Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surprised at how I was treated in a&e

264 replies

broken86 · 01/09/2023 13:55

This has been playing on my mind for the last week and I just wondered if it was me being sensitive or not.

Last week I had an accident and it was obvious right away that I'd done something to my ankle, I threw up and almost passed out from the pain (which isn't like me, I'd say I've a very high pain threshold and not a drama Queen) I'd never felt pain like it even not giving birth.

Dh ran me to a&e and helped me to a seat and checked me in at the desk. I then told him to leave as there were signs all over saying no one could wait with you.

I felt pretty self conscious and exposed in the waiting room sat with only one shoe on and one bare foot. My leg had really swollen and I was obviously in a lot of pain and while it could just be paranoia I felt a lot of people were just staring at me.

The worst part was when I got called into triage, I couldn't put weight on my sore foot so had to pull myself up using the chair in front then somehow hobble all the way across the room to the triage area. The nurse waiting for me stood leaning on the door frame looking bored out her head at having to wait longer for me and everyone in the waiting room just stared at me struggling Confused

At one point I felt there's no way I can do this but it was such an unfriendly atmosphere I didn't even feel I could ask for help. Once I made it into the triage room and sat down the tears were pouring down my face due to the pain, The nurse didn't even look in my direction just asked me questions and typed into the computer before telling me to go to minor injuries and pointing to an area at the end of the corridor.

Once again I had to struggle down by myself, part of me wanted to ask for a wheelchair but awkwardly thought the nurse must think I'm being a wimp or else she would have offered. I had to support my weight on the handrail all the way down with everyone in the waiting room just starting at me again.

Once I was in minor injuries it was a totally different experience, they couldn't have been nicer getting me pain killers etc Turns out my ankle is broken and I've damaged the ligaments and am now off work and not able to drive etc for the next few weeks which is a total pain but can't be helped.

The total lack of any kind of human kindness in a&e still plays on my mind though, obviously a room full of people at a&e aren't going to be in the best form but a lot of people had ignored the "no family waiting" signs and were sat happily chatting away to each other. I couldn't imagine myself being there keeping someone company and not offering to help someone who was obviously in a lot of pain to cross a room, likewise I couldn't imagine a nurse in a&e not acknowledging when someone is in pain or even just giving them a friendly smile etc.

Obviously I'm grateful for the care I've received so far and that I will need going forward but was just wondering (while Sat with my foot up) if this is what people would expect in a&e?

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 01/09/2023 15:08

plehpleh · 01/09/2023 14:13

I hope you feel better soon and I'm glad minor injuries were kind to you.

It's sad but I've experienced the same. Not trying to make excuses but I think the staff are spread too thin and are in sort of survival mode, which can rob them of their compassion. I think with all the stuff about the NHS in the news recently as well, morale is low. Not an excuse, but maybe an explanation.

I worked in a hospital for 6 years. I remember when I started I cried a lot in the toilets about things I'd seen and had to help with (you're only human after all). By the end of my six years I was disgusted with myself for how detached I had become when around horrific situations. But it was a coping mechanism. I got out and am pleased to say I feel I fully have my compassion back but it was scary how desensitised the environment makes you, almost like being in a war zone. If you're not the kind of person who can find healthy ways of handling that while maintaining your compassion, it can really affect you and I think a lot of people, like me, detach for the sake of their own mental health.

Speedy recovery to you ❤️‍🩹

I've often thought this could be the case with some people, that they just can't manage the pressure combined with being compassionate. I had a horrible midwife once who made me feel awful after a bad ventouse delivery when I was in pain aftewards and worried about going to the toilet. Zero patience, actually sighed, looked almost aggressive, came back with a catheter and said "well if you refuse to try you'll just have to have this put in". Made me feel like shit.

A second different midwife was clearly under the same level of pressure but had a totally different approach, and I was asking her about it ie. having to do overtime etc, barely getting enough rest before coming back to work. It's the words and approach they both chose, it couldn't have been more different and actually the first miserable midwife who huffed and puffed spent more time faffing going to get a catheter than if she'd acted like the second midwife and kindly explained what was normal and to simply pour water over the stitched area while weeing and that would help relieve the stinging.

You were treated badly, OP, and just treating you kindly and showing some sympathy wouldn't have taken any extra effort on her part. It's basic things that are missing when you're booking in for triage. The booking people know what you're there for - why don't they tell you that if you're likely to have to struggle on one leg to someone with you to help you get about or fetch a wheelchair? Those notices on the walls about not allowing people to stay with you are useless because the nobheads who don't need anyone are the ones who are ignoring those posters, and the ones who DO actuallly need someone to stay with them are the ones heeding the posters and no-one tells them otherwise.

