Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surprised at how I was treated in a&e

264 replies

broken86 · 01/09/2023 13:55

This has been playing on my mind for the last week and I just wondered if it was me being sensitive or not.

Last week I had an accident and it was obvious right away that I'd done something to my ankle, I threw up and almost passed out from the pain (which isn't like me, I'd say I've a very high pain threshold and not a drama Queen) I'd never felt pain like it even not giving birth.

Dh ran me to a&e and helped me to a seat and checked me in at the desk. I then told him to leave as there were signs all over saying no one could wait with you.

I felt pretty self conscious and exposed in the waiting room sat with only one shoe on and one bare foot. My leg had really swollen and I was obviously in a lot of pain and while it could just be paranoia I felt a lot of people were just staring at me.

The worst part was when I got called into triage, I couldn't put weight on my sore foot so had to pull myself up using the chair in front then somehow hobble all the way across the room to the triage area. The nurse waiting for me stood leaning on the door frame looking bored out her head at having to wait longer for me and everyone in the waiting room just stared at me struggling Confused

At one point I felt there's no way I can do this but it was such an unfriendly atmosphere I didn't even feel I could ask for help. Once I made it into the triage room and sat down the tears were pouring down my face due to the pain, The nurse didn't even look in my direction just asked me questions and typed into the computer before telling me to go to minor injuries and pointing to an area at the end of the corridor.

Once again I had to struggle down by myself, part of me wanted to ask for a wheelchair but awkwardly thought the nurse must think I'm being a wimp or else she would have offered. I had to support my weight on the handrail all the way down with everyone in the waiting room just starting at me again.

Once I was in minor injuries it was a totally different experience, they couldn't have been nicer getting me pain killers etc Turns out my ankle is broken and I've damaged the ligaments and am now off work and not able to drive etc for the next few weeks which is a total pain but can't be helped.

The total lack of any kind of human kindness in a&e still plays on my mind though, obviously a room full of people at a&e aren't going to be in the best form but a lot of people had ignored the "no family waiting" signs and were sat happily chatting away to each other. I couldn't imagine myself being there keeping someone company and not offering to help someone who was obviously in a lot of pain to cross a room, likewise I couldn't imagine a nurse in a&e not acknowledging when someone is in pain or even just giving them a friendly smile etc.

Obviously I'm grateful for the care I've received so far and that I will need going forward but was just wondering (while Sat with my foot up) if this is what people would expect in a&e?

OP posts:
mightymalties · 03/09/2023 16:30

I'm so sorry you had this experience OP and am sending unmumsnetty hugs your way. Unfortunately I'm not in the least surprised as I experienced similar (and worse) after an injury to my foot which left me completely unable to walk for 4 months, and still recovering ten months on.

Admittedly, my experience is tempered by the fact that I'm a lone parent of disabled DC with absolutely no help from family whatsoever and a limited social circle due to years without support for my children.

A&E in my area has huge waiting times, so I planned a trip to minor injuries through 111 two days after my accident when I was able to arrange childcare for my youngest. I also called the reception in before setting off to remind that I would be accompanied by my LD adult son due to being unable to walk, and was assured there would be a wheelchair available.

There were no wheelchairs, so DS went to ask for help while I waited in taxi. He was told to go to the opposite side of the hospital to find one (there were none); got lost and distressed. So taxi driver asked. Same result. Called reception again, to be told that both DS and taxi driver can't have been looking hard enough and there was nothing more they could do to help.

Managed to hobble about halfway to the reception, down a long corridor with nowhere to stop and rest, before a lady with a hospital lanyard walked past, did a double take, and asked why I wasn't in a wheelchair. After telling DS to stay with me a moment, she came back with a chair closely followed a minute or so later by the receptionist AND a porter, both of whom had a pair of crutches for me from somewhere obviously very close by. Receptionist was hugely apologetic, and as the unit was empty when I arrived I was seen swiftly and received good care afterwards.

I didn't complain at the time, but afterwards I wished I had. One thing after another went wrong. I won't go into detail about that, but the experience was traumatic and related to abysmal organisation, communication and support. Not the staff themselves: almost every doctor, nurse, caregiver and porter I met were truly lovely. Yes, I did complain. Formally, and on several occasions. I received only one follow-up call and nothing since. But a few days after the worst of it, the trust was rated inadequate after a CQC inspection.

Please do complain, politely but firmly. It may help the next person avoid being treated so poorly even if there is no real remedy for yourself.

