Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surprised at how I was treated in a&e

264 replies

broken86 · 01/09/2023 13:55

This has been playing on my mind for the last week and I just wondered if it was me being sensitive or not.

Last week I had an accident and it was obvious right away that I'd done something to my ankle, I threw up and almost passed out from the pain (which isn't like me, I'd say I've a very high pain threshold and not a drama Queen) I'd never felt pain like it even not giving birth.

Dh ran me to a&e and helped me to a seat and checked me in at the desk. I then told him to leave as there were signs all over saying no one could wait with you.

I felt pretty self conscious and exposed in the waiting room sat with only one shoe on and one bare foot. My leg had really swollen and I was obviously in a lot of pain and while it could just be paranoia I felt a lot of people were just staring at me.

The worst part was when I got called into triage, I couldn't put weight on my sore foot so had to pull myself up using the chair in front then somehow hobble all the way across the room to the triage area. The nurse waiting for me stood leaning on the door frame looking bored out her head at having to wait longer for me and everyone in the waiting room just stared at me struggling Confused

At one point I felt there's no way I can do this but it was such an unfriendly atmosphere I didn't even feel I could ask for help. Once I made it into the triage room and sat down the tears were pouring down my face due to the pain, The nurse didn't even look in my direction just asked me questions and typed into the computer before telling me to go to minor injuries and pointing to an area at the end of the corridor.

Once again I had to struggle down by myself, part of me wanted to ask for a wheelchair but awkwardly thought the nurse must think I'm being a wimp or else she would have offered. I had to support my weight on the handrail all the way down with everyone in the waiting room just starting at me again.

Once I was in minor injuries it was a totally different experience, they couldn't have been nicer getting me pain killers etc Turns out my ankle is broken and I've damaged the ligaments and am now off work and not able to drive etc for the next few weeks which is a total pain but can't be helped.

The total lack of any kind of human kindness in a&e still plays on my mind though, obviously a room full of people at a&e aren't going to be in the best form but a lot of people had ignored the "no family waiting" signs and were sat happily chatting away to each other. I couldn't imagine myself being there keeping someone company and not offering to help someone who was obviously in a lot of pain to cross a room, likewise I couldn't imagine a nurse in a&e not acknowledging when someone is in pain or even just giving them a friendly smile etc.

Obviously I'm grateful for the care I've received so far and that I will need going forward but was just wondering (while Sat with my foot up) if this is what people would expect in a&e?

OP posts:
C152 · 02/09/2023 19:13

It's not how it should be but, unfortunately, this doesn't sound unusual and is exactly what I would expect.

Newbie999 · 02/09/2023 19:06

I really sympathise with you. I broke my ankle in 2011. It was so painful. I had an operation as it was badly damaged.

A few things that were useful - a “Limbo” plastic sock for showering, a little plastic stool to perch on in the shower or when doing things in the kitchen, a long “picker upper” to get things off the floor and not bring too proud to accept help from friends and family.
I wish you well and you will get back to normal! I did. Do your physio when you are further along with your recovery. Sending love🥰😘

GrandTheftWalrus · 02/09/2023 19:04

I went to a&e in July with a broken ankle. The minute they called my name and the triage nurse saw me limping she went and got a chair right away. I'd put in a complaint. I was also alone as dh had to watch the kids. But my a&e doesn't have a 1 person only rule anymore.

Jack80 · 02/09/2023 18:57

Put a complaint into PALS

AnneValentine · 02/09/2023 18:50

Not even a bit unusual sadly. I broke my tibia and fibula. Significant displaced spiral fracture of the tibia. Required 6 hour surgery. Was horrific. I was also 33 weeks pregnant.

the nurse offered me paracetamol and asked me why I couldn’t walk to the triage room. When she dumped me back in waiting room - I was ALONE - a consultant spotted me and was furious. Gave her the riot act.

