Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTF! Why do you need a degree for customer service???

40 replies

Dogonthebed · 01/09/2023 22:57

I’m not outing any company particularly, I am talking generally. I have no intention of naming names but it’s a growing trend for jobs advertising salaries £20’000 - £25’000 a year, stating pref a degree!

I have had many varied roles through my life always working up to supervisor and managerial level through hard graft and giving my all. It doesn’t matter what you do for a living from cleaning toilets to being GM, my work ethic will always be the same, you are paid to do a job to the best of your abilities. It is a contract between yourself and employer.

Yet…. I can’t get even a customer service job interview apparently because I don’t have a degree! I have run telesales teams, Legal Offices, Legal Cashiering! I took a break to look after my ASD child during the Pandemic and now can’t even get to the next stage!
If I had a degree I wouldn’t be applying for entry level roles! RAH !!!!! I have life and work experience, proven competency from being promoted.
anyone else?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user68997555098 · 02/09/2023 10:35

Createausername1970 · 02/09/2023 10:28

Slightly off topic. A friend was doing very well in her career, it was suggested she applied to join their management training route. But then, because she didn't have GCSE maths at grade C she couldn't apply. What she did have was Grade One O Level maths. She had to do GCSE maths at night school for a year (at her own expense) in order to get a GCSE qualification, before she could be considered. She got A* in the end.

But what a pointless waste of time and money.

That's so idiotic of them to request. I'd have challenged that as they are considered equivalent and are accepted at HE level (even higher standard than the GCSE).

What a waste of time and money!

Createausername1970 · 02/09/2023 10:28

Slightly off topic. A friend was doing very well in her career, it was suggested she applied to join their management training route. But then, because she didn't have GCSE maths at grade C she couldn't apply. What she did have was Grade One O Level maths. She had to do GCSE maths at night school for a year (at her own expense) in order to get a GCSE qualification, before she could be considered. She got A* in the end.

But what a pointless waste of time and money.

user68997555098 · 02/09/2023 10:11

*Tangled123
I have a degree but have never been asked to prove it for a job. For a retail job, I would just lie about it. Like you say, it isn’t required.

Yeah this!

If you're old then you put that you did a degree in some bullshit subject at some now non-existent polytechnic in 1989 and who the fuck is gonna check?

I've never been asked to prove I had a degree either.

I must say I've never seen customer service jobs requiring a degree. It is stupid thing to request without it being more specific or relevant in some way to the job, as degrees, and quality, varies so much.

Tootingbec · 02/09/2023 08:46

I would apply regardless. I do a lot of recruiting for this type of role for a large global company and we really struggle to get good capable people with experience. Honestly couldn’t give a toss about a degree or not!

THisbackwithavengeance · 02/09/2023 08:43

Tangled123 · 02/09/2023 00:27

I have a degree but have never been asked to prove it for a job. For a retail job, I would just lie about it. Like you say, it isn’t required.

Yeah this!

If you're old then you put that you did a degree in some bullshit subject at some now non-existent polytechnic in 1989 and who the fuck is gonna check?

TroglodytesTroglodytes · 02/09/2023 08:14

Apply anyway. In the current climate there is a shortage of applications. If you meet the other criteria you may well be considered.

I work in admin and they started asking for a degree for my role about 10 years ago (I don’t have one but have worked there for 15 years so before it became a requirement). In the last 2 years this has been dropped! We really struggle to recruit now and the job is reasonably paid for the work. The candidates are just not there at the moment.

PinkRoses1245 · 02/09/2023 07:41

That’s ridiculous! It’s discrimination really when it’s not a genuine requirement. Good HR teams should be pushing for degree to only be included when required

jallopeno · 02/09/2023 07:39

Apply anyway

Toomanylaughs · 02/09/2023 07:37

BringOnSummerHolidays · 02/09/2023 06:22

I think the problem is more ageism. They prefer a 20 something for an entry level role, not someone 45. You can apply even without a degree, it’s just preferable. I bet someone 45 with a degree has the same outcome with being rejected.

I know Mumsnet don’t like people saying they look younger than they do but I do. people have always been very surprised at my age (hated it when I was a teen who looked like an 11 year old though!) and I still get ID’d…so when I was 32 I got hired for a PR agency entry level job. I had cut down on some of cv and avoided dates of my undergrad and I had just graduated from my MSc.