Longtime · 03/09/2023 15:32

broken86 · 03/09/2023 11:21

What a bizarre thing to say Confused
You do know what A&E stands for? I'm sure a lot of people do abuse the system but I'm 100% confident I was in the right place.

broken86, you absolutely were! A & E is accident and emergency after all! I don't live in the UK so had a different experience when I was stretchered and ambulanced to A & E for my broken ankle. They don't just x-ray and put in plaster. I had to have a closed reduction to start with and a temporary cast, followed by surgery to attach a plate and screws, followed by a more permanent cast days later after the swelling went down. I have a broken fibula, a dislocated tibia and torn ligaments in between and around the bones, but yes, it's still considered a broken ankle. It's 13 weeks since my accident and I'm still using a crutch, can only manage a maximum of 5000 steps/day and that in pain/limping and really slowly, I need to elevate and ice my leg a lot of the time. They say it will be around six months until I'm back to normal so polymere you know what you can do with your condescending attitude!

Coffeeandcrocs · 03/09/2023 13:56

Was it QA in portsmouth by any chance?

ohhhhfffsss · 03/09/2023 13:25

Nurse was probably at end of long shift

She might have been, or she might have been a complete cow. The latter people do go into nursing too (though they shouldn't).

pookie999 · 03/09/2023 13:19

Cloudysky81 · 01/09/2023 19:27

Being a triage nurse in ED is possibly the worst job in the NHS.
I don’t think there’s a queue of people lining up to do it.
What do you want your complaint to achieve?

All patients want is for people to do the job they are paid to do in an appropriate and professional manner which includes giving care to your patients. This is the job they signed up for

pookie999 · 03/09/2023 13:16

Sadly I had a similar experience with a shoulder issue at a&e. I was waiting over 6 hours for an xray. Lying on the floor crying in pain. The only people with compassion were the male staff (I'm in my 60s so no attraction involved) and non uk staff. The nurse on duty was awful and made a ridiculous comment that I needed to exercise my broken shoulder. When I asked what diafnosis that was based on she said "whatever" and walked off. I had to beg for painkillers before leaving and paying £60 for a taxi home. My GP got it all sorted a couple of days later but I would now avoid a&e at all costs

Pickle59 · 03/09/2023 11:57

this is neglect and happens far too often which is why it must be reported or things will never change. it’s heartbreaking to think of this treatment when people are at their most vulnerable. we’ve got to stop thinking alll NHS workers are angels, they’re not. I hope you’re ok

Jzp · 03/09/2023 11:42

I was a nurse for 40 years and for most of that time worked on the wards in a busy inner city hospital which I loved. I did do a few shifts on A&E occasionally and even more occasionally had to visit it with one or other of my children. I’m not in the least surprised by your experience. A&E nurses can be very rude and are a totally different breed to most nurses. Some however are not, as you yourself found out.
You absolutely MUST complain to PALS. Do it today while everything is still fresh in your mind.

broken86 · 03/09/2023 11:21

pollymere · 02/09/2023 23:13

You were in pain but it wasn't life threatening. Save A&E for people who really need it. Minor Injuries or Urgent Care can X-ray and put you in plaster so for anything like that you really don't need A&E. My local Minor Injuries you can book an appointment via 111 so you know you won't be waiting for ages either and they'll give you meds whilst you wait.

What a bizarre thing to say Confused
You do know what A&E stands for? I'm sure a lot of people do abuse the system but I'm 100% confident I was in the right place.

OP posts:
Sunnydayz · 03/09/2023 11:18

I had a similar experience in an A+E.
Broken heel bone (didn’t realise at the time.) Dropped off by ambulance. Sat in the waiting room in a wheelchair. The nurse called me in and just stood at the door and waited for me. I was like ok… so hopped into her office on my good foot. She swear she rolled her eyes as I did it.
Once she looked at my foot her attitude changed! She went to get my wheelchair to wheel me out to be admitted.
Another patient said they couldn’t believe she made me hop in, so perhaps people were staring because they were surprised you were having to struggle in without help!

RiderofRohan · 03/09/2023 11:18

@gmor6787 you are simply talking nonsense. GPs are working from GP surgeries and are overwhelmed by the sheer number of patient contacts they have to deal with every day. I am a GP who chooses to work in an A&E setting because frankly being a GP in a surgery is a thankless, relentless job where all the woes of the NHS are pinned on you. People blame you for the waits in A&E, waits for elective surgery, waits for cancer treatment, etc...

gmailconfusion2 · 03/09/2023 09:52

I'm not surprised. I have pid that hasn't responded to 2 rounds of antibiotics, keep getting agonising stabbing pains in lower abdomen that stop me being able to move, went in as couldnt cope with the pain. Was told to go to gp, didn't examine me at all to consided if it was appendicitis or an abscess or ovarian cyst. All they did was do a urine dip stick a d give me pain killers. Apparently they don't do ultrasounds.