It's just awful. Whenever I've had to access medical care in France or Spain it's like a different world. I am starting to think that we will just take anyone for nursing or HCA positions now because staff shortages are so great.

Whisperingangel1 · 01/09/2023 15:08

I could have written something similar myself, A&E is appalling. I broke my ankle 7 years ago, went to A&E hopping on one leg, could not bear any weight. Noone helped I just hopped my way to X ray, had it X rayed and was told it was just a sprain and that I wasn't trying hard enough to walk. I repeatedly told them it was too painful to put weight on it and they kept telling me I was being ridiculous. Sent me home without anything. Took 3.5 wks to get diagnosed with ankle break after my GP agreed to an mri scan. In the 3.5 weeks I had hopped my way to my hometown where my mum worked alongside an orthopedic specialist who thank god gave me a special boot so I could walk.

michalwave · 01/09/2023 15:08

I would have let DP stay with me, until someone asked him to leave. You also needed him for support to walk so not sure why you asked him to leave without asking if he could stay.

I think you're expecting too much. Last time I was in A&E for a burnt hand (spilt tea). The triage nurse checked and asked if tea was from a kettle or hot water tap. When I said hot water tap, she looked less concerned. Then another nurse came and got me and sat me down in a room and told me to let cold water tap run over my hand. I must have sat there for 40 minutes. They let DH sit with me.

I can't remember them smiling me or being 'nice' as you call it, but I was so grateful that they saw me quickly. Usually waiting time is 4 hours, I was seen straightaway. That's all I could think of, how quickly they helped me.

If you're seen quickly and efficiently, why do you need them to be sweet as well? They must see so much crap in A&E and must be densensitised to a lot of it.

Oftenaddled · 01/09/2023 15:07

I wouldn't blame other patients for not helping. There were medical professionals there. I'd have happily advocated for you and got their attention but I would worry about making the damage worse if I tried to help an injured woman to walk.

I have spent a lot of time in hospitals with patients I'm caring for, and in some you need to speak up. That's really unfortunate but it does usually work. Just a polite and assertive request.

That sounds awful and I hope you recover well

AcesBaseballbat · 01/09/2023 15:07

Yes, some of them are shocking.

I had a mental health crisis during Covid (in 2021, not 2020) and took an overdose of 20 paracetamol, and still had to wait six hours in A&E without even being triaged, even though my GP had phoned ahead and promised me someone would be waiting for me. Surely an overdose is a real emergency that requires real immediate attention?

They also at first refused to admit me since I wasn't capable of clear speech. I had to write down loads of stuff since and really fight hard to be allowed inside at all - surely someone arriving who can't verbally speak is a sign of an immediate medical emergency?

Autumnismyfavouritetime · 01/09/2023 15:06

We had a similar experience last week. My 17 year old ds dislocated his knee and was off to France that night so we really needed it looked at.
The staff were so unfriendly and made us feel unwelcome and as though we were wasting their time.
It was such an awful atmosphere in the waiting room. At one point, two miserable looking nurses walked over, one glanced over at the waiting area and suddenly beaming said ‘oh look, there’s my Niece’. She called her over, took her in a room and attended to her. No idea where this woman was on the waiting list but to us all sitting there it looked as though she expedited her because she was family. The rest of us continued to wait in the gloomy atmosphere with the miserable staff.

Claricethecat45 · 01/09/2023 15:06

I am sorry to hear your experience but sadly not at all surprised; Frankly no one cares...certainly not enough to act on a human level.

My tall large DS aged 22 did exactly the same..broke his ankle. It was the size of a melon, bruised and painful and he couldn't walk.

In my case, a porter pointed me to a wheel chair (old and like a supermarket trolley with disobedient wheels) and watched me take about 30 minutes to push DS as much as I could up a long ramp on a steep slope, from the far corner of the very expensive car park, to the A+E entrance. Im about 5ft nothing and perhaps 50kgs and a bit...Son is 6ft 2 and at least 80kgs....I was in pain, DS was in pain, and the porters and many other passers by just watched. I did ask for help but porters all said 'not my job until you are in the hospital' - basically they are 'not allowed to' in case they 'put their back out' and Manual Handling guidance forbids it; after a 7 hour wait, X rays showed a complicated fracture and a surgery was needed.

