Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

just got thrown out of a bar for having a (private) conversation with my friend about immigration

359 replies

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 01:23

Just to give some background I am a child of an immigrant (my father) and my mothers parents both came from Ireland. Me and a friend met up this afternoon for lunch and a few drinks. We went to a local bar and ended up staying until last orders when it got quiet and we got on the subject of the state of the country and cost of living. I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country. Pointing out that we are a small island compared to the rest of the world and the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here. My friend disagreed and said that this country was built on immigration to which I agreed but replied that we had seen such a massive increase in the last 20 years (something like 10 million). This is where we were interrupted by one of the bar staff who said he’d like us to finish our drinks and anyway he “didn’t like the tone of our conversation”. Me and my friend were shocked. We’ve never been asked to leave a bar due to a conversation we were having. She called it communism, I said it’s cancel culture. AIBU to think his reaction is completely out of order ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Couldyounot · 01/09/2023 19:28

We’ve never been asked to leave a bar due to a conversation we were having. She called it communism, I said it’s cancel culture.

A friend and I were asked to leave a pub in Exeter once for singing a Derek and Clive song. We got the harmonies right and everything. Nope. "Offensive and in bad taste" so out we went. Clearly we were being communistically cancelled.

And their beer was off, too.

pointythings · 01/09/2023 19:12

If you're using the 'well, they've been through a safe country' argument then you're at best ignorant. Asylum seekers are not in any way legally obliged to seek asylum in the first safe country they come to.

And if the barman was asking other people to drink up and go, has it occurred to you that they wanted to get on with the job of cleaning and tidying so that they could actually go home when their shift finished? If everyone stayed until the last minute, that would have to be done after closing and it isn't as if bar work pays particularly well so why would anyone doing it want to go beyond their hours?

MalcolmsMiddle · 01/09/2023 19:07

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 01:48

It’s relevant because living in a democracy means freedom of speech and opinions

You do have freedom of speech - you said your opinions. What you don't have is freedom from consequence. Maybe the barman over-reacted given the time and place but please don't confuse freedom of speech with being able to say what you want without reproach.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 19:06

If anyone does actually want to engage in a discussion about the pressures on public services, we could perhaps start by considering why the government which funds state schools has imposed on state schools a 43% increase since 2019 in employer pension contributions. A charge that immediately goes back to the government anyway, but the government of course has not funded that increase in costs that schools as employers have to pay. What impact do we think this change has had on the provision in state schools?

middler · 01/09/2023 18:53

Thedancingbear look you might not change someone's mind in one moment with a few posts because people tend not to do that but your posts and other posts do make people think about things and there is great value in that but the moment you say you can't win the hearts and minds of "these people because they had no hearts and minds, then people are less likely to listen to you because you are dismissing them for not immediately agreeing with you. I just think when we are respectful of each other and not dismissive there is room to develop our views on things, but you can't do that unless you are free to have the conversation.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:45

middler · 01/09/2023 18:36

Thedancingbear look all those things you mention contribute to the problem of pressures on services and maybe the OP will alter their viewpoint by reading your posts and others on here (or not) but if people can't even have conversations about these subjects no one develops their views, or shifts their views or understands there is a different way of looking at things. If conversations just get shut down there can be no development of viewpoints at all or exchange of different points of view. I think we just need to learn to respect difference a bit more and appreciate that people do hold views different to our own and we can have non hostile conversations about those views. I feel uninformed about this subject.I am a little more informed from reading some of these posts which can only be a good thing I support every single refugee on those boats coming in but I know not everyone takes my position. I just don't support people being shut down for expressing their viewpoint and I don't want to be the kid of arrogant twit who won't listen to anyone who does not agree with me.

But I (and another poster) are trying our hardest to engage in those conversations and all that's coming back is 'free speech innit, can't say nuffin'.

I was chided upthread for saying you couldn't win the hearts and minds of these people because they had no hearts or minds. Well, we've tried using facts and arguments, and PPs weirdly don't seem interested. I think my point is proved.

middler · 01/09/2023 18:36

Thedancingbear look all those things you mention contribute to the problem of pressures on services and maybe the OP will alter their viewpoint by reading your posts and others on here (or not) but if people can't even have conversations about these subjects no one develops their views, or shifts their views or understands there is a different way of looking at things. If conversations just get shut down there can be no development of viewpoints at all or exchange of different points of view. I think we just need to learn to respect difference a bit more and appreciate that people do hold views different to our own and we can have non hostile conversations about those views. I feel uninformed about this subject.I am a little more informed from reading some of these posts which can only be a good thing I support every single refugee on those boats coming in but I know not everyone takes my position. I just don't support people being shut down for expressing their viewpoint and I don't want to be the kid of arrogant twit who won't listen to anyone who does not agree with me.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 18:34

It is rather confusing people posting about small boats and at the same time worrying about the population of the UK having risen by about 10million in the past 30 years.

