Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to tell you reviewing your GCSE paper isn't "free"

393 replies

BorrowedThyme · 01/09/2023 17:45

I've never begrudged putting aside a few hours for genuine disappointing shock grades, or when a student has so nearly made the grade they need for their next stage.

But this year it has gone totally over the top.

And recalling GCSE papers for the school to review is NOT "free" - it just doesn't cost the parent anything, that is all. It relies either on teachers volunteering their spare time, or the school employing an additional, qualified person to do it.

I spent 25-30 hours in the last week of the holiday doing this, and now have a whole new list to somehow try and cram in to a single weekend

My head of department has already contacted some parents to say no, we are not doing it for such and such a student, and honestly, you would think we were chopping their kids hands off, or something, the abuse, and threats and accusations we get!

Some of the students we have said no to have already got their sixth form places, and don't need to check their grades, some are so far from the next grade up that they are many times more likely to go down than up, and some have got exactly what was predicted, anyway.

Occasionally a grade goes up, but it is very rare, and in genuine cases, I am happy to spend the time checking. Most of the cases we are getting requested now though, are not genuine! None of the papers I have checked this year are going up, although several might actual go down if the parents take it further.

So please, before expecting this service for the school, keep in mind

a) Is it necessary? Not if your child has got their sixth form place or apprenticeship, or whatever they wanted.

b) Is it likely? Parents often over estimate their children's likely GCSE grades, particularly if they have helped them revise, and marked a few mock papers, etc- children perform best in a one to one situation with a lot of encouragement, such as they might get at home with a parent, but this is not how they are assessed.

c) Somebody has to be just below the next grade boundary! That is how grade boundaries work!

d) Some grade bands are very narrow - being 3 marks off a 6 could actually be 2 marks from a 4.

e) It isn't a case of " just finding one more mark" - the marking has to be withing a tolerance. 2 examiners might mark the same paper differently, but that does not mean one is right and one is wrong. Yes, I find marks in the papers that I would have given that the examiner has not, but I also find marks the examiner has given that I would not, and overall, the mark comes out the same, or virtually the same. The grade is not going to be changed over a disagreement about fractions of marks. It needs to be a substantial difference for the grade to be changed, and not a case of strict or lenient marking.

Yes, it is sometimes worth having a look at the papers, no it is not worth this wholesale demand that has developed this year.

If this school review system continues to be abused, I expect it will be withdrawn very soon!

OP posts:
Abbimae · 02/09/2023 20:52

I refused to do this in holidays. I got sent quite a list whilst abroad and got told I had days to do the A level ones. I asked would I be paid overtime and pointed out I have no way to access on holiday. I basically Got called lazy. Very seldom do these new teacher reviewed papers get upped as tolerance on 6 markers for example is +- 1 so can vary a lot on a whole paper.

GottNoIdea · 02/09/2023 20:50

twelly · 02/09/2023 20:25

The reason why teachers in some cases need to be involved is that marks can go up and down - there is always a risk. If a paper goes straight to remark there is a risk the grade could be lower, also I believe as I have been told that you pay per paper so at A level so you would choose which paper out of the 3 or 2 papers in a subject which to go for first. This is why teachers need to be involved in some cases.

If the mark goes down they don’t give you the lower grade.

GottNoIdea · 02/09/2023 20:47

Each exam board has different prices, AQA GCSE for example is £40, but you will get refunded if the mark goes up. For Maths I wouldn’t do it if more than one grade, English I would say max of 2-3 grades.

grass321 · 02/09/2023 20:43

I believe as I have been told that you pay per paper so at A level so you would choose which paper out of the 3 or 2 papers in a subject which to go for first. This is why teachers need to be involved in some cases.

Our GCSE board for English is pay per paper. The teacher also pointed out that sequential reviews reduces the risk of one paper falling and offsetting the other if it rises. Plus the cost. She's advised which paper to go for first.

Whereas the History doesn't let you have a review if you view the papers first. Plus it has to be both papers reviewed so a slightly eye watering £150.

Jac1970stone · 02/09/2023 20:38

For me it’s a different matter this year though and that is that for Maths, my subject, the grades for GCSE are higher for grades 9-4 than at any other time for the current format (since 2017). This has had a major effect on many trying to get into college or sixth form and has no bearing on the fact that this cohort lost basically two years of solid education and are still bearing a huge brunt from covid. Yet colleges are not taking the rise in grade boundaries into account and devastating many young people. When you bear in mind the difference in the grade boundary for a six this year was 27 points higher than in November 2017, and a grade 5 was 20 points higher it is a ridiculous uplift that many students (and teachers) weren’t expecting.

to tell you reviewing your GCSE paper isn't "free"
twelly · 02/09/2023 20:25

GottNoIdea · 02/09/2023 19:59

I’m an exams officer in a school, I have no idea why teachers are getting involved in this…
There is no need, it is all done through the exams boards, if your grade goes up you get your money back.
Why involve the teachers, my daughter has just sat her GCSEs at another school and their process is the same. We have requested a remark of her maths as she is grade off a 9, you pay the fee online fill in the form and the EO sends it off to the exam board.