LawfulSearch · 02/09/2023 18:21

HelpMeGetThrough · 01/09/2023 14:13

Sounds like A&E where I am, it's a thoroughly unpleasant experience with extremely disinterested staff.

Won't say where, but down the pointy end of the country.

I think your A&E is my A&E.

Extremelycowgirl · 02/09/2023 12:13

@Bubbles332 I am so sorry to hear of your loss and I hope that you are recovering from what must have been a very traumatic and deeply frightening experience.

Bubbles332 · 02/09/2023 09:11

@Extremelycowgirl A&E is absolutely the place to be if you are bleeding in early pregnancy. The outcome of my PALS complaint was that I should have been examined, a doctor should have taken a blood test to measure my HCG levels and they should have used one of the US machines they have on the ward to see what was going on. Instead they took a dismissive attitude that I was ‘seeking reassurance’, gave me some platitudes about how it’s common and they knew I was upset and sent me home. This resulted in a haemorrhage which put my life in danger and caused me to have to go back in an ambulance. Imagine how much cheaper and more straightforward it would have been if they’d just kept me in at the time!
I don’t mean to seem like I’m jumping all over your comment, but bleeding in early pregnancy is always an emergency and should be taken very seriously. The attitude that we are looking for unnecessary ultrasounds because we are a bit sad or want someone to reassure us is dangerous. I don’t blame you though obviously because you are just repeating what you heard the A&E doctors say.

Winnading · 02/09/2023 09:07

LuckyCats · 01/09/2023 22:39

Sign of the times I’m afraid, I fell over in the town centre a couple of weeks ago, full on face plant damaged both my knees and hands, stayed sitting on my knees for a good minute because I was shaking and shocked and not one person asked me if I was ok or offered to help me up.
people are just less friendly now but nurses should be caring.
Even in doctors surgeries they don’t do the basics of care and dignity, the last smear test I went for the nurse didn’t even give me paper to cover myself with and did not care when it hurt.

I've had such horrendous smears I opted out.
The relief of not getting letters reminding me, no nurse offering to do a smear right now while I'm there, or telling me over and over to book one on my way out is immense.
Just ask at your surgery reception next time you are there and they will opt you out on the system there and then.

Oblomov23 · 02/09/2023 07:37

There's no excuse.

Even with nhs cuts in funding equalling staff shortages, even being short staffed on that day, doesn't excuse basics. there are certain basics that shouldn't really come down to money or stress. We expect common courteously and basic care and pleasantries from staff that are in caring professions.

In fact from any profession. If I go into a cafe and they are rushed off their feet and tell me there are no tables etc and they can't serve me, fine, but they can tell me that politely.

NameChangeEmbarressed · 02/09/2023 06:20

I'm so sooty you experienced that OP. I really would make a complaint to PALS. You were in pain and vulnerable and should have been treated with compassion and she should have at the very least got you a wheel chair.

I hope you heal quickly and aren't in too much pain x

@TwizzerlingToadstools ..... The doctors receptionists are exactly the same, blatantly ignore you, heads down, even though no phones ringing and no other patients. Zero empathy, made to feel a nuisance and constantly trying to fob you off with regards to contacting them online.
They have zero people skills.*

I'm a GP receptionist and I love my job and helping our patients. I promise you we are not all like the ones at your surgery, me and my colleagues would be mortified if we had made one of our patients feel the way you do. Please consider putting in a complaint to the practice if you feel that strongly about their attitudes.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 01/09/2023 23:21

That sounds horrible and I'm sorry.

But if you were unable to move you should've said so. Your husband should have stayed. You should have expressed your needs.

They were awful. But you need to start advocating for yourself! You are not a time waster or a burden! Speak UP!

Brimfullofash · 01/09/2023 23:01

I had the same many years ago. Had to walk to triage, walk to xray, walk to see the doctor. Only after the xray confirmed the break did they decide to get me a wheelchair

Medusaismyhero · 01/09/2023 22:49

My friend and I witnessed an accident recently where a cyclist was struck by a car at a roundabout.

