Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to tell you reviewing your GCSE paper isn't "free"

393 replies

BorrowedThyme · 01/09/2023 17:45

I've never begrudged putting aside a few hours for genuine disappointing shock grades, or when a student has so nearly made the grade they need for their next stage.

But this year it has gone totally over the top.

And recalling GCSE papers for the school to review is NOT "free" - it just doesn't cost the parent anything, that is all. It relies either on teachers volunteering their spare time, or the school employing an additional, qualified person to do it.

I spent 25-30 hours in the last week of the holiday doing this, and now have a whole new list to somehow try and cram in to a single weekend

My head of department has already contacted some parents to say no, we are not doing it for such and such a student, and honestly, you would think we were chopping their kids hands off, or something, the abuse, and threats and accusations we get!

Some of the students we have said no to have already got their sixth form places, and don't need to check their grades, some are so far from the next grade up that they are many times more likely to go down than up, and some have got exactly what was predicted, anyway.

Occasionally a grade goes up, but it is very rare, and in genuine cases, I am happy to spend the time checking. Most of the cases we are getting requested now though, are not genuine! None of the papers I have checked this year are going up, although several might actual go down if the parents take it further.

So please, before expecting this service for the school, keep in mind

a) Is it necessary? Not if your child has got their sixth form place or apprenticeship, or whatever they wanted.

b) Is it likely? Parents often over estimate their children's likely GCSE grades, particularly if they have helped them revise, and marked a few mock papers, etc- children perform best in a one to one situation with a lot of encouragement, such as they might get at home with a parent, but this is not how they are assessed.

c) Somebody has to be just below the next grade boundary! That is how grade boundaries work!

d) Some grade bands are very narrow - being 3 marks off a 6 could actually be 2 marks from a 4.

e) It isn't a case of " just finding one more mark" - the marking has to be withing a tolerance. 2 examiners might mark the same paper differently, but that does not mean one is right and one is wrong. Yes, I find marks in the papers that I would have given that the examiner has not, but I also find marks the examiner has given that I would not, and overall, the mark comes out the same, or virtually the same. The grade is not going to be changed over a disagreement about fractions of marks. It needs to be a substantial difference for the grade to be changed, and not a case of strict or lenient marking.

Yes, it is sometimes worth having a look at the papers, no it is not worth this wholesale demand that has developed this year.

If this school review system continues to be abused, I expect it will be withdrawn very soon!

OP posts:
Hawkins0009 · 01/09/2023 22:36

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 22:33

It's the method we have.

It means that when someone says "this is definitely a grade x", they're making a guess.

But if a person gets eg a nine and so does eg 30 others but due to the bell curve then what makes the difference between some getting the 9 and others getting lower grades ?

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 22:34

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 22:33

Not quite! The distribution for certain subjects is very definitely not bell-shaped.

What Ofqual do require is comparable outcomes to the previous year, so the same grade distribution.

Good point.

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 22:33

It's the method we have.

It means that when someone says "this is definitely a grade x", they're making a guess.

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 22:33

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 22:30

Because OFQUAL requires grade distribution on a bell curve.

Not quite! The distribution for certain subjects is very definitely not bell-shaped.

What Ofqual do require is comparable outcomes to the previous year, so the same grade distribution.

to tell you reviewing your GCSE paper isn't "free"
Hawkins0009 · 01/09/2023 22:32

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 22:30

Because OFQUAL requires grade distribution on a bell curve.

Is that a better or worse method ?

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 22:30

Hawkins0009 · 01/09/2023 22:25

If the students study etc why should those that succeed gain the 9 then just adjust the exam etc ? Rather than only giving a certain percentage the 9 if all achieve it

Because OFQUAL requires grade distribution on a bell curve.

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 22:25

curaçao · 01/09/2023 22:24

We got a kevel physics remarked and it was exactly that-a remark.we could see the marks each examiner had given for each question

This year? It wasn't a remark. They were not actively looking for marks.

Hawkins0009 · 01/09/2023 22:25

LimeTreeGrove · 01/09/2023 22:11

I think how it works with grade boundaries is that a certain percentage of the candidates get each grade. So, say 3% get 9. If they set grade 9 at a certain percentage and then 25% of kids achieved that grade it would devalue a 9.
That's my understanding but I'm not a teacher and I might be wrong!