The reason why teachers in some cases need to be involved is that marks can go up and down - there is always a risk. If a paper goes straight to remark there is a risk the grade could be lower, also I believe as I have been told that you pay per paper so at A level so you would choose which paper out of the 3 or 2 papers in a subject which to go for first. This is why teachers need to be involved in some cases.

LookatEsa · 02/09/2023 20:25

GottNoIdea · 02/09/2023 19:59

I’m an exams officer in a school, I have no idea why teachers are getting involved in this…
There is no need, it is all done through the exams boards, if your grade goes up you get your money back.
Why involve the teachers, my daughter has just sat her GCSEs at another school and their process is the same. We have requested a remark of her maths as she is grade off a 9, you pay the fee online fill in the form and the EO sends it off to the exam board.

Is it expensive? If you aren’t well off would it be a lot to take a risk on? I tried Google but it brought different figures for a clerical or other re-mark.

GottNoIdea · 02/09/2023 19:59

I’m an exams officer in a school, I have no idea why teachers are getting involved in this…
There is no need, it is all done through the exams boards, if your grade goes up you get your money back.
Why involve the teachers, my daughter has just sat her GCSEs at another school and their process is the same. We have requested a remark of her maths as she is grade off a 9, you pay the fee online fill in the form and the EO sends it off to the exam board.

somethingischasingme · 02/09/2023 18:46

Dds school marked on the results which papers were close to a boundary and recommended a review. Each paper cost us £5 and it was the teacher of that subject who told us to do it. So the English teacher came to talk to us and told us she would look at the paper if we got it.

NotAMug · 02/09/2023 18:37

SomersetS · 02/09/2023 18:35

My DD missed out on a place at Med School because of a surprise A Level grade. We sent it back for a remark and they found 15 marks! 15!!! I’m still furious. We did sort it out but it took 12 months to regain a place. For some, the request really is valid.

That is awful, 15 marks is a huge amount. To be fair this isn't what OP is talking about, she is talking about those wanting to shift up a grade when 1 mark off. Of course hers needed to be remarked. How stressful for her.

NotAMug · 02/09/2023 18:35

needtofatoff · 02/09/2023 11:47

It is of equal importance ensuring that all students recieve the grade they deserve.

Arguably they deserve the grade they get on the day. Some kids may not perform on the day and get an 8 instead of a 9, based on previous work they deserved a 9 but may have been nervous and made a mistake, this has no real issue for most people for any career choice, even if when remarked they may have got the 9.

Those who don't perform on the day and get a 3 instead of a 4 means they don't get onto their college course. Whilst that is the correct thing for some, it may be that small margins of error mean that its worth getting remarked as they can then do their course.

My DS did not get all the grades he deserved due to a school error but that one subject won't matter ever to him so he wanted to leave it, several of his results were 1 off the next grade but that was how he performed that day, maybe another examiner would have marked him up or even down, who knows. I also think it's important to not allow children to believe that nothing but 9s across the board matter because in most cases they really don't.

SomersetS · 02/09/2023 18:35

My DD missed out on a place at Med School because of a surprise A Level grade. We sent it back for a remark and they found 15 marks! 15!!! I’m still furious. We did sort it out but it took 12 months to regain a place. For some, the request really is valid.

cantkeepawayforever · 02/09/2023 18:19

ClickAndCollecting · 02/09/2023 18:15

I just looked back at the email we were sent by school for A Level results last month. Luckily we didn’t need any remarking.

It said this:
The relevant Head of Department (not your individual teacher) should be your first port of call if you need advice about your examination marks and how these correspond to grades; they will also be able to offer you advice about whether submitting a paper for examination board review is a sensible idea.
If you are very close to the next grade threshold or if we suspect that your paper might have been poorly marked, we will very likely support a review of marking. If you receive a grade under what we predicted, it would certainly make sense to seek the Head of Department’s guidance’

It is quite vague but implies the school
will be actively involved from the start and supports reviews? It doesn’t talk about teachers doing this in their own time. I still don’t think parents are immediately the enemy here unless they are abusive.

That is almost word for word what my dc’s school sent out - from the years before seeing the paper before asking for a review was possible. So it may well be that schools are just recycling a process - and wording - from previous years without realising the excessive impact it now has on staff workload.

cantkeepawayforever · 02/09/2023 18:16

The teacher may automatically suggest a review for all marks within a certain distance of the borderline - may well not gave looked at the paper at all. I have had 2 papers for my dc reviewed over the years - both supported by staff - but in neither case did the teacher review the paper, just the marks.

