Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cambridge University Slavery Research

133 replies

CallumDansTransitVan · 31/08/2023 17:42

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/31/ex-tory-mp-threatens-sue-cambridge-university-slavery-research-antoinette-sandbach

Read this article today & I'm sure it will bring mixed feelings. Interested to know other peoples thoughts on it.

My personal feeling is if I had been the lady in question. I would of ignored her name being included, as the likelihood was that the paper in question would of been fogotten about fairly quickly.
But I do believe she should not be outed for the actions of ancestors who were dead long before she came into existence. Nor do I see any justification for including her name on the paper.

Before anyone starts on oh but she has family wealth due to the history. None of these families were exactly paupers even before slavery.

Ex-Tory MP threatens to sue Cambridge University over slavery research

Student says he has been pressured to remove a reference to Antoinette Sandbach, a descendant of a slave merchant

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/31/ex-tory-mp-threatens-sue-cambridge-university-slavery-research-antoinette-sandbach

OP posts:
HRTQueen · 31/08/2023 21:11

Oh boo hoo

She has as her family have benefitted greatly frok slavery

no one is saying she is responsible but at least acknowledge this

DisquietintheRanks · 31/08/2023 21:10

BethDuttonsTwin · 31/08/2023 20:22

Well said. Bored to tears with it all. My ancestors were dirt poor, all living in poverty in the West Midlands. My children’s fathers lived in poverty in Ireland, his line only escaped by an ancestor marrying a Welshman and getting out. I bear no responsibility whatsoever for any historical wrongs committed by privileged wealthy men.

Of course you bear no responsibility- no one alive does. But you have benefitted from it.

stripeyjug · 31/08/2023 21:10

Absolutely! It's just interesting where and why people choose to direct the subject.

it's pretty odd!

CallumDansTransitVan · 31/08/2023 21:09

BethDuttonsTwin · 31/08/2023 21:02

The discussion is wherever the posters involved take it isn’t it?

@bellac11 did you know that the reason we never hear much about the trans-Saharan slave trade is that the slaves were routinely brutally castrated before reaching their destination so that they wouldn’t be able to procreate? And that is why there are no descendants in those countries to raise awareness of the plight of their ancestry. It was far worse, in far larger numbers, for far longer, but if you try to talk about it, it’s dismissed as “whataboutery”. Did you also know that after Britain abolished slavery and were patrolling the seas to prevent other countries from taking part in the slave trade, when the British Navy would see slave ships and try to save the slaves on those ships, the slave masters aboard would throw them all overboard and leave them to drown in order to avoid being caught with them?

It is not “whataboutery” to expand the discussion or object to the biased discussion of these matters, and question why one particular country is being focussed on. Some might suggest that Brits are easy to guilt and possibly might pay up “reparations” one of those days. In the meantime telling everyone they’re racists for not thinking in a very specific and politically/academically determined way about race sure does shame people into shutting up and letting those who think The Right Way “win” all the discussions. Not to mention make loads of money writing books/articles/giving seminars/teaching diversity courses, with a nice side gig of raising their profiles to sell those books by calling everyone racist on current affairs shows and podcasts.

A very well thought out post so thank you.

OP posts:
Diffrent · 31/08/2023 21:09

Takoneko · 31/08/2023 21:06

I get what you meant now.

I agree. Complaining that historians aren’t focused on the present is like complaining that botanists aren’t writing about bears. 😂😂

Grin
stripeyjug · 31/08/2023 21:09

No question some of the wealth created in the early 1800's was made by the families use of slaves. But there is no way in this world, you could confidently say any money or property held today came directly from it.

I don't think you can confidently say the wealth has no impact...

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 21:07

BethDuttonsTwin · 31/08/2023 21:02

The discussion is wherever the posters involved take it isn’t it?

@bellac11 did you know that the reason we never hear much about the trans-Saharan slave trade is that the slaves were routinely brutally castrated before reaching their destination so that they wouldn’t be able to procreate? And that is why there are no descendants in those countries to raise awareness of the plight of their ancestry. It was far worse, in far larger numbers, for far longer, but if you try to talk about it, it’s dismissed as “whataboutery”. Did you also know that after Britain abolished slavery and were patrolling the seas to prevent other countries from taking part in the slave trade, when the British Navy would see slave ships and try to save the slaves on those ships, the slave masters aboard would throw them all overboard and leave them to drown in order to avoid being caught with them?

It is not “whataboutery” to expand the discussion or object to the biased discussion of these matters, and question why one particular country is being focussed on. Some might suggest that Brits are easy to guilt and possibly might pay up “reparations” one of those days. In the meantime telling everyone they’re racists for not thinking in a very specific and politically/academically determined way about race sure does shame people into shutting up and letting those who think The Right Way “win” all the discussions. Not to mention make loads of money writing books/articles/giving seminars/teaching diversity courses, with a nice side gig of raising their profiles to sell those books by calling everyone racist on current affairs shows and podcasts.

