Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to tell you reviewing your GCSE paper isn't "free"

393 replies

BorrowedThyme · 01/09/2023 17:45

I've never begrudged putting aside a few hours for genuine disappointing shock grades, or when a student has so nearly made the grade they need for their next stage.

But this year it has gone totally over the top.

And recalling GCSE papers for the school to review is NOT "free" - it just doesn't cost the parent anything, that is all. It relies either on teachers volunteering their spare time, or the school employing an additional, qualified person to do it.

I spent 25-30 hours in the last week of the holiday doing this, and now have a whole new list to somehow try and cram in to a single weekend

My head of department has already contacted some parents to say no, we are not doing it for such and such a student, and honestly, you would think we were chopping their kids hands off, or something, the abuse, and threats and accusations we get!

Some of the students we have said no to have already got their sixth form places, and don't need to check their grades, some are so far from the next grade up that they are many times more likely to go down than up, and some have got exactly what was predicted, anyway.

Occasionally a grade goes up, but it is very rare, and in genuine cases, I am happy to spend the time checking. Most of the cases we are getting requested now though, are not genuine! None of the papers I have checked this year are going up, although several might actual go down if the parents take it further.

So please, before expecting this service for the school, keep in mind

a) Is it necessary? Not if your child has got their sixth form place or apprenticeship, or whatever they wanted.

b) Is it likely? Parents often over estimate their children's likely GCSE grades, particularly if they have helped them revise, and marked a few mock papers, etc- children perform best in a one to one situation with a lot of encouragement, such as they might get at home with a parent, but this is not how they are assessed.

c) Somebody has to be just below the next grade boundary! That is how grade boundaries work!

d) Some grade bands are very narrow - being 3 marks off a 6 could actually be 2 marks from a 4.

e) It isn't a case of " just finding one more mark" - the marking has to be withing a tolerance. 2 examiners might mark the same paper differently, but that does not mean one is right and one is wrong. Yes, I find marks in the papers that I would have given that the examiner has not, but I also find marks the examiner has given that I would not, and overall, the mark comes out the same, or virtually the same. The grade is not going to be changed over a disagreement about fractions of marks. It needs to be a substantial difference for the grade to be changed, and not a case of strict or lenient marking.

Yes, it is sometimes worth having a look at the papers, no it is not worth this wholesale demand that has developed this year.

If this school review system continues to be abused, I expect it will be withdrawn very soon!

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 22:06

A stressed and hardworking teen may really need the review. Why should they accept a mark lower than the one they worked hard for? I have had two friends’ kids get a review. Both recommended by school. One went up one grade and other two. Good for them and their school.

This is the paid job of the exam board. This is not what the OP is doing.

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 22:05

twelly · 01/09/2023 21:58

I believe this was before then when the script could be ordered for a fee - so no, experienced professional teachers!

Even then you couldn't do it at A-level. It was remark or look at the paper.

I'm wondering why experienced, professional teachers had such a nightmare with exam marks that they routinely have swathes of kids who would pay to have their papers back then pay for a remark.

LookatEsa · 01/09/2023 22:02

I find the whole thing sad. I presume it isn’t an issue in areas with high deprivation because even if a teacher reviews and sees a big chance to improve the parent doesn’t have money upfront for the exam board. Do schools in these areas have any fund for this as it would also affect school stats

ClickAndCollecting · 01/09/2023 22:00

BorrowedThyme · 01/09/2023 18:28

Welcome to the real world Jon!

And why should I sacrifice my family time this weekend just to pander to someone's immaturity? You sound like you think I should! Can I just remind you that this is VOLUNTARY! and I have already done around 30 hours over the last week, and I don't have to do any of it.

I am afraid he would be one of the ones we turned down today. Sorry

Ugh your tone is really unpleasant.

Blame the system not the parents. They are taking the option offered. They don’t know the teacher is volunteering unpaid time. Why would they?

A stressed and hardworking teen may really need the review. Why should they accept a mark lower than the one they worked hard for? I have had two friends’ kids get a review. Both recommended by school. One went up one grade and other two. Good for them and their school.

Your sneering tone to kids and parents is just yuk. However tired and angry you are, there is no need for this.

And my kids didn’t need reviews so I have no skin in the game.

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 01/09/2023 21:58

Hmmph · 01/09/2023 21:42

No need to be so nasty. My school has not offered and I have not asked for any teachers to look at any papers. Nor am I telling anyone how to do their job.