The cyclist was literally flipped over and landed headfirst onto the road in front of our car. The impact knocked his helmet off and he had a really nasty looking and very large head wound.

Obviously we called an ambulance, got a blanket etc. After a few minutes the injured cyclist wanted to try and get up but I urged him not to and encouraged him to stay in the recovery position. I was really worried that he'd landed on his head and could have a neck or spinal injury.

When the ambulance arrived, the paramedics took a cursory look at him (literally a look, no vitals or real exam carried out) and then asked if he could get up. He managed it (with difficulty and zero assistance from the paramedics).

I was horrified! I'd witnessed the accident close up and thought he could've died or been seriously injured. No idea how things turned out as we've not heard a peep from the police who took our details and my friend's dashcam footage 🙄

Boomboom22 · 01/09/2023 22:45

It is weird how many nurses, only in hospital not Dr's or minor injuries, can blank you even when talking to you. Shocking communication. I don't see why they can't work 8 or 9 hour shifts it can't be safe doing 12 or 16.

LuckyCats · 01/09/2023 22:39

Sign of the times I’m afraid, I fell over in the town centre a couple of weeks ago, full on face plant damaged both my knees and hands, stayed sitting on my knees for a good minute because I was shaking and shocked and not one person asked me if I was ok or offered to help me up.
people are just less friendly now but nurses should be caring.
Even in doctors surgeries they don’t do the basics of care and dignity, the last smear test I went for the nurse didn’t even give me paper to cover myself with and did not care when it hurt.

ButterCrackers · 01/09/2023 22:21

You had obvious mobility problems and then didn’t help you to move about. I’d say to make a complaint.

Cloudysky81 · 01/09/2023 22:17

TheGirlFromTomorrow · 01/09/2023 20:45

There are literally people on this thread saying that the same treatment has caused them significant harm. I'm assuming you're a medical professional from your lack of ability to value kindness, but surely you understand people shouldn't walk on broken legs?

And the complete lack of compassion, empathy, and caring is totally cool with you? You don't think it's at all concerning that A&E departments are staffed by near psychopaths? You don't think that kind of attitude is incredibly bloody dangerous when peoples' lives and health is at stake?

All of the things I've listed are happening right now in hospitals. Some have happened to me personally. But it's fine to treat people like dogshit for daring to need medical attention?

Christ on a bike.

I’m more concerned ED departments are barely staffed to be honest.
I care far more about staffing levels and correct treatment then how people speak to me.

The post says the treatment was fine, the minors injuries staff were fine. Only the triage nurse was a bit off. I’d count that as a win with the NHS how it is.

VeronicaSawyer89 · 01/09/2023 21:54

Cloudysky81 · 01/09/2023 19:27

Being a triage nurse in ED is possibly the worst job in the NHS.
I don’t think there’s a queue of people lining up to do it.
What do you want your complaint to achieve?

More money for more nurses so people can be triaged quicker and the nurses aren't overworked, perhaps?