People crossing in small boats accounts for less than 1% of that increase.
Indeed even last year, where there was the highest number of small boats crossing, those people made up less than 8% of the net migrants to the UK in the year.

Aranas · 01/09/2023 18:33

Either your conversation truly was private and you were asked to leave for other reasons, or it wasn't private at all, and your misinformed views could be heard by the barman.

FWIW, yes you have freedom of speech, but if I owned an establishment and you were saying the same thing there, you would be told to voice your opinions elsewhere.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/09/2023 18:28

YABU. Anyone who blames the issues of this country on "boat people" is at best ignorant of the actual problem.

Oh and as others have said "freedom of speech" doesn't mean what you think it means.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:27

middler · 01/09/2023 18:19

I don't read the OP post as talking about small boats only that would be ludicrous to think the small number taking the huge risks involved to get to the UK that route, are the cause of increased pressure on services. I take her post as meaning the total number of immigrants over the years has put pressure and yes that means all people coming into a country. Her point about people on boats seems to be connected to why they leave safe countries and take the risks involved to get to the UK. I read that as another point she raised in her conversation. All immigrants use the services whatever their contribution is, and I do not doubt that they make a significant contribution. But more users of a service means more pressure on a service inevitably regardless of what occupational status the person using the service has.

OP says "I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country. Pointing out that we are a small island compared to the rest of the world and the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here."

Anyway this has turned into an argument about immigration. The OP was not unreasonable to express their viewpoint in a public bar with a friend whether I or you agree with it. However as this thread shows there are certain topics that are so polarising that it is simply easier to no longer discuss them in earshot of people who will be so offended you don't hold their viewpoint, they will ask you to leave the space you are sharing. I uphold the right of others to hold an opinion that differs from mine, unless it expresses ideas that are harmful and I don't think the OP's did.

Okay, but if you don't read the OP as talking about small boats and asylum, what kind of immigrants do you think she means?

People on skilled worker visa who we specifically invite in to alleviate pressure on services?

Students, who spend a shedload of money and pay a shedload of tax, are unlikely to need our hospitals or our benefit system, and then most often leave?

Or some other kind of immigrant? If the latter, what?

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 18:26

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 18:25

Thank you for your thoughtful comment. That is my way of looking it too that we need to be able to have these discussions and debates so we can learn from each other. I’m always open to hearing the view points of others but being shut down for merely mentioning the word immigration and my concerns around it and then MN’s immediately labelling me bigoted or racist is ignorance in itself. Totally unhelpful and no it’s not ok for bar staff to police our conversations either

Which services in particular were you thinking there are pressures on that are as a result of migration?

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 18:25

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/09/2023 17:39

It doesn't sound like your conversation was bigoted OP.

I always say that if people had not constantly tried to close down conversations about immigration before the Brexit vote it might have gone the other way.

Closing down conversations does not achieve harmony, it just breeds resentment.

In any event, your friend was challenging your views. Aren't people allowed to debate anything these days? Aren't we learning anything from the treatment of women for speaking up for womens' sport and spaces? Can we stop cancelling everyone and have meaningful debates. Hey, you might even change someone's mind, or educate them.

Thank you for your thoughtful comment. That is my way of looking it too that we need to be able to have these discussions and debates so we can learn from each other. I’m always open to hearing the view points of others but being shut down for merely mentioning the word immigration and my concerns around it and then MN’s immediately labelling me bigoted or racist is ignorance in itself. Totally unhelpful and no it’s not ok for bar staff to police our conversations either

OP posts:
StefanosHill · 01/09/2023 18:22

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 18:12

The weather has been somewhat different from last year, which may be a factor in the decrease in the number of boat crossings.

The question might be better asked why people think it is ok to own one or more empty properties, when there are people in need of housing?

To quote a pp it seems a bit heartless not to give up stuff. A room, move elsewhere and give up the property. If so inclined it could be done. If people suggest it they can offer first, I don’t see why they wouldn’t.

