Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cambridge University Slavery Research

133 replies

CallumDansTransitVan · 31/08/2023 17:42

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/31/ex-tory-mp-threatens-sue-cambridge-university-slavery-research-antoinette-sandbach

Read this article today & I'm sure it will bring mixed feelings. Interested to know other peoples thoughts on it.

My personal feeling is if I had been the lady in question. I would of ignored her name being included, as the likelihood was that the paper in question would of been fogotten about fairly quickly.
But I do believe she should not be outed for the actions of ancestors who were dead long before she came into existence. Nor do I see any justification for including her name on the paper.

Before anyone starts on oh but she has family wealth due to the history. None of these families were exactly paupers even before slavery.

Ex-Tory MP threatens to sue Cambridge University over slavery research

Student says he has been pressured to remove a reference to Antoinette Sandbach, a descendant of a slave merchant

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/31/ex-tory-mp-threatens-sue-cambridge-university-slavery-research-antoinette-sandbach

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Titerama · 03/09/2023 18:18

I’m done talking with you about race.

(repeating for my own benefit so I don’t forget and engage again with someone as determined as this to paint the black guy as the bad guy)

nonheme · 03/09/2023 17:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

CallumDansTransitVan · 03/09/2023 16:57

Titerama · 03/09/2023 16:38

Right… so you don’t perceive it as harmful that he’s been threatened with being sued, dragged though the national press, had his educational and life accomplishments scrutinised and picked apart, told to pipe down about historical facts that have impacted his family, and been dictated to by random internet strangers (that’s you) who think they know better what he should be doing and saying in his life’s work?

You hit the nail on the head with the 'historical facts' part in your post. There was no historical reason for him to single out one living family member. Nor is their any reason for cambridge university to allow her to be singled out.

I very much doubt he is suffering much with all the press attention. If his desires as a black activist is to promote discussion he has succeeded beyond his wildest dreams. Also the people being threatened with legal action are the University.

OP posts:
Titerama · 03/09/2023 16:38

Right… so you don’t perceive it as harmful that he’s been threatened with being sued, dragged though the national press, had his educational and life accomplishments scrutinised and picked apart, told to pipe down about historical facts that have impacted his family, and been dictated to by random internet strangers (that’s you) who think they know better what he should be doing and saying in his life’s work?

CallumDansTransitVan · 03/09/2023 15:40

Titerama · 03/09/2023 09:27

Yeah I don’t think you understand what direct quote means. Let alone the difference between control and influence.

Regardless, it seems your view is that he should not talk about the impact of slavery because you think he should be celebrating how wonderful and kind the UK has been to raise him up so the other black and brown children can be similarly grateful.

I’m done talking with you about race.

Can you give an example please of the 'harm' (your quote) he is suffering?

OP posts:
Titerama · 03/09/2023 09:27

Yeah I don’t think you understand what direct quote means. Let alone the difference between control and influence.

Regardless, it seems your view is that he should not talk about the impact of slavery because you think he should be celebrating how wonderful and kind the UK has been to raise him up so the other black and brown children can be similarly grateful.

I’m done talking with you about race.

CallumDansTransitVan · 02/09/2023 23:51

Titerama · 02/09/2023 19:20

@CallumDansTransitVan
”I feel it was a fair response to your claim that Malik Al Nasir is still suffering under the control of Ms Sandbach.”

Are you struggling with reading comprehension?

Not in the slightest. This quote is lifted directly from your post 'He gets to be on the receiving end of her power wealth & influence, and so the harm continues down the generations.'

That to me reads that you believe he is continuing to suffer. I'd argue that he appears to have a reasonable life. All credit to him for coming from humble beginings. To me that would be a better thing for him to promote to younger students from deprived backgrounds. Be they black or white.

OP posts:
Titerama · 02/09/2023 19:20

@CallumDansTransitVan
”I feel it was a fair response to your claim that Malik Al Nasir is still suffering under the control of Ms Sandbach.”

Are you struggling with reading comprehension?

CallumDansTransitVan · 02/09/2023 15:36

Sorry just posted and saw VeloVixens reply.

OP posts:
CallumDansTransitVan · 02/09/2023 15:35

Titerama · 02/09/2023 08:26

OP’s latest argument boils down to well he’s had a good life in the UK so he shouldn’t get uppity and say true things about the white people who previously enslaved his family. Oh, and the money magically vanished or was diluted or something and you can’t prove otherwise so stop talking about that too.

FFS

I feel it was a fair response to your claim that Malik Al Nasir is still suffering under the control of Ms Sandbach.