Just a misery all round with totally disinterested staff with zero interest. Even the Dr who eventually came, looked at my Son and said 'so which ankle are we looking at?' Christ !!! It was the now navy blue one the size of two bloody melons - I dont think there is an answer. Crap NHS NOT fit for any purpose and the staff who work there.....stood around doing nothing...for a long time but happy to sit and snack and watch...patients struggle. I dont recall it ever being this bad and I despair. Workload and staff shortages are a convenient excuse; There are plenty of staff, just bone idle and demotivated. And no one - inside the NHS or outside - gives a stuff.

Coffeetree · 01/09/2023 15:04

I've only ever had kindness in the NHS personally but I totally believe you. I think probably the staff's shitty attitude had filtered down to the patients.

I had a very similar experience once in a hospital abroad. Literal broken foot and as I was leaving the clinic on my own, literally hopping, I said, "Could I maybe borrow crutches or a cane or something?" and they pointed at a shop a few hundred meters down the street where I could buy crutches. It was pouring rain and i was hopping down the street with a cast on one foot. Absolutely no one helped. And get this: got to the shop, they didn't take credit card and told me there was a cash machine around the corner. I think by that time I was so bedraggled I was beyond help. So yeah, especially when you're on your own, people can sometimes be awful.

BashCandicoot · 01/09/2023 14:59

Some people shouldn’t be in “caring” professions because they’re not suited to it. Some people go into caring professions because it suits them, ie it gives them an opportunity to have power over people.

Different situation but one of the midwives who I came into contact with when I had DC2 clearly relished the chance to exercise power over me. She was physically rough, verbally nasty and had a glint in her eye that suggested she was loving it.

Years later I happended to be talking to a friend and she was telling me about the nasty midwife she had and surprise surprise it was the same one.

She’s either dead or long retired now but if it’s the latter, I hope her carers are rough with her and scold her for being incontinent.

Anyway - complain. I wish I had. It might have been cathartic. As it is, if I think too much about that birth experience I cry.

WoolyMammoth55 · 01/09/2023 14:58

Sorry to hear this OP and hope you're feelingok today.

I fractured my tibial plateau - basically broken knee/leg - about 18 years ago. Like you I'd thrown up from the pain, and my knee was swollen to the size of a football - no exaggeration!

When we parked in A&E my partner went in to ask for a wheelchair for suspected broken leg and was told they didn't give them out unless a break was confirmed as "too many were stolen".

I hopped from the car into the waiting room, and into the triage room, and down the corridor to x-ray, and was in tears the whole way - excruciating! Then once they'd x-rayed they brought the wheelchair around.

It took 3 surgeries over 2 years for me to recover from that injury and the surgeon said no doubt that trying to balance/weight bear on the fractured joint had made the damage worse.

It's madness! There must be a better way.

Wishitsnows · 01/09/2023 14:57

You should complain but it seems that this is not at all unusual. There’s really no excuse. The nurse has to be there for a set amount of hours there is no reason not to at the bare minimum be nice to patients

JustAllRoundShit · 01/09/2023 14:55

I've had a ligament tear and it's the worst pain I've ever experienced. Even worse than giving birth (but thankfully not so long). A broken ankle plus a ligament tear must have been absolute agony.

I'm sorry a n e were not more understanding or helpful. Yes a bit of empathy and kindness can make a big difference. I think you've got good advice from others and I have got nothing to add to that. Hope you will feel better soon.

Trixiefirecracker · 01/09/2023 14:54

I’ve just been to A and E with my son. Was seen almost immediately, staff couldn’t have been kinder. Nurse was extremely helpful and caring. Was really impressed. After reading some horror stories on here and not having been for a long while, I was expecting the worst. I will definitely be emailing some positivity but equally, if you think they have been unkind and remiss then definitely get in touch with the hospital.

bonzaitree · 01/09/2023 14:50

I refuse to respond to healthcare professionals until they make eye contact. If they’re staring at the computer I sit in silence and wait until they look at me to respond.

One doctor I said « can you look at me whilst you’re speaking » It worked.

In no other profession is it ok to behave like this. It because we have no choice but to go there- it’s not like you can say « sod that I’ll go to this other doctors »

Receptionists are the worst.

TheGirlFromTomorrow · 01/09/2023 14:50

DepartureLounge · 01/09/2023 14:39

The NHS is stuffed with very burned out, desensitised staff who are this close to just not turning up anymore, nowhere more so than in A&E, where they're also picking up the slack for myriad other failing services. I think you're being a bit precious in truth. You could certainly have asked for pain relief and perhaps also for help getting to minor injuries.

I'm a bit of a complainer by temperament. I take the view that nothing changes if you don't. But I'd let this one go if I were you. PALS are up to their eyes in cases where shortcomings in care led to poor clinical outcomes. You just feel that people weren't optimally kind to you, which is very different. Honestly, move on.

