Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Village food competition

262 replies

Sweepies · 01/09/2023 14:14

This is mostly light-hearted, my village has a very large "show" every year with many tents, food vans, entertainment etc. They have the standard exhibitions you can enter, for photography, flower arranging, longest carrot, most attractive onion, etc.

I decided to enter one of the baking competitions with a friend to see if either one of us would place 1st, 2nd or 3rd. The prize for 1st place is £3! So all to play for as you can imagine.

The category was a baked item using ready made puff pastry, I decided to make a "posh" bacon and cheese turnover using some nice bacon, brie and cranberry - finished it off with sesame seeds. My friend made some kind of chorizo twist thing.

After entering it I noticed there we're probably about 15 entries in all, including a rival bacon and cheese turnover though it looked like something from Greggs - I wasn't too worried.

After judging was over and a couple of drinks we went to see the results, neither of us placed, and the bloody rival bacon and cheese turnovers won - but what really annoyed me was the judge hadn't tried a single thing!

Most (not all) items had been sliced in half once (??) but nothing tried. I assume they were sliced to see the quality of the pastry - but as we were told to use ready made pastry that seemed a bit redundant.

I thought okay fair enough, maybe the judge doesn't like puff pastry - but it was the same for every food item. The cake category, pies, salads, sandwiches, wraps - nothing was tasted, just cut in half once.

So Mrs. Judge wouldn't have known my posh pastry contained bloody expensive bacon, brie and cranberry as it never entered her mouth. This, to me, seems to go against the spirit of the competition. If I'd known it went on looks alone I'd have put a lot more effort into how it looked and not how it tasted.

All previous years, even after coming out of covid, at least a small portion of the food was tried, so maybe it's just the judge. Or maybe it's me, expecting too much from a cooking competition.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
ifIwerenotanandroid · 02/09/2023 17:57

JudgeJ · 02/09/2023 13:43

Not a tale from the fete but the pub quiz, when we'd just moved into the village we went into the pub on quiz night and decided to enter. We won first prize and it wasn't a popular victory although we were asked to join a few teams, a bit like Harry Kane!

DH & I decided to try our luck at the weekly quiz in a local pub. On the 3rd or 4th week, we won - to be met with a frosty silence & a bad atmosphere. We announced that we would be donating our winnings to the pub's favourite charity, & normality was restored. I'm not sure we would've got out alive otherwise.

5foot5 · 02/09/2023 17:37

Sinamin · 02/09/2023 14:01

It's not hilarious, it's a fucking outrage.

I was purely explaining the whys and wherefores of proper judging so I don't understand your nasty attitude to me.

Did you miss my decorated wellie and heaviest turnip post? If you really feel the need to be randomly nasty please do it on another thread because apart from your contribution this thread is utterly lovely.

Well I thought your explanation was interesting and a useful contribution to a highly entertaining thread.

My favourite AIBU thread in a long time.

5foot5 · 02/09/2023 17:25

feralunderclass · 02/09/2023 15:15

Not a village as such but our small town church used to do an annual fete where one of the competitions was 'nicest baby'. At the end the judges would go around telling the mothers why their babies didn't win, such as his eyes are too close together, his head is too big for his body type of thing.

Our village fête used to have bonniest baby competition until the early 1970s. Then it was felt that maybe this wasn't the best idea. I think it was my Dad pointed out "Every mother thinks her baby is the bonniest."

So they changed the competition to bonniest mother and baby. As if this made it any better!

Ormally · 02/09/2023 17:16

I read this thread backwards. Lost it at "Nice big raspberries, a little dense, not dusted with icing sugar."

Please, please, don't forget to take and add more photos of similar comment cards for the next shows you go to.

Stayfreshcheesebag · 02/09/2023 16:45

Oh my word - I am official county cheese scone queen. 18 entries!! £5 top prize money.

No need to mention the other classes I entered...nothing to see there.

Village food competition
feralunderclass · 02/09/2023 16:00

ButterRoad · 02/09/2023 15:49

And no one went after them with pitchforks, shouting ‘My Lily-Mae is PERFECT, you wonky-eyed Jesus freaks!’?

No weirdly no one seemed to mind, but even as a 10 year old I felt very uncomfortable when the critique started.

