Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surprised at how I was treated in a&e

264 replies

broken86 · 01/09/2023 13:55

This has been playing on my mind for the last week and I just wondered if it was me being sensitive or not.

Last week I had an accident and it was obvious right away that I'd done something to my ankle, I threw up and almost passed out from the pain (which isn't like me, I'd say I've a very high pain threshold and not a drama Queen) I'd never felt pain like it even not giving birth.

Dh ran me to a&e and helped me to a seat and checked me in at the desk. I then told him to leave as there were signs all over saying no one could wait with you.

I felt pretty self conscious and exposed in the waiting room sat with only one shoe on and one bare foot. My leg had really swollen and I was obviously in a lot of pain and while it could just be paranoia I felt a lot of people were just staring at me.

The worst part was when I got called into triage, I couldn't put weight on my sore foot so had to pull myself up using the chair in front then somehow hobble all the way across the room to the triage area. The nurse waiting for me stood leaning on the door frame looking bored out her head at having to wait longer for me and everyone in the waiting room just stared at me struggling Confused

At one point I felt there's no way I can do this but it was such an unfriendly atmosphere I didn't even feel I could ask for help. Once I made it into the triage room and sat down the tears were pouring down my face due to the pain, The nurse didn't even look in my direction just asked me questions and typed into the computer before telling me to go to minor injuries and pointing to an area at the end of the corridor.

Once again I had to struggle down by myself, part of me wanted to ask for a wheelchair but awkwardly thought the nurse must think I'm being a wimp or else she would have offered. I had to support my weight on the handrail all the way down with everyone in the waiting room just starting at me again.

Once I was in minor injuries it was a totally different experience, they couldn't have been nicer getting me pain killers etc Turns out my ankle is broken and I've damaged the ligaments and am now off work and not able to drive etc for the next few weeks which is a total pain but can't be helped.

The total lack of any kind of human kindness in a&e still plays on my mind though, obviously a room full of people at a&e aren't going to be in the best form but a lot of people had ignored the "no family waiting" signs and were sat happily chatting away to each other. I couldn't imagine myself being there keeping someone company and not offering to help someone who was obviously in a lot of pain to cross a room, likewise I couldn't imagine a nurse in a&e not acknowledging when someone is in pain or even just giving them a friendly smile etc.

Obviously I'm grateful for the care I've received so far and that I will need going forward but was just wondering (while Sat with my foot up) if this is what people would expect in a&e?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VeloVixen · 15/12/2023 20:50

Toastiesforever · 04/09/2023 13:31

I have to ask.

Has anyone ever went back and confronted the healthcare worker that disrespected them or made fun of them?

And i dont mean days later, i just mean at the timer after treatment/xrays or confirmed diagnoses.

In my opinion these people carry on doing it as they are never directly confronted about their rudeness and unsympathetic attitude.

Its absolutely awful and im sorry to everyone its happened to as i know how it feels.

Yes. I called the junior sister out for her outrageous unprofessional behaviour only a few weeks ago. She was gossiping with two other nurses at the desk in full hearing of a waiting room of people. What she didn’t know is the patient she was gossiping about (saying she might be pregnant) was my daughter. As I pointed out to her she had put my daughter in a precarious situation as I had no idea she was having sex with anyone and now I knew which wasn’t fair on dd. Dd is a young adult and I’m laidback so I don’t care (though I was worried about the fact she must be having unprotected sex) but some parents might have gone ballistic. I didn’t shout at her but she was made aware I was raging. Not just about the massive confidentiality breach but also the sniggering and gossiping.

141mum · 15/12/2023 19:24

I have had a lot of dealing with local hospital, they disgust me, yes we know you work hard, poorly paid, but does this make you loose compassion, manners and don’t care attitude ,the worst thing I did was clap for NHS, every one I know is saying the same, GP is just as bad

NameChangeEmbarressed · 06/09/2023 15:58

RiderofRohan · 04/09/2023 12:38

@gmor6787 I work in London in a busy hospital. In the NHS you consider it a good job if you get to take your hour for lunch and leave on time generally. I do not see 36 patients a day and then have paperwork on top. So compared to my GP job, this is cushy. People who don't work in the NHS don't always have the perspective to understand this.

You make a lot of assumptions. All NHS waiting times have gone up- for A&e, cancer care, elective surgery. Naturally more people are looking to the GP to step in with pain relief, palliative care, etc.

Rather than vilifying, speak to the surgery receptionists and ask to actually get some facts. Even better, write to your MP and let them know about the issue so they can act on your behalf. I'm sure the GP surgery will reply letting you know about the post pandemic strain that so many surgeries face. And it's the politicians you really want- if you are looking for actual change.