As for numbers that is a big drop, just reading pp it’s somewhere with a 2

Which is about half last year’s crossings

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 18:21

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:20

We could ask that, couldn't we? Or we could just blame poor brown people from failing states.

This is why I struggle with these threads. The people arguing 'we're not racist, we have legitimate concerns' are always looking in the wrong place. House prices too high? It's not rich people sitting on empty properties, it's brown people. Stuck in traffic? Not poor town planning, it's brown people clogging the motorway. Can't get a GP appointment? Not underinvestment, mismanagement, or people not looking after themselves - too many brown people. It's fucked up.

Why do we allow companies from tax havens to buy properties in the UK and then have them sit empty for years at a time, with know way of knowing who actually owns them?

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:20

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 18:12

The weather has been somewhat different from last year, which may be a factor in the decrease in the number of boat crossings.

The question might be better asked why people think it is ok to own one or more empty properties, when there are people in need of housing?

We could ask that, couldn't we? Or we could just blame poor brown people from failing states.

This is why I struggle with these threads. The people arguing 'we're not racist, we have legitimate concerns' are always looking in the wrong place. House prices too high? It's not rich people sitting on empty properties, it's brown people. Stuck in traffic? Not poor town planning, it's brown people clogging the motorway. Can't get a GP appointment? Not underinvestment, mismanagement, or people not looking after themselves - too many brown people. It's fucked up.

middler · 01/09/2023 18:19

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:04

(i) I've not suggested we commandeer the empty housing stock. We need a more considered programme of carrot and stick to get it back in the market. Even the Tories have made moves on this front. That will take time but millions or refugees are not going to arrive on our shores overnight. And however you cut it, if you think there is an overcrowding problem, 1 million fallow properties is a big part of the picture.

(ii) The OP specifically says she was talking about small boats.

(iii) beyond refugees, what other kind of immigration do you think is pressuring our services? Is it people coming on skilled worker visas - doctors, nurses, engineers - who help alleviate pressure on our services? Is it people who come here to study, who spend a shedload of money, and if they stay afterwards, are among our brightest and best? Or is there another kind of immigration I'm missing?

(iv) even refugees contribute to the economy. They are nearly always of working age, and often middle class (they've had the means to get here), and educated. Of course there are some bad apples, but refugees certainly don't have a monopoly on that.

I don't read the OP post as talking about small boats only that would be ludicrous to think the small number taking the huge risks involved to get to the UK that route, are the cause of increased pressure on services. I take her post as meaning the total number of immigrants over the years has put pressure and yes that means all people coming into a country. Her point about people on boats seems to be connected to why they leave safe countries and take the risks involved to get to the UK. I read that as another point she raised in her conversation. All immigrants use the services whatever their contribution is, and I do not doubt that they make a significant contribution. But more users of a service means more pressure on a service inevitably regardless of what occupational status the person using the service has.

OP says "I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country. Pointing out that we are a small island compared to the rest of the world and the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here."

Anyway this has turned into an argument about immigration. The OP was not unreasonable to express their viewpoint in a public bar with a friend whether I or you agree with it. However as this thread shows there are certain topics that are so polarising that it is simply easier to no longer discuss them in earshot of people who will be so offended you don't hold their viewpoint, they will ask you to leave the space you are sharing. I uphold the right of others to hold an opinion that differs from mine, unless it expresses ideas that are harmful and I don't think the OP's did.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:16

StefanosHill · 01/09/2023 17:40

That is a fair bit lower than last year if that number ends up being correct

I see this empty homes thing a fair bit on here, how do you do it. Do you mean the state requisitions property?

Would you or others who are keen be ok with putting your property or things in too?

Sorry, you're right, it's a bit higher than I'd first calculated. It'll probably end up being something beginning with a '2'.

We granted asylum to just under 24000 people last year. That's people on boats and everywhere else; it's only a small part of net migration and the rest is mostly skilled workers and students. The number of people waiting for their applications to be processed has shot up from very few a decade ago to over 100000 at the moment. That's a shocking figure but entirely a function of systemic failure. It's incredible that the Tories are managing to make capital out of this when it's a symptom of their policies.

Regarding the empty homes thing: I've mentioned this upthread but it's a complex problem that will take time to fix, perhaps through tax incentives and penalties. Of course sequestration isn't the answer.

