Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fucked off with my brothers?

32 replies

bigbluebag · 01/09/2023 17:07

Hi. I’m annoyed and fed up with my siblings but the frustration has been building up for a while and I’m genuinely unsure now if I’m being dramatic or unfair about it all now.

there’s a big age gap between my siblings and I. I’m the youngest by a big gap, so whilst I was still at home at school they were all living independently and working full time and well into their adult lives. Fast toward to now and I’m my 20s and they are in their 40s. I’ve always been close to my parents and siblings and we all get on well. But the age gap means my dad is significantly older than my friends dads so I can’t ask them for advice

my dads behaviour has changed- he’s always been slightly unaware and says the wrong stuff (nothing bad, can’t even think of an example but say we were in a restaurant he would loudly exclaim that the light is ugly looking - whereas everyone else would be thinking it but wouldn’t say it out loud, that sort of thing) but as he has got older he’s become more outspoken and so on. Unfortunately he has a strong family history of Alzheimer’s in 60s-70s and I sometimes wonder if these changes are normal age related changes or the start of something worse, but he won’t go to the doctor. He’s my dad so I’ll always have his back but it’s becoming increasingly difficult especially in public. For example we were out on a walk and walked past a garden that looked really unkempt and ugly and he loudly said ‘that garden looks awful doesn’t it!’ I know I sound like I’m making excuses because he’s my dad but he doesn’t mean to be hurtful but he can be sometimes 😫 He just seems to say what comes in his head.

I’ve asked my brothers SO MANY TIMES to speak to him and they agreed that he’s becoming increasingly embarrassing with his outspokenness but they never say anything. They’re close to my parents (live 1-2 hours away) whereas I live less than half an hour away so I see them more and I only just moved out of home too so they seem to be leaving it to me to deal with

The problem is, my dad now thinks I’m just being moany/baggy and he dismisses me saying oh that’s quite hurtful, you shouldn’t say that out loud etc and he dismisses it as me just nagging him and tells me to go away and drop it. He’s always been stubborn but again it seems to be getting worse. But when my brothers visit him, they too notice and agree that he’s behaving embarrassingly but they don’t do anything and for them it’s all like old chums, but they’re quite happy for me to be seen as the moaning/nagging/miserable one by our dad for me raising it

i haven’t used the best examples of things he does/says that’s embarrassing and ultimately I should just leave him to it, but he’s quite old now and I’m genuinely worried he will say something and someone will hear him and have a go at him especially as I’m certain this is the onset of Alzheimer’s as this is exactly how his brothers and sisters all started

I’m not trying to be moany and naggy but I feel so angry at my brothers that they’re happy to leave me to deal with it and they can take a backseat so they don’t ruin their relationship with him. Ironically enough, I’m sure he would believe them and wouldn’t think they were moaning or nagging him

sorry very long winded but AIBU to be upset and fed up and frankly quite fucked off at them for leaving me to try and deal with it all?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YukoandHiro · 02/09/2023 09:40

When I saw the title I absolutely knew this would be a parenting health/caring situation. So often men just abandon their responsibilities if there is a woman to mop up.

But in your circumstances your brothers are also of an age where they should be taking responsibility to let you enjoy the freedom of your 20s without any of these concerns.

Do you still live at home? If so, move out asap - you need to focus on your own life at this age.

Do your brothers live nearby? you've told them your worries, I would reiterate them again and then step completely back and focus on yourself right now

DisquietintheRanks · 02/09/2023 09:35

If your father has Alzheimers "saying something " will make not one jot of difference. So YABU about that.

If he doesn't have Alzheimers, it's not for you to try and edit his public image.

Have you read up about Alzheimers? Is he showing any symptoms?

Fwiw my father was embarrassing long before developing Alzheimers. So this might just be him.

Shelby2010 · 02/09/2023 09:28

My MIL had a sudden turn to this type of behaviour when previously she had been the kindest person. For her sadly it was Alzheimer’s.

There’s no point nagging because he won’t change - not even if one of your brothers pointed it out. He can’t.

  1. Find some gentle phrases like ‘That’s not a kind thing to say’, less that he’ll listen but more for the benefit of passers by, to dissociate yourself from the comments.
  2. If anyone one else pulls him up just say ‘Sorry, he can’t help it he has Alzheimer’s.’ (Doesn’t matter that he hasn’t yet been diagnosed, if you are ready to diffuse situations you will be less worried)
  3. Speak to his GP - they will be used to handling this type of situation. Your dad certainly won’t be the first elderly person who’s family have noticed a change in behaviour or personality.
bigbluebag · 01/09/2023 21:37

Lonicerax · 01/09/2023 20:29

Why do you go out with him - can you avoid that and just see him at home.
even if he was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s he would still be rude and not want to hear your corrections.