ButterRoad · 02/09/2023 15:49

feralunderclass · 02/09/2023 15:41

The minister's wife and Sunday school teachers 🤣

And no one went after them with pitchforks, shouting ‘My Lily-Mae is PERFECT, you wonky-eyed Jesus freaks!’?

feralunderclass · 02/09/2023 15:41

ButterRoad · 02/09/2023 15:32

Who were the judges???

The minister's wife and Sunday school teachers 🤣

ButterRoad · 02/09/2023 15:32

feralunderclass · 02/09/2023 15:15

Not a village as such but our small town church used to do an annual fete where one of the competitions was 'nicest baby'. At the end the judges would go around telling the mothers why their babies didn't win, such as his eyes are too close together, his head is too big for his body type of thing.

Who were the judges???

ButterRoad · 02/09/2023 15:32

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/09/2023 14:15

Purely because of this thread I just popped into our village produce show - mainly veg but a few home baking classes as well

Nothing really exciting to report, but the atmosphere in there was poisonous with tight-lipped glares all round ... sounds like another which should feature on here, if only I knew the inside story

Well, go back and do some research. Bring a notebook and claim to work for the local paper and are following up rumours of foul play and brown envelopes for ‘Bonniest Baby’ or ‘Largest Marrow’. Say all sources will be anonymous.

feralunderclass · 02/09/2023 15:15

Not a village as such but our small town church used to do an annual fete where one of the competitions was 'nicest baby'. At the end the judges would go around telling the mothers why their babies didn't win, such as his eyes are too close together, his head is too big for his body type of thing.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/09/2023 14:15

Purely because of this thread I just popped into our village produce show - mainly veg but a few home baking classes as well

Nothing really exciting to report, but the atmosphere in there was poisonous with tight-lipped glares all round ... sounds like another which should feature on here, if only I knew the inside story

Sinamin · 02/09/2023 14:01

gelatogina · 02/09/2023 07:47

Yes you definitely won the dullest post on the thread. No need to suck all the fun out of the hilarious fact a horse lost to a scone.

It's not hilarious, it's a fucking outrage.

I was purely explaining the whys and wherefores of proper judging so I don't understand your nasty attitude to me.

Did you miss my decorated wellie and heaviest turnip post? If you really feel the need to be randomly nasty please do it on another thread because apart from your contribution this thread is utterly lovely.

Vitriolinsanity · 02/09/2023 14:00

HOTY vs Scone. Scone wins.

How is that even plausible, except in a Village Fair?

Anotherchristianmama · 02/09/2023 13:44

Tom Barnaby will be along shortly

JudgeJ · 02/09/2023 13:43

ElizabethBest · 02/09/2023 00:31

I had never lived in rural England until about a decade ago when we moved to a little village on the South Coast. My husband, on the other hand, grew up in a small village. He BEGGED me not to enter a cake into the village show our first year. I thought it would seem like poor form not to take part. How wrong I was! My fraisier cake won first prize and if looks could kill I’d have dropped dead on the spot. A decade later and there are STILL people who pointedly snub me at village events. DH has really enjoyed his 10 years of “I told you so”! Grin

Not a tale from the fete but the pub quiz, when we'd just moved into the village we went into the pub on quiz night and decided to enter. We won first prize and it wasn't a popular victory although we were asked to join a few teams, a bit like Harry Kane!

JudgeJ · 02/09/2023 13:38

If you want strict judging better join the WI, they have a rule book for county shoes etc. And there is most definitely tasting of food entries.

Really? The chocolate cake recipe I referred to up thread was from the WI and it was the WI judge who decided than the 'winner' was the only entry that differed from all the rest.

JudgeJ · 02/09/2023 13:30

This was 1970s and the latest fad in handwriting was italics.

Sounds like Ruth Fagg, I used to love it but it was quite hard to learn.

StefanosHill · 02/09/2023 13:22

Vitriolinsanity · 02/09/2023 13:21

Was the winner either a) head of the WI b) head of the PTA?

I came 2nd with my chicken liver pate. It was cut-throat, but I won a rose bush.

Less pressure in the Masterchef final.

Less pressure in the Masterchef final.

ha ha

Vitriolinsanity · 02/09/2023 13:21

Was the winner either a) head of the WI b) head of the PTA?