As a GP receptionist, Thankyou. People do not understand how tough the job can be and how much stuff we have to deal with.

JustMeOk · 05/09/2023 21:23

SoundsLikeAYouProblem · 01/09/2023 14:05

The triage nurse sounds awful and maybe a complaint will make her treat the next person with a bit more compassion.

DH or I would offer you help in that situation, but I probably wouldn’t expect anyone to help me. I once came off a motorbike when it seized and was picking myself, and it, off the road and someone walked past and didn’t even ask if I was okay! I’ve come to learn not to expect anyone to care these days.

I hope you have a speedy recovery and aren’t in Too much pain Flowers

I once dropped my motorbike in the snow (I say 'dropped', but it actually slid away from me when I was slowly shunting in heavy traffic. I was 6 months pregnant at the time, and struggled to lift it back up. More than a dozen people walked past as I struggled and not one of them even glanced my way, never mind offering to help. My faith in human nature died that day....

Olivececelia92 · 05/09/2023 19:19

I'm so sorry you were treated this way, and I know staff are overworked and underpaid but that isn't an excuse.
I ended up in a&e myself a year or so ago as I had severe stomach cramps and had blood in my stool. I was in the waiting room bent double, throwing up into a sick bucket and barely able to keep still from the pain, and everyone was just looking at me like I was a mad women. Not one other person looked in pain, they were either talking on their phones loudly, or on laptops. I couldn't believe it.
Luckily the staff were friendly!

Marie324 · 05/09/2023 15:02

This is unfortunately normal in A&E from my experience and it shouldn't be that way. I was really poorly with pneumonia and days away from giving birth and received no kindness or empathy from the triage nurse. No one offered their chair for me in the waiting room and they could see I was upset and struggling. I wouldn't dream of treating a patient in this way and I am also a nurse by profession. I don't know why people go into this job when they are incapable of showing any kindness.

Mumto2kids86 · 04/09/2023 19:51

Very sorry you experienced this. I took my seven year old son to the urgent care centre a few weeks ago. He had a very deep cut to the head. He was patched up by the triage quickly but I was very surprised that they made us wait a full four hours before gluing his head. I felt like there was a lot of people sat there who needed antibiotics or had a pulled muscle type injury. I heard one man said he had felt slightly dizzy for a week! He was very scared I’m bleeding through his bandage. He was treated with kindness by staff there but can’t help thinking that it’s not the individuals it’s the NHS as a whole. It’s a mess.

Mrsmozza123 · 04/09/2023 19:49

sorry you went through this. It’s not surprising really. I called the early pregnancy unit to self refer as I was having a miscarriage and I probably got less sympathy than the time I called the garage and told them my clutch had gone. I think sometimes staff become desensitised. What is a huge deal to you is just the daily grind for them.
How sad though, imagine giving that little of a shit about your job and your fellow humans.

Lolalady · 04/09/2023 15:44

NHS is diabolical. My GP practice used to have 2 doctors. You could always get a same day appointment if required. Now it has about 12 GPs and appointments are as rare as hen’s teeth. If you are fortunate enough to get a telephone appointment it’s more than likely a clinician who calls - not a doctor!!

Then of course you have the “care navigators” (formerly known as receptionists) who basically decide whether you are worthy of the doctor’s time! Last time I called and asked to see a doctor I had to explain my symptoms to a care navigator who then bluntly said “well what do you want us to do about it “ I was speechless!

Differentstarts · 04/09/2023 14:34

Toastiesforever · 04/09/2023 13:31

I have to ask.

Has anyone ever went back and confronted the healthcare worker that disrespected them or made fun of them?

And i dont mean days later, i just mean at the timer after treatment/xrays or confirmed diagnoses.

In my opinion these people carry on doing it as they are never directly confronted about their rudeness and unsympathetic attitude.

Its absolutely awful and im sorry to everyone its happened to as i know how it feels.

Yes loads of time it doesn't usually end well because what gives us peasants the right to question God I mean healthcare workers

Toastiesforever · 04/09/2023 13:31

I have to ask.

Has anyone ever went back and confronted the healthcare worker that disrespected them or made fun of them?

And i dont mean days later, i just mean at the timer after treatment/xrays or confirmed diagnoses.

In my opinion these people carry on doing it as they are never directly confronted about their rudeness and unsympathetic attitude.

Its absolutely awful and im sorry to everyone its happened to as i know how it feels.

RiderofRohan · 04/09/2023 12:38

@gmor6787 I work in London in a busy hospital. In the NHS you consider it a good job if you get to take your hour for lunch and leave on time generally. I do not see 36 patients a day and then have paperwork on top. So compared to my GP job, this is cushy. People who don't work in the NHS don't always have the perspective to understand this.