Yeah that’s a good point. We’ve just always been close and gone out and done family stuff and he really enjoys it so I suppose I’d be reluctant to stop but you’re right it might be best just to do things at home more often x

OP posts:
Lonicerax · 01/09/2023 20:29

Why do you go out with him - can you avoid that and just see him at home.
even if he was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s he would still be rude and not want to hear your corrections.

bigbluebag · 01/09/2023 20:15

BrawnWild · 01/09/2023 18:42

Not to scare you but in hindsight my parent got like this when they were very il.

I think you either need to insist again on a doctor appointment or phone his doctor yourself and say you know you cant force him in but you do have concerns and hope that they can consider your concerns at his next routine appointment (which he probably has for blood tests etc)

Honestly yeah, this is what I’m so worried about. In fairness this has been a change over the last while rather than a sudden change but it’s still worrying me. And because my friends parents are all significantly younger I don’t have any experiences to compare for what others are like at that age. I love my parents so much and I just want to protect them as much as I can x

OP posts:
bigbluebag · 01/09/2023 20:14

I’m not asking for social service intervention it’s just my brothers are idolised and I feel like myself and my mum are now just seen as naggers whereas if they just spoke to him and said something along the lines of hey best not to make personal comments about people in public then he would actually listen to them and not dismiss them straight away as being argumentative etc x

OP posts:
bigbluebag · 01/09/2023 20:13

Thanks for all the advice.

im just worried because I know what a great person he is but he doesn’t always come across like that. And I’m worried someone will pull him up for passing a comment or he’ll cause upset.

sorry but I completely disagree with the poster that said I need to be more compassionate to him! I’m trying my best to help him and protect him. I might be wrong for trying to make him change but his welfare has been at the forefront of my mind. There’s been a few times where he’s made quite harsh comments eg after I made my OP I took him to the shops and there was a large person in the shop and he turned to me and said ‘Jesus look at the size of that buffoon’ but he says it quietly so the person can’t hear him but other people around can. I can’t really remember other examples but that just happened 30 minutes ago. Honestly, he’s not a horrible person but he says things more and more that are very much on the boundary of outspoken and being flat out rude and hurtful. I just don’t want him to cause upset to anyone else but also to get into bother from anyone.

I don’t know what I want my brothers to do. I suppose I just want them to try and talk to him. In his older age they’ve become increasingly idolised so I’ve asked them to have a word with him and they say they will but then don’t. So he seems them as being old chums whereas I’m the one nagging and moaning at him and picking arguments. I’m not even being mean about it I’m just saying to him ‘hey it’s not the best to talk about people’s weight in public because it can be hurtful’ But he just says I’m nagging him and he seems to have this idea that I’m just an argumentative woman but honestly I don’t think I am (or maybe I am and I just don’t realise it)

OP posts:
JaneIntheBox · 01/09/2023 20:03

'Why' exactly do you have to 'deal' with anything? What do you expect your brothers to do?
Ultimately if he refuses to see a doctor none of you can make him. Being 'embarrassingly rude' won't qualify for social service intervention.
Unless you can get an authority figure of some sort to intervene there's nothing you can do until something drastic happens unfortunately.

WiddlinDiddlin · 01/09/2023 20:02

Stop nagging and moaning at him - it isn't going to change him, it isn't benefiting anyone.

I would speak to your siblings about what you all think you should do, but beyond that - theres a good chance even if they put pressure on him, he won't do anything but he will then feel worse about everything and not want to spend time with any of you. That is hardly going to help.

I do understand what it feels like - my Dad sounds exactly the same in some respects, but he isn't going to change, he can't - he was always a spoilt arsehole and now he is a really offensive spoilt arsehole. He has embraced old age as a green light to be vile to people if he feels like it, and all having a go at him achieves is him not speaking to us.

Shelby2010 · 01/09/2023 20:01

Could you speak to his GP about your concerns & ask them to call him in for a ‘routine check up’. There is medication that can sometimes help if it’s started early enough.

Also think about whether you need to get Powers of Attorney in place.

Lavender14 · 01/09/2023 19:55

I think you need to push it with your brothers to be honest. I think pps are correct that they may unconsciously (or consciously) be expecting you to take on the bulk of caring responsibilities due to being female and being closer geographically to your dad. So they may be just opting out because its easier.

I would speak to them again, say that you're worried about alzheimers and the big changes you see in your father and I would ask what they notice since they're visiting less often. If they agree and they say yes we notice it too I'd ask if they are concerned it could be the start of something like that, again if they say yes then I'd say I've done my bit to try and get him to the gp and it's affecting my relationship with him that I'm the only one encouraging him to go. Because it's only me he thinks I'm being unreasonable. So I need you both to step up and have a very direct chat with him and tell him he needs to go.

I would suggest that if your dad knows he has that family history he's probably scared of it and the idea of going to the gp might (in his mind) 'open a can of worms' when the reality is he'll either be reassured or it'll be picked up early.

I do think age makes people care less. My mum does things like that all the time and just doesn't give a toss what other people think about it anymore. Drives my sister and me crazy and it's embarrassing when you're out and about. I would drop it from your end and keep an eye. Maybe keep a note of things you find worrying and then in a month or two if you're still worried go back to your brothers with the things and maybe specific examples will gee them up? I hope he's just getting a bit sassy in his old age though. Caring for someone with alzheimers is a lot and you will need to be proactive in making sure your brothers are splitting his care 3 ways if it comes to that.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 01/09/2023 19:45

Unfortunately this does happen with many people as they get older OP. When my MIL was in her early 70's she used to say some really nasty outrageous things, and when challenged used to say 'If I cant' say what I like at my time of life, when can I?' She was perfectly aware of what she was saying, but for some reason no longer felt she had to hold back, like most of us do when we're younger. Personally, in your shoes, I'd enjoy what time you have with your DD, and as others have advised, don't get dragged into being a carer as time goes on, just because you're female.

jlpth · 01/09/2023 19:36

You have done your best - just ignore it from now on. If he says something embarrassing in public, hold your hand up and mouth sorry whilst he isn’t looking. Other than that, let him crack on. Neither he nor your brothers will listen, you’ve tried, so that’s the end of your responsibility imo.

junbean · 01/09/2023 19:35

What would happen if you didn’t nag him? His behavior isn’t my going to change. He’s getting older and that’s why he’s acting that way. He can’t help it. It’s a bit cruel actually to expect him to change, when it’s not in his control and you know it. You’re ruining the relationship, not your brothers and not your dad. Have some compassion and leave him be. If he embarrasses you in public, that’s on you. Everyone else would look at him like he’s an old man, that’s what old people tend to do.

Oigetoffmylawn · 01/09/2023 19:24

I'm sadly in the same boat OP.

My mum is displaying the very subtle personality changes that are indicative of the early stages of Alzheimer's (of which we have a strong family history). She just "more" - all her little personality quirks are now just that bit harsher, more common, very subtle but definitely there. And my siblings (all substantially younger in my case) are not seeing it/ taking me seriously.

I take heart in the fact that diagnosed now, or later won't change the outcome and have stopped beating he drum. I just watch out for more dangerous signs.

AgnesX · 01/09/2023 19:05

Where's your mother? Can't she say something?

stayathomer · 01/09/2023 19:00

It may not be Alzheimer’s op though, as all of my relatives have aged they’ve all become more like you say your dad is. I think we’re all going to get there, I’m only 43 and I’m definitely not the fun loving person I was even ten years ago!! My mum said once it’s a mixture of being more tired, sore and fed up, Because life has battered you about a bit, and also loving having the freedom of not having to consider your words!!! Saying that, you’re worried, so speak frankly to your brothers, maybe they’re just terrified of dealing with it x

WaitTheNoo · 01/09/2023 18:59

ultimately I should just leave him to it

☝🏻

diddl · 01/09/2023 18:55

What do you think that your brothers can say or do?

Perhaps they'd rather just enjoy their time with him?

Throckmorton · 01/09/2023 18:54

RhymesWithTangerine · 01/09/2023 18:37

This anger is completely misdirected. YABU.

Your brothers know that your DF is not going to change. There is literally NOTHING they can say that slows dementia or changes a stubborn old man.

They accept that, why can’t you? Is it because you need to believe there is a magic set of words that will solve the situation? There isn’t.

That sounds like you think there is no benefit in even diagnosing dementia? If so, you would be wrong

AppleKatie · 01/09/2023 18:53

My grandmother became increasingly outspoken and rude until well into her 90s when she did sadly die but never had a diagnosis of Alzheimer’s of indeed any significant loss of memory (beyond the kind of ‘normal’ getting muddled that is expected in advanced old age).

You don’t know it is Alzheimer’s, and if it is very sadly you can’t cure him so perhaps try and take the ‘does it matter’ approach. Love him for who he is and spend us much positive time together as you like. Be there for your mum IF she wants to talk, she will be better placed than you to know when he needs a doctor, trust her.

BrawnWild · 01/09/2023 18:42

Not to scare you but in hindsight my parent got like this when they were very il.

I think you either need to insist again on a doctor appointment or phone his doctor yourself and say you know you cant force him in but you do have concerns and hope that they can consider your concerns at his next routine appointment (which he probably has for blood tests etc)

RhymesWithTangerine · 01/09/2023 18:37

This anger is completely misdirected. YABU.

Your brothers know that your DF is not going to change. There is literally NOTHING they can say that slows dementia or changes a stubborn old man.

They accept that, why can’t you? Is it because you need to believe there is a magic set of words that will solve the situation? There isn’t.

Throckmorton · 01/09/2023 18:31

Can you raise your worries with your mum?