But exams are important to children - school spends 12 years telling them they are, so teachers can't turn around after GCSES and suddenly day they're not. And secondly, if I'd spent a year or more teaching people, I'd be quite invested in their results too.

Ah but it is fine for you to be nasty though, right?

Yes you are! You are saying they should analyse the questions to see where to improve which is exactly what they do bloody do! This is already 'a thing' so no need to tell teachers to do this as it is routine for them!

I get they are important so stick your hand in your pocket if it is that important and pay for them to be remarked. You're invested in your child's results as they have yet to learn to deal with disappointment and that is a sore spot for you.

They are invested in their results they worked damn hard to get them there but that doesn't mean they work all their unpaid leave either too. Teachers are not public property to be flogged like slaves because of a sense of entitlement in parents who can't tell their darlings no.

SaySomethingMan · 01/09/2023 21:58

curaçao · 01/09/2023 21:57

I don't see why teachers are looking at the scripts. At my kids if you want a remark you tell the school and they send it ti the exam board and you are charged for it. I dont understand the point of the teachers remarking it when they aren't in a position to change anything.confused!

i don’t understand this either

twelly · 01/09/2023 21:58

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 21:56

Free access to marked scripts was introduced by Edexcel in 2017. They can't have been in the job long?

I believe this was before then when the script could be ordered for a fee - so no, experienced professional teachers!

uneffingbelievable · 01/09/2023 21:57

This year has been a little wild west - thankfully my DC did better than he would if teacher assisted grades -so no re-marks from me!

However, someone has to explain how 75+% in one subject can get you a 7/8 but in another subject get you a 5 - that is bonkers as has happened in drama across the country and I know the school is looking into it. DC has lost out on his chosen A level on this basis as he needed a 7- luckily taking a philosophical view on it but still rankles him.

SaySomethingMan · 01/09/2023 21:57

So parents can take their children’s papers for a remark at a cost to them, and you won’t have to do any work? Why not take this option then? Why continue to do something you’re not happy with doing when there’s an option for parents?

Divorced111 · 01/09/2023 21:57

I’ve just left my Exams Officer job. The number of students asking for scripts has definitely gone up, but so far we had only had about 6 students pay for reviews (only about 180 students in Year 11 and Year 13 put together).

Only a handful of teachers had had a look at scripts - but most were still away. The majority of students decide to pay for a review without a teacher having seen the script.

It does feel frantic this year - the higher grade boundaries have come as a shock and where I work(ed) teachers were predicting higher grades - significantly higher in some cases - than students have achieved and that has caused distress. This is especially true for GCSE.

But yes the whole system feels wrong - in so many ways. Not least JCQ being out of touch with who is available to do what and when in schools (and also how little power Exams Officers actually have being support staff, but that’s irrelevant to this thread).

It also feels bad that it costs money for a possibly improved grade - that not everyone can afford.

curaçao · 01/09/2023 21:57

BorrowedThyme · 01/09/2023 18:34

The "system" depends on volunteers and goodwill, like much in education

I don't see why teachers are looking at the scripts. At my kids if you want a remark you tell the school and they send it ti the exam board and you are charged for it. I dont understand the point of the teachers remarking it when they aren't in a position to change anything.confused!

surreygirl1987 · 01/09/2023 21:56

I was thinking this after seeing so many people suggesting remarks on MN. We never even thought about asking for that when I was at school. A grade was a grade.

Me too - didn't know there was an option of a second look of any sort!

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 21:56

twelly · 01/09/2023 21:47

I am afraid I disagree with you as I know of teachers who have told me they have always reviewed papers and view it as part of their job - in my view they are professional. As I said before for arts subjects the work load is even great - not so much for the less subjective subjects.

Free access to marked scripts was introduced by Edexcel in 2017. They can't have been in the job long?

surreygirl1987 · 01/09/2023 21:56

anyone else can either just go straight to a paid-for check or drop it?

Parents/pupils are worried that the marks might decrease in a review (and therefore they might get a lower grade). So many parents like a teacher to take a look first, to advise. I have told some parents I think the pupil was lucky to get the mark they did so would not recommend a review!