It's not a big ask to expect a nurse to acknowledge that you have difficulties with walking and you're clearly in a lot of pain. What's the point of a nurse who doesn't care that you're injured?

landbeforegrime · 01/09/2023 14:50

i did think the twist was going to be you were surprised by a really postive experience in how you were treated. sadly not. I know it's not acceptable at all but I think at the moment the default is that people are not being treated very well at A&E. It's wrong that they have signs up saying no one can wait with you and then allow everyone to do just that. The signs might be a hangover from covid days and not apply anymore though so worth asking - it would be odd to ban this now. It's also terrible that no one in the waiting room came to help you, but the triage nurse absolutely should have been more compassionate and found you something - chair or crutch - without you having to ask. Unfortunately the squeeky wheel gets the grease though and you cannot expect people to look out for you. I had done my back in and needed to be with my DC at A&E during covid - he was still breastfeeding. Husband wasn't allowed to stay. I explained that I couldn't pick him up, run after him, etc and if was on my own I would need help with carrying him around and with positioning him for breastfeeding. They insisted my husband left then offered no help. It set back my progress and increased the number of osteopathy sessions I would have otherwise needed (which of course I was paying for privately). Whatsmore there was a family of 5 for one child also sat there who were apparently allowed to break the rules. I complained but it was a useless reply - I don't think I went through PALS. You should definitely complain though to PALS as it might make a difference for someone else. You could've done more damage by putting weight on your foot and they should have to comment on that and why they don't automatically provide assistance for people with foot or leg injuries. Shouldn't the nurse have realised this and as part of her role she should have been able to assess this and make sure your injury wasn't made worse? It's really terrible, but if (and let's hope not) there is a next time advocate loudly for yourself. If you have to say I cannot get up you're going to have to get me a wheelchair then so be it. You can't rely on anyone else doing it for you I'm afraid. Hope your foot is better now.

ungryHippy · 01/09/2023 14:50

You should have said you needed a wheelchair instead of waiting for help to be offered.
Everyone is too concerned with their own problems to pick up on a stranger's cues.

Aworldofmyown · 01/09/2023 14:49

Our A&E let my 65 year old mother walk on a broken leg from A&E to xray! And back!
Then they sent her home without crutches.
Absolute shit show.

teatimenow · 01/09/2023 14:48

Sounds fairly standard for A&E nurses. Sorry you went through that OP. Try not to take it to heart too much, you're just a number in the system at A&E, and the system is broken.

DepartureLounge · 01/09/2023 14:48

If you must complain, do it to your MP, not the unit or PALS. Staff burnout can only be fixed with improved resourcing. Everyone in front-line NHS work wants that as much as you and I do.

ittakes2 · 01/09/2023 14:47

I am brought up in a very community oriented culture - I am always the one helping elderly people or people looking lost etc.
But I must admit ... I am not sure how you think a stranger might offer to help? If you thought you had broken something I would have expected your partner to make sure you had a wheelchair and if you needed a wheel chair than he could have stayed as support despite the sign. I think if I saw someone hobbling I would assume they had refused the use of a wheelchair.
While the nurse could have been kinder - if you need some help ask - people are not mind readers. There are lots of people who don't want help and get annoyed or feel frightened if strangers approach them.
I hope you feel better soon.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 01/09/2023 14:47

I wouldn’t expect a patient or family member in the waiting room to help but would have expected help from the nurse when requested. Did you actually ask her though? I also would have always painkillers to be offered, I have always had painkillers offered when in A&E.

anyolddinosaur · 01/09/2023 14:45

When I had a similar injury someone stayed with me and we appropriated a wheelchair. In the event it was simply a bad sprain, although apparently my ankle had been broken previously. I had not gone to a&e on that occasion because I could put weight on it and thought that meant a sprain. I left with crutches.

If you can walk, even if it's very painful, they'll assume sprain until x-ray shows otherwise.

Wrongsideofpennines · 01/09/2023 14:44

I would complain. Trying to walk on it could have made injuries worse so they should have offered you a wheelchair or checked if there was someone with you, or got a porter - assuming you said you weren't able to weight-bear.

I imagine the 'no family waiting' signs are leftover from covid times and I would have ignored them particularly because you needed assistance to move. Last time I was in A&E with my baby there were 4 people with one toddler patient.

Sooty20235 · 01/09/2023 14:44

I was left to hop down corridors when I broke my foot in May. Its madness and awful!

Swipe left for the next trending thread