WinterFireJanuaryEmbers
Agree wholeheartedly. But we must also be careful that in researching history we don't place the sins of the Fathers on current descendants. How often do we hear terms like 'White Privilege' or 'White Racism' in discussions where African slavery is part of the topic. If we carry on claiming certain groups are privileged because of their skin colour we will encourage their racism eventually, as well as devalue situations of serious racism.

Takoneko
I'm assuming it was a typo in VeloVixens post. But she is quite correct that any money given to the family in the 1830's will have been considerably diluted 200 years on.
The other thing we must question with the compensation scheme at the time. Had it not existed, how much longer would slavery have continued. How many more people would of suffered the trade.

OP posts:
VeloVixen · 02/09/2023 15:30

Takoneko · 02/09/2023 10:48

Oh you sweet summer child.

The £35k (worth over £3million today without considering any interest or return on investment) was paid to Sandbach by the government to compensate him for the loss of his slaves. The compensation went to slave owners not slaves.

Oh that makes more sense. 🙈. Well it doesn’t, but you know what I mean!

Takoneko · 02/09/2023 10:48

VeloVixen · 02/09/2023 07:42

I’ve just been googling and apparently Samual sandbach paid 35k compensation in the 1800s to his ex slaves. Which would have been a considerable amount of money then.

he also had “several” children so any inheritance she got generations later would have been very diluted due to time and numbers of children.

Oh you sweet summer child.

The £35k (worth over £3million today without considering any interest or return on investment) was paid to Sandbach by the government to compensate him for the loss of his slaves. The compensation went to slave owners not slaves.

Titerama · 02/09/2023 08:26

OP’s latest argument boils down to well he’s had a good life in the UK so he shouldn’t get uppity and say true things about the white people who previously enslaved his family. Oh, and the money magically vanished or was diluted or something and you can’t prove otherwise so stop talking about that too.

FFS

WinterFireJanuaryEmbers · 02/09/2023 08:22

I love history and am supportive of anyone trying to wrangle the morally complex truth of Britain's past - but the idea that history is important because it stops us making the same mistakes is (for me) the pinnacle of desperate human optimism.

I don't for one second believe that the crimes and tragedies of the past would not happen again, given the right circumstances. I think we humans are fundamentally programmed to exploit whatever we can for our own gain. The repetition of war, especially, seems inevitable. As the World Wars fade into the distant past, any lessons learned from them are being forgotten and war will come again. And with war comes the devaluation of human life - and awful crimes against people.

Scottishskifun · 02/09/2023 08:00

FoodFann · 02/09/2023 07:14

Wow that is fascinating, but of course it’s also a distressing thing to uncover. You’re not responsible for your GGGGrandfather’s actions, but, AS is in a position of power and privilege… is she still benefiting from the actions of her ancestors? Is our country still being run by descendants of slave owners, due to the power that has been handed down to them as a result?

It's not a pleasant one to discover and is unsettling but nothing our family can do about it.

You don't get to request which family you are born into though. There are many who have benefitted from multiple horrific events throughout history. Doesn't mean the present day is in control of that.

What I find wrong with this paper is only listing her because she's in the public eye. You either list all descendents fully found or none. As for how the country is run this is dependent on the MP. Lords is still very posh but there are a few who don't have generational wealth.

VeloVixen · 02/09/2023 07:42

I’ve just been googling and apparently Samual sandbach paid 35k compensation in the 1800s to his ex slaves. Which would have been a considerable amount of money then.

he also had “several” children so any inheritance she got generations later would have been very diluted due to time and numbers of children.

VeloVixen · 02/09/2023 07:36

That’s really interesting. My ancestors left the U.K. and worked on slave plantations in Gyuana. Apparently as indentured servants which I guess doesn’t make them as bad as the plantation owners. Plus there was a “mixing” of servants and slaves when it came to relationships so some of my ancestors were also slaves.

it’s so long ago that I can’t get worked up about it at all. It does seem a bit unfair that she’s been named when it was nothing to do with her and he’s only named her and nobody else? But it’s probably only in the press as she’s kicked up a fuss.

FoodFann · 02/09/2023 07:14

Scottishskifun · 31/08/2023 17:49

I'm kind of in agreement with her she has only been named as she's a public figure.

My great great great grandfather ran a mill in the North West of England with terrible conditions and often using people and children from the work house
barely paying them and many would have died. I only know this because an Uncle did a full family tree back generations.
Am I responsible for my great great great Grandfather along the same veins..... I don't think so and nor would someone publish it as it wouldn't really mean anything as I'm not in the public eye.