They blatantly thought I was early to mid 20s like all the other new starts did and were . The HR person looked at me like a ghost when I brought my passport in the first day and kept staring at the date of birth page and then up at me. I think she kept it to herself though because the managers tried to take the piss out of me and treat me like all the other fairly timid 24 years olds.

I raised a health & safety complaint and other complaints after 4 months with them only to get fired the next week for no discernible reason (obviously it was the complaint ) .

When I appealed the decision with them which I had to do before going to ACAS, they made a comment that someone with my experience would have been better suited for somewhere else and I could see they now all knew. And they were blatantly ageist.

I was actually planning to leave the job at the 6 month mark and had already been applying for jobs so it worked out quite well for me - they didn’t have a leg to stand on and I negotiated 8K settlement from them and started a new job the next month.

I also negotiated an agreed reference with them as part of the settlement and their first draft of it listed my date of birth alongside my name. I told the ACAS conciliator to tell them to remove it which she backed me up on it so they did.

It was like they didn’t want any other employers “tricked” into thinking they were hiring a gullible young person as opposed to a hardened 30 year old 😂

it’s NONE of employers business what age I am so if I ‘fool’ employers, more power to me - they shouldn’t be ageist anyway!

daisychain01 · 02/09/2023 06:32

Dogonthebed · 02/09/2023 00:38

Ah maybe I should 🤥 I would be terrified of being found out though!

Honestly, @Dogonthebed dont take that dreadful advice to lie on your CV. I would never suggest doing that, it's not necessary.

Although it's massively frustrating not to secure a role you can do standing on your head with your eyes closed, stay true and accurate, but check your CV to make sure there are no telltale signs of age and sex. You shouldn't need to do this by rights, but even with the Equality Act (2010) in place, recruiters are still silently discriminatory, so you need to take away their chance to be so.

list the qualifications and CPD you have but without dates (you can always evidence those when you get your foot in the door).
no need to include a photo
Highlight your best roles, really bring out your experience and expertise and take out any irrelevant info to keep your CV brief but impactful.
add a personal statement of 2-3 lines max, which tell them who you are: committed, enthusiastic, skilled and experienced, used to working under pressure to meet deadlines etc. what value add are you bringing to the role.

give them every reason to add you to their Yes pile and not their No pile.

it's soul destroying to be rejected but keep going, it really is a numbers game.

BringOnSummerHolidays · 02/09/2023 06:22

I think the problem is more ageism. They prefer a 20 something for an entry level role, not someone 45. You can apply even without a degree, it’s just preferable. I bet someone 45 with a degree has the same outcome with being rejected.

pinkfondu · 02/09/2023 06:18

I would apply regardless op.

I dont remember the exact quote, but basically not having the required skills or qualifications only stops women from applying, men apply regardless.

VictoriaVenkman · 02/09/2023 06:12

I saw this last time I was job hunting. Worrying trend.

GRex · 02/09/2023 05:47

"Pref" isn't mandatory, just a preference that you can ignore. Apply anyway and see how it goes. Lots of people don't include their degree in the CV past a certain age, and managers will be more interested in experience. If they ask if you have a degree, turn it round saying "I have 10 years of relevant experience instead"'. Good luck!

Lincslady53 · 02/09/2023 05:40

In the 80s the large company I worked for would require their marketing employees to have a degree. A 2:2 would be fine. After Blairs revolution to get 50% of the population to Uni, the requirement to get a marketing job increased. If you didn't have a 1st, you wouldn't get an interview. I started my career as an A level management trainee at one of the main supermarkets. Now a degree is required. All Blair did was reduce youth unemployment and make them pay their own way with student loans instead of claiming the dole.

ThinWomansBrain · 02/09/2023 03:08

Apply anyway - with more mature applicants (sorry!) they will base the selection decision on your experience.

I have a professional qualification and an MSc now, but I was about 50 before I got the degree.
I've always applied for anything, despite most part and post qualified roles in my profession specifying that a degree is required (and most in my field will state degree plus prof. qualification).
I've never even bothered to reference the lack of a degree in my applications. Who knows, I may have been sifted out of the shortlist for that on some occasions, but I have a pretty high hit rate of being shortlisted, and it rarely came up as a question in interviews.

