Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Village food competition

262 replies

Sweepies · 01/09/2023 14:14

This is mostly light-hearted, my village has a very large "show" every year with many tents, food vans, entertainment etc. They have the standard exhibitions you can enter, for photography, flower arranging, longest carrot, most attractive onion, etc.

I decided to enter one of the baking competitions with a friend to see if either one of us would place 1st, 2nd or 3rd. The prize for 1st place is £3! So all to play for as you can imagine.

The category was a baked item using ready made puff pastry, I decided to make a "posh" bacon and cheese turnover using some nice bacon, brie and cranberry - finished it off with sesame seeds. My friend made some kind of chorizo twist thing.

After entering it I noticed there we're probably about 15 entries in all, including a rival bacon and cheese turnover though it looked like something from Greggs - I wasn't too worried.

After judging was over and a couple of drinks we went to see the results, neither of us placed, and the bloody rival bacon and cheese turnovers won - but what really annoyed me was the judge hadn't tried a single thing!

Most (not all) items had been sliced in half once (??) but nothing tried. I assume they were sliced to see the quality of the pastry - but as we were told to use ready made pastry that seemed a bit redundant.

I thought okay fair enough, maybe the judge doesn't like puff pastry - but it was the same for every food item. The cake category, pies, salads, sandwiches, wraps - nothing was tasted, just cut in half once.

So Mrs. Judge wouldn't have known my posh pastry contained bloody expensive bacon, brie and cranberry as it never entered her mouth. This, to me, seems to go against the spirit of the competition. If I'd known it went on looks alone I'd have put a lot more effort into how it looked and not how it tasted.

All previous years, even after coming out of covid, at least a small portion of the food was tried, so maybe it's just the judge. Or maybe it's me, expecting too much from a cooking competition.

So, AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
16
AllTheAll · 14/09/2023 15:48

That explains so much! If they're to be sold, then yes you don't want a slice taken out by a judge.

But judges should actually taste food items to properly judge! What a conundrum at the Village! What a scandal there would be if first went to Pamela Shrewsbury for her beautiful sherry trifle. Marjorie Hammersworth bought it and discovered that it was made with shave cream!

Updates at 4 as we head to the village pub for the final battle!

mindutopia · 13/09/2023 10:35

This is actually pretty standard - which is odd. I do a lot of village shows as I'm a bit of a competitive cook/gardener. Most of the time, no one eats them. Even the winning ones look rubbish sometimes, so if it's not taste, I can't imagine what they are basing the decision on, other than bake, but that doesn't look amazing either.

MsSquiz · 13/09/2023 10:24

@AllTheAll the food entries we considered donations for people to then buy so they could raise money from it

PuttingDownRoots · 13/09/2023 07:59

At ours you wmeuther collect by a certain time or they go in the auction.

A giant marrow sold for over a hundred pounds!

VenusClapTrap · 13/09/2023 07:55

Normally yes, you collect your entries at the end and take them home. Not sure why pp had to buy it, unless they are automatically considered donations to the tea and cake tent at their show, or something.

AllTheAll · 12/09/2023 18:07

MsSquiz · 10/09/2023 14:52

I will never get over my SIL's village fete when I made the most amazing Victoria sponge cake for the competition, arrived 5 mins before we were told the competition closed, to find out we were "too late for judging" and they had judged early!

I was furious! So furious that my MIL ended up buying my full cake for us to take up to eat because I refused to pay them any money for it!

I haven't entered since and it happened in 2018!

Wait- you don't just take your entry back home? You have to buy it?

JamMakingWannaBe · 11/09/2023 21:18

My daughter won a trophy for "Best Overall Exhibit" in the junior section this weekend. Very proud parents. My entries won naff all!

Lisdeflores · 11/09/2023 20:51

@VenusClapTrap brilliant post and as crazy as they are they are part of what makes a local community. I love entering our local show ,although I remain bitter about my chutney being disqualified this year!

VenusClapTrap · 11/09/2023 13:52

I almost don’t dare post this, but I’m the Show Secretary for our village show, for my sins (never volunteer to ‘lend a hand’ by the way; before you know it that will be interpreted as quite literally ‘running the show’ as the previous Show Secretary runs for the hills cackling manically).

Shows bring out the crazy in everybody. It’s glorious. From the monthly committee meetings (think Vicar of Dibley) which are a seething hotbed of arguments about typography and the perennial question of “what are we going to do about the judges”, to the allegations of fixing, brutal disqualifications and judges notes, and recriminations about Nicola’s dog eating an unattended crystallised fruit entry and getting the shits behind the marquee. It’s all bonkers.

