Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to tell you reviewing your GCSE paper isn't "free"

393 replies

BorrowedThyme · 01/09/2023 17:45

I've never begrudged putting aside a few hours for genuine disappointing shock grades, or when a student has so nearly made the grade they need for their next stage.

But this year it has gone totally over the top.

And recalling GCSE papers for the school to review is NOT "free" - it just doesn't cost the parent anything, that is all. It relies either on teachers volunteering their spare time, or the school employing an additional, qualified person to do it.

I spent 25-30 hours in the last week of the holiday doing this, and now have a whole new list to somehow try and cram in to a single weekend

My head of department has already contacted some parents to say no, we are not doing it for such and such a student, and honestly, you would think we were chopping their kids hands off, or something, the abuse, and threats and accusations we get!

Some of the students we have said no to have already got their sixth form places, and don't need to check their grades, some are so far from the next grade up that they are many times more likely to go down than up, and some have got exactly what was predicted, anyway.

Occasionally a grade goes up, but it is very rare, and in genuine cases, I am happy to spend the time checking. Most of the cases we are getting requested now though, are not genuine! None of the papers I have checked this year are going up, although several might actual go down if the parents take it further.

So please, before expecting this service for the school, keep in mind

a) Is it necessary? Not if your child has got their sixth form place or apprenticeship, or whatever they wanted.

b) Is it likely? Parents often over estimate their children's likely GCSE grades, particularly if they have helped them revise, and marked a few mock papers, etc- children perform best in a one to one situation with a lot of encouragement, such as they might get at home with a parent, but this is not how they are assessed.

c) Somebody has to be just below the next grade boundary! That is how grade boundaries work!

d) Some grade bands are very narrow - being 3 marks off a 6 could actually be 2 marks from a 4.

e) It isn't a case of " just finding one more mark" - the marking has to be withing a tolerance. 2 examiners might mark the same paper differently, but that does not mean one is right and one is wrong. Yes, I find marks in the papers that I would have given that the examiner has not, but I also find marks the examiner has given that I would not, and overall, the mark comes out the same, or virtually the same. The grade is not going to be changed over a disagreement about fractions of marks. It needs to be a substantial difference for the grade to be changed, and not a case of strict or lenient marking.

Yes, it is sometimes worth having a look at the papers, no it is not worth this wholesale demand that has developed this year.

If this school review system continues to be abused, I expect it will be withdrawn very soon!

OP posts:
Piggywaspushed · 03/09/2023 11:42

Testina · 03/09/2023 11:19

Top end yes, between an 8 and a 9, but not a 4 and a 6!

Well, actually between a 7 and a 9 , there are very few marks. The 8 band is teeny. But, yes, not very important.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 03/09/2023 11:31

@BorrowedThyme ah. I see your point, and fair enough.

cocoloco117 · 03/09/2023 11:25

Hmmph · 01/09/2023 18:24

"when it's not important..."

I take issue with this as the parent of a perfectionist teen. You might not think it's important, but to Jon who has worked hard for 2-3 years on your subject and who was expecting to get a 7 and has just missed it they are absolutely gutted and it means so much to them.

I’d say little Jonny has learn a very important life lesson.

Testina · 03/09/2023 11:19

Top end yes, between an 8 and a 9, but not a 4 and a 6!

Piggywaspushed · 03/09/2023 11:09

Testina · 03/09/2023 10:45

Good luck with finishing it!

d) Some grade bands are very narrow - being 3 marks off a 6 could actually be 2 marks from a 4.

I’d still love to know what subject this is though! I’ve not seen anything so narrow.

Film studies has very narrow grade boundaries at the top end.

MrsHamlet · 03/09/2023 10:49

GottNoIdea · 02/09/2023 20:50

If the mark goes down they don’t give you the lower grade.

That's not true. There is no longer grade protection so it can go down and you still have to pay.

Testina · 03/09/2023 10:45

Good luck with finishing it!

d) Some grade bands are very narrow - being 3 marks off a 6 could actually be 2 marks from a 4.

I’d still love to know what subject this is though! I’ve not seen anything so narrow.

BorrowedThyme · 03/09/2023 10:29

Anyway, I worked through most of my list yesterday, and only a few more to go now, so I am hoping to finished by lunch time and then I can get on with what I am actually supposed to do this weekend - plan for next week!

OP posts:
BorrowedThyme · 03/09/2023 10:28

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 03/09/2023 10:19

I have sympathy with the OP, but this sentence (the latter part) is very wrong:

"None of the papers I have checked this year are going up, although several might actual go down if the parents take it further."

Do you mean putting down grades because the parents have annoyed you? I hope not. Hoping I've misread.

Not great you're having to use leave and not even be paid, though.

No, I mean that if the parents pay for the exam paper to be reviewed by the exam board, there is far more chance of the exam board putting the grade down rather than up.

I guess this is the whole crux of the issue - parents want us to check first, before they take that risk - although I could have told them their children had fair enough grades, without the hours of checking through the papers

OP posts:
Testina · 03/09/2023 10:26

@marmaladeandpeanutbutter if you hope you’ve misread, maybe re-read? Because yes, you did.

noblegiraffe · 03/09/2023 10:22

Do you mean putting down grades because the parents have annoyed you? I hope not. Hoping I've misread.

You've misread.

The OP has zero power to change grades.

Piggywaspushed · 03/09/2023 10:22

No! You are misunderstanding!

What she means is if they go to the exam board for an actual paid for 'review' the mark could go down. In spite of what a teacher might suggest.

I do think this thread, and the word 'review' in the title, has led to inordinate confusion...

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 03/09/2023 10:19

I have sympathy with the OP, but this sentence (the latter part) is very wrong:

"None of the papers I have checked this year are going up, although several might actual go down if the parents take it further."