WhatsitWiggle · 01/09/2023 21:55

Lovetotravel123 · 01/09/2023 18:04

I was thinking this after seeing so many people suggesting remarks on MN. We never even thought about asking for that when I was at school. A grade was a grade.

Totally this! I missed my predicted grade A in A level Maths. It still upsets me 30 years later. But I had my place at Uni, it made no difference, except to my ego. No one, at school or at home, made any indication that reviewing the paper was possible. It was just one of those things.

Thelondonone · 01/09/2023 21:53

Yabu as you are getting involved in a marking process that has fuck all to do with you. It’s not a remark, it is a review of marking and as a teacher, not something I would touch with a barge pole. Scripts are free to look at but there is no way I would suggest I look at a paper to a parent. I am going to suggest to a couple of students (when I return in September) that I’d like to see their paper) and possibly ask my school to look at a ‘review of marking’. I would never suggest this to a child or I aren’t as they have to pay. I think that’s harsh’, parent spunks up £150 quid-no change in grade-I get it in the neck-no thanks…. No offence but more fool you.

Testina · 01/09/2023 21:53

“d) Some grade bands are very narrow - being 3 marks off a 6 could actually be 2 marks from a 4.”

😳 really?! I’ve looked at quite a few GCSE and L2 BTec grade boundaries recently due to a particular Facebook group I’m in and don’t remember seeing anything that close. That’s so narrow! What subject is that?

Clymene · 01/09/2023 21:53

MrsHamlet · 01/09/2023 21:45

@Clymene you're not wrong about that. It's the "x marks off" that is the issue.

Someone has to be, and reviewers don't know where the candidate sits or what they need and they're not looking for those marks anyway.

Ah okay, understood.

Saz12 · 01/09/2023 21:52

I'm not in England, and dc not at that stage yet. But surely teachers should be able to choose whose papers to review (ie, those who they are genuinely surprised about), and anyone else can either just go straight to a paid-for check or drop it?

WithOneLook · 01/09/2023 21:52

Hmm well, as a teacher myself I've always requested papers back for at least 50% of my cohort for a whole host of reasons and that's been ongoing for my whole teaching career (11 years to date).

It's not a new thing though. I insisted one of my a level papers was remarked (and paid for it but was subsequently refunded), even though my teacher said it was a waste of time, escalated it through the formal complaints procedures and they basically gave in to shut me up. I went from an E grade to an A garde. "Never known it to happen before" blah blah blah but it doesn't change the fact it did. No system is infallible and sometimes people just get it wrong.

surreygirl1987 · 01/09/2023 21:52

I spent 25-30 hours in the last week of the holiday doing this, and now have a whole new list to somehow try and cram in to a single weekend

Same! I'm HoD though and I'm trying to protect my department from unreasonable work (they should not be doing this in their holidays) so I'm doing it all... (I should not be doing this in my holidays either, or at least I should be paid for it, but if I don't I know there will be consequences!).

floribunda18 · 01/09/2023 21:52

My daughters re-marks cost nearly £300, of course they aren't free.

Digimoor · 01/09/2023 21:51

YABU - I've asked for 6 papers back for school review
The grades may not matter for 6th form but they will impact uni offers

Cubic · 01/09/2023 21:51

noblegiraffe · 01/09/2023 21:42

The lady I spoke with in the exam team said they like teachers to look at the papers first

I bet they do. Not them doing the looking though.

That is a fair point but there does also seem to be benefit to the teacher if their performance is linked at least in part to their students grade. Again this sits with the school not the parents as suggested by OP.

OvaHere · 01/09/2023 21:50

YANBU about the time and stress it's causing you but that's more the fault of this government than the kids or their parents. For both A level and GCSE in England the 'hard return' approach taken by England has caused a fair bit of upset.

It's all very well saying if they've got a college place it doesn't matter but in some cases it does.

I only just discovered this week that at degree level Glasgow School of Art requires a 7 in English Language GCSE so that rules out DS applying even though he got an 8 in Art, made his college place and may do really well at Art A Level.

He was too far off a 7 for it to be worth asking for a review but if he was very close I might do.

I understand your annoyance especially if your school hadn't anticipated this would happen, although I would argue it was very foreseeable especially after the similar upset with A Levels a week prior.

However aren't these ups and downs just part of teaching, same as ups and downs in a lot of jobs?

As a disclaimer - yes I do think teachers should be paid more like much of the public sector or at the very least overtime for situations such as this.