Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a joint student rental without guarantors is risky?

35 replies

imogo · 31/08/2023 12:52

DC is arranging his first joint student rental property with friends. All full time students. The flat is currently empty, and so the landlord and tenants all want to move quickly. It is a "joint and several" contract. The landlord has waived his right to get references. He also says he doesn't need guarantors. 🤔The other tenants and (reportedly) parents are happy to proceed on this basis, but I think that adding guarantors will be a safety net. e.g. if one tenant can't pay their rent, and the others become liable for making up the difference, there will be no guarantor to chase for reimbursement.

I realise that if I am a guarantor I increase my own personal liability, but if not, and my son becomes liable, I will end up cushioning him financially anyway - at least a formal guarantor arrangement will help me to redress this.

Aibu?

OP posts:
imogo · 31/08/2023 23:49

Consider this scenario ...

  1. Students Alex and Chris sign a "joint and several" contract for 12 months and split the £2000pcm rent between them.
  2. After the first month, Chris drops out of uni and moves back home.
  3. When the rent becomes due, Alex pays his £1000 share but Chris doesn't.
  4. The landlord chases Chris but gets no response.
  5. The landlord demands that Alex makes up the shortfall.
6 Alex can't afford it, so his mum steps in to pay the additional £1000 to the landlord.
  1. Alex and his mum try to recover the money by taking Chris to court, but he declares himself bankrupt, so they don't get it.

If Chris had a guarantor, then step 5+ would have been different - the landlord could have chased the guarantor for the money, leaving Alex out of it. Or, if he did chase Alex, then Alex could subsequently chase Chris's guarantor to recover the loss.

This is why I think guarantor agreements protect tenants as well as landlords.

OP posts:
Precipice · 31/08/2023 14:09

6monthsto50 · 31/08/2023 13:32

Don’t give your name as a guarantor. Let your adult son decide if he wants to proceed.

The landlord isn't asking for the guarantor anyway.

However, as to your 'let your adult son decide'. The son may be an adult, but he's a young adult, just off at university. It's common for landlords to require guarantors from students. If you come at it with an approach that it's for the adult son to decide - there's nothing for the son to decide. Either he can find a place and you (in the hypothetical) can serve as guarantor or he can't find a place. He may be able to find a place not requiring a parental guarantor, but this not guaranteed - it's often difficult for students to find a place as there is a lot of competition and rental listings don't specify that they require or don't require a guarantor. What do you expect to happen?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 31/08/2023 13:34

modgepodge · 31/08/2023 13:19

Yeah from memory the guarantors are all responsible for all the rent, not just their own child’s, so if you were guarantor you’d be responsible for all the tenants rent anyway. So not sure it makes much difference.

Not necessarily. I am guarantor for my son's rent and it specifically says I am only liable for his share and nobody else's.

Last year I am not so sure, but fortunately we got to the end of the year with no dramas and he got his deposit back too!

6monthsto50 · 31/08/2023 13:32

Don’t give your name as a guarantor. Let your adult son decide if he wants to proceed.

Rudolphthefrog · 31/08/2023 13:23

The way I understood it though, you as guarantor would be effectively joint and severally liable too - and you wouldn’t necessarily know who the other guarantors even are. So if flatmate X didn’t pay their share of the rent, or caused damage, instead of only being able to pursue some penniless students, now the landlord can also pursue their guarantors. Any of them, not just X’s. So instead of your son and his friends being liable for X’s debt, now you are too. The point of a landlord asking for guarantors is to protect themselves, not the students or their parents.

I dare say some people have persuaded landlords and agencies to agree to different terms, but I would be extremely careful what you wish for here!

Dotjones · 31/08/2023 13:21

As long as you're happy to be legally responsible for the whole of the rent if anyone defaults then you can be a guarantor. But it's key that you understand you're not just guaranteeing your son's rent, you're guaranteeing the whole lot. I don't see any benefit to you in doing this. You say you'll end up having to help your son if one (or more) of the others don't pay. That's fine but what benefit is there to you making yourself legally responsible for the others?

Precipice · 31/08/2023 13:21

There's no difference to you. If your son can't pay, you acknowledge you'd be paying anyway. Having the (other) parents listed as guarantors would be no help to you.

modgepodge · 31/08/2023 13:19

Yeah from memory the guarantors are all responsible for all the rent, not just their own child’s, so if you were guarantor you’d be responsible for all the tenants rent anyway. So not sure it makes much difference.

ky7sa · 31/08/2023 13:16

I was in a flatshare exactly the same as that when I was in uni and it devolved into a complete mess when one tenant went AWOL.

I'd advise against you being the ONLY parent guarantor who steps up as you will likely not just be responsible for your son's share, but for the entire rent, if the group of tenants falls into arrears. Check the wording on the guarantor agreement.

Ghastisflabbered · 31/08/2023 13:15

This is fairly normal for student lets - I’ve lived in a few over the years (two bachelors degrees and two masters) and every single time it was part of the contract that if one person couldn’t pay then the rest of us were liable.

Even if they did have guarantors - you would have no redress against the other guarantors - that would be for the landlord/letting agent.