Saturday after that huge drive. The friend can visit any other day that’s not today. I want to come home from the drive and sit and watch some TV in peace. Full disclosure, I also don’t like this friend. We’re civil, but she’s one of those really extreme right wing Canadians, so we have very little in common.

DH has now woken up feeling angry that I won’t let his friend visit today. Apparently she’s only free today and DH doesn’t want to go meet her for dinner/drinks instead (he gets anxious with commuting).

Am I being unreasonable to say she cannot visit today after my 5 hour drive??

OP posts:
jannier · 02/09/2023 15:28

Why are people assuming phobias are fake? Or is it only something women can have...driving, commuting and going out all fit together it's not like ohhh it's a phobia about driving but he always gets drunk, he hates water so can't bath our kids but baths himself thing.

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2023 15:24

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 13:04

AGAIN, how the hell does a lay in the DAY AFTER, help her on.the.day when she has been driving for 5 hours? She needs the respite ON.THE.DAY, not 2 bloody days later!

She needs as the mother of basically a newborn baby that time ON.THE.DAY.

Making your wife, and mother of 2 children, one basically a newborn, drive for 5 hours, and then come back and get no respite that night is not 'thoughtful'. It's the exact fucking opposite!

Selfishness and manipulation and control is NOT a mental health condition.

He is absolutely a fucking selfish pig.

He didn’t make her do anything. She suggested and facilitated the trip and knew she would be driving. He forgot about the friends’ visit. This is a long standing MH problem of which the OP has always known and is supportive, and for which he is in treatment. And there is nothing in any of her posts to suggest he is using his condition to control her - in fact she points out that he pulls his weight in the relationship.

He is actively getting help for the condition and if he’s on medication, this could be affecting his behaviour, mood, memory and thought processes - and agoraphobia is frequently a symptom of anxiety/depression. But hey, let’s ignore all of that, and misinterpret/misread what she actually posted in favour of supporting your narrative that her DH hasn’t got a mental health condition at all, but is just a manipulative, selfish fucking pig. Because that’s what you read on MN relationship threads so it must be true.

GrumpyPanda · 02/09/2023 15:07

Can't believe the opinions I'm reading and telling OP she's BU. OP is solo driving 5 hours today to visit HIS granny, she also has a tiny baby so she'll be completely knackered come tonight. So now her absolute ninny of a partner suddenly announces he'll land her with a very difficult visitor and because of his weird hang-ups, can't take that visitor elsewhere? I'd be furious. OP YANBU in the slightest. Hand him the baby after you get back and have a long bubble bath with a glass of wine and a mystery novel. Oh and he owes you big time.

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2023 14:56

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 11:32

Don't be so ignorant and naive, some men DO use mental health issues as an excuse to control. This is well-known. Read Relationships and you'll see this. Hundreds of threads on it.

Some. Not all. And it’s ignorant to assume this is happening here when the OP hasn’t said anything to that effect, and has said several times that this is a long standing problem of which she was aware before they married. So she’s clearly on board with it and supportive of him, and doesn’t need to be told he’s a controlling arse when he’s actually suffering from a diagnosed MH problem for which he is getting treatment.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 02/09/2023 14:01

@Sueveneers no, OP offered to drive them to see the grandma, he didn’t EXPECT her to at all, OP offered..

SeatonCarew · 02/09/2023 13:39

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 02/09/2023 10:54

This. He does seem so Inflexible.

And I can't believe you are getting so much flack for this with two DCs, one a young baby, on top of a five-hour drive and visit to his GM - which you have suggested, facilitated and organised on his behalf.

We have similar visit distances and its tiring. We are expected to stay for lunch and tea and its tiring and I remember it being tiring with the DC too, trying to keep them from being too restless in a room full of breakables, whilst listening to quiet conversation. (DH often "naps" during the visit) then coming home, putting DC who'd been couped up all day in the car and in sitting rooms to bed etc...I'd want to collapse at home quietly before the next busy day of childcare too ( particularly when the day has disrupted 4 month old's routine and theyve slept in the car, and need bedtime feeds)

And waking up "angry"? What's that about. Angry at you because HE forgot to even mention he'd made plans. "Suddenly" remembering once the other plans you'd made on his behalf were in place and apparently the friend is only able to do Saturday and cannot do any other day. Well has he actually asked her? Or is she just inflexible too.
What is he doing to suggest a workable compromise?
Is he relying on the fact that he's angry to force you into backing down and putting up with it?

