Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apologies that are ruder than just replying late

88 replies

GalGadont · 31/08/2023 15:03

For context: I’m not a particularly speedy replier to texts, and most of my friends aren’t either. I don’t take offence if people are slow to reply to non-urgent messages, partly because I’m slow too, partly because in general I just assume that we’ve all got busy lives and people will reply when they have time and energy. If I’ve been a particularly long time in replying to a message I might put ‘sorry to be slow’ or similar in my reply when I do send it, but I don’t make excuses for why because that implies that if it had not been for the excuse ‘reason’ I would have replied more quickly which I think we both know is bullshit, and I don’t want to insult their intelligence by repeatedly providing made-up excuses for why I’ve been slow. (Obviously if there was an actual reason I would mention it).

So: I don’t have form for taking offence when people are slow to reply, and my friends know this. However, some of them who are otherwise good friends evidently feel compelled on some occasions to offer excuses anyway. I know this is very small fry in the scheme of things, but AIBU to think these come across as way ruder than just late replying?! A particular favourite which I’ve had from a couple of friends is ‘sorry, I thought I’d replied’. IMO this scores the double-whammy of both insulting the recipient’s intelligence (since personally I don’t think I’ve ever hallucinated replying to someone when I haven’t…) and, if taken at face value, implying that you/the conversation are so unimportant to them that they can’t remember whether they’ve replied to you or not. I’ve also recently had variations on ‘sorry, I read your message and then forgot about it’ (really put this bluntly), which may well have the merit of total honesty, but IMO comes very firmly under the heading of situations where total honesty is not the best policy!!

These are good friendships otherwise, so AFAIK it’s genuinely not a situation where someone is intentionally trying to hurt my feelings or blow me off.

YABU - these responses are fine

YANBU - these responses are ruder than just replying late, and it would be better if they just didn’t give an excuse

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
randomusernam · 31/08/2023 20:29

Well I say sorry I thought I'd replied sometimes because I write the text and somehow get distracted by life/children/work all sorts and then I think to myself a few days later mmm so and so hasn't relied. Look at my phone and see the text staring back at me!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/08/2023 20:11

Oh! I have genuinely thought I’ve replied when I haven’t before - so perhaps got interrupted by DC and forgotten to press send. So I might well say “I thought I’d replied”. Oops!

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/08/2023 20:07

This what I meant by personalising it in a way that other people aren't doing. They're not saying "I find YOU forgettable." They are saying "I forgot to reply to this message." It's not about you.

Also this. You seem to be taking this incredibly personally. The person who thought they'd replied to you but hadn't is almost certainly doing the same to others.

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/08/2023 20:06

willittho · 31/08/2023 15:42

I think this is a simple case of you understanding that other people aren't you and don't necessarily behave exactly as you do.

You're a slow reply, you don't think that's rude. Lots of people do, for instance.

You don't begin to write a message then forget about it, lots of people do.

And so on.

I agree. On balance I think its ruder to take days to reply to a message than it is to say you thought you'd replied but hadn't.

I couldn't get particularly exercised about either and I don't expect instant replies but it does slightly piss me off when people have clearly read messages and then take a week to respond to them.

CheekyHobson · 31/08/2023 19:46

It’s the going out of your way to underline that you find someone forgettable that I find weird.

This what I meant by personalising it in a way that other people aren't doing. They're not saying "I find YOU forgettable." They are saying "I forgot to reply to this message." It's not about you. If I forget to reply to someone, it's not about the quality of our relationship or how I regard them. I might forget to reply to one of my best friends because I was in the middle of juggling a school departure when her message came in, and instead reply to someone I know far less well because their message arrived when I was standing in line at the supermarket. You're making their response about you as a person, when it's not.

GalGadont · 31/08/2023 19:38

CheekyHobson · 31/08/2023 19:26

’Sorry, I read your message and forgot it’ just seems unnecessary to me. Why say it?

I think most people who say it do so because they aren’t loading it with the same meaning you are. To you it sounds like “Other things in my life are more important than remembering to reply to your message therefore you are not important.” Whereas maybe for many people, answering text messages is fully understandable as a lower priority in life and they don’t take a forgotten reply as a message about their personal importance.

Its a way of telling the person you weren’t deliberately ignoring them or deliberately deprioritizing them, it just slipped your mind.