And I would be happy to pay a bit more tax to help people fleeing war and persecution.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 18:12

StefanosHill · 01/09/2023 17:40

That is a fair bit lower than last year if that number ends up being correct

I see this empty homes thing a fair bit on here, how do you do it. Do you mean the state requisitions property?

Would you or others who are keen be ok with putting your property or things in too?

The weather has been somewhat different from last year, which may be a factor in the decrease in the number of boat crossings.

The question might be better asked why people think it is ok to own one or more empty properties, when there are people in need of housing?

everybody8 · 01/09/2023 18:07

It wasn't private it was in public

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:04

middler · 01/09/2023 17:36

No refugees on boats account for a tiny % of immigrants but the OP did not suggest this. You can't just take empty homes that belong to people and commandeer them though can you so that does not solve the housing issue.

Look an increase in a population through immigration puts pressure on services. The OP simply stated fact.
That same increase brings solutions to many issues too, maybe her friend said this too and the barman did not hear that part of what sounds like a discussion on immigration where different views were held. We should be able to have discussions without being accused of racism for having an opinion that differs from ours. I am not anti-immigration. I am not anti-supporting refugees. I am anti policing people because they express an opinion that they are entitled to express and then accusing them of racism.

(i) I've not suggested we commandeer the empty housing stock. We need a more considered programme of carrot and stick to get it back in the market. Even the Tories have made moves on this front. That will take time but millions or refugees are not going to arrive on our shores overnight. And however you cut it, if you think there is an overcrowding problem, 1 million fallow properties is a big part of the picture.

(ii) The OP specifically says she was talking about small boats.

(iii) beyond refugees, what other kind of immigration do you think is pressuring our services? Is it people coming on skilled worker visas - doctors, nurses, engineers - who help alleviate pressure on our services? Is it people who come here to study, who spend a shedload of money, and if they stay afterwards, are among our brightest and best? Or is there another kind of immigration I'm missing?

(iv) even refugees contribute to the economy. They are nearly always of working age, and often middle class (they've had the means to get here), and educated. Of course there are some bad apples, but refugees certainly don't have a monopoly on that.

middler · 01/09/2023 17:53

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/09/2023 17:39

It doesn't sound like your conversation was bigoted OP.

I always say that if people had not constantly tried to close down conversations about immigration before the Brexit vote it might have gone the other way.

Closing down conversations does not achieve harmony, it just breeds resentment.

In any event, your friend was challenging your views. Aren't people allowed to debate anything these days? Aren't we learning anything from the treatment of women for speaking up for womens' sport and spaces? Can we stop cancelling everyone and have meaningful debates. Hey, you might even change someone's mind, or educate them.

Yes this.

"Closing down conversations does not achieve harmony, it just breeds resentment."

I think some of the Brexit voters were giving a big two fingers up to the people of the UK(many seen on this thread) who look down their nose at anyone who does not hold their specific views as being uneducated or lacking literacy. It is so arrogant to just dismiss people because they don't hold your viewpoint and to see your viewpoint as being the right one and people absolutely hate it. I think we need to listen to others rather than just shut them down as if only our take on things is valid.

I am not even agreeing with the overall OP's viewpoint, I am simply defending her right to express it and getting told I am uneducated, can't think for myself.This attitude is what is polarising people in the UK, also in the US.

babysharkdoodoodedoodedoo · 01/09/2023 17:48

Good. Racist and ignorant people should be called out.

neverbeenskiing · 01/09/2023 17:43

Liv999 · 01/09/2023 15:57

Yanbu, you weren't causing trouble, you were voicing your opinion which you're entitled to do whether the barman agrees or not he sounds like a twat

It sounds like he was doing his job to me. Bar staff are entitled to use their discretion when it comes to what constitutes acceptable behaviour. Plenty of people would consider loudly voicing racist opinions in a public place to be a form of "causing trouble", or at the very least it has the potential to cause trouble.

There is no inalienable right to sound off about your opinions on immigration in a particular bar at a particular time. OP may be entitled to her opinions, but that doesn't mean the barman and anyone else in the vicinity is obligated to listen to them.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 01/09/2023 17:41

Rosieposy89 · 01/09/2023 17:31

You sound like a xenophobic racist. It's even worse coming from a family of immigrants

And this is categorically not the way to win the argument.

I'd suggest you ask for your comment to be deleted. It's unhelpful and won't change anyone's mind about immigration. A reasoned commentary of the advantages of it might.