You make a lot of assumptions. All NHS waiting times have gone up- for A&e, cancer care, elective surgery. Naturally more people are looking to the GP to step in with pain relief, palliative care, etc.

Rather than vilifying, speak to the surgery receptionists and ask to actually get some facts. Even better, write to your MP and let them know about the issue so they can act on your behalf. I'm sure the GP surgery will reply letting you know about the post pandemic strain that so many surgeries face. And it's the politicians you really want- if you are looking for actual change.

Defiantjazz · 04/09/2023 12:23

i went to the local minor injuries unit once as I’d accidentally sliced the tip of my finger off while cutting pizza 🙄.

I had a dressing over it and I just know the staff there thought I’d just cut my finger. The look of surprise on the nurses face when she took the dressing off and saw that, yes, I’d sliced the tip of my finger off, was quite amusing.

Rockschooldropout · 04/09/2023 12:16

That’s awful I’m so sorry to hear about your experience and you should absolutely complain .. I broke my ankle a few years ago and the pain was horrific .. I was told it was probably just a sprain by the unsympathetic triage nurse and even when the x ray showed a break .. I was sent off with no crutches after being placed in plaster ! It was only when I went to fracture clinic they were horrified and rushed off to get me crutches 🙄

however a couple of weeks ago I had to attend a and e with a severe tachycardia attack .. despite it being heaving and literally .. three people collapsed in the waiting area ..they were lovely and very kind .. they were so full I had to sit in the waiting area hooked to a drip but hcas were coming round constantly doing everyone’s obs .. it honestly looked like a battlefield in there but the staff were kind and working as hard as they could for everyone …
Im an ex nhs nurse and sadly I could never go back to working in these conditions…
do put a complaint in because you were not treated with dignity or respect .. the main things that were drummed into me when I was training

gmor6787 · 04/09/2023 12:07

RiderofRohan. It does sound like your job is ‘cushy’ your words but I doubt the doctors going on strike because the hours they work is reducing their hourly pay to £14 would agree.
I presume you don’t work in an inner city hospital where waiting is up to 10 hours in A&E.
People go to A&E because they can’t get to see a GP for weeks, are very often told to by staff at their surgery.
.What my point was, why with the same staff at my surgery prior to covid I could get an appointment within the week to see my doctor but now 2+ years later it’s 3 weeks if I’m lucky. I’m pretty sure his list hasn’t increased in size to warrant that time frame.

RiderofRohan · 04/09/2023 08:17

gmor6787 · 04/09/2023 07:41

RiderofRohan If I am talking nonsense then half of the country is too. Why, post pandemic, are GPs not working 5 days as they did before. As I already stated, one of GPs in my practice only works 1 day per week. He’s not of retirement age so where is he the other 4. Doing private work perhaps.
I can’t imagine working in A&E is less stressful than being a GP.

But you are speculating. You admit you have no idea what this GP does when he is not at the practice. What the general public don't know is many GPs work in different roles such as teaching at medical schools or tribunal work. Many have specialist interests in dermatology, diabetes, women's health etc and run NHS clinics to make up for the lack of consultants in those fields. Some, like myself, work in acute care.

The safe number of patient contacts a GP deals with in a day, according to the BMA, should be around 25. However most GPs must see many more, often 36+ (that's 18 patients per 3 hour clinic, 10 minutes per patient) to deal with demand. In between morning and afternoon clinic your GP is checking blood results, writing referrals and making visits to the palliative/housebound. I would often eat at my desk while going through letters from specialists, and then have to get my game face on for afternoon clinic without a minute to unwind. Then I would stay 1-2 hours late to finish paperwork in the evening. Unsurprisingly, many GPs are burnt out and looking to get out.

As a GP who works in A&E, I can tell you my job is cushy compared to actual GP work. It's shift work, I almost always take my designated break and any unfinished work at the end of my shift is handed over to the next doctor. I get to go home on time most days.

I'm sorry the NHS is not fit for purpose and I'm sorry it is impossible to see a GP, get an ambulance and that the wait to see a specialist is so long. But it's not your GPs fault and that's the simple truth. Blaming your GP instead of recognising there is a major problem with funding and retention doesn't help anyone.

https://www.pulsetoday.co.uk/news/workload/40-of-gp-practices-set-limit-on-number-of-patients-seen-per-day/#:~:text=The%20BMA's%20guidance%20on%20safe,this%20'arbitrary'%20workload%20limit.