I’m a single mum and my kids, work, staying on top of my weekly chores and getting 10 minutes to myself are always going to take priority over going back through the messages I’ve missed during the week and replying to them, especially when I have new messages coming in too.

I said in my original post that I’m more than fine with slow replies, and I don’t actually expect an apology of any kind. Of course we’ve all got higher priorities than responding to non-urgent messages. It’s the going out of your way to underline that you find someone forgettable that I find weird. If you want to apologise just say ‘sorry for late reply’ and leave it at that.

OP posts:
livinglifetothefull · 31/08/2023 19:32

I once had a friend that took 3 weeks to reply to a message about some tickets i had for a festival .
I even rang her 4 times coz i new she would love to go i got no answer so took someone els .
she replied 3 weeks in a right hump ( no longer in touch )
i also had worked with a woman that took a weeks to reply to anyone as she was just to busy but yet she was always on her phone but didnt like if if no one got back to her in 5 seconds . ( blocked )
I just dont get it not replying for weeks or answering calls or even doors .
Sometimes i am busy and i cant message back asp but will do it at some point that day other times i just send a quick one saying ill give you a call or text later and i do .
Its not hard to do is it .

GalGadont · 31/08/2023 19:28

nadine90 · 31/08/2023 17:57

Why not say it? If you'd not replied because your phone had exploded in your hand, would you not say that? Why would you not tell them the reason if it was as mundane as having forgotten?

‘Why not’ is never a particularly compelling rationale

Yes, I would say if my phone had exploded in my hand. Unlike ‘I read your message and forgot it’, it doesn’t imply anything about finding the other person unimportant.

OP posts:
CheekyHobson · 31/08/2023 19:26

’Sorry, I read your message and forgot it’ just seems unnecessary to me. Why say it?

I think most people who say it do so because they aren’t loading it with the same meaning you are. To you it sounds like “Other things in my life are more important than remembering to reply to your message therefore you are not important.” Whereas maybe for many people, answering text messages is fully understandable as a lower priority in life and they don’t take a forgotten reply as a message about their personal importance.

Its a way of telling the person you weren’t deliberately ignoring them or deliberately deprioritizing them, it just slipped your mind.

I’m a single mum and my kids, work, staying on top of my weekly chores and getting 10 minutes to myself are always going to take priority over going back through the messages I’ve missed during the week and replying to them, especially when I have new messages coming in too.

SullysTail · 31/08/2023 19:24

Whenwillglorioussummercome · 31/08/2023 15:06

I often say I thought I’d replied because it’s true. I read messages and reply in my head all the time, and then realise with horror ages later I never actually wrote or sent it. Sometimes I’ve half typed it and then had to check a detail and forgotten to go back to it. I’m the same with email.

I do have ADHD and I’ve been like this ever since texts and emails began.

This is me. I also have ADHD.

Whenwillglorioussummercome · 31/08/2023 19:22

Weighin · 31/08/2023 18:42

I find it strange that people can function and hold down a job if they really think they’ve replied to something but haven’t.

I think not replying because you’re busy and it’s not a priority or urgent is actually ok but if people really are so manic they can’t keep track then how do they succeed at work?

Well, for me, I don’t succeed hugely. I have had repeated ADHD burnout, and have had to find strict ways to cope with the demands of work. In my spare time I can’t sustain that without serious harm to my mental health.

I also have to prioritise my mental energy for work, which pays my bills, over checking up constantly on my WhatsApps.

It does happen at work too, despite my efforts. Not remotely ideal.

Luckily none of my friends has ever taken offence at my texting habits.

pnw22 · 31/08/2023 19:06

Positive41 · 31/08/2023 18:12

People will respond to who they want to respond to in a timely manner-busy or not

All this 'i'm too busy', 'i wrote a message in my head' is bullshit.

No-one is that bloody busy- it takes a second to respond

Agree!

user1477391263 · 31/08/2023 19:05

I find it strange that people can function and hold down a job if they really think they’ve replied to something but haven’t. I think not replying because you’re busy and it’s not a priority or urgent is actually ok but if people really are so manic they can’t keep track then how do they succeed at work?