I'd concede that the friend is only over from Canada for a short while, but.
However, I'd also consider:
How much effort is he going to put into getting the children up and ready for the journey and the visit, and keeping them sorted out during visit and in the car?
How much effort will he put into getting them fed and into bed on the return.
Is he expecting a meal prepared for the friend?
Who is shopping and cooking and tidying the house for that?
Has he worked out how much time there will be all the above when you get home before the friend turns up. What if there's heavy traffic on the way home.?

Is the friend the type who will muck in and help or will they expect it to be all calm and organised on arrival?

Has he offered to get a takeaway, take her to a local restaurant?

Its fine for him to ask for friend to visit - but given that he's almost double booked you - what is he prepared to do to lighten the load? Or is he just going to display how angry he is that he can't have things exactly the way he wants them and for you to facilitate that?

If he's not getting help with the things that are preventing him going out and driving etc and in effect constraining your family life, how sustainable is that now that you have two DC?
Why does he think its OK for you to always carry the extra load? Does he try to balance that by helping in other ways? How do you feel about being assigned that role long term?

Thank you for typing all this out and saving me the bother. I couldn't agree more.

I hope, OP, that he will be stepping up and pulling his weight during the day, including taking the lead socially at granny's and looking after the DC. I really hope he appreciates all the effort you are making on his behalf, and that with a young baby.

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 13:04

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 02/09/2023 13:00

Because she'll get a lie in?

Because she'll get chance for time to herself as he has?

Because its thoughtful?

Because he has a serious MH condition?

He's not selfish or a pig

AGAIN, how the hell does a lay in the DAY AFTER, help her on.the.day when she has been driving for 5 hours? She needs the respite ON.THE.DAY, not 2 bloody days later!

She needs as the mother of basically a newborn baby that time ON.THE.DAY.

Making your wife, and mother of 2 children, one basically a newborn, drive for 5 hours, and then come back and get no respite that night is not 'thoughtful'. It's the exact fucking opposite!

Selfishness and manipulation and control is NOT a mental health condition.

He is absolutely a fucking selfish pig.

starfishmummy · 02/09/2023 13:01

I'd also say I'd put up with it.after driving 5 hours with the visit in between, you can plead tiredness and take yourself off to bed (with a good book) and leave husband to look after the kids and entertain his friend.

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 13:01

I'd say yes only if he has both of the kids with them (providing you're not breastfeeding) and watches them with the friend. That will put a real dampner on it and she'll probably leave early.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 02/09/2023 13:00

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 12:49

And how exactly, will that help the OP on the night, when after 5 hours driving, she has to watch the kids too, while he is downstairs pissing it up?

He is a fucking selfish pig!

Because she'll get a lie in?

Because she'll get chance for time to herself as he has?

Because its thoughtful?

Because he has a serious MH condition?

He's not selfish or a pig

Babewhat · 02/09/2023 12:58

@curliegirlie that was my comment and from reading your post I hope it didn’t upset you. My point was that there is a segment of people who can’t/won’t drive and also make it everyone else’s problem and become super complacent about it, by default putting the burden on their partner/friends/anyone else around them. Not everyone, and as someone else said, there’s generally a bit of over indexing in other areas in a healthy relationship (which it doesn’t sound like the OP is experiencing in this example).

It sounds very frustrating for you in your specific case. Tangentially, I hope you live somewhere with decent transport infrastructure, as it’s absolutely shocking the way public transport has been systematically dismantled in many (most?) areas of the U.K, making it almost impossible not to drive. But that’s a whole other thread! Apologies again if my comment came across as too much of an over generalisation x

HardcoreLadyType · 02/09/2023 12:55

I think you’ve done the right thing, and the advantage to you of her coming today is that you have the perfect excuse for avoiding her as much as possible, as having had such a big day, you are understandably tired, and have a good reason to want to tuck yourself up in bed, and cuddle your baby!

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 02/09/2023 12:52

OP - it was shitty of him to forget his friend was coming but I'll admit I've done similar before, mind has too much going on and it slips through until its happening. Make sure you have a calendar and "if it's not on the calendar it's not happening" as the motto in our house goes.

He's clearly got deep issues and it's good he's working on them.

It's one night, you say he does his fair share and he'll do extra to make up this inconvenience so just taking yourself off upstairs is the best thing to do.

So what if she's not your political sway, its inconsequential tbh

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 12:49

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 02/09/2023 12:43

OP had clearly said he helps with the housework and will be doing mornings for the next few days to make up for it

He's not a selfish pig

And how exactly, will that help the OP on the night, when after 5 hours driving, she has to watch the kids too, while he is downstairs pissing it up?

He is a fucking selfish pig!

