Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult ballet - being allowed en pointe too soon!

58 replies

balletfliss · 31/08/2023 15:07

I've noticed some really poor technique in adult pointe classes over the past few years, but never as bad as the past year. I don't know why that could be.

It's actually dangerous in that it risks injury, their turnout is wrong or non existent, and placement poor. Chatting before and after classes I'm not surprised to hear that most of these women have never done pointe before, even as children. They've been allowed to buy pointe shoes and join the pointe class after only one or two years as adult ballet beginners at the school.

One woman had done a year in grade four as a complete beginner and just been fitted for her pointe shoes. Ridiculous! I'd seen her in the grade 4 class and she couldn't manage all of the steps in flat shoes, or very well.

I wonder if anyone has found the same? I haven't been back to those classes as it doesn't inspire trust in the teachers involved. I also worried for them, injury-wise. Fortunately I've found somewhere where they're quite strict with entry criteria and care about the dancers.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
couruetsuivi · 03/09/2023 11:46

My 16 year old started ballet when she was 5 and has just got her first pointe shoes (Bloch Amelie) this summer, in time for classes beginning in September. She's very much a recreational once a week dancer, but is also an ex gymnast and is very strong.

My other DD was fitted for pointe shoes at 11 years for starting Intermediate Foundation, but she'd been dancing since she was two and danced a few days a week, including associates. She'd also attended compulsory pre pointe classes and wore demi pointe shoes where needed.

Both of my DCs trained for minimum nine and 11 years before going en pointe. The idea that an adult beginner can be ready in one or two years (unless an undiscovered genius talent) is ludicrous and shouldn't be allowed.
It might need to be reinforced to these people that dancing in soft shoes is real ballet just as much as pointe is.

taxi4ballet · 02/09/2023 15:46

Ohmylovejune · 02/09/2023 15:39

Oh that's hard!

Interestingly when I ran I used to suffer as my foot doesn't flex up to run very well and the sports physio said I'd make a fab ballet dancer because my taylers glide is oddly positioned and so makes flexing for running hard but, when flexing the other way, makes my foot exceptionally pointy!

Sadly, the only part I could realistically play would be the ballet dancing elephants in Fantasia!

It is hard. People have no idea how difficult ballet actually is, because the dancers make it look so effortless.

Ohmylovejune · 02/09/2023 15:39

Oh that's hard!

Interestingly when I ran I used to suffer as my foot doesn't flex up to run very well and the sports physio said I'd make a fab ballet dancer because my taylers glide is oddly positioned and so makes flexing for running hard but, when flexing the other way, makes my foot exceptionally pointy!

Sadly, the only part I could realistically play would be the ballet dancing elephants in Fantasia!

aspirationalflamingo · 02/09/2023 15:32

taxi4ballet · 02/09/2023 15:03

Stand on one leg and see how long you can balance for. Not all that easy, is it? Try it on tiptoe if you can.

Can you feel what your ankle is doing? Wobbling around to help you keep your balance. Now imagine falling over sideways on that ankle. You'd pull all the tendons & ligaments, and that can cause permanent damage to the ankle joints. Your knees won't thank you for it either.

Talented dance students and professional ballet dancers will have spent many years strengthening their ankles, feet, legs and core muscles, and will have developed fantastic balance. They will be dancing for many hours a week. That's how they can dance in pointe shoes - and why it is seriously inadvisable for anyone else to try it.

That's quite scary. I'd be surprised if adults (without a ballet background) attending a recreational/casual ballet class for an hour a week could reasonably be expected to appreciate those risks.

A responsible instructor should be making them aware. I would have thought they had a duty of care to do so.

dodobookends · 02/09/2023 15:24

balletfliss · 01/09/2023 11:01

Ah, a professional! I don't think I would like to use just paper towels, though as a girl I'd use lambs wool as that's all we were allowed, and we weren't allowed elastics just ribbons (I think that's still how it works at RBS, possibly).

Nowadays, for minimal pointe, I use protective gel pouches and elastics!

The pros often use elastic when performing, usually concealed underneath the ribbons. Helps avoid disaster if the ribbon breaks.

taxi4ballet · 02/09/2023 15:03

Ohmylovejune · 31/08/2023 23:26

What are the injuries you can cause? Are they dreadful and debilitating for normal life or do they just stop you doing ballet for a while? Like running and picking up a achilles issue or planter fascitis?

Stand on one leg and see how long you can balance for. Not all that easy, is it? Try it on tiptoe if you can.

Can you feel what your ankle is doing? Wobbling around to help you keep your balance. Now imagine falling over sideways on that ankle. You'd pull all the tendons & ligaments, and that can cause permanent damage to the ankle joints. Your knees won't thank you for it either.