The judging is honestly anonymous though. I promise! Or it is in our village anyway - I steward the judging and whilst I often disagree heartily with their ‘eccentric’ decisions, they do spend years training to be a judge and take it very, very seriously. Sadly they are literally a dying breed (horticultural ones anyway). Ours are in their nineties. Go to, enter and enjoy your shows now while you can; Village horticultural societies are closing every years due to the lack of judges and difficulty recruiting volunteers to organise the shows. So actually, ignore my first paragraph about not offering to lend a hand - please do! It’s mad but it’s lots of fun, as this thread demonstrates.

My3dahliasarebloominlovely · 10/09/2023 16:26

@Sweepies I must say that your turnovers look cowing lush as we say in south Wales

EvilElsa · 10/09/2023 15:44

There are hunter classes in showing. So the OP will have a show hunter of a particular weight (flat class) or a working hunter (jumping class). It's not a breed, it's a type. The OP referred to her horse as a hunter as this is the class he will have competed it.

MsSquiz · 10/09/2023 14:52

I will never get over my SIL's village fete when I made the most amazing Victoria sponge cake for the competition, arrived 5 mins before we were told the competition closed, to find out we were "too late for judging" and they had judged early!

I was furious! So furious that my MIL ended up buying my full cake for us to take up to eat because I refused to pay them any money for it!

I haven't entered since and it happened in 2018!

tameimpalas · 10/09/2023 14:17

Brilliant…still making me laugh now

Pliudev · 10/09/2023 13:53

I entered my three Yr old DS in the under 5s fancy dress competition at our village fete. He went as a bee and I made him a padded stripey body with sting and black hat with feelers. We were beaten by Hansel and Gretel who were wearing green shorts and t shirts. It was 40 years ago and the judge claims not to remember, but I do.

BlodynYGog · 10/09/2023 13:33

I was overtaken in the last 200m of the Cardiff Half by a man dressed as a giant peanut. She shame still burns.

cassie2and2 · 10/09/2023 12:20

cor where is that fireplace, I found one in a thrift shop with with gold embroidery a load of latin writing a crown and Balmoral on it

cassie2and2 · 10/09/2023 11:35

funny things around judging -- the table of bakes where a nibble had been taken out of each entry apart from one where there were a few crumbs and couple pieces of quiche arranged in a v sign left on the plate. The beautiful schnauzer that was disqualified after the Barbara Woodhouse type judge handled him a bit rough round his nether regions and he turned around and nipped her

Spotsmum · 10/09/2023 10:44

Hunter? Isn't it a horse?

Lollipopsicle · 10/09/2023 10:10

Definitely! Damn it!

Lollipopsicle · 10/09/2023 10:09

BeatenByAScone · 02/09/2023 18:31

Perhaps I need another name change to BeatenByAnAcrylicBlanket, but... my beret came second!

In all fairness to the judge, there was such a wide range of entries that it must have been very difficult to choose.

First prize went to the white crocheted blanket, and third to the blue crocheted octopus.

Oh, the detail in your beret though. Definition should have got 1st!

Lollipopsicle · 10/09/2023 09:13

OnionTarteDisaster · 02/09/2023 07:51

Definitely me! This is the photo I sent to my friends in the dizzying excitement of coming 3rd and winning a whole £1. Little did I know it would all come crashing down just a short week later 😂

It did taste great though!

Yep, definitely burnt and not caramelised! 😂

SingingKlingon · 06/09/2023 12:06

What a great thread! I love a thread where the person being mentioned joins the thread!

This definitely deserves to be in classics!

I want to know if the two of you meet up in the pub!!

SonicStars · 05/09/2023 11:55

I'd love to win a ferret.
I'm now thinking about the possible ways to cheat a win in the heaviest turnip contest. I presume they'll cut them open to reveal any lead hidden inside so I need something that looks and cuts like turnip but is denser.

Maybe a swede in a turnip skin??

S4mJune · 05/09/2023 07:25

I got 2 firsts in our village show and the prize for a first was 50p 😊 It cost me £1 to enter so I just got my money back. It was still really fun.

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 05/09/2023 07:00

1mabon · 04/09/2023 19:17

Get over it, if that's all you have to moan about you're extremely fortunate.

Have you lost anything? Like your sense of humour?