Weedoormatnomore · 03/09/2023 08:41

Similar experience to what I had, was my hand though. Never felt pain like it couldn't get rings off hand swelling. 111 sent me to hospital in an other county. Was there about 4 hours before they attempted to get rings off in which time fingers had swollen more took 45 mins and a lot of pain to get them off was biting into my top due to the pain. About 9 weeks since my accident and still can't drive as unable to grip.

gamerchick · 03/09/2023 08:39

They've spent the last 3 years frontline of a pandemic while we all stayed at home and the clapping unfortunately didn't pay their bills or or cure their PTSD from the horrors that they had to witness

Our A&E has been a shithole with appalling attitudes long before any virus appeared.

Elfblossom · 03/09/2023 08:35

Sadly it's all just part of the Tory plan.
Run it into the ground, denigrate the staff, 'customers' complaining and unhappy - that way we'll all be glad & cheer when they 'rescue' us with private health care and smiling nurses.

Never mind that we'll all go bankrupt when an accident happens or that it'll cost you £50k to give birth naturally including £100 just to hold your own baby.

if you felt like people were looking at you, it's because they are - they've been there hours and they're bored rigid. They're looking at you and weighing up if your imjury is A, genuine & B, bad enough that you'll push them back in the treatment queue - then they go back to minding their own business.

The triage staff aren't disinterested or bored - they're overworked, overwhelmed and underpaid, undervalued.

They've spent the last 3 years frontline of a pandemic while we all stayed at home and the clapping unfortunately didn't pay their bills or or cure their PTSD from the horrors that they had to witness.

They haven't had any time to recover because the pandemic continued & is into routine backlogs and they are all dealing with the Cost of living crisis too ...

Add to that, the amount of people that go to A&E (a fair few unnecessarily too) and the triage has to be quick and 'cold'. They don't have the time to be 'nice' to you because that 'there there poor thing' time is someone else's triage time.

I've spent more time in A&E than most over the last 15 years. One daughter suffered a Stroke at 13 and another has Ehlers Danlos Syndrome and has had to be in a cast doesns of times to stabilise dislocations.

This year I has Perimenopause bleeding so bad that my GP sent me to A&E (my first time for myself and not a child) and it had certainly changed since pre-pandemic.

It was rammed. What was once the children's waiting room with toys & a TV was now full of portable screens to turn it into 4 bays for treatment.

I was there for 5 hours and it was hell but that only made me appreciate the staff more and understand why they all looked how they did. I couldn't do it. I wanted to tell some of those waiting to f* off to the nearest Boots so I know triage staff felt the same but 99% of the time they can't because if they do & 1 person turns out to be worse than initially assessed its litigation & lose your job.

Winnading · 03/09/2023 08:09

pollymere · 02/09/2023 23:13

You were in pain but it wasn't life threatening. Save A&E for people who really need it. Minor Injuries or Urgent Care can X-ray and put you in plaster so for anything like that you really don't need A&E. My local Minor Injuries you can book an appointment via 111 so you know you won't be waiting for ages either and they'll give you meds whilst you wait.

My local minor injuries unit is shut on certain days. And currently there is no xray machine. So they send you off to a and e anyway.

Not every area is the same. I thought that would be obvious

VeloVixen · 03/09/2023 08:00

You were in pain but it wasn't life threatening. Save A&E for people who really need it. Minor Injuries or Urgent Care can X-ray and put you in plaster so for anything like that you really don't need A&E.

I do wish that firstly people would read the OPs posts and secondly realise not all hospitals are the same.

my local hospital similar to the OP there is one “a&e” waiting room. You are then triaged and sent either the next stage of a&e, or minor injuries or SDEC. Out of those three options only a&e deal with broken bones. The other two don’t X-ray or plaster.

gmor6787 · 03/09/2023 07:56

The NHS is in a mess, we all know that especially A&E but I think GPs are making it so much worse. During covid they got used to working from home, or turning up at the surgery a couple of days a week to do telephone/video consultations. Since covid they have pretty much kept to that regime.
They blame shortage of GPs but my surgery has exactly the same number of staff as before covid so why the wait to even get a phone call and getting a face to face is nigh impossible. If you look on their attendance at the surgery, one GP only does one day. None of the staff work full time.

That’s why A&E is overwhelmed.

Splishsplashsplooshsplosh · 03/09/2023 07:44

pollymere · Yesterday 23:13

You were in pain but it wasn't life threatening. Save A&E for people who really need it. Minor Injuries or Urgent Care can X-ray and put you in plaster so for anything like that you really don't need A&E. My local Minor Injuries you can book an appointment via 111 so you know you won't be waiting for ages either and they'll give you meds whilst you wait.