ClickAndCollecting · 02/09/2023 18:15

I just looked back at the email we were sent by school for A Level results last month. Luckily we didn’t need any remarking.

It said this:
The relevant Head of Department (not your individual teacher) should be your first port of call if you need advice about your examination marks and how these correspond to grades; they will also be able to offer you advice about whether submitting a paper for examination board review is a sensible idea.
If you are very close to the next grade threshold or if we suspect that your paper might have been poorly marked, we will very likely support a review of marking. If you receive a grade under what we predicted, it would certainly make sense to seek the Head of Department’s guidance’

It is quite vague but implies the school
will be actively involved from the start and supports reviews? It doesn’t talk about teachers doing this in their own time. I still don’t think parents are immediately the enemy here unless they are abusive.

CM1897 · 02/09/2023 18:10

cantkeepawayforever · 02/09/2023 18:09

That has always been possible, and paid
for reviews are not the subject of this thread. It is asking the teacher to review the full paper in detail (not just look at the overall marks) to see if a review should be paid for, that is the issue.

The teacher just did it automatically. We must just be lucky

cantkeepawayforever · 02/09/2023 18:09

CM1897 · 02/09/2023 18:05

My daughter is having her English GCSE remarked at the recommendation of her teacher. She was 2 marks off of a 7. She doesn’t need a 7 but worked hard and wants it. There is a fee if the mark doesn’t change, it is free if her mark changes

That has always been possible, and paid
for reviews are not the subject of this thread. It is asking the teacher to review the full paper in detail (not just look at the overall marks) to see if a review should be paid for, that is the issue.

ShipSpace · 02/09/2023 18:07

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 02/09/2023 18:05

Point proven! Thank you!

Aw, bless

CM1897 · 02/09/2023 18:07

ShipSpace · 02/09/2023 17:59

They are absolutely not entitled to make their teachers work, unpaid during their holidays.

It’s not the student’s fault that teachers aren’t laid to do it though. Blame the school/government

cantkeepawayforever · 02/09/2023 18:06

Genuine question - did the system, when introduced, of being able to request scripts, intend for those scripts to be reviewed for parents by teachers?

Or did it intend that parents / students could request the scripts so that they could review them themselves?

So is it the system, or the way parents are choosing / being encouraged to use the system, the problem? I agree with @noblegiraffe back in 2018 and posted above that this was wholly foreseeable- but was it intentional or to an extent thoughtless?

CM1897 · 02/09/2023 18:05

My daughter is having her English GCSE remarked at the recommendation of her teacher. She was 2 marks off of a 7. She doesn’t need a 7 but worked hard and wants it. There is a fee if the mark doesn’t change, it is free if her mark changes

ClickAndCollecting · 02/09/2023 18:05

borntobequiet · 02/09/2023 17:55

making out the students are the problem for requesting something they are more than entitled to?

In what way are students entitled to make their teachers work, unpaid, in their holidays?

The students have been told they can ask for teachers to look at their exam scripts. Are you blaming them for asking?

I don’t think teachers should do it unpaid, but I don’t think you can blame students for asking. Calling them entitled is silly. All this ‘making the teachers work unpaid’ is just emotive language blaming kids, when the system should never have been introduced in the first place.

If you ask for a service that you have been told is provided, is that ‘entitled’?

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 02/09/2023 18:05

Point proven! Thank you!

ClickAndCollecting · 02/09/2023 18:01

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 02/09/2023 17:52

No you never said that in your post that I commented on! So no there is no apology as there was not one line in that post that mentioned that.

I am not so angry, I do not have to read all your posts at all I read your post perfectly well but you expect me to read all your posts about teachers?

No I am not being unreasonable to expect teachers to be paid for their work and to be treated with respect. Yes it is their fault, they are entirely responsible for their actions and if they threaten and abuse that is their fault.

Oh here we go with the 'this is how you communicate at work' crap! No we have to be polite and smile at people and take the punches and say nothing in return.

I said on the previous page that teachers should never be abused.
You on the next page accused me of not caring that teachers are abused.
Am I meant to repeat that like a mantra in every post?

Weird.

I reckon in a career in hospitals for thirty years I have experienced at least as much abuse as you have, if not more. I am still able to discuss the role and challenges without being rude to others. I believe that rudeness is not acceptable. Not from parents. Not online really either, but hey.

Plenty of teachers have discussed the unacceptable workload without being as unreasonable as you and one or two others. This new system has not been introduced by parents or students. It if didn’t exist then they would pay as previously happened

But do carry on calling people entitled just for using a system they have been advised exists.

ShipSpace · 02/09/2023 17:59

borntobequiet · 02/09/2023 17:55

making out the students are the problem for requesting something they are more than entitled to?

In what way are students entitled to make their teachers work, unpaid, in their holidays?

They are absolutely not entitled to make their teachers work, unpaid during their holidays.