The discussion is wherever the posters involved take it isn’t it?

Absolutely! It's just interesting where and why people choose to direct the subject.

Again, you personally are not being stopped from saying what you want to here. You are posting freely about this area of your interest. You are not being silenced.

continentallentil · 31/08/2023 21:06

LylaLee · 31/08/2023 17:52

Exactly, she’s an idiot.

He’s using her as an example of a descendant who appears to be still benefitting from wealth got from slavery.. and that’s it. So what?

Takoneko · 31/08/2023 21:06

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:53

Sorry, I was being silly and sarcastic it didn't come off as I intended. I meant that, the poster who is annoyed by people talking about history is not being forced to click on a thread about it.

I get what you meant now.

I agree. Complaining that historians aren’t focused on the present is like complaining that botanists aren’t writing about bears. 😂😂

Moonwatcher1234 · 31/08/2023 21:06

JaneyGee · 31/08/2023 19:40

Britain's wealth wasn't derived from slavery. It came from the industrial revolution, and the industrial revolution was built on the backs of the white working class. Also, in 1833, Britain used 40% of its national budget to buy freedom for all slaves in the Empire. We borrowed so much the debt wasn't paid off until 2015.

Another inconvenient fact: "The Barbary states of North Africa waged a war of piracy and enslavement against all shipping that passed through the straits of Gibraltar. Thousands of vessels were taken, and more than a million Europeans and Americans sold into slavery." That's a quote from Christopher Hitchens. Should Morocco and Libya compensate us?

This obsessive focus on slavery and colonialism is part of a larger campaign to make British people ashamed of their history and identity. I recently tuned in to a Radio 4 program about Jane Austen, for example, and within five minutes they were talking about slavery. And just look at the new books in Waterstones. It's ridiculous. Title after title attacking Britain. Recently, a left-wing agitator called Tariq Ali published a book on Churchill. It was reveiwed by the leading Churchill historian, a man who knows his subject inside out, and he dismissed it as a mix of distortions, cherry-picked quotes and outright lies, all designed to make Churchill seem like a monster. This is going on day in day out.

I’m embarrassed for you - you need to do some serious reading and switch off Gbeebies. Don’t believe all the nonsense you’re being fed.

CallumDansTransitVan · 31/08/2023 21:05

stripeyjug · 31/08/2023 20:51

@CallumDansTransitVan

"including the claim that the Sandbach family made all their wealth from slavery."

So some wealth was made from slavery just not all?

No question some of the wealth created in the early 1800's was made by the families use of slaves. But there is no way in this world, you could confidently say any money or property held today came directly from it. After all a couple of bad business decisions instead of good ones and they could of been bankrupt. Think 'Names at Lloyds' as an example of rich people becoming very poor suddenly.

MarySmit The above post applies to your suggestion she should pay reparations. I'm interested also in who you think those reparations should be paid to?

OP posts:
BethDuttonsTwin · 31/08/2023 21:02

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:39

No because the discussion isn't The Whole Entire Slave Trade, is it? It's about this lady and her name being brought up in a TED talk about Britain.

You are completely allowed to start your own discussion about anything.

Edited

The discussion is wherever the posters involved take it isn’t it?

@bellac11 did you know that the reason we never hear much about the trans-Saharan slave trade is that the slaves were routinely brutally castrated before reaching their destination so that they wouldn’t be able to procreate? And that is why there are no descendants in those countries to raise awareness of the plight of their ancestry. It was far worse, in far larger numbers, for far longer, but if you try to talk about it, it’s dismissed as “whataboutery”. Did you also know that after Britain abolished slavery and were patrolling the seas to prevent other countries from taking part in the slave trade, when the British Navy would see slave ships and try to save the slaves on those ships, the slave masters aboard would throw them all overboard and leave them to drown in order to avoid being caught with them?

It is not “whataboutery” to expand the discussion or object to the biased discussion of these matters, and question why one particular country is being focussed on. Some might suggest that Brits are easy to guilt and possibly might pay up “reparations” one of those days. In the meantime telling everyone they’re racists for not thinking in a very specific and politically/academically determined way about race sure does shame people into shutting up and letting those who think The Right Way “win” all the discussions. Not to mention make loads of money writing books/articles/giving seminars/teaching diversity courses, with a nice side gig of raising their profiles to sell those books by calling everyone racist on current affairs shows and podcasts.

RampantIvy · 31/08/2023 21:02

Alycidon · 31/08/2023 18:34

She can't be held responsible for the actions of her ancestors - I don't think she should have been named.

A great uncle of mine was a Nazi. It doesn't mean that I am a Nazi sympathiser.