I went to a uni open day the other week to discuss doing a part time degree (my own interest rather than career related), and the professor I was speaking to jumped in straight away to suggest I'd be better off doing an MA rather than an undergraduate degree.

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 02/09/2023 03:05

RoomOfRequirement · 01/09/2023 23:11

Requiring a degree for a role like this shows the HR/Recruiting departments don't have a clue what they're doing. I have a couple high level degrees/certifications, but I also believe the obsession with Uni is becoming ridiculous. Not every job needs a degree and for many those with lived experience will do a much better job than a career student who has never lived in the real world.

Have you looked at the NHS? Many of their roles don't require a degree.

Don't blame us in HR - we are rarely the ones setting these requirements.

This week I had to persuade a Director to remove a degree requirement from a new role they've just created the JD for. Not necessary at all and they saw my point in the end, but a lot of Managers see it as a lazy way to say 'needs a bit of a brain'.

polokiss · 02/09/2023 02:54

I saw this trend emerging 10 + years ago even to get a cleaning or security position you needed some kind of qualification. I think as more and more people get these specialised degrees and qualifications then employers feel they can ask for it. I also notice that you usually need GCSE Math and English at a C or 5/4 for pretty much any job and loads of people do not have maths at that level.

givemeasunnyday · 02/09/2023 02:49

I agree, it's ridiculous. None of the CEOs of the business I used to work for had degrees, they all worked their way up from the bottom, so to insist on a degree for a basic job is ridiculous, not to mention it cheapens degrees.

I can't see that anything learned in a degree course could benefit someone in a customer service job.

sofasofa42 · 02/09/2023 02:09

Are they saying BD as standard OR degree level. This is so different.
Degree level is considered 5 yrs plus in the work place at a clerical level. So not school leaver with 5 yrs experience at Tesco's for example.
Ignore the job descriptions. Apply and make sure you cv looks amazing. No waffle and no photo.

Dogonthebed · 02/09/2023 01:23

ShadyPaws, my DH recruits in a position that you absolutely need a degree for. It is a smaller company but pays well. He would rather see work ethic rather than a 1st. If you have a degree in the area you are applying, I would go for smaller established firms.

OP posts:
Toomanylaughs · 02/09/2023 01:21

ShadyPaws · 02/09/2023 00:53

I'm the opposite, I have a degree but can't seem to get any further than min wage because for a 30k job they want about 5 years experience in that field and relevant qualifications plus a load of other stuff
What's the point in advertising for a trainee manager with.. management experience

It’s just typical employers wanting as much as they can get for very little and effectively underpaying people.

Their entry level jobs are often given to moderately experienced people who are just in need of some more experience.

I did a masters in a new field when I was 30 and despite having several years of work experience before my masters that was all dismissed and when I graduated I just had to start at graduate/entry level and even then I noticed a lot of the roles wanted experience in that particular industry.

Catsmere · 02/09/2023 01:13

ShadyPaws · 02/09/2023 00:53

I'm the opposite, I have a degree but can't seem to get any further than min wage because for a 30k job they want about 5 years experience in that field and relevant qualifications plus a load of other stuff
What's the point in advertising for a trainee manager with.. management experience

It was like this in my job hunting days twenty years ago - job agencies wanted applicants to have degrees, have some years’ experience in the specific job (they had apparently never heard of transferable skills) AND they really wanted you to be seventeen, so you’d be on youth wages. All said job agency staff seemed to be twentysomethings to whom anyone over 30 was far too old to be considered.

NerdyBird · 02/09/2023 01:12

The company I work for is actively removing the requirement to have a degree from many of the job roles. It's meant to increase diversity, but it's a fairly new thing for them so don't know if it's made a difference.

user68997555098 · 02/09/2023 01:04

Given the majority of young people HAVE degrees it's not dissimilar to asking for A levels when I was a teenager (a v low %, was it under 10% went to Uni late '70s?)

What is the percentage who go to university and have degrees now?

Though that number will start to fall, I suppose, over the next few years.