I came 2nd with my chicken liver pate. It was cut-throat, but I won a rose bush.

Less pressure in the Masterchef final.

JudgeJ · 02/09/2023 13:20

I'd be more pissed off at the bullshit first prize. 3 fuckin quid??!

You get monetary prizes??? Rosettes only for us!

JudgeJ · 02/09/2023 13:17

Sweepies · 01/09/2023 14:14

This is mostly light-hearted, my village has a very large "show" every year with many tents, food vans, entertainment etc. They have the standard exhibitions you can enter, for photography, flower arranging, longest carrot, most attractive onion, etc.

I decided to enter one of the baking competitions with a friend to see if either one of us would place 1st, 2nd or 3rd. The prize for 1st place is £3! So all to play for as you can imagine.

The category was a baked item using ready made puff pastry, I decided to make a "posh" bacon and cheese turnover using some nice bacon, brie and cranberry - finished it off with sesame seeds. My friend made some kind of chorizo twist thing.

After entering it I noticed there we're probably about 15 entries in all, including a rival bacon and cheese turnover though it looked like something from Greggs - I wasn't too worried.

After judging was over and a couple of drinks we went to see the results, neither of us placed, and the bloody rival bacon and cheese turnovers won - but what really annoyed me was the judge hadn't tried a single thing!

Most (not all) items had been sliced in half once (??) but nothing tried. I assume they were sliced to see the quality of the pastry - but as we were told to use ready made pastry that seemed a bit redundant.

I thought okay fair enough, maybe the judge doesn't like puff pastry - but it was the same for every food item. The cake category, pies, salads, sandwiches, wraps - nothing was tasted, just cut in half once.

So Mrs. Judge wouldn't have known my posh pastry contained bloody expensive bacon, brie and cranberry as it never entered her mouth. This, to me, seems to go against the spirit of the competition. If I'd known it went on looks alone I'd have put a lot more effort into how it looked and not how it tasted.

All previous years, even after coming out of covid, at least a small portion of the food was tried, so maybe it's just the judge. Or maybe it's me, expecting too much from a cooking competition.

So, AIBU?

Our village fete had a Gentlemen's Baking section, apparently not now allowed in these 'enlightened' days, and my late OH had won the year before for his lemon drizzle cake, following the official recipe. The next year they were given a recipe for a chocolate cake, his first couple of efforts came out looking cracked and dry but as his friends said their efforts looked the same her entered one of them. On the day all the entries bar one looked much the same, the odd one looked fresh out of an M and S box and no prizes for guessing which one won!

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 02/09/2023 13:09

My oldest dc refused to do cooking at gcse after the teacher gave her a lower mark than her friend for a similar reason.
Apparently hers "looked better'.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 02/09/2023 13:04

BeatenByAScone · 02/09/2023 11:08

Since you've brought up the 'acrylic versus wool' I'm preparing myself for further indignance when I pop along in about an hour to see how my beret has done. It's knitted in a very lovely 100% British wool yarn, dyed in-house by the vendor. The knitted dolls in the same class are of course knitted in garish acrylic yarns.

Can we have a photo of the beret, please? Love a bit of good knitting. Hope you've won!

Sometimes you can lose by being too good. I put craft items into a very strictly run local market. My painted flowers were disallowed because 'another lady already does dried flowers, so you can't do dried flowers as well'. Nice to know my painting is so realistic. I argued my case but they wouldn't budge. I guess they wouldn't believe the flowers were painted.

And once, for the Open Gardens Day teas in the village hall, I made some cupcakes with prefect swirly frosting & bought exquisite garden-themed decorations to sit on the frosting. (I'd just learnt how to make these then-fashionable cupcakes so was very enthusiastic & careful to get them just right). All the visitors refused to buy one on the grounds that they were so perfect they were obviously shop-bought!

ifIwerenotanandroid · 02/09/2023 12:51

Something upthread reminded me of another flower arranging incident. The class title: 'A Study in Yellow'. Spring show, so lots of entries with yellow daffodils etc. What won? The only non-yellow entry - three bright orange gerbera just stuck in a vase.

Judged by the 6-legged spider woman, of course. She was the only judge they ever used.