If the students study etc why should those that succeed gain the 9 then just adjust the exam etc ? Rather than only giving a certain percentage the 9 if all achieve it

curaçao · 01/09/2023 22:24

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 01/09/2023 18:17

I get increasingly annoyed by the fact that everyone talks about getting a paper ‘re-marked’. That’s not what happens. You can get a clerical check to check whether there were any clerical errors in the adding up of the original marks or a review of marking where the reviewer checks that the original examiner was reasonable in their application of the mark scheme. They’re not looking for ‘one or two more marks’ so little Johnny can squeak into the grade above!

We got a kevel physics remarked and it was exactly that-a remark.we could see the marks each examiner had given for each question

Mindovermatter247 · 01/09/2023 22:24

When I was at school years ago, it was the teachers who decided wether it was worth the hassle, parents had no say. My maths teacher sent mine back and turns out they missed marked it by 7. I went up from c to b. They only did it for 3 others I believe.

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 22:21

twelly · 01/09/2023 22:11

What you are saying is factually incorrect as there was apparently a different between ordering a photocopied script and the real scripts!
Clearly there is a difference in what teachers regard to be part of their role - which is the same for all jobs, different schools clearly have different expectations and procedures. It is a question of professionalism in my view.

No, my mistake, it was GCSE where you could either get the script or the remark. So they could only do it for A-level, and only for GCSE in recent years.

While looking it up, I came across my post from 2018 where I warned against this happening!

to tell you reviewing your GCSE paper isn't "free"
Stopthatknocking · 01/09/2023 22:20

I really don't remember that! Gcse were in 2019 and a levels in 2021.
My memory must be rubbish

mrsconradfisher · 01/09/2023 22:18

Stopthatknocking · 01/09/2023 22:13

How does everyone know their dc are ' 1 mark from the next grade' or 'only 3 makes off a 9?'
We just got told grades for our dc, no marks.

It’s ok the slip that they get with the results. Then all you need to do is look at the grade boundaries.

surreygirl1987 · 01/09/2023 22:14

However, someone has to explain how 75+% in one subject can get you a 7/8 but in another subject get you a 5 - that is bonkers as has happened in drama across the country and I know the school is looking into it.

The school shouldn't be surprised - this is entirely normal... and not just between subjects but also WITHIN subjects for different exam boards. Grade boundaries get shifted annually depending on how easy or hard an exam series is deemed to be (based on marks awarded), to ensure a spread of grades.

LimeTreeGrove · 01/09/2023 22:13

Countdown2023 · 01/09/2023 22:12

At my school if they want a paper to be re-marked because they are 2 or 3 marks off then we let them apply for a re-mark. I don’t waste my time trawling through papers on the off-chance.

otherwise it will be a significant amount of papers to review - 2 papers for each GCSE and 3 papers for each A Level!

That seems fair enough.

Stopthatknocking · 01/09/2023 22:13

How does everyone know their dc are ' 1 mark from the next grade' or 'only 3 makes off a 9?'
We just got told grades for our dc, no marks.

Countdown2023 · 01/09/2023 22:12

At my school if they want a paper to be re-marked because they are 2 or 3 marks off then we let them apply for a re-mark. I don’t waste my time trawling through papers on the off-chance.

otherwise it will be a significant amount of papers to review - 2 papers for each GCSE and 3 papers for each A Level!

LimeTreeGrove · 01/09/2023 22:11

uneffingbelievable · 01/09/2023 21:57

This year has been a little wild west - thankfully my DC did better than he would if teacher assisted grades -so no re-marks from me!

However, someone has to explain how 75+% in one subject can get you a 7/8 but in another subject get you a 5 - that is bonkers as has happened in drama across the country and I know the school is looking into it. DC has lost out on his chosen A level on this basis as he needed a 7- luckily taking a philosophical view on it but still rankles him.