Well, I use email at work, not messaging systems or social media. It's easy to see what I've replied to and haven't.

anunlikelyseahorse · 31/08/2023 19:00

Some people take umbrage if you don't reply straight away. Quite often I don't reply straight away because I'm busy, and then forget. I mean it doesn't bother me personally one way or the other, but with one acquaintance it's like the bloody elephant in the room if I don't apologise for a late reply. Just because you don't like honesty other people do 🤷‍♀️.
And yeh sometimes I've definitely replied, but for whatever reason the message hasn't sent (quite common as my phone won't send texts via SMS, so if I've run out of data or no Wi-Fi then the message doesn't send.

Weighin · 31/08/2023 18:42

I find it strange that people can function and hold down a job if they really think they’ve replied to something but haven’t.

I think not replying because you’re busy and it’s not a priority or urgent is actually ok but if people really are so manic they can’t keep track then how do they succeed at work?

fivelilducks · 31/08/2023 18:35

If you were stood in front of someone speaking, and they just blanked you, that would be rude. Texting someone and them not replying to your preferred timeframe is not rude, and the notion that it is is what causes us all to be attached to our phones 24/7- never able to switch off. It's unhealthy for the brain. Grow up

NotAMug · 31/08/2023 18:16

OK I am a bit on the fence here. I always reply and usually very quickly. Once i typed a message out replying and was sure I had sent it. After a day or so I went to message again to chase up and my reply was still in the WhatsApp typing box so it does happen. I am now mortified that she might have thought I was lying about thinking I'd sent it!

I run a sports team and I have to chase up selection responses, one parent I have to chase every time after emails, texts etc. Bearing in mind, I work full time, plus work in the evenings and volunteer in a big role at this club running several teams she responds often the day before or morning of a match to say yes or no, she apologises and says she's been busy. Makes me so angry! I have started giving her a deadline to respond and if not I select someone else, she still respond ls days later and is miffed I've picked someone else.

Positive41 · 31/08/2023 18:12

People will respond to who they want to respond to in a timely manner-busy or not

All this 'i'm too busy', 'i wrote a message in my head' is bullshit.

No-one is that bloody busy- it takes a second to respond

nadine90 · 31/08/2023 17:57

Why not say it? If you'd not replied because your phone had exploded in your hand, would you not say that? Why would you not tell them the reason if it was as mundane as having forgotten?

GalGadont · 31/08/2023 17:57

RunnyPaint · 31/08/2023 17:41

Thank you, OP. I am a "thought I'd replied" type 😳This thread prompted me to check and respond to two messages. My friend (who is usually worse than me) responded immediately 😊

😊

OP posts:
pollykitty · 31/08/2023 17:42

I have a lot to do in any given day between running my own business and family stuff. The number times I have meant to reply to someone, got distracted, and then forgot, but then REMEMBERED, is like INFINITY. I’ve also thought I replied and then checked because I hadn’t heard back and realized I didn’t. People provide excuses because they feel guilty and you are being a bit fussy to think these excuses are insulting. Basically the person is saying ‘You Do matter to me, my life is crazy and I’m struggling to remember to do anything right’

RunnyPaint · 31/08/2023 17:41

Thank you, OP. I am a "thought I'd replied" type 😳This thread prompted me to check and respond to two messages. My friend (who is usually worse than me) responded immediately 😊

sonjadog · 31/08/2023 17:39

Honestly, I would expect my friends to forget about me in the short term. I certainly don’t have them at the forefront of my mind all day every day, so it wouldn’t even occur to me to react to a «sorry I forgot» message.

longtompot · 31/08/2023 17:33

A particular favourite which I’ve had from a couple of friends is ‘sorry, I thought I’d replied’. IMO this scores the double-whammy of both insulting the recipient’s intelligence (since personally I don’t think I’ve ever hallucinated replying to someone when I haven’t…) and, if taken at face value, implying that you/the conversation are so unimportant to them that they can’t remember whether they’ve replied to you or no

Well, I did exactly this yesterday when texting my dh that his dinner was ready. I opened my phone to text, got distracted and then thought oh hang on a sec, did I text? I hadn't! I didn't text him that I thought I had messaged him, but I am just showing you can in fact mean to message someone and forget.

ThatsMsAtomicBob · 31/08/2023 17:33

I think there's a massive difference between trying to explain your behaviour or lack of contact and commenting, unprompted, on someone's physical appearance that has nothing to do with you.

Anyway, you seem to be tarring all friends who do this with one particular ex friend's brush. People don't act the same. If they are trying to cut you out as a friend you'll know about it one way or another.