Spendonsend · 31/08/2023 20:57

bellac11 · 31/08/2023 20:34

I havent seen it to be honest, but having learned about it a bit over the last few days, I would see why its brought up, it went on for longer and with a wider reach than the transatlantic trade. I dont see it as whataboutery at all. Im not quite sure why its not talked about in the same way.

I guess because it isnt directly relevant to malik's phd which is a fairly specific topic on the 'kinship networks and mercantile hegemony in later day British Slavery - the case of sandbach-tinne'

Which is personal to him.

(Although not having read it, he may reference other things for context. -His longer articles seem quite in depth)

bellac11 · 31/08/2023 20:56

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:38

My extremely limited understanding is they're linked but different. It come across as whataboutery because sometimes it is introduced into the discussion as a way to deflect attention from Britain's role. One does not excuse the other but some people are quite keen to hand wave away Britain's role by bringing in other countries.

I would imagine its about context, slavery has existed for thousands of years and despite laws now, will exist for thousands of years

I find that discussion about the transatlantic slave trade often would give the impression, if one didnt know more, that Britain was the only country in the trade, but empires have come and gone and will come and go again, imperial powers involved a number of different countries, all competing for land and resources and power. That has never changed and will never change.

I dont have any strong feeling about the transatlantic slave trade that is over and above the feeling I have about the roman or greek slave trade or in fact other trades. Britain was no better and no worse

AS another poster set out above, my ancestors (Ive researched back many hundreds of years on most lines) wer edirt poor indentured servants (virtually slaves), a were the majority of the working classes hundreds of years ago.

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:53

Takoneko · 31/08/2023 20:51

Sorry… I don’t understand what you mean.

Sorry, I was being silly and sarcastic it didn't come off as I intended. I meant that, the poster who is annoyed by people talking about history is not being forced to click on a thread about it.

Takoneko · 31/08/2023 20:51

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:35

I do worry about all these posters who are being forced to engage in topics that they aren't interested in. It's a massive safeguarding red flag IMO.

Sorry… I don’t understand what you mean.

stripeyjug · 31/08/2023 20:51

@CallumDansTransitVan

"including the claim that the Sandbach family made all their wealth from slavery."

So some wealth was made from slavery just not all?

Gruelle · 31/08/2023 20:47

bellac11 · 31/08/2023 19:46

Rather naively, I have only just became aware of the sub sarahan slave trade which puts another perspective on different levels of exploitation and the numbers of countries involved

Its never talked about as far as I can see

It’s a great mistake to imagine that, just because you didn’t know something, the rest of the world has also existed in a state of blissful unknowing …

And it’s probably problematic to draw firm conclusions based on a very little knowledge acquired minutes or days ago …

Richmondgal · 31/08/2023 20:45

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 19:17

Indeed. Also puzzled by the posters saying "it's not her fault, she didn't do it!!", when I don't think the student is saying she did, is he? If she's still benefitting from slavery money, she's still benefitting from slavery money. So are loads of people. It's the way of the world. I wonder if the real reason she's upset is because she's worried about reparation claims?

No if I was her I wouldn’t give a monkeys

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:44

Toprepandhowmuch · 31/08/2023 20:41

Or perhaps it is putting Britain’s role in the slave trade in its wider historical context?

It depends how it's phrased and why the person is keen to talk about it, I guess. Context and tone and all that.

MarySmit · 31/08/2023 20:43

She is not responsible for the sins of her ancestors, but she is a beneficiary of their I'll gotten wealth. It would be appropriate for her to pay reparations as a result.

Toprepandhowmuch · 31/08/2023 20:41

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:24

Really? I see it popping up every time there's an attempt at a discussion about Britain's role in the slave trade, especially on Mumsnet and Twitter. It's a nifty way of shifting focus away from the main topic while still being broadly on the subject. Top tier whataboutery. It's admirable, in a way.

Or perhaps it is putting Britain’s role in the slave trade in its wider historical context?

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:39

BethDuttonsTwin · 31/08/2023 20:37

But then people like you dismiss it as “whataboutery” and suggest that these facets of the discussion are only being discussed to detract from The Main Issue - ie your preferred political analysis. Overall implication being that’s the only one that counts and only “racists” would think otherwise and wish to study the entire picture.

No because the discussion isn't The Whole Entire Slave Trade, is it? It's about this lady and her name being brought up in a TED talk about Britain.

You are completely allowed to start your own discussion about anything.

Diffrent · 31/08/2023 20:38

bellac11 · 31/08/2023 20:34

I havent seen it to be honest, but having learned about it a bit over the last few days, I would see why its brought up, it went on for longer and with a wider reach than the transatlantic trade. I dont see it as whataboutery at all. Im not quite sure why its not talked about in the same way.

My extremely limited understanding is they're linked but different. It come across as whataboutery because sometimes it is introduced into the discussion as a way to deflect attention from Britain's role. One does not excuse the other but some people are quite keen to hand wave away Britain's role by bringing in other countries.