vipersnest1 · 01/09/2023 21:48

Unfortunately @broken86, that was my experience about 18 months ago when DC2 (adult) had appendicitis. The doctor they saw just dipped the urine and found a trace of blood. No other tests, and we were sent away with a diagnosis of UTI. As we were driving home from the hospital, DC, was writhing around and crying in pain, but refusing to let me take them back as 'they won't do anything'.
The only plus was that (because we were both so insistent that this was the same as an incident before where an ambulance crew felt it was a grumbling appendix), DC was given a slot at a clinic with direct access to surgery if needed the next day.
Of course, we were there first thing in the morning, but even so, delays meant that DC didn't get an ultrasound until late afternoon, when it was decided they needed surgery urgently. DC still didn't get surgery until the next day (first on the list because of urgency), because once they had been put on the list, two other people came in with an immediate need and their surgeries were very long (no gripes about them of course), so DC's surgery was delayed.
Meanwhile, I've gone round in a massive circle for two years, needing surgery for a prolapse, which hugely affects my life and my mental health.
I have a bone spur pressing on a nerve to my arm and I'm still waiting 18 months down the line to even be seen.
I had a breast cancer scare four months ago, but due to the wait for an appointment, I ended up going private (luckily, I could afford it, even though it ate into my rainy day money significantly).
I could go on, but will say just one more thing:
As part of the investigations of my prolapse, just over a year ago, I had to have a flexi-sig (similar to a colonoscopy). The pain was off the scale and I was very traumatised by the whole thing - I couldn't sleep on my left side for weeks as it brought back the memories.
I've never done it before, but I wrote a letter of complaint, saying how brutal it was and that I felt the pain was a 10. The reply I got from the consultant said that in his and a nurse's opinion my pain score was a 2. At that point I gave up.
The system is horribly broken. But, IME, there is also a collusion within the NHS that minimises women's pain. Unless you're screaming and shouting in pain, they assume it's not that bad. It's so wrong.
Sorry for the rant, but I wanted to tell you and other PPs that they are not alone.
Try putting in a complaint. It might not help you, but could help someone else.

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 01/09/2023 20:52

Cloudysky81 · 01/09/2023 20:37

But that isn’t what happened.
The triage nurse was a bit off, as they always are and likely always will be.
Then by the posters own admission the rest of the treatment was great.

And that attitude could put people off seeking help or speaking up.

After the events of the last few weeks we ought to be challenging poor practice. Before anyone gets daft, I’m not suggesting that the triage nurse is killing patients, I’m suggesting that if we don’t challenge this poor practice we accept that health professionals are beyond reproach.

xdestarx · 01/09/2023 20:48

Exactly the same treatment as I got when I broke my ankle a few years ago, so must be the standard! Apart from I did ask for a wheelchair and was told I'd have to find one if I wanted one. I asked where they were and they said they shrugged and gestured inside the hospital... So went without instead of hopping the wards in search of one!

TheGirlFromTomorrow · 01/09/2023 20:45

Cloudysky81 · 01/09/2023 20:37

But that isn’t what happened.
The triage nurse was a bit off, as they always are and likely always will be.
Then by the posters own admission the rest of the treatment was great.

There are literally people on this thread saying that the same treatment has caused them significant harm. I'm assuming you're a medical professional from your lack of ability to value kindness, but surely you understand people shouldn't walk on broken legs?

And the complete lack of compassion, empathy, and caring is totally cool with you? You don't think it's at all concerning that A&E departments are staffed by near psychopaths? You don't think that kind of attitude is incredibly bloody dangerous when peoples' lives and health is at stake?

All of the things I've listed are happening right now in hospitals. Some have happened to me personally. But it's fine to treat people like dogshit for daring to need medical attention?

Christ on a bike.

Cloudysky81 · 01/09/2023 20:37

TheGirlFromTomorrow · 01/09/2023 20:22

What do you think keeping quiet will achieve?

It could well be you one day being starved, injured, ignored, refused medication, laughed at, traumatised, or even possibly allowed to die through negligence. Will you be glad people kept quiet about being treated like cunts then?

But that isn’t what happened.
The triage nurse was a bit off, as they always are and likely always will be.
Then by the posters own admission the rest of the treatment was great.

TheGirlFromTomorrow · 01/09/2023 20:22

Cloudysky81 · 01/09/2023 19:27

Being a triage nurse in ED is possibly the worst job in the NHS.
I don’t think there’s a queue of people lining up to do it.
What do you want your complaint to achieve?

What do you think keeping quiet will achieve?

It could well be you one day being starved, injured, ignored, refused medication, laughed at, traumatised, or even possibly allowed to die through negligence. Will you be glad people kept quiet about being treated like cunts then?

Swipe left for the next trending thread