I think how it works with grade boundaries is that a certain percentage of the candidates get each grade. So, say 3% get 9. If they set grade 9 at a certain percentage and then 25% of kids achieved that grade it would devalue a 9.
That's my understanding but I'm not a teacher and I might be wrong!

surreygirl1987 · 01/09/2023 22:11

Even then you couldn't do it at A-level. It was remark or look at the paper.

Oh yes, and forgotten about this. Were they not allowed a remark if they recalled the paper? This wasn't that long ago...

twelly · 01/09/2023 22:11

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 22:05

Even then you couldn't do it at A-level. It was remark or look at the paper.

I'm wondering why experienced, professional teachers had such a nightmare with exam marks that they routinely have swathes of kids who would pay to have their papers back then pay for a remark.

What you are saying is factually incorrect as there was apparently a different between ordering a photocopied script and the real scripts!
Clearly there is a difference in what teachers regard to be part of their role - which is the same for all jobs, different schools clearly have different expectations and procedures. It is a question of professionalism in my view.

mrsconradfisher · 01/09/2023 22:11

My son has got one very unexpected result at A level, in fact the whole cohort got very unexpected results in the subject. School got the papers back for that subject and for another where he was incredibly close to the grade he needed. His head of 6th form plus the subject teacher have both reviewed the papers and they are being sent for a remark/review. It’s that important to him that he has decided to take a Gap year as he couldn’t face going somewhere he didn’t really want to go and is going to apply again next year.
Yes the grades may not go up but quite honestly it’s a risk we are prepared to take and I’m very thankful to his teachers for supporting him. This is someone’s future we are talking about, not just a random stab in the dark to get higher grades than they deserve. This A level cohort especially have been completely screwed by the government this year with the grade boundaries, what they have experienced is totally unfair and in most cases not a true reflection of the work they have put in. That coupled with the papers not being marked accurately or fairly, is it any wonder that more and more parents/students are questioning it?
Oh and I’m also a TA. Apart from the 2 weeks I’ve been on holiday I’ve also been working, preparing resources and interventions for my class for when I go back. So whilst I understand your frustrations, I think some degree of work in the summer is just part of the job.

surreygirl1987 · 01/09/2023 22:09

*A stressed and hardworking teen may really need the review. Why should they accept a mark lower than the one they worked hard for? I have had two friends’ kids get a review. Both recommended by school. One went up one grade and other two. Good for them and their school.

This is the paid job of the exam board. This is not what the OP is doing.*

Yes, we are talking about parents recalling papers and asking teachers to read them.

TheGander · 01/09/2023 22:09

Our school charges for re marking. It didn’t really occur to me to request it, I trust DS got the correct marks 1st time

surreygirl1987 · 01/09/2023 22:08

But exams are important to children - school spends 12 years telling them they are, so teachers can't turn around after GCSES and suddenly day they're not. And secondly, if I'd spent a year or more teaching people, I'd be quite invested in their results too.

Oh God. Yes of course we are 'invested' in their results, and care about the children, but I think parents/pupils forget that while these are the only GCSEs the pupils will ever sit, the teachers deal with this EVERY SINGLE YEAR. So as HoD, that's more than a hundred pupils getting exam results, every year in my case. Imagine that over, say, just 20 years of teaching. That's 2000 pupils. To each of them, their GCSE result is of absolute crucial importance. But to a HoD of 20 years, this is the 2000th pupil they've seen go through GCSE in their subject. 20 consecutive summer holidays with A THIRD given up (figure on 6 weeks holiday, and from A Level results day) to reading endless exam papers pupils have emailed in as they want another mark to get them over the grade boundary. Thousands upon thousands upon thousands of hours of family time spent in this way instead.

And of course pupils' GCSE results are important... but so are people's lives and families 🤦‍♀️ We give it our absolute all during term time, but clearly we should be giving it our all during our holidays too ...

And people are wondering why there is a recruitment and retention crisis, and moaning that their kids are not being taught by people with degrees in that subject...?!

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/09/2023 22:07

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 19:10

You are confusing parents paying the exam board to review the marking with teachers being asked to look at the paper and review the marking for free during their holiday to decide whether it is worth the parent paying for a review.

No I'm not. Dc has already had some scripts checked by her teachers. We were approached by them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread