Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Village food competition

262 replies

Sweepies · 01/09/2023 14:14

This is mostly light-hearted, my village has a very large "show" every year with many tents, food vans, entertainment etc. They have the standard exhibitions you can enter, for photography, flower arranging, longest carrot, most attractive onion, etc.

I decided to enter one of the baking competitions with a friend to see if either one of us would place 1st, 2nd or 3rd. The prize for 1st place is £3! So all to play for as you can imagine.

The category was a baked item using ready made puff pastry, I decided to make a "posh" bacon and cheese turnover using some nice bacon, brie and cranberry - finished it off with sesame seeds. My friend made some kind of chorizo twist thing.

After entering it I noticed there we're probably about 15 entries in all, including a rival bacon and cheese turnover though it looked like something from Greggs - I wasn't too worried.

After judging was over and a couple of drinks we went to see the results, neither of us placed, and the bloody rival bacon and cheese turnovers won - but what really annoyed me was the judge hadn't tried a single thing!

Most (not all) items had been sliced in half once (??) but nothing tried. I assume they were sliced to see the quality of the pastry - but as we were told to use ready made pastry that seemed a bit redundant.

I thought okay fair enough, maybe the judge doesn't like puff pastry - but it was the same for every food item. The cake category, pies, salads, sandwiches, wraps - nothing was tasted, just cut in half once.

So Mrs. Judge wouldn't have known my posh pastry contained bloody expensive bacon, brie and cranberry as it never entered her mouth. This, to me, seems to go against the spirit of the competition. If I'd known it went on looks alone I'd have put a lot more effort into how it looked and not how it tasted.

All previous years, even after coming out of covid, at least a small portion of the food was tried, so maybe it's just the judge. Or maybe it's me, expecting too much from a cooking competition.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
CrazyCatLady13 · 01/09/2023 16:50

I got a commended one year and highly commended the next for flower arrangements in primary school 😁 I think they felt sorry for me, I didn't have oasis so used loo roll & the flowers were just from our garden, I think most of them were daisies 😁

2PintsOfCidernaBagofCrisps · 01/09/2023 16:44

Maybe the judge has read the Agatha Raisin book about the poisonous quiche that killed the judge at the village fair. Maybe they don't think it's worth the risk 😉

Autumn7 · 01/09/2023 16:41

Hehe sounds like The Archers.. yep I'd be annoyed too, waste of time and money

Autumn7 · 01/09/2023 16:39

harriethoyle · 01/09/2023 15:04

@AffIt I'm so sorry but that made me laugh - reminded me of the time I was overtaken by one inflatable boob in the finishing moments of a half marathon... 😝

🤣🤣you were robbed!

Cynicaltheorist · 01/09/2023 16:38

Sweepies · 01/09/2023 16:29

Messy and unprofessional, I call it rustic! And you can’t really tell from that photo, but their cheese to bacon ratio was all over the place.

I like your style, OP!

Prescottdanni123 · 01/09/2023 16:35

@BigOldBlue1

Country shows don't have massive money pots to draw from. It is meant to be a bit of fun anyway. Any village - even one with a close community - would turn into a war zone if the residents were competing for big money.

Sweepies · 01/09/2023 16:29

Bored1000 · 01/09/2023 16:12

To be fair, the aesthetic appearance of the winner is more pleasant than yours, the appearance of yours looks quite messy and unprofessional, the winner also has a more ‘golden’ look to the pastry so looks more appetising even if it isn’t

Messy and unprofessional, I call it rustic! And you can’t really tell from that photo, but their cheese to bacon ratio was all over the place.

OP posts:
DuesToTheDirt · 01/09/2023 16:27

Sweepies · 01/09/2023 14:40

Glad to see I'm not totally bonkers! And in answer to the comments about a fix; all the entrants names were supposedly hidden, so I think the judge just had a bit of an aversion to....well, judging. Here is a pic post slicing. The top most bacon and cheese turnovers won first place, the rather....well done....onion pie thing won second place. Apparently one slice is all it takes to judge the quality!

If it's done on looks, well that onion pie looks terrible. (Sorry, onion-pie-maker, if you're on here).

crosstalk · 01/09/2023 16:26

I was the beneficiary of village judging. In the village dog show (8 dogs, the ninth ran out of the ring to sort out the Best Rabbit competition) my fox terrier won best conformation, best sporting breed, best young handler (or rather my DD did), best in show AND waggiest tail. The judge was staying with the show organiser, her good friend. Who when not organising village shows bred fox terriers. My lap of honour was conducted in utter silence and friends didn't talk to me for at least two village film nights. Years later we all agreed it was better than the current dog show now the professionals have got their hands on it and come with dogs in special crates, beautifully shampooed and the handlers have Combs in their Pockets.

ButterRoad · 01/09/2023 16:21

AffIt · 01/09/2023 14:41

I was once up in the supreme of show at a local county show on my hunter (who went to HOYS) where all sections were judged together - cattle, sheep, horses and ponies, industrial etc.