40% of GP practices set limit on number of patients seen per day

Around 40% of GP practices implement a maximum number of patient contacts a day, a Pulse survey has revealed. 

https://www.pulsetoday.co.uk/news/workload/40-of-gp-practices-set-limit-on-number-of-patients-seen-per-day#:~:text=The%20BMA's%20guidance%20on%20safe,this%20'arbitrary'%20workload%20limit.

gmor6787 · 04/09/2023 07:41

RiderofRohan If I am talking nonsense then half of the country is too. Why, post pandemic, are GPs not working 5 days as they did before. As I already stated, one of GPs in my practice only works 1 day per week. He’s not of retirement age so where is he the other 4. Doing private work perhaps.
I can’t imagine working in A&E is less stressful than being a GP.

ungryHippy · 04/09/2023 07:18

broken86 · 04/09/2023 02:16

Yes our desk is in the middle of all the seats with really thick glass so you have to shout to say what your problem is Confused

I was surprised at the complete lack of privacy last time I went to A&E, especially since the NHS makes such a big deal about confidentiality with records etc.

You can't help hearing everything said as people are told to speak up so the receptionist behind glass screen can hear. Have to give name, address, phone number, details of accident/injury.

Although have to admit it makes waiting a bit more interesting... a very drunk woman with an obvious ankle injury came in supported by equally drunk friend with a bruised eye. When asked what happened the woman pointed at the "friend" and said "She disrespected me, so I kicked her in the face and fell over."

broken86 · 04/09/2023 02:16

kiptee · 03/09/2023 21:58

Also at my local A and E you have to say what's wrong with at the desk in entrance no bloody privacy

Yes our desk is in the middle of all the seats with really thick glass so you have to shout to say what your problem is Confused

OP posts:
kiptee · 03/09/2023 21:58

Also at my local A and E you have to say what's wrong with at the desk in entrance no bloody privacy

kiptee · 03/09/2023 21:57

Was in A and E this week. Not going into why but I was in a lot of pain asked five times over 1.5 hours for painkillers and I didn't get them. Ended up having paracetamol from my bag which didn't cut it

Morgysmum · 03/09/2023 21:55

It's not great but sadly, how it is. I don't think the other people, where really bothered by you. I would have kept my partner with me, but that would have been to help you walk.
I feel on the ice in December, I took myself to A&E but mine was a wrist injury. I knew been near December, it would be busy with winter and Christmas parties.
It was a 4 hour wait, I hadn't eaten anything, as my wrist looked like it might be displaced. So I thought I might need surgery or, they might have to pull my wrist, to get the bones in the right place. I was thirsty, but the drinks machine was put of order. One woman was crying in pain, she sat next to me, we talked a bit, after i asked what was hurting, she went back to the receptionist, to ry and get her bumped up the Q. As the signs said, if your symptoms get worse, tell the receptionist.
She did get seen before me. When I got triarged, I was sent for X-ray, the nurse asked if I had taken any painkillers, I said no, as I didn't want to drink.
After X-ray and another wait, I got my a half pot put on my wrist. It wasn't displaced. Then I got a cup of tea. Which was the best cuppa ever, after waiting 4 and a half hours to drink. I didn't get given painkillers. Just told to take some when I got home.
When I first arrived at hospital, I was told to go to minors, but it was closed, I managed to find a member of staff, who took me and another woman, who had been sent to the same place, back to A&E he told them to stop sending people to the minors.

GrandTheftWalrus · 03/09/2023 19:37

Longtime · 03/09/2023 15:32

broken86, you absolutely were! A & E is accident and emergency after all! I don't live in the UK so had a different experience when I was stretchered and ambulanced to A & E for my broken ankle. They don't just x-ray and put in plaster. I had to have a closed reduction to start with and a temporary cast, followed by surgery to attach a plate and screws, followed by a more permanent cast days later after the swelling went down. I have a broken fibula, a dislocated tibia and torn ligaments in between and around the bones, but yes, it's still considered a broken ankle. It's 13 weeks since my accident and I'm still using a crutch, can only manage a maximum of 5000 steps/day and that in pain/limping and really slowly, I need to elevate and ice my leg a lot of the time. They say it will be around six months until I'm back to normal so polymere you know what you can do with your condescending attitude!

I'm at the cast stage after having my stitches out. I'm 4 weeks in. As I waited 2 weeks for my surgery

WitchFire · 03/09/2023 17:53

It's not unusual op. Totally rubbish though.

Cudjoe · 03/09/2023 17:47

I have had several horrible experiences with hospitals.. like awful and then some great ones. Once while I was having a miscarriage the Dr casually started to giggle and pointed to the monitor getting to my scared and saddened husband attention and informing him that I had to poop. The nurses looked at each other then at me then at the floor. I was beyond mortified. I hate hospitals