Talented dance students and professional ballet dancers will have spent many years strengthening their ankles, feet, legs and core muscles, and will have developed fantastic balance. They will be dancing for many hours a week. That's how they can dance in pointe shoes - and why it is seriously inadvisable for anyone else to try it.

taxi4ballet · 02/09/2023 14:34

@Thepeopleversuswork To answer your question about pointe shoes, the shoes are not soft. The dancers don't literally stand on the tips of their toes unsupported, nor do they scrunch their toes up. Pointe shoes are solid all the way round, and you basically slide your foot into something that holds the whole foot tight. The shoes have a flat 'platform' on the tips, which is what the dancer stands on when en pointe, and the whole shoe has a strong, stiff shank which runs all along the sole of the foot, and bends halfway along so you can actually move in them. So they are basically dancing with their feet held firmly in a foot-shaped hard cone.

taxi4ballet · 02/09/2023 14:22

Strawfairytart · 31/08/2023 21:56

Adults are allowed to do dangerous sports/activities if they choose to.

While you may be right, you don't gatekeep adults trying to dance on their tippy toes.

Adults get to choose. You can choose not to do what you don't want to.

In the nicest possible way, I don't think so. Their instructors, coaches and teachers are professionally liable for any harm that might befall their students if they allowed them to try something way beyond their capabilities.

Pointework is way beyond the capabilities of almost everybody, including most recreational ballet dancers.

Nobody is stopping any random grown adult from swanning into a dancewear shop or some website and buying pointe shoes. Nobody will prevent them from ricking their ankle while they totter precariously about their living room. And no reputable dance teacher would allow such a person to take part in a pointe class.

Hillarious · 01/09/2023 11:48

My DD did ballet from 4 to 18 at a very well respected ballet school and loved it. She had pointe shoes at 16, but the amount of pointe work she did was minimal. But what got me most about the pointe shoes was that they were very expensive, and I still had to embroider the ends and sew on the ribbons!

balletfliss · 01/09/2023 11:37

Definitely try adult ballet. I'd recommend it to anyone. There's people of all ages in the classes.

The individual customising is fascinating. The glue I've never used for myself, but you can buy it from most ballet shops. I've used it for my DD's shoes in the past though.

OP posts:
megletthesecond · 01/09/2023 11:07

I'd love to try adult ballet, not en pointe though. The you tube videos showing how to customise a ballet shoe fascinate me.

balletfliss · 01/09/2023 11:01

Dustyblue · 01/09/2023 07:40

I always wondered how en pointe works. This explains it and shows some ouchy-looking feet!

Pain, satin and paper towels: What it takes for ballerinas to dance on their toes – The Durango Herald

Ah, a professional! I don't think I would like to use just paper towels, though as a girl I'd use lambs wool as that's all we were allowed, and we weren't allowed elastics just ribbons (I think that's still how it works at RBS, possibly).

Nowadays, for minimal pointe, I use protective gel pouches and elastics!

OP posts:
gillygeey · 01/09/2023 05:52

Did it as a kid but never get to pointe level as I gave up in my early teens. Went back for adult classes for a good few years which I really enjoyed. No one ever suggested going en pointe, didn't really think it would be a thing unless super experienced

balletfliss · 01/09/2023 04:02

Strawfairytart · 31/08/2023 21:56

Adults are allowed to do dangerous sports/activities if they choose to.

While you may be right, you don't gatekeep adults trying to dance on their tippy toes.

Adults get to choose. You can choose not to do what you don't want to.

Ballet isn't generally considered a dangerous sport though 😀

I can assure I'm not trying to 'gate-keep' as everyone should try ballet, at any age.

Why the rush for people who have never been en pointe before, or never done ballet, to go en pointe. Is it impatience to do 'proper' ballet 'like the ballerinas?'.

Do ballet properly rather than bypass the basic training needed to do pointe work safely and correctly. Beginner adults going en pointe after one year or two - not good really. I've seen the results of that, hence the thread.

OP posts:
Saschka · 01/09/2023 02:41

Goodbookandcupoftea · 31/08/2023 23:26

Not relevant to your original point, but just wondered about adult ballet classes. Are they just for people who have danced as children? I've no dance experience whatsoever, would it be a waste of time to take up an adult ballet class?

DH started aged 35 (and he is very uncoordinated, and has left/right dyspraxia). He loves it. He’ll never be a pro, obviously, but loves the classes.

I danced as a child but then switched to gymnastics and had a long break before going back in my 20s - adult classes are so much more fun than as a child! Less pressure, more about enjoyment than relentless drilling. I also found I really enjoyed contemporary classes, which I’d never really been exposed to before.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 01/09/2023 02:18

don't know how I marked out half the comment. Sorry.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 01/09/2023 02:18

My DD1 began lesson at age 4. She took lessons twice a week, went to summer dance camp, joined a junior company that performed publicly, but was not allowed on point until she was 13 years old. All of her teachers said that the feet must be fully developed before pointe not still growing, because pointe could cause malformations.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 01/09/2023 00:58

balletfliss · 31/08/2023 23:01

I've always wondered how pointe work works: do you literally stand on the absolute tip of your toes? or do you sort of scrunch your feet up and curl your toes forwards?

I'm not a dance teacher, and I bet someone can give a better explanation than me. I'll try.