Do you mean putting down grades because the parents have annoyed you? I hope not. Hoping I've misread.

Not great you're having to use leave and not even be paid, though.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 03/09/2023 10:06

When I was at school I was predicted an A* but got an A. The school requested the papers and turned out that the teacher forgot to teach us a part of the curriculum, so if nothing else it helped future years and the teacher.

BorrowedThyme · 03/09/2023 10:02

really, that is not what the thread is about, but please don't start on teachers terms and conditions - if you don't like yours, then become a teacher. Anybody is being accepted right now, you could be teaching within a year if you think its such a good deal

OP posts:
BorrowedThyme · 03/09/2023 10:01

ArthurChristmas22 · 03/09/2023 09:45

It is a true shame that a thread about exam paper reviews has dropped into a typical response of how hard done by teachers are.

I honestly think you need to review the private sector and other salaries. If you pro-rated your current salary to a 12 month equivalent and compared against other jobs, you would be very well off. You also get a 30% pension contribution (private sector averages about 5%) and 6months full pay sick leave.

For those of you asking what other jobs have to deal with the conditions you do, I work for a charity. I work about 30hr a week overtime unpaid, I get no sick leave pay, and my pension contributions are 4%. Oh, and 4 weeks holiday a year. When I worked in private corporate environment, I worked the same overtime unpaid, 4 weeks leave, 10% pension and sick leave. Whilst your salary may need adjusting, your benefits package overall is well above the private sector. Something needs to give.

Despite all these hours I work, never once have I not taken a call on the evening or weekend if my 'client base' has needed me (what an awful phrase). I'm about to take the only two days I have managed with my own children this whole summer, and my laptop is still coming away from me.

Thankfully, my own children's teachers have willing looked at DD paper and it is them that have suggested a remark, not me. I asked for a meeting when schools were reopened to discuss which subject my DD would drop. If you don't love your job anymore, why are you still doing it?

I absolutely do love my job - the teaching part of it, I absolutely do NOT get 6 months sick pay! and when I had cancer a few years ago I spent much of the year on no income at all, borrowing from friends and relatives while waiting for benefits application to be processed!

And every single one of my children has left university and been earning more than me WITHIN A WEEK! and had better terms and conditions as well!

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 03/09/2023 09:48

FFS.

ArthurChristmas22 · 03/09/2023 09:45

It is a true shame that a thread about exam paper reviews has dropped into a typical response of how hard done by teachers are.

I honestly think you need to review the private sector and other salaries. If you pro-rated your current salary to a 12 month equivalent and compared against other jobs, you would be very well off. You also get a 30% pension contribution (private sector averages about 5%) and 6months full pay sick leave.

For those of you asking what other jobs have to deal with the conditions you do, I work for a charity. I work about 30hr a week overtime unpaid, I get no sick leave pay, and my pension contributions are 4%. Oh, and 4 weeks holiday a year. When I worked in private corporate environment, I worked the same overtime unpaid, 4 weeks leave, 10% pension and sick leave. Whilst your salary may need adjusting, your benefits package overall is well above the private sector. Something needs to give.

Despite all these hours I work, never once have I not taken a call on the evening or weekend if my 'client base' has needed me (what an awful phrase). I'm about to take the only two days I have managed with my own children this whole summer, and my laptop is still coming away from me.

Thankfully, my own children's teachers have willing looked at DD paper and it is them that have suggested a remark, not me. I asked for a meeting when schools were reopened to discuss which subject my DD would drop. If you don't love your job anymore, why are you still doing it?

Piggywaspushed · 03/09/2023 09:37

Oh , OP, how I wish you'd made your title clearer!!

noblegiraffe · 03/09/2023 09:03

That's not the school remarking, that's the exam board. It's their paid job. Unlike the OP.

Mummamap · 03/09/2023 09:00

Our school will only remark if you are two marks below the next grade level. Each paper remarked is charged £50

EllasMami · 03/09/2023 08:53

Thank you for this thread! My daughter told me yesterday that she wants to have one of her GCSEs rechecked. She is one mark off the higher grade and it was the one subject she really cares about, loves and will now take to A level.
I will discourage her to address with her HoY tomorrow having read this. X

ilovechocolate07 · 03/09/2023 07:49

We were given a price list with ours for remarks. Some were close but it is what it is and it's gutting to be so close but that's what you got... close. Surely it would need to be marked by a third party and not the teachers.

spirit20 · 03/09/2023 04:43

I definitely think it's worth having an exam paper checked. As someone who marks GCSE exams for an exam board myself, I am very well aware of the issues that can happen. Especially this year, there was such a shortage of markers in some subjects that people with very little experience/subject knowledge etc. ended up being hired and rushed through training, so it's definitely not surprising that mistakes would happen, despite the exam boards efforts at quality assurance. I know very well that the same question can be given a very different mark depending on who marks it.

That said, as a teacher and Head of Faculty, I don't respond to emails asking for me to look at papers. When I am back at work on Monday, I will reply with a blanket email to all requests to simply tell them the procedure for paying for a review of marking from the exam board themselves. . If they choose to go ahead and do that, good luck to them, but I (or my team) won't be spending our time looking through papers to try and help them decide if it's worth it or not.

Even if I were willing to spend ages going through papers, it would be a waste of time anyway as ultimately it's what the exam board decide that counts and their opinion of what counts as a certain mark can be completely vary depending on who marks it.

But ultimately, I have enough work of my own and especially since the poor outcome of the strikes etc. I am doing absolutely no extra 'goodwill' work - if it' isn't important enough for the government to pay for, then it isn't important enough for me to do.

MibsXX · 03/09/2023 03:00

Actually here in wales they are charging for reviews of results.....

Swipe left for the next trending thread