We were all beaten by a bloody scone. I'm still bitter about it. 😄

That’s brilliant. I’m imagining your hunter refusing to be shown or jumped ever again, because of The All-Conquering Scone.

Blueberrycreampie · 01/09/2023 16:15

I never go to anything in mine or surrounding villages but this thread has made me want to seek out the next village show to check whether the entries are in face tasted by anyone. I never thought for one moment they wouldn't be!

Flumpaphone · 01/09/2023 16:14

I've been on the other side of this, I've been a judge (don't hate me!). Harrowing experience.

I was relatively new to the village and wandered down whilst the fete was being set up and thinking it would help me integrate into village life, asked if I could help with anything. Oh how green, how naive.

"Yes" said village grand dame "you could judge the junior Easter Bonnet competition" I wondered why she was smirking. They might as well have asked me to bring peace to the Middle East.

Oh reader, the bonnets were laid in front of me, but how to judge, the best looking? The most inventive? How many points to knock off for it being so obviously done by an adult? The pressure, the stress!

I was judging away and looked up to see a line of mothers with folded arms glaring at me.

I was clearly set up to take the fall and didn't dare go in the pub for a month.

Bored1000 · 01/09/2023 16:12

To be fair, the aesthetic appearance of the winner is more pleasant than yours, the appearance of yours looks quite messy and unprofessional, the winner also has a more ‘golden’ look to the pastry so looks more appetising even if it isn’t

Blueberrycreampie · 01/09/2023 16:11

@Cynicaltheorist Yes must have been some scone🤣

Confrontayshunme · 01/09/2023 16:11

Our church held a baking competition where the vicar judged but refused to taste anything. He didn't even cut them! People were livid that a weird gluten free lemon cake (that was two weeks old because the woman had made a Ukraine themed wedding cake for her DD which she wouldn't let anyone eat) covered with readymade fondant beat this amazing one which everyone ate and had homemade curd and the most delicious cake inside. The winner looked prettier, but it was just fondant and ribbon with silk flowers on top. It was mad.

If you are judging food, you have to taste

Blueberrycreampie · 01/09/2023 16:10

@Sweepies I have to say that looks amazing. I could certainly eat it right now!

Cynicaltheorist · 01/09/2023 16:10

Blueberrycreampie · 01/09/2023 16:06

That's hilarious!

And now I'm salivating and trying to imagine just how amazing that scone must have been if it was better than a HOYS hunter or a vintage Massey Ferguson tractor...

Blueberrycreampie · 01/09/2023 16:06

AffIt · 01/09/2023 14:41

I was once up in the supreme of show at a local county show on my hunter (who went to HOYS) where all sections were judged together - cattle, sheep, horses and ponies, industrial etc.

We were all beaten by a bloody scone. I'm still bitter about it. 😄

That's hilarious!

imed · 01/09/2023 16:04

Love this thread! Just the very best of Mumsnet Grin

unfaircake · 01/09/2023 15:57

In fact, I have a better story than my too big cake. a friend entered a home made from scratch cornish pastie. She was the only entrant and didn't win, how cruel, she was only about 15 too.

I do quite enjoy the pettiness in general, but also enjoy looking at how shit some things are, and having a laugh at the shit things that come before other things that look really good!

thecatsthecats · 01/09/2023 15:55

I'm still smarting from my 1996 second place in the Paint an Insect on a Stone contest.

Fifteen blotchy ladybirds or butterflies, versus my anatomically correct stone fly. Goddamn my parents for suggesting I do something "more unique".

Cynicaltheorist · 01/09/2023 15:55

AffIt · 01/09/2023 14:41

I was once up in the supreme of show at a local county show on my hunter (who went to HOYS) where all sections were judged together - cattle, sheep, horses and ponies, industrial etc.

We were all beaten by a bloody scone. I'm still bitter about it. 😄

Priceless. Thanks for making me laugh. Beaten by a scone...

VeronicaBeccabunga · 01/09/2023 15:52

I do <3 this thread.
I'm a townie, but I thoroughly enjoy the local agricultural show and our annual town horticultural society show.
I've always assumed that there was a secret handbook or similar in which all the esoteric rules and regulations were only made available to the locals.
For my own amusement I have often photographed entries and, better still, the judges comments, which are usually unreasonable 😂

Village food competition
Cynicaltheorist · 01/09/2023 15:51

You can't expect reason at these events, it's all about local politics. I had a friend who moved to Wales and decided to throw herself into village life by participating in the baking contest at the village show. Her entry for the 'Sweet Tart' competition was a lovely frangipane and pear tart. For the 'Savoury Teatime Treat' she made some luxury sausage rolls with chutney. The tart was rejected because, apparently, in that village a 'tart' meant an item with a pastry top. (Basically a pie: who knew?) Her fabulous big, on-trend sausage rolls were rejected because 'You serve chutney alongside your sausage roll, not inside it.'

She's lived there for a few years now and has entered each year and never won, even though she's a fabulous cook. It's not about the food, OP, it's about who you are — and if you're an incomer you could be as good as Nigella and you still wouldn't win.

rhino12345 · 01/09/2023 15:48

I'd start a riot