No, you're not literally standing and putting the whole weight on your toes. Toes are straight and should be a pulled up sensation out of the shoe (bad explanation). You need to have the strength in the feet, ankles and legs and core should also be strong so that you're pulled up. You also don't want to sink into the shoes.

You should have the good posture, placement and turnout from your years of training dancing in flat ballet shoes, then perhaps demi pointe shoes. If your technique isn't strong on flat you really shouldn't be going on pointe.

The people I saw couldn't get over the box and weren't turned out from the hip etc

While this is a good explanation of the technique, I suspect it won't be a lot of help to a non-dancer.

@Thepeopleversuswork no scrunching - you are indeed on the very tips of your toes, not on bent-over ones. A well-fitted shoe spreads the weight a bit up the foot, so it's not really possible to do it (properly) without that support - and therefore quite hard to visualise.

musicmum75 · 31/08/2023 23:54

Goodbookandcupoftea · 31/08/2023 23:26

Not relevant to your original point, but just wondered about adult ballet classes. Are they just for people who have danced as children? I've no dance experience whatsoever, would it be a waste of time to take up an adult ballet class?

Not at all 😊 I started adult beginners ballet in my mid 20s with no experience at all and am still going to classes 20 years later 😊

balletfliss · 31/08/2023 23:41

I bought a wonderful pair of Gaynor Mindens and wish I'd had them as a child as they are the most comfortable I've ever worn

They are extremely comfortable! The fitter said people don't want to wear anything else once they have had them. Last ages too if you wear them a lot.

I would also say that dancing through 3-21 you probably more likely to have a solid base technique!

OP posts:
balletfliss · 31/08/2023 23:38

MaitreKarlsson · 31/08/2023 21:23

Long-time dancer here, RAD and ISTD exams a long (long) time ago, not good enough to do it as a career but still do adult classes.

I have never heard of older adults doing ballet lessons en pointe unless they either did loads of pointe work in their youth, or were actually professional dancers.
My current class includes some very good adult dancers, some danced professionally, but absolutely no one is en pointe any more.

@GLORIAGloriarse it's a fair point, but it's so extreme and potentially damaging I think it isn't that simple...even girls who do dancing for several years aren't automatically allowed pointe shoes unless their technique is good enough (at least that was how it was in my day....)
Adults haven't got a hope of developing that strength if they are starting older. They are also likely to be a lot heavier...likely to lead to joint problems etc.

@balletfliss I think I'd probably report that first school to their qualifying authority - sounds very weird.

Would you advise reporting? I wonder if they would take it seriously as it's adults not children at risk of injury? I would hope so. I wouldn't need to prove it as it was stated in the class description on their school page. I will consider.

I only do minimal pointe. I was saying to a pp that I only do a couple of classes a month. The teachers themselves, even if teaching pointe, don't really wear pointe shoes. I know an ex professional, in her 40s, and she doesn't go en pointe at all (though her technique is amazing).

I agree that an adult who has never done pointe or ballet before (or possibly even if they have, depending) cannot possibly reach the necessary standard and strength needed for pointe.

OP posts:
SuziLikeSuziQ · 31/08/2023 23:38

Nearly a decade ago I took up ballet again as an adult. I'd done ballet from the age of 3 right through to 21 (I studied at uni) with 9 years of pointe work. I was about 33 when I took it up again. After about a year they started a pointe class which I joined but there were only 4 of us. I really enjoyed the class but there was a lot about strengthening and we did lots of basic exercises, not just going straight to dancing in the centre. I think if anyone had tried to join who didn't have the technique, the teacher would have said something. She was quite exacting towards us!

I bought a wonderful pair of Gaynor Mindens and wish I'd had them as a child as they are the most comfortable I've ever worn!

I think done correctly, there's no reason adults can't do pointe classes but it should absolutely be based on a qualified ballet teacher's accurate assessment rather than any adult who wants to being able to.

For the pp who wanted to know - you can absolutely get a dance teacher's qualification and if you want to start lessons you need someone who is part of an organisation such as the Imperial Society of Teachers of Dance.

TheYadaYada · 31/08/2023 23:33

I was en pointe at 14.

I now do ballet after quite the hiatus, but would run for the hills if it was suggested to me now. I’m just glad to still have a vaguely good postural stability and non-knackered feet.

AlltheFs · 31/08/2023 23:27

underneaththeash · 31/08/2023 22:33

I got to grade 5 ballet as a child and was basically told I was too fat to go en pointe. So, I stopped ballet. I was quite plump TBH. I'm actually not now, but I'm much heavier than most ballerinas

Surely standing on the tip of your foot is only for tiny tiny people!

You don’t have to be tiny, friends daughter is a young adult and quite big (tall but also a 12/14 ish size). She has been having lessons for a long time and she finds pointe easy. She isn’t ever going to be pro but is a very good amateur.

She’s obviously strong enough and good enough for it.

I’m glad I didn’t get that far though myself as it transpires as an adult that I have some fairly significant hip and knee issues (genetic) that give me enough gip, if I’d have pushed myself then I’d be buggered now. And I was very petite then.