Wow that is fascinating, but of course it’s also a distressing thing to uncover. You’re not responsible for your GGGGrandfather’s actions, but, AS is in a position of power and privilege… is she still benefiting from the actions of her ancestors? Is our country still being run by descendants of slave owners, due to the power that has been handed down to them as a result?

Sayitaintso33 · 02/09/2023 07:11

JaneyGee · 31/08/2023 19:40

Britain's wealth wasn't derived from slavery. It came from the industrial revolution, and the industrial revolution was built on the backs of the white working class. Also, in 1833, Britain used 40% of its national budget to buy freedom for all slaves in the Empire. We borrowed so much the debt wasn't paid off until 2015.

Another inconvenient fact: "The Barbary states of North Africa waged a war of piracy and enslavement against all shipping that passed through the straits of Gibraltar. Thousands of vessels were taken, and more than a million Europeans and Americans sold into slavery." That's a quote from Christopher Hitchens. Should Morocco and Libya compensate us?

This obsessive focus on slavery and colonialism is part of a larger campaign to make British people ashamed of their history and identity. I recently tuned in to a Radio 4 program about Jane Austen, for example, and within five minutes they were talking about slavery. And just look at the new books in Waterstones. It's ridiculous. Title after title attacking Britain. Recently, a left-wing agitator called Tariq Ali published a book on Churchill. It was reveiwed by the leading Churchill historian, a man who knows his subject inside out, and he dismissed it as a mix of distortions, cherry-picked quotes and outright lies, all designed to make Churchill seem like a monster. This is going on day in day out.

Slavery wasn't the only evil, although it was an enormous one, of colonialism or Empire.
For 300 years we were the Putins of our day. We invaded, conquered and annexed a quarter of the Globe.
We plundered the countries of their wealth and their people. That made us very rich.

I do however agree that what we were doing was what every civilisation had done and was doing. We were just doing it on a global scale. We were the best at exploiting our fellow people.

Nanaof1 · 02/09/2023 06:59

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

And both ends of the spectrum do it. I just would like to know what the end game is. We all need to learn about the history of slavery, all of it. Then what? What is the goal? Will it help end present-day slavery? What is the end game?

junbean · 02/09/2023 06:45

The research is absolutely brilliant. For the same reason we teach about the Holocaust in school, we have to face facts to avoid history repeating itself. The first sign of a failing society is bans on books, misinformation, etc. - the masking of truth. If we can’t hold ourselves accountable for the truth and reality of our existence, who will? Better to own up to who you are and how you got there, and do what’s right with it. It almost never happens, and look at the world now and where it’s headed.

I’m saying this as a descendent of slave owners. I would never object to that information being shared either, as I’ve shared it with my community quite openly, and have done everything I can to push back on the culture that slavery created.

Nanaof1 · 02/09/2023 06:33

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Diffrent · 01/09/2023 22:42

chmod777 · 01/09/2023 22:36

So you haven't actually seen the Ted talk (which is what I assume you mean by "web chat", you just decided yo make an inflammatory thread about it after getting bored of lecturing black people about how golliw*gs aren't racist.

after getting bored of lecturing black people about how golliwgs aren't racist.*

Oh for fuck's sake! OP, sort your head out. Honestly, posting history should somehow be flagged before people engage. What a waste of everyone's time.

chmod777 · 01/09/2023 22:36

CallumDansTransitVan · 01/09/2023 21:02

You could argue she was not singled out if she is the only current surviving member of the family. I'd be doubtful that all living descendants and their finances found it into the paper or onto his webchat.

As previously stated, how long does time have to pass before it ceases to be the current generations fault? I don't know the families entire financial history, as I'm sure neither you nor the author do. Stating that any money made came from proceeds of slavery simply cannot be proven. As an example, in the past 200 years one of them may of married into another wealthy family.

I'm not sure a claim that he is enduring under the thumb of the White Woman when you read his wiki page.
He is currently a 57 year old 3rd Year PHD student at Cambridge. In prior years he got a BA Honours in Geography & Sociology from Liverpool University & a MA in New Media Production from Liverpool Screen School.

In between he seems to have spent his time playing music, writing poems and going on talk shows/fesitvals promoting black rights etc. Given that length of time in further education, I'd suggest the UK has done OK by him.

So you haven't actually seen the Ted talk (which is what I assume you mean by "web chat", you just decided yo make an inflammatory thread about it after getting bored of lecturing black people about how golliw*gs aren't racist.

Diffrent · 01/09/2023 22:36

how long does time have to pass before it ceases to be the current generations fault?

Is he saying it's her fault?