Where we live it's the opposite. If you went to minor injuries with a suspected broken bone they"d send you to A and E. I know because they did this with my 5 year old. So we had to wait twice.

VeloVixen · 03/09/2023 07:16

Seymour5 · 03/09/2023 06:34

I rang 111 and they told me to go to A&E, and said they’d book me in. The wait of several hours I expected, and accepted. The dismissive and disinterested attitude of the nurse who ‘treated’ me wasn’t acceptable. I wish I’d fed back.

Recruitment into nursing seems to miss one vital element. The ability to show kindness. The outcome may be the same, but when one is in severe pain, immobilised, and very worried, the tone of voice and expression can make a huge difference.

Funnily enough the NMC insist that universities have to undertake “values based recruitment “ so they are supposed to ask questions which make the applicant demonstrate such qualities. I suspect in reality as long as nobody comes across like a psychopath they’re offered a place, numbers of applications for nursing have plummeted like a stone and there’s 50% course vacancies at some universities.

RiderofRohan · 03/09/2023 07:14

Sorry about your experience but as a GP who works in A&e, it is too common. I do everything in my power not to go to A&e as a patient, but like in your case, sometimes it's unavoidable. I found myself on the receiving end when I took my mother to A&e while she was clearly having a heart attack. Won't go into details but it was a quite grim reception.

The lack of empathy generally comes from being understaffed, overstretched and burnt out. It's an issue we currently have in A&E, hospitals, ambulances, GP surgeries, etc... It's a symptom of the problem, which is a crumbling NHS. And it will only get worse unless the problem is fixed.

VeloVixen · 03/09/2023 07:14

Summerlovin24 · 03/09/2023 07:08

Nobody cares
Nurse was probably at end of long shift. They were probably understaffed and she never got a break all day. May have young kids at home/money worries cos they are overworked and underpaid. Bills, food and mirtgages going up yet wages aren't. I'm not defending her but this is typical of Employers these days. Employers try and squeeze every last drop out of us. It happens in my job. Push me and push me til I reach breaking point then shout at my manager because he demanded to know why I hadn't done something- because I was non stop ALL DAY LONG WITHOUT A MINUTE TO SPARE
I understand why you feel surprised but frankly I'm not. Nobody gives 2 shits

Then it’s time for that nurse to leave her job. I’m an overworked midwife. I know what it’s like to not get breaks, to not have time to do everything you need/want to do on a shift. But I still care. And I would not stand and watch someone struggle like that. It would probably have been quicker for the nurse to have fetched a wheelchair than stand and watch the OP struggle. It doesn’t take time to express a bit of sympathy/empathy.

Summerlovin24 · 03/09/2023 07:08

Nobody cares
Nurse was probably at end of long shift. They were probably understaffed and she never got a break all day. May have young kids at home/money worries cos they are overworked and underpaid. Bills, food and mirtgages going up yet wages aren't. I'm not defending her but this is typical of Employers these days. Employers try and squeeze every last drop out of us. It happens in my job. Push me and push me til I reach breaking point then shout at my manager because he demanded to know why I hadn't done something- because I was non stop ALL DAY LONG WITHOUT A MINUTE TO SPARE
I understand why you feel surprised but frankly I'm not. Nobody gives 2 shits

Lurkylurks · 03/09/2023 07:04

pollymere · 02/09/2023 23:13

You were in pain but it wasn't life threatening. Save A&E for people who really need it. Minor Injuries or Urgent Care can X-ray and put you in plaster so for anything like that you really don't need A&E. My local Minor Injuries you can book an appointment via 111 so you know you won't be waiting for ages either and they'll give you meds whilst you wait.

OP explained in one of her posts that you can't go straight to Minor Injuries where she is, everything has to be triaged through A&E first.

Seymour5 · 03/09/2023 06:34

pollymere · 02/09/2023 23:13

You were in pain but it wasn't life threatening. Save A&E for people who really need it. Minor Injuries or Urgent Care can X-ray and put you in plaster so for anything like that you really don't need A&E. My local Minor Injuries you can book an appointment via 111 so you know you won't be waiting for ages either and they'll give you meds whilst you wait.

I rang 111 and they told me to go to A&E, and said they’d book me in. The wait of several hours I expected, and accepted. The dismissive and disinterested attitude of the nurse who ‘treated’ me wasn’t acceptable. I wish I’d fed back.

Recruitment into nursing seems to miss one vital element. The ability to show kindness. The outcome may be the same, but when one is in severe pain, immobilised, and very worried, the tone of voice and expression can make a huge difference.