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 02/09/2023 12:43

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 11:30

FFS have a think about what you're saying. She has two children including a 4 month old baby, and he expects her to drive for 5 hours? She's looking after for all intent and purposes a newborn baby plus another child. Will he look after the children while he is entertaining for hours after his wife drove for 5 hours? I doubt it. It will all be on OP. He's a selfish pig of 'man'.

Edited

OP had clearly said he helps with the housework and will be doing mornings for the next few days to make up for it

He's not a selfish pig

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 12:42

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 02/09/2023 12:41

Did you miss the part where his anxiety covered travel in general or did you chose to overlook that?

Then omit taxi. But he surely could walk somewhere.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 02/09/2023 12:41

smartiesneberhadtheanswer · 02/09/2023 11:11

@WandaWonder

Anxiety is horrible but it should never be used to control another person. The husband perhaps could have walked, cycled or taken a taxi to a venue to meet his friend? That would be completely reasonable and meet both his and OP's needs

Did you miss the part where his anxiety covered travel in general or did you chose to overlook that?

nameitagain · 02/09/2023 12:20

@Ducksinthebath It’s absolutely unhinged to fake a very transmissible illness to avoid spending time with someone if it might also jeopardise your husband seeing her. She might not want to hang out with someone who’s been spending 5 hours in a tin can with a sick person and is probably ill themselves.

I have no idea sometimes why people can’t just be adult and say they’ve had a long drive, aren’t up to an evening of socialising so can they just say hello and duck out or the other half goes out somewhere with their friend. Far better than behaving like a child over it and making up a stupid story.
Unhinged???? Really? You have a weird idea of what unhinged means
And people do this because there are to many ridiculously self important people who have a problem with being told that they are less important than someone else's rest is. People get all uppity and feel insulted. People can't deal with that shit and it's easier to say they aren't well than deal with the inevitable fall out and sniping

ihadamarveloustime · 02/09/2023 12:15

Oh, hadn't even occurred to me that after a long day of driving for the OP, she'll get to be in charge of the baby and toddler when they get home, too, as he will have a (n unwanted, bigoted, right wing) friend round to visit. That she'll no doubt not be allowed to disappear from helping entertain when she's not shushing the children.

Sueveneers · 02/09/2023 12:08

misteek · 02/09/2023 11:56

why cant you visit granny another day? if seems odd you suddenly decide to visit when his friend is visiting for 1 day.

Did you read OP's post? The visit with the granny had been planned long ago, the granny doesn't have long to live, OP didn't just decide on the visit. In fact she didn't even know husband's friend was visiting, until the last minute.

misteek · 02/09/2023 11:56

why cant you visit granny another day? if seems odd you suddenly decide to visit when his friend is visiting for 1 day.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 02/09/2023 11:52

Rosscameasdoody · 02/09/2023 11:09

You clearly missed the fact that the OP has been aware of his MH difficulties from before they were married. She clearly understands the issues involved and only posted about this one event. Why are you patronising her ?

I've already acknowledged that I missed OP's updates.

I don't think I was patronising her and it is not my intention to do so. If I did I apologise, to her.
She posted asking if she was unreasonable. I was saying that I didn't think she was. This may be one event, but as I said in my post

"that doesn't mean that his behaviour is helpful or considerate, particularly waking up "angry" with the woman who has been supporting and helping him."

He's not behaving fairly by being angry with the OP. That's just my opinion, it is not stated to patronise the OP, nor is pointing out that in the light of this "one" event and his reaction to it, this is unfair on the OP, and given they now have two DC, this needs to be worked out and made sustainable.

Tortoisetowers · 02/09/2023 11:45

A four month old baby and a huge commute?!

I'm honestly shocked that anyone would think you are being unreasonable! Honestly shocked!

I think your suggestion of him going out is entirely fair. Surely there is a local pub they can meet?

Willmafrockfit · 02/09/2023 11:44

i said yanbu until i read she is only free then
so i guess you will have to suck it up

curliegirlie · 02/09/2023 11:43

Madness that anyone with two kids can’t drive, yet is clearly in situations where they need to be driven. What would have happened if he had kids with someone else who couldn’t drive?

I'm in that situation unfortunately. In my case I spent 7 years on and off having lessons and failed 7 tests so in the end decided to stop chucking good money after bad. I hate being so reliant on DH for journeys I can't do by walking or public transport, and not being able to share the driving etc, but it is what it is.

I have hemiplegia. I don't think that alone has affected by ability to drive or pass my test (plenty of people with the same condition do, with steering balls or other adaptations), but I was also a very nervous driver and my anxiety around roundabouts etc was unreal. I was 27 or 28 when I started learning. I do wish I'd started earlier when I was younger and more